Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the answer to ‘bed blocking’?

646 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 01/11/2022 19:07

Another day, another article about ‘bed blockers’ (put in speech marks because I know it’s a bit of a goady term).

I was shocked to find out a third of beds are taken up by ‘social patients’ in some trusts, who are medically fine to be discharged but can’t be because the care they need afterwards isn’t in place. I feel irate that the whole point of lockdowns to ‘stop the NHS from being overwhelmed’ needn’t have happened if it wasn’t overwhelmed in this way to start with.

Whats the answer? Early intervention so they don’t end up in hospital in the first place? A rise in taxes to pay for more services? I’m not sure the working population can afford to pay more tax.

The ‘ageing population’ issue means this can surely only get worse?

OP posts:
Zone2NorthLondon · 01/11/2022 21:49

Walkingthedog46 · 01/11/2022 21:40

Maybe hospitals could have their discharge teams working evenings/weekends. My husband’s consultant said he was fit to go home one Friday afternoon but as the discharge team wasn’t available to process his discharge he remained in hospital over the weekend. Coincidentally, that same weekend a friend’s daughter was in A&E waiting to be admitted but no bed was available.

DC teams work 24/7 weekend,eve, bank holidays to relieve bed pressure and help with DToC. Surprised being medically stable he wasn’t promptly dc and followed up in community. Unless a poc was required and no agency available to undertake it?
as an aside hope your husband is well now

mumda · 01/11/2022 21:45

Again Tory policy development team here perhaps? Or journo looking for outrageous comments?

hatgirl · 01/11/2022 21:45

Untitledsquatboulder · 01/11/2022 21:27

Is this voluntary or involuntary euthanasia you are advocating? And just for the elderly or for other groups too?

I'm not advocating for euthanasia at all. I'm advocating for not over medicating old age in the pursuit of prioritising life over comfort and dignity.

The human body isn't designed to live as long as we now expect it to. For many people the result is a long, cruel and undignified death.

I feel the same about any condition where there is very little quality of life remaining and also absolutely in favour of promoting life regardless of disability for as long as that person has some enjoyment and quality of life in being alive.

it's about encouraging people to think and write down their decisions about their own personal line in the sand, normalising advance directives and empowering families and professionals to promote wellbeing over existing.

Mrsmch123 · 01/11/2022 21:44

Untitledsquatboulder · 01/11/2022 21:27

Is this voluntary or involuntary euthanasia you are advocating? And just for the elderly or for other groups too?

It's not euthanasia tho is it....it's the natural progression of dying. I'm a huge advocate for anticipatory care planing. Not only does it help the family accept what is happening to their loved one but it also allows healthcare professionals to have frank and honest discussions about dying and that not everyone should have all interventions thrown at them just because its available.....lots of time the kindest and most ethical things to do is nothing. People have such are hard time accepting that doing nothing or withdrawing treatment is in fact the best thing to do.

Zone2NorthLondon · 01/11/2022 21:44

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 01/11/2022 21:39

Locally, in services, it's Delayed Transfer of Care (DToC), which is a better and more descriptive phrase.

Yes DToC. that’s used in LA and discharge teams.
The scary dc team coordinator who know the cost of an acute bed in London and will recite it at any opportunity

motherofthelittlescreamingone · 01/11/2022 21:42

Oh and by the way, labour's Care plan was a great idea. It just wasn't funded remotely enough - if they had got elected, it wouldn't be happening now even before the costs of the pandemic. Putting a few pence on income tax and "taxing the rich" isn't enough

antelopevalley · 01/11/2022 21:42

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 01/11/2022 21:37

Yet people providing care for relatives saves the government £130 billion a year, so clearly many people do look after family members, often at great personal cost to their health and to their finances.

People are living longer, with more complicated needs. It's not always safe or practical for care to be provided by family.

And let's not forget it's usually women who provide the care. Often in this country, in the past when families were larger, a daughter (I had one aunt who remained unmarried and stayed home to look after my grandparents, my grandad really as my gran died quite young), in some of those cultures you talk about, it's the daughter in law.

In cultures where people look after their elderly relatives at home, you do not have two adults working until 68 years old. You have one adult who either does no paid work or only works part-time. When the push was for everyone to work full-time and to have a later retirement age, the government were warned that fewer people would be able to care for their elderly relatives.
My mum cared for my gran, but she retired at 58 years old and cared for her mum once she herself turned 60. I will still be working full-time at that age.

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 21:41

(In Topgub's area)
I really do hope that it isn't real and she has shared no stats other than generic news about how tough it is in the community causing delays in assessments. But that is not hospital discharge stats. (In her specific area. )
Lotsa Gov money spent to discharge people and peeve hospital discharge delays over past years. Will always be some but not regular

Walkingthedog46 · 01/11/2022 21:40

Maybe hospitals could have their discharge teams working evenings/weekends. My husband’s consultant said he was fit to go home one Friday afternoon but as the discharge team wasn’t available to process his discharge he remained in hospital over the weekend. Coincidentally, that same weekend a friend’s daughter was in A&E waiting to be admitted but no bed was available.

viques · 01/11/2022 21:39

inthemiddlepiggyinthemiddle · 01/11/2022 19:13

The we old fashioned way of convalescent homes.

Difficult to staff, because everywhere is struggling, but that is the only way, remove those who need a very small amount of assistance. Free up bed for those is real need. Where I live there used to be 4 or 5 - one really big one. All gone, most now flats.

I agree, there needs to be an interim place of care that frees up hospital beds before care at home can be sorted, the problem is that convalescent homes only delay the realisation that there aren’t enough people prepared to work for the poor wages that home care companies offer.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 01/11/2022 21:39

Zone2NorthLondon · 01/11/2022 21:37

Abhorr phrase bed blocker, I know it’s in parlance and daily usage..but that’s a real actual person. Not just a patient blocking a bed
what to do
employ OT , PT to assess and identify suitable step down provision
fund hospital at home reduce bed pressure
increase support worker /HCA wages as retail and catering jobs pay more
rapid treatment teams to dc home promptly with follow up

Locally, in services, it's Delayed Transfer of Care (DToC), which is a better and more descriptive phrase.

antelopevalley · 01/11/2022 21:38

hatgirl · 01/11/2022 21:04

I always find it really interesting on these sorts of threads that nearly everyone who has worked in elderly care in some shape or form almost unilaterally says in some form that we culturally we need to have a big conversation about what dying of old age actually looks like.

it's nearly always people who haven't worked in elderly care that are horrified by the idea that we want to 'euthanise' people.

I find it immoral the way we prioritise life at all costs over dignity and wellbeing in old age.

People deserve good and dignified deaths. Not being left at the mercy of an NHS which is being disembowelled and a social care system that is paralysed.

Loads of people who go home with carers do not need to be euthanised. None of my relatives in this position wanted this. When my father in law went home with carers he had lots of family regularly visit and even went to his granddaughters wedding.
People working in hospitals do not see people at home and how much they can enjoy life once they recover from being ill in hospital.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 01/11/2022 21:37

NearlChristmas · 01/11/2022 20:34

Years ago families looked after their elderly relatives and in some cultures they still do. Not in greed ridden modern Britain though.

Yet people providing care for relatives saves the government £130 billion a year, so clearly many people do look after family members, often at great personal cost to their health and to their finances.

People are living longer, with more complicated needs. It's not always safe or practical for care to be provided by family.

And let's not forget it's usually women who provide the care. Often in this country, in the past when families were larger, a daughter (I had one aunt who remained unmarried and stayed home to look after my grandparents, my grandad really as my gran died quite young), in some of those cultures you talk about, it's the daughter in law.

Zone2NorthLondon · 01/11/2022 21:37

Abhorr phrase bed blocker, I know it’s in parlance and daily usage..but that’s a real actual person. Not just a patient blocking a bed
what to do
employ OT , PT to assess and identify suitable step down provision
fund hospital at home reduce bed pressure
increase support worker /HCA wages as retail and catering jobs pay more
rapid treatment teams to dc home promptly with follow up

DamnUserName21 · 01/11/2022 21:37

Cuppasoupmonster · 01/11/2022 21:30

It seems like only a matter of time before the next fall/hospital admission unless she’s supervised 24/7?

Even with 24 hour care, if a person a poor mobility, falls are inevitable. Keeping this lady independent in her home (providing she is coping and able to get around her home) is the ultimate goal.

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 21:37

Bit on the whole most LAs in England at least, likely other UK have worked hard to speed up hospital discharges . Huge expensive investments in that.

But If @Topgub 's LA and hospitals haven't , and regular people (even 80%) with regular care packages are sat waiting for 3 months for those, even a discharge then that is so so awful and should be front page news

As they will be one of few areas in England that failed to use extra millions of covid funding nor to invest and spend in discharge funding from hospitals. I wonder where they put that money ?

antelopevalley · 01/11/2022 21:35

My Aunt was stuck in hospital waiting for a care package. There is such a shortage of carers they were struggling to arrange it. She needed a hospital bed and commode delivered as well which took ages.
Social care needs to be properly funded so people want to work in it.

DamnUserName21 · 01/11/2022 21:35

Cuppasoupmonster · 01/11/2022 21:20

I think that’s quite selfish if I’m honest.

Doesn't sound like she needs 24 hour care so no need for a home yet. It's cheaper to keep her home too and if she is managing with support from 4x POC and family, why should she go in a home?

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 21:31

@Topgub
You didn't link anything relevant about hospital discharges lengths- and there is monitoring. You linked genetic websites talk about increases in delays generally for assessments due to covid pressures over past couple years. No shit Sherlock that is known info!

Covid has caused impact in all services. You've linked genetic weblinks that talK about community and other waits for assessments not specific hospital delayed discharge stats.

That's not news -,yes covid has caused waits in community as unprecedented influx work to do - and it isn't hospital length of regular delay stats.

It is terribly sad that your LA is underperforming- if it is - and we trust your word though no stats shared...

Ours and many others aren't.

It should be never be that people are regularly waiting in hospital for 3 months + for care packages throughout the year.

Cuppasoupmonster · 01/11/2022 21:30

Iheartmysmart · 01/11/2022 21:23

Why? She self funds her care and the family pick up the slack. What’s selfish about that. If the NHS hadn’t caused her to lose mobility by dropping her she wouldn’t be in this state now.

It seems like only a matter of time before the next fall/hospital admission unless she’s supervised 24/7?

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/11/2022 21:27

I had the opposite problem when DM was admitted to hospital. The doctor asked to speak to me as they needed to make arrangements to send her home despite her being barely conscious in bed and having heart and kidney failure. I'd been warned by her GP that this would probably happen and to tell them I wouldn't be caring for DM. The hospital doctor looked at me as though I was something she'd trodden on and told me in that case she'd have to involve social services. DM died four days later (thankfully in a different ward), on the day they were planning on discharging her.

motherofthelittlescreamingone · 01/11/2022 21:27

Honestly, I think that the voters are at fault. Theresa May ran her election campaign with a proposal that social care should be fixed using a portion of the assets of older people, whether or not you are in a home. They had a costed plan. And Labour and the Lib Dems labelled it a death/dementia tax and opposed it, even when she put a cap on it (which should have been in the initial proposal, save that I think it should be a percentage of your assets so you are not just protecting the wealthy). TM lost the election and a generation of politicians have concluded that it is too toxic to touch and they will just pretend that tinkering around the edges is the way to go.

People fell for it, because they love the idea that we can have all this stuff for free that we don't have to pay for.

Putting a couple of p on income tax is not going to fix things. Not even close. Socialised care of the elderly using their assets is what is needed. Unless you want to pay masses more tax.

But voters won't vote for it. The elderly won't pay for their own care. And doctors will always see their duty as prolonging life rather than managing death until things are really palliative (which I totally understand).

People do not want to face up to basic truths about death and taxes.

(My grandmother had a heart bypass in her late 70s that gave her 15 more years, but was already in cognitive decline and she spent 10 of them demented. I'm not sure that is living, really. My other grandmother had a heart bypass at nearly 90 and then died within 2 years of a stroke - I will treasure those years with her, but honestly she and her family understood that there wasn't long left and when she died she was ready to go - every time I saw her, she tried to say goodbye, because she felt that she was just being patched up again and again and episodes were going to get more and more frequent, which was very depressing for a lady who was sharp and positive otherwise.).

Untitledsquatboulder · 01/11/2022 21:27

hatgirl · 01/11/2022 21:04

I always find it really interesting on these sorts of threads that nearly everyone who has worked in elderly care in some shape or form almost unilaterally says in some form that we culturally we need to have a big conversation about what dying of old age actually looks like.

it's nearly always people who haven't worked in elderly care that are horrified by the idea that we want to 'euthanise' people.

I find it immoral the way we prioritise life at all costs over dignity and wellbeing in old age.

People deserve good and dignified deaths. Not being left at the mercy of an NHS which is being disembowelled and a social care system that is paralysed.

Is this voluntary or involuntary euthanasia you are advocating? And just for the elderly or for other groups too?

Josie45 · 01/11/2022 21:27

GelatoQueen · 01/11/2022 19:38

Make the NHS a better / more efficient organisation ( lots of money going to waste in the NHS currently) and put more money going into social care. Make social care a viable career - not minimum wage. Stop talking about people being clinically ready to go home .... everyone needs to be working to the same ends, if a discharge fails, it will cost the health service more, so stop the artificial divide between clinical and social care. Treat social workers with the same respect as nurses / consultants (often more poorly paid). Make it clear to older people and their families that they will be expected to cover some of the costs of care as the state will not fully fund it ... I could go on ....

This, the NHS are literally wasting millions on projects that are not planned properly by the people at the top.
People being paid dam good salaries that are not in touch with what's going on on the shop floor.
Projects that get shut down after 5 years, (after they've spent millions)that could of been beneficial in preventing hospital admissions but failed due to lack of planning and poor use of resources.

marmaladepop · 01/11/2022 21:26

IntrovertedPenguin · 01/11/2022 20:52

If we can pay millions to refugees for hotels, send millions for a war that isn't our fight, pay foreign aid to a country with its own space programme!... we can afford to build more care homes and train more staff. And give them an actual wage that'll bring the right people into those jobs.

100% agree.

Swipe left for the next trending thread