Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Son doesn’t want to attend an activity, do I force him to go?

32 replies

DoesntWantToGo · 01/11/2022 16:50

DS is 8, he started attending an activity about 6 months ago (think Scouts/Cubs/Beavers etc). To start with, he loved it. He has SEN and adhd and constantly moves and needs stimulating. The activity was perfect for it! Recently, he’s been saying he doesn’t want to go just before we get ready to leave. He loves it when he’s there, and says how much he enjoys it and wants to go next week. He also uses up loads of energy in a healthy way, and has friend there to play with. But when I pick him up from school the day of the activity, he starts saying no he doesn’t want to go. Now I don’t want to push him and force him to do something he doesn’t want to. But at the same time, I don’t want him to give in too easily and then regret it later (there’s a waiting list, it took a year for him to get his place). I also don’t want to waste my time and money every week if he’s saying he doesn’t want to go. But he loves it when he’s there. I had suggested that he goes until the end of the year, and if he’s still not sure, then he can leave. But my mam says I’m being mean and shouldn’t force him to go, even though he loves it when he’s there.

so wise mumsnetters, what do I do?

YANBU- try and get him to go for a few more weeks and see if he changes his mind
YABU- don’t force him, save my money for something else

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hankunamatata · 01/11/2022 22:12

Check with leaders. We have child who doesn't take part in anything, they don't want to be there but they tell us parents say they have to.

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/11/2022 22:09

If he enjoys it while there carry on

if he said at the end /after / I didn’t enjoy j don’t went to go next week then i would consider stopping

dd4 at the time last year was doing a dance club after school. She liked 2/3 then said she didn’t like it. Twice I had to collect her early as upset

so I said to her that it was fine to stop but she would lose her place and wouidnt Be able to go next term if she changed her mind

she didn’t lol

where as swimming and gym she loves and enjoys going

as your ds @DoesntWantToGo enjoys while there I would continue

Soproudoflionesses · 01/11/2022 21:31

My dd is the same with one of her after school clubs but is always glad she has done it afterwards.
The annual subs are due in January so we are going to have a serious conversation then about whether to continue. Tough one.

notanothertakeaway · 01/11/2022 19:02

BuryingAcorns · 01/11/2022 16:56

use the 'agree but don't change plans' tactic.

DS: I don't want to go to cubs today
You: I know. You never feel like it after a tiring day at school. You need a good break and some dinner.
You - 15 minutes befofe it's time to go: DS, into uniform. Let's go to cubs and see your friend. Aren't you doing X fun activity this week?

I let DS drop a few activities but insisted he stuck with the one he enjoyed when he got there. He's glad now as he's become very good at it.

@BuryingAcorns I think this is a good approach

museumum · 01/11/2022 18:56

I would speak to him after the session. Ask him how the feels after and if he enjoyed it and is glad he went.
I often don’t feel like doing things but then am really glad I did after.

ladygindiva · 01/11/2022 18:55

My kids do with this dance. They are 5. They moan before going but I can see they love it there and are simply buzzing after, so I ignore their complaints and force them to go 🤣

LimeCheesecake · 01/11/2022 18:54

Judy Murray once said that her boys often said they wanted to give up tennis - so she’d say you have to go, but if at the end you say you don’t want to go next time, then we’ll cancel, but it’s too late on the way there to cancel. And that everytime she’d ask them on the way home “do you want to give up/not go next time?” They’d always said no. If they had said they wanted to quit on the way home, she’d have let them.

I’ve taken that approach with everything except swimming. Tell me afterwards you don’t want to go next week, I’ll cancel. Tell me when you are getting ready, then no.

so perhaps make him go, then ask him at pick up “did you enjoy it this evening? Was it fun? Do you want to go next week?” If he says yes, then next week when he complains remind him you asked him when you left and it’s too late to cancel now, he has to go tonight but if after the club tonight he says he doesn’t want to go next week, you’ll cancel.

DoesntWantToGo · 01/11/2022 18:52

Thanks everyone. It looks like my plan to stick it out to the end of the year is the general advice. A couple of people mentioned about issues when he’s there? There’s never anything. The leader is amazing and very understanding of his needs. I always stay and he always joins in as soon as he arrives. He checks in with me sometimes, but I help out so he never has any problems finding me

OP posts:
DoesntWantToGo · 01/11/2022 18:47

@BabyofMine its literally just a t-shirt or jumper which I have ready in hit wardrobe and help him put on. He has sensory issues with clothes, but these don’t cause any problems

OP posts:
purpleme12 · 01/11/2022 18:44

If I know my child likes the activity or will like it, yes I do make her go.
Also, if I always made it her choice we might never go to stuff (even stuff she loves)
Sometimes you have to make the decision for them

PutYourShoesOnWereLate · 01/11/2022 18:38

As an adult, I do wish sometimes that there was someone to force me out to activities that I know I would enjoy when I got there. Its just getting out of the house which is too big a hurdle sometimes.

2bazookas · 01/11/2022 18:36

talk to activity leader and see if there's some reason?

If all else fails, call DC#s bluff. "I don't want to go" "Okay, you don't have to go." (no further comment or questions). See how that works.

Goldbar · 01/11/2022 18:16

I would make him go but tell him that if he doesn't want to take part when there, he can sit the activity out with me. This is what I do with my DC when they refuse to do swimming or any other activity and it's amazing how quickly they get into it when there.

Maray1967 · 01/11/2022 17:55

If you know he loves it when he’s there then get him to go. Both of mine have done the ‘I don’t want to go today’ routine and I always said they needed to stick at it. DS 1 now an adult would have dropped out of his main activity that he loves if I’d let him do this ten years ago.

It’s different if they actually don’t like it - I’d agree with the pp about saying they’ve made a commitment especially if it’s a team thing for a term but they can give it up afterwards.

If it’s really not good, ie they are being ignored while there, which happened once to one of mine which I witnessed, then I would take them out of it straightaway.

romdowa · 01/11/2022 17:34

Its the adhd that is making him do this. Even as an adult I get this way. I love doing something but I just can't get started . I was the same as a child too but was never encountered to push through and go. My advice is to say to him to go and once he gets there if he decides he still doesn't want to attend ,you'll take him home . But no pressure , no talking about cost and how long it took to get his place, as this will just compound the shame he already feels for not wanting or not being able mentally to go.

StrataZon · 01/11/2022 17:29

Activities are important for children but I never force mine to continue something they don't want to go to. My mum did this and I never forgave her!
BUT mine always understand they are signing up for the term snd they can't just drop out.. If they leave we must give the leader notice they are leaving at end of term.

I also made sure, at that age, if they dropped an activity it was replaced with something else.

Does he go to other activities? If so I'd try and explore further with him what it is he doesn't like about this one and what else he would like to do instead.

Movingsoon21 · 01/11/2022 17:17

It might be more that he doesn’t want to leave the house than that he doesn’t want to go to the specific activity. I often felt like that as a child - once I was home from school I hated the thought of going back outside, but once I was out I enjoyed it.

good idea to just focus on one thing at a time - I.e. let’s get your clothes on, let’s get your shoes on, rather than “let’s go to Beavers”. Is there anything he really likes that you could only give him when he’s in the car going to this activity?

BabyofMine · 01/11/2022 17:17

Could it be that he doesn’t like the process of getting ready? Does he need special clothes he has to find, do they get lost or are they not somewhere easy to reach? Could you streamline everything so it’s all ready for him so getting ready for the activity is REALLY easy? Ie literally laying out his clothes ready, packing his bag or equipment needed etc (Not saying you don’t already do this but just in case!)

erinaceus · 01/11/2022 17:11

Have you talked to him about it outside of just before/after a session, to see if he has an opinion then?

DoesntWantToGo · 01/11/2022 17:08

@BuryingAcorns i like that idea. I might try it tomorrow and see how it goes, rhanks!

OP posts:
DoesntWantToGo · 01/11/2022 17:06

@x2boys hes not nervous or anxious that I can tell. It’s more like he just doesn’t fancy it. As soon as we arrive he’s running around and playing, he always chews his clothes when he’s worried and he never does that before or during the activity

@lifeturnsonadime I’m not dragging him, but he just says he doesn’t want to go. Lots of whinging and delaying. Doesn’t want to put on his clothes, doesn’t want to get ready. I usually cajole him along by focusing on everything a bit at a time, rather than saying we are going?

OP posts:
DoesntWantToGo · 01/11/2022 17:04

@Solasum hes actually very foody (I think because he moves so much he’s starving!) so I always make his favourite meal before going, so he eats nicely and has the positive association :)

@Dacadactyl he doesn’t watch tv or play on games. He doesn’t like anything that requires sitting down, which is why I was so happy when he started this. If we weren’t there, he would probably be playing outside. Nothing productive, but not sitting on a screen :)

OP posts:
madnesss · 01/11/2022 16:59

No, I never forced mine. The only thing he will learn is that you are not listening to him which is the most important thing he needs from you.

BuryingAcorns · 01/11/2022 16:56

use the 'agree but don't change plans' tactic.

DS: I don't want to go to cubs today
You: I know. You never feel like it after a tiring day at school. You need a good break and some dinner.
You - 15 minutes befofe it's time to go: DS, into uniform. Let's go to cubs and see your friend. Aren't you doing X fun activity this week?

I let DS drop a few activities but insisted he stuck with the one he enjoyed when he got there. He's glad now as he's become very good at it.

lifeturnsonadime · 01/11/2022 16:55

Are you having to 'force him' in the literal sense to go or is he just needing encouragement.

If it's the former then stop if the later then it's probably just a transition issue.

Is he able to vocalise the issue? Have you spoken to the leaders about the issue and whether there might be something going on there that you are unaware of?