Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend outed me - AIBU?

185 replies

Somefriend0 · 01/11/2022 13:15

I posted about something happening in my life (NC for this). Think a big life event with family drama becoming a problem. Some of the info was quite personal, but not identifying I thought!

Friend saw this, guessed it was me, and brought it up over dinner in front of 8 other people at the weekend. All friends and their partners, some are quite new relationships so I don't know them all that well. I denied it because she was talking about personal stuff I did not want other people knowing, but she just kept on going like a dog with a bone.

Our friends were obviously uncomfortable and I was just in shock.

I've known this girl since I was 5 and she's never done anything like this before. She is competitive and loves to get one up on people, but it's usually pretty harmless stuff.

I'm angry, embarrassed, and I feel like my privacy has been invaded. Yes it's a public forum but the whole point is that it's anonymous. I feel so hurt.

I kept a lot of things vague and any details would be pretty common things. Lesson learned though, be careful.

YABU - it's not a big deal, let it go.
YANBU - she was way out of line.

Maybe she'll even see this but I don't care!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fraaahnces · 06/11/2022 04:05

I think I would definitely be shifting her place in the order of priorities amongst my group of friends if I were you. She’d be heading right to the bottom of the Christmas card list.

Everyflippingusernameistaken · 06/11/2022 00:42

I hope the bitch is no longer your friend?!

Madamum18 · 03/11/2022 14:43

She is NOT a friend. I would speak to her, tell her something along the lines of:

"I am very upset and hurt that you brought ...up at the meal the other night. I do not want my personal business discussed like that in front of people I dont know that well. Please never do that again!"

She will bluster. Repeat, repeat, repeat ...the above.

And I would step back from her for good!!

Somefriend0 · 03/11/2022 10:01

BadNomad · 03/11/2022 00:45

Unless you've changed a lot of details about the confrontation, you've pretty much confirmed to her that she was right and you were lying. You should have stayed quiet and kept on denying it. If only to not embarrass the people who defended you against her.

Why would the friend who tried to move the conversation on be embarrassed?

You think it's some terrible stain on her honour? 😂

OP posts:
SmileyClare · 03/11/2022 08:53

I see your points (about being identifiable on here) certainly giving specific locations narrows it down, or of course putting your photo up and asking everyone “Guess my age” 😂.. always cringe at those.

I suppose some posters (for example the friend who uses her particular experience to help others) wouldn’t mind being recognised?

Anyway, just my musings.

I don’t think I could be completely certain of knowing someone on here so definitely wouldn’t ask them in real life “Are you spacegirl65 “ or whatever. How fucking awkward for all concerned!

notimagain · 03/11/2022 07:54

SmileyClare · 02/11/2022 20:22

I'm surprised how many people have recognised posters they know on here. There's something like 8 million unique users a month on Mumsnet, huge sections posting from all over the world.

I always thought it was coincidental if a situation on here looked similar to experiences in your own life. I mean no one knows for sure if they've spotted Hannah's mum from Brownies do they? It's speculation and very rare to have a real life "dilemma" that's unique.

However, Op appears to be have been not only recognised but publicly humiliated Shock so it's possible although I still think extremely rare.

I think it's as @DuchessofAnkh99 as said..you don't have to drop much what you might think is vague but what is actually slightly specific info into a post or sequence of posts and those similarly placed and well enough informed (e.g by living in the same area and /or having kids in same schools and / or being same line of work) can work out who you are.

Over the years I've certainly worked out the identity of one MN'er and have a strong suspicion I know who another one is...but I wouldn't dream of outing either.

DuchessofAnkh99 · 03/11/2022 06:48

SmileyClare · 02/11/2022 20:22

I'm surprised how many people have recognised posters they know on here. There's something like 8 million unique users a month on Mumsnet, huge sections posting from all over the world.

I always thought it was coincidental if a situation on here looked similar to experiences in your own life. I mean no one knows for sure if they've spotted Hannah's mum from Brownies do they? It's speculation and very rare to have a real life "dilemma" that's unique.

However, Op appears to be have been not only recognised but publicly humiliated Shock so it's possible although I still think extremely rare.

Yes, but sometimes when people mention a school, or a town - then the situation becomes very localised.

Even if they don't name it but start talking about a school issue at a private school in Tunbridge wells, if you are in that location and know the private schools it can be the work of moments to work out who it is.

Otherwise specific situations - I had a very specific work situation, involving complexities of leave and notice before resigning and posted on here and then pretty much told (many) people the word for word story...I name changed rapidly and am now more careful with detail and altering it.

I also know I have around 5 or 6 friends on here. I recognise two of them regularly as I know their style of writing. One has a unique home situation she writes about to help others and the other is in a more remote location and again slightly unusual home setup, but never changes details when she writes! She has previously been outed too by someone local to her so should know better.

My 6 friends will probably be able to ID me as one of us 6 if they read this, even with some changed/vague details (and 6 isn't the correct number Grin! off to name change I go!)

BadNomad · 03/11/2022 00:45

Unless you've changed a lot of details about the confrontation, you've pretty much confirmed to her that she was right and you were lying. You should have stayed quiet and kept on denying it. If only to not embarrass the people who defended you against her.

ellyeth · 03/11/2022 00:00

That's a really horrible, spiteful thing to do. She is not a friend.

MugginsOverEre · 02/11/2022 22:47

"Mumsnet? Ha ha! Isn't that site not called NET-MUMS?! That's the thingy you're on about, right? Yeah I was on it years ago when I was expecting [childsname]"

Throws em right off. No self respecting MN viper would be a Netmums member Grin

MugginsOverEre · 02/11/2022 22:40

DuchessofAnkh99 · 01/11/2022 13:38

possibly lesson learned on how many details you need to change!

I always when posting change

  1. sex and number of kids,
  2. I invent or switch relatives parents or siblings about whom I am talking - my sister becomes my cousin or aunt, my aunt becomes my uncle etc etc
  3. Always name change regularly and definitely after I have been on the schools board (I do post advice when asked about the school my kids go to then immediately name change!)

When I have previously "spotted" one or two people it is always because the make the situation too identifying or if you think you might vaguely know, then look back and see other threads which tie you in to the person.

Same. I have anywhere between 1 and 4 kids. Ages always vary. Their sexes get changed more than Eddie Izzard. My neighbours are varied ages, familial groups (ie Mum, dad and kid, or adult mum and adult son etc.) The basics of my posts are truth but the details are always purposely changed so if anyone was to do an advanced search, they would say, "Oh that can't be so and so. They live in Gloucestershire according to them last week and we're nowhere near that!"

I've never been to Gloucestershire. Can't even spell it. Autocorrect fixed it for me!

OP your friend is nasty. I hate when people try to put down or embarrass someone just to make themselves look better or more interesting. Vile type of people.

knockyknees · 02/11/2022 22:12

Wow, she's an utter bitch. She'd be my ex-friend after this. She deliberately set out to embarrass/humiliate you for her own twisted gain.

Had I been one of the other guests at the dinner, I'd be thinking what a horrible person she is, who has shown her true colours, and would definitely be a person to avoid in the future.

ReallyTryingTo · 02/11/2022 21:58

Yeah, I'm with the masses on this. She is way out of line.

keffie12 · 02/11/2022 21:50

She is no friend. When someone shows you who they are believe them. She is nasty, vicious and cannot be trusted

ItsAllTheSame · 02/11/2022 21:14

What a nasty thing to do! I wouldn't even bother to explain why (to her), just block her. If you message her, or have any other contact, knowing what you know now, she could turn that against you. She could even show any messages you send her to other people. Cut her out completely, and good riddance.

DaughterofDawn · 02/11/2022 21:12

SmileyClare · 02/11/2022 20:22

I'm surprised how many people have recognised posters they know on here. There's something like 8 million unique users a month on Mumsnet, huge sections posting from all over the world.

I always thought it was coincidental if a situation on here looked similar to experiences in your own life. I mean no one knows for sure if they've spotted Hannah's mum from Brownies do they? It's speculation and very rare to have a real life "dilemma" that's unique.

However, Op appears to be have been not only recognised but publicly humiliated Shock so it's possible although I still think extremely rare.

It’s wild isn’t it? It seems so unlikely but it happens more than I thought I suppose.

I mean even if I saw a situation that seemed familiar I would have probably just assumed it was all a coincidence.

If anything it is the kind thing to do unless they’re like sleeping with your spouse or something. lol

SuperSue77 · 02/11/2022 20:42

NRTWT but what a bitch. You don’t need people like this in your life. I had an old school “friend” who dropped me after her wedding - no explanation as to what I had done wrong. I lost weight before her wedding, at which I was a bridesmaid, but my main motivation for the weight loss was another friend’s wedding a few months earlier who had 3 other bridesmaid who were all size 8 and I didn't want to be the one fat bridesmaid!
Thing was, I realised afterwards that she had always been a toxic influence in my life, gas lighting me on several issues and being downright mean and rude about me in front of her other “friends”. I’m quite glad she cut me off as my new husband would never have tolerated her crap behaviour. I hear about other friends who have stayed in touch with her and they complain about her behaviour and I just think how glad I am to not be exposed to it any longer.
I do wish her well and her family, but I don’t lose a minute’s sleep over the lack of communication now and just pity those who are still exposed to it.
Wow - that was therapeutic!

SmileyClare · 02/11/2022 20:22

I'm surprised how many people have recognised posters they know on here. There's something like 8 million unique users a month on Mumsnet, huge sections posting from all over the world.

I always thought it was coincidental if a situation on here looked similar to experiences in your own life. I mean no one knows for sure if they've spotted Hannah's mum from Brownies do they? It's speculation and very rare to have a real life "dilemma" that's unique.

However, Op appears to be have been not only recognised but publicly humiliated Shock so it's possible although I still think extremely rare.

Wheredoallthepensgo · 02/11/2022 20:08

Wow what a backstabbing nasty piece of work she is.

I keep hearing Sister Michael from Derry Girls saying "I think we've all lost a bit of respect for you now Claire" while reading this - hey "friend" everyone that was there and everyone (apart from an odd bod) on this thread now know what you're really like!

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 02/11/2022 19:38

What a bitch.

I have an acquaintance like that op

Totally ours people or belittles people whilst pretending to not realise how uncomfortable it would make people feel.

Nasty spiteful way to behave

Step back from the toxic op

withgraceinmyheart · 02/11/2022 19:33

Yanbu, I’ve recognised someone before and I would absolutely never bring it up.

redstararnie76 · 02/11/2022 19:32

It’s a horrible thing for her to have done. I’m trying hard to think of anything she might think could possibly justify it!

Was there anything negative in your original post that she might have interpreted as being about her? Difficult friend or anything like that?
Even so, it doesn’t excuse her, but just might make her slightly less of a bitch?

OldFan · 02/11/2022 19:32

That's really mean of her. Sad Hugs OP xx

Somefriend0 · 02/11/2022 19:29

VladmirsPoutine · 02/11/2022 18:59

I haven't read the whole thread but surely the thing to have done is just deny and make her look like the mad one. Turn back to her as in why would you be posting on mumsnet sort of thing. She can't explicitly prove its you unless she has your phone/laptop at hand and shows everyone your account.

I've recognised one person here because the thread details were so specific to the event but the interesting thing was that she completely twisted what had actually happened so she wouldn't be seen as unreasonable. I sometimes respond to her comments on other threads though Grin

I denied it but I'm a terrible liar and I think my embarrassment was probably obvious.

OP posts:
Mandyjack · 02/11/2022 19:29

She should've discussed it with you in private that's very humiliating for her to do that

Swipe left for the next trending thread