Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised that so many people have separate finances?

266 replies

PlumPudd · 01/11/2022 11:22

DP and I pretty much share out the paying of our costs, with perhaps a bit of accounting for the fact that we’re on different incomes. The main costs, mortgage, bills, shopping, childcare etc. we broadly split by income, so we have direct debits set up and DP pays a bit more than me. For more discretionary things like clothes, meals out, toiletries, memberships etc. we sometimes pay for our own and sometimes get for both, for example the Amazon account is in DP’s name and we both just get things from there when needed. If I’m doing a clothes shop from H&M DP will add a few bits and I’ll just pay to save on the cost of two deliveries.

Savings are also seen as broadly common e.g. we’re about to move and I’m putting in a bit more than DP just because I’ve ended up with more in the bank, and DP covered some other big costs from their account earlier in the year.

We don’t really keep count, or get pissed off if one pays for more than the other on a particular month as we see the money as our shared money, that’s financing our shared life, regardless of whose income it originally came out of. DP also doesn’t expect me to spend less on discretionary things because my income is a bit lower. It probably helps that neither of us has exorbitant hobbies and that we have a broadly similar view of what’s reasonable to spend on what.

I thought until recently that this is how most couples were, (assuming they are in a committed and happy relationship - different if things are rocky of course) but a few friends have been quite shocked and said that no, they keep their finances very separate. And pay 50 50 or some other carefully calculated split for shared cost like rent / mortgage and then pay for everything else out of their own salary and have their own savings.

So what do you do and why?

OP posts:
DaphneduM · 01/11/2022 15:47

We're in our sixties and have been married over 25 years. Always had separate finances and it works for us. I just pay a direct debit monthly to my husband's account for roughly half the bills. We are most definitely a team. Sometimes he pays restaurant bills, sometimes me. Likewise house repairs, car servicing etc. It roughly works itself out and neither of us stress about the small stuff. But separate accounts are important for me regarding the big stuff - we have our own savings and I would never sacrifice my financial autonomy, nor would my husband expect it. When we moved house a few years ago we ended up with some surplus equity which we split 50/50 into our separate savings. While he's a brilliant step-dad, I feel responsible for my daughter and it was me who paid for her wedding, and gave her a sizeable deposit for their house. I've also done other stuff for her during an expensive time for them paying childcare. Money is never an issue for us and has never caused arguments. Our savings are similar amounts, as are our pensions income. It works well - no reason to change it.

Hbh17 · 01/11/2022 15:45

Been married over 30 years & never had a joint account. Just agree who pays for what, which can vary, & then basically never need to discuss money again. So simple & straightforward - I genuinely couldn't be bothered with all the negotiating some people seem to do. Plus it gives both of us a measure of independence, which is so important.

glassfully · 01/11/2022 15:40

I think it's a bit odd that you have separate accounts but then buy for each other. Most couples have joint accounts or a joint one for household and personal one for themselves.

I don't chase my DP if I pick him something up from the shops on my way home but we do pay each other back for bigger purchases like clothes or Amazon orders. Otherwise we may as well have joint accounts.

startfresh · 01/11/2022 15:39

MandalayFray · 01/11/2022 11:27

I personally think it’s a generational thing, the only people I know with ‘family’ money are older couples. Which is also why it’s a bit of a ‘thing’ on MN (as most posters on AIBU for example are 55-75)

I don’t know one couple under 35 that does this, finances are kept separate and joint expenses are split (either 50:50 or dependent on salary %)

I think the attitude of joint money comes from times where one parent didn’t work, or worked PT.

Under 35 and we have one account where we get paid into. We get a little amount each month transferred into our own accounts for Christmas and birthday presents if we need to. Everything else comes from joint account.

luxxlisbon · 01/11/2022 15:21

QforCucumber · 01/11/2022 15:16

@luxxlisbon explained it much better than me, it's not about having to justify it - DH has no care in the world if I come home with new boots, or say I met a friend for lunch while at work - Vice versa, but knowing I can just do this as there's money in my account without having to think about what's due to come out in the next week or 2 or check what bills are due, for us just works.

Maybe this is because our earnings are pretty much on a par with each other, but while we are paying out £1200 a month in childcare fees the leftovers after bills do have to be kept an eye on - having our own accounts allows us each to know what we are able to spend each month, without have to do a reconciliation before deciding if we can afford that new coat or not this month.

Same.
If I look at the joint on day 1 it’s easy to think ‘wow there so much money I can do whatever I want with it’, but then £1500 comes out for the mortgage, and then bills and then £1000 for childcare at the end of the month etc.
With my personal spending money in a separate account it’s easy to see and say ‘slow your roll moneybags, you’ve actually only got £150 left for the rest of the month to spend on shit you don’t need without dipping into money earmarked for savings’.

QforCucumber · 01/11/2022 15:20

@DontMakeMeShushYou also completely this What is kind of sad is people thinking that others who choose to make different arrangements don't have such strong marriages or aren't such strong teams.

how many threads on here a week of women who want to leave but have 0 access to separate money - neither relationship is stronger because of how finances are arranged.

I was raised with a SAHM and a dad with a single joint account, he questioned every penny she spent, justifying why she bought the more expensive school shoes when there were some £10 cheaper. Maybe that's why I do not ever wish to be in a similar position.

mrsmacmc · 01/11/2022 15:16

Separate and pay X amount into the house account. It would make me overthink too much if we pooled money.

QforCucumber · 01/11/2022 15:16

@luxxlisbon explained it much better than me, it's not about having to justify it - DH has no care in the world if I come home with new boots, or say I met a friend for lunch while at work - Vice versa, but knowing I can just do this as there's money in my account without having to think about what's due to come out in the next week or 2 or check what bills are due, for us just works.

Maybe this is because our earnings are pretty much on a par with each other, but while we are paying out £1200 a month in childcare fees the leftovers after bills do have to be kept an eye on - having our own accounts allows us each to know what we are able to spend each month, without have to do a reconciliation before deciding if we can afford that new coat or not this month.

ChickpeaPie · 01/11/2022 15:15

What a weird thread, OP you have split finances.
We have joint current account and joint savings account. Everything goes into it, everything comes out from it. Neither of us questions the other ones spending.

Medoca · 01/11/2022 15:10

MavisChunch29 · 01/11/2022 14:16

Also if everything is joint and both have access to the account, how do you buy the other person a gift and surprise them? If they look at the account they will know exactly where it is from and how much you spent. Or that at least you have drawn cash out to a certain value.

We have our own credit cards that are paid off in full every month from the joint account. So by the time the money comes out, the gift has already been received. We’re not really the type to quibble about who spends what, we have similar spending habits and it’s never been an issue.

AMorningstar · 01/11/2022 15:07

MandaLynn · 01/11/2022 14:55

sometimes I Fancy coffee and cake, or buying myself something new without having to explain it.

Our finances are shared and I would never feel the need to explain what I'm spending. Nor would I expect DH to explain if he wanted a new jumper, some coffee, whatever. Big purchases are discussed, but not day to day spending

Same. It's weird people think they'd have to justify normal daily purchases from a joimt account, I said earlier that DH and I don't even look at what each other buys generally.

If we were buying a sofa or something then yeah but otherwise we're both free to use the money

luxxlisbon · 01/11/2022 15:06

FamilyTreeBuilder · 01/11/2022 14:58

If you feel that you have to explain the fact you've got a coffee and a cake when out with friends, you have bigger issues than money.

I am meeting a friend for lunch in town tomorrow. DH's response when I mentioned my plans was "ooh nice, where are you going" rather than "what are you going to spend?

To me it’s not about justifying, it’s about keeping money for bills, saving and spending separate for budgeting/saving reasons.

So we have 95% of our money in a joint / joint savings but for me it’s easier to have my ‘own’ card with my ‘own’ money while going out to dinner with a friend or shopping after work. That way I know there is £300 to blow on a jacket rather than spending money on the joint that is actually due to come out on a DD in a weeks time.

We don’t just leave our whole salary in the joint, we save straight away rather than saving what’s left over. ‘Frivolous’ money being separate just makes that quick and easy to do.

reigatecastle · 01/11/2022 15:01

DH and I are our own people and want to spend our own money. We pay into a joint account for bills and work out other things between us like holidays and meals out etc. At the moment he pays more towards the bills because I pay ds' rent for his room at university.

I would hate to have a joint account and have DH seeing everything I buy. It's up to me once the bills are paid.

And paying for presents by cash doesn't really work when you order things online.

We've been married nearly 25 years by the way, so no lack of commitment!

DontMakeMeShushYou · 01/11/2022 15:00

Oblomov22 · 01/11/2022 13:51

Actually I think it's kind of sad. Fir this new generation. For joint to not be the norm. As a real unit why not have joint. Who cares who earns the most, put it all together and pay all out of it. And you can have your own aswell. Is it because they are all assuming that marriage is short term rather than long term?

I think people make assumptions about what is the norm based on their own and their parents' choices. My parents were married for well over 50 years, until they both passed away, and they lived their married life perfectly happily with separate finances. Of course they were a "real unit". And no, clearly they didn't assume that marriage was a short term thing.
Exactly the same as DH and I, who are still perfectly happy with keeping separate accounts after 25 years.

What is kind of sad is people thinking that others who choose to make different arrangements don't have such strong marriages or aren't such strong teams. Why do you feel the need to believe that your marriage is stronger because of the way you organise your finances? Why do you think your marriage would be weaker if you separated your finances? What is it about your partner's or your own character that means that separate finances would suddenly become inherently unfair?

thecatsthecats · 01/11/2022 15:00

Motherhubbardscupboard · 01/11/2022 13:13

What is the point in having separate finances if you're married? You're not much of a team if one person can afford to go on holiday and the other can't, or if one can retire and the other can't. And if you split, it will be considered joint money anyway. I really don't understand why people bother to faff around deciding how much they should each contribute. Just have a joint account! (However for unmarried couples I agree, better to keep it separate, although you do read some horror stories about how the make partner won't support the female when she's on mat leave etc)

Lol at the idea that separate finances means that you're not a team.

You're also overlooking the fact that some couples earn enough that their joint contributions can comfortably cover everything whilst leaving the rest separate.

We jointly agree what is spent from shared funds and we don't interfere with separate disposable income.

Take for example, a holiday we're having next year for a friend's foreign wedding. It's looking a bit expensive, and we've agreed a budget from the joint expenses, and are hoping to get a deal. I might be pregnant then. If it costs more, I'd skip it on principle, but my husband is happy to pay the excess. Or he might go alone.

I think that's perfectly good teamwork and negotiation around shared assets personally.

LilSebastiann · 01/11/2022 14:59

Also sometimes one half of a couple is simply horrendous with money and you'd be mad to share a bank account with them.

FamilyTreeBuilder · 01/11/2022 14:58

If you feel that you have to explain the fact you've got a coffee and a cake when out with friends, you have bigger issues than money.

I am meeting a friend for lunch in town tomorrow. DH's response when I mentioned my plans was "ooh nice, where are you going" rather than "what are you going to spend?

LilSebastiann · 01/11/2022 14:57

My parents share finances. My Mum stopped working forever when I was kid. I don't think this was discussed properly. I think my Mum feels trapped and my Dad at times resents her for it.

Because of this I resolved to always be financially independent and also have control over my earned money. Me and my partner discussed financial attitudes prior to moving in and think splitting bills and then having our own money is the best way to reduce any resentment. I earn more so I will buy big purchases (holiday, new washer) but they key is I OFFERED this he does not expect it. I will also help him out on non-frivolous costs if he is going to struggle i.e. car repairs.

We review money somewhat often and check in if we still feel the arrangement is fair / is working based on current circumstances.

I think it is nice to share finances completely but as a couple I don't think it would work for us.

MandaLynn · 01/11/2022 14:55

sometimes I Fancy coffee and cake, or buying myself something new without having to explain it.

Our finances are shared and I would never feel the need to explain what I'm spending. Nor would I expect DH to explain if he wanted a new jumper, some coffee, whatever. Big purchases are discussed, but not day to day spending

luxxlisbon · 01/11/2022 14:47

How can someone not want every single penny of their income not to be used to help 'the family'. I couldnt look my children in the eye if i worked that way

You couldn’t look at yourself in the eye of every single penny didn’t go to them/the family??
So you don’t think it’s acceptable to treat yourself to a coffee, new shoes, have your nails done, meet with friends for dinner??

QforCucumber · 01/11/2022 14:47

Why be married if you're not a team We are an absolute team, but sometimes I Fancy coffee and cake, or buying myself something new without having to explain it. I couldn't agree more with the present thing, or surprising each other now and again - DH will buy me the odd bunch of flowers, my engagement ring cost £1800 - I'd have definitely noticed that disappear from a joint account.

We a sole account each for whatever we wish, and a joint account for everything else - bills, childcare, groceries, mortgage. We know that all necessary bills are paid without having to even think about it (standing orders on payday into that account)

Our owns accounts are to do with as we please, DH buys a pack of golf balls or I'm buying a yoga mat it's just easy. We've been together 12 years and its always been like this, we know each other's income, we have each other's pin numbers etc it's not secretive - it works.

Moknicker · 01/11/2022 14:47

DH and I have combined finances except for tax purposes.
I dont know anyone else in our peer group who does that. Split finances are the norm.
Im early 50s - been married since we were in our thirties. We both work although i was a SAHM for 5 years in between.

FamilyTreeBuilder · 01/11/2022 14:47

We've never had separate finances really. When we were renting with other people in a house share we did, when we bought our first property we opened a joint account, for a while I paid from my account into the joint and he did the same, eventually it got too much of a faff, we both closed our individual accounts and everything went joint.

Dh earns 10 or 20 times what I earn, this has fluctuated over the years as I am self-employed but definitely at the moment as i'm studying too. We do have money under individual names - i have a pension in my name only, we have ISAs which you can't hold jointly, and I have a chunk of premium bonds which can't be held jointly either. But we are both well aware of where all the money is.

Thymely · 01/11/2022 14:41

We used to have a mixture of joint accounts and separate accounts, eventually ditched the joint accounts and now split expenses, not particularly evenly probably, but doesn't matter. I guess we are better off now than we were so not so much need to keep track of our income/expenditure by using a joint account. I would hate having to explain some slightly extravagant purchase made off a joint account, or taking money for presents from one.

MavisChunch29 · 01/11/2022 14:35

Financial abuse happens because one partner is a twat, whether the accounts are joint or otherwise. One of the key things for success of a long term relationship is being on the same page where money is concerned. That doesn't mean you earn the same amount as the other person but you have a very similar attitude to saving and spending.

So what is important, with all of these posts about what works and doesn't work, for couples is that regardless of whether finances are totally separate, partly joint or wholly joint then that arrangement works for that particular couple.

There is no objective right and wrong when it comes to joint or separate finances but there is when it comes to financial abuse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread