Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised that so many people have separate finances?

266 replies

PlumPudd · 01/11/2022 11:22

DP and I pretty much share out the paying of our costs, with perhaps a bit of accounting for the fact that we’re on different incomes. The main costs, mortgage, bills, shopping, childcare etc. we broadly split by income, so we have direct debits set up and DP pays a bit more than me. For more discretionary things like clothes, meals out, toiletries, memberships etc. we sometimes pay for our own and sometimes get for both, for example the Amazon account is in DP’s name and we both just get things from there when needed. If I’m doing a clothes shop from H&M DP will add a few bits and I’ll just pay to save on the cost of two deliveries.

Savings are also seen as broadly common e.g. we’re about to move and I’m putting in a bit more than DP just because I’ve ended up with more in the bank, and DP covered some other big costs from their account earlier in the year.

We don’t really keep count, or get pissed off if one pays for more than the other on a particular month as we see the money as our shared money, that’s financing our shared life, regardless of whose income it originally came out of. DP also doesn’t expect me to spend less on discretionary things because my income is a bit lower. It probably helps that neither of us has exorbitant hobbies and that we have a broadly similar view of what’s reasonable to spend on what.

I thought until recently that this is how most couples were, (assuming they are in a committed and happy relationship - different if things are rocky of course) but a few friends have been quite shocked and said that no, they keep their finances very separate. And pay 50 50 or some other carefully calculated split for shared cost like rent / mortgage and then pay for everything else out of their own salary and have their own savings.

So what do you do and why?

OP posts:
Swonderful · 02/11/2022 19:42

cptartapp · 01/11/2022 11:52

We pay into a joint pot proportionate to earnings. So DH earns five times what I earn and puts five times into the pot for our shared and child related expenses.
He is a spender and I a saver. That way as long as he's paid his share he can spend the remainder of his salary however he wants. No need to ever discuss or run anything past each other.

Doesn't that mean he has 5 times as much spending money?

StripeyMow · 02/11/2022 19:38

Blossomtoes · 02/11/2022 18:43

The first version works fine if neither of you are selfish arseholes.

Absolutely agree. If your partner happily sees you go without, then the issue is with them. However you decide to budget, you should both agree what you consider fair terms.

BiasedBinding · 02/11/2022 19:38

StripeyMow · 02/11/2022 19:30

Whatever works for your family is the best way, not everyone is good at budgeting, not everyone has to budget.

In my household we have separate accounts, DH earns more so pays a bit more than I do in terms of household bills and we share the cost of family holidays. We then each have money remaining to pay our own expenses (Mobiles, subscriptions, hobbies etc.) We know what each other earns and sat down and did the joint costings early on, so there is no duplicity in this, but it does give you some financial freedom. Just because you’re married you don’t stop being an individual. If you are lucky enough to have some excess why not have access to your ‘own’ money so you can treat yourself or each other. It doesn’t make you less of a team or bonkers as some have stated 🙄 Do what’s best for you

You say “do what’s best for you” but there is clear judgement in your “financial freedom” comments there.

StripeyMow · 02/11/2022 19:30

Whatever works for your family is the best way, not everyone is good at budgeting, not everyone has to budget.

In my household we have separate accounts, DH earns more so pays a bit more than I do in terms of household bills and we share the cost of family holidays. We then each have money remaining to pay our own expenses (Mobiles, subscriptions, hobbies etc.) We know what each other earns and sat down and did the joint costings early on, so there is no duplicity in this, but it does give you some financial freedom. Just because you’re married you don’t stop being an individual. If you are lucky enough to have some excess why not have access to your ‘own’ money so you can treat yourself or each other. It doesn’t make you less of a team or bonkers as some have stated 🙄 Do what’s best for you

Medoca · 02/11/2022 18:47

We have a joint account, wouldn’t bother me in terms of money if one wanted to spend £4k on a holiday, I’d be more pissed of they didn’t ask as I’d be doing the childcare if they went away. So in that respect we’d consult with each other. If one of us wanted to spend £4k on a purchase which didn’t involve childcare, neither of us would have an issue. Also, why are you using your current account for large purchases. Use your credit card, at least then if something goes wrong it’s much easier to claim.

Blossomtoes · 02/11/2022 18:43

howdoyougethingsdone · 02/11/2022 18:36

A friend's husband earns substantially more than her. They split all bills. She can't easily afford to go on holiday whilst he can! He has lots of spare money and she has none.

Another friend and her husband just have a joint account that both their salaries are paid into, all bills come out of, and what is left technically belongs to both of them. They buy what they want out of this but discuss very big purchases.

I think the second option works best.

The first version works fine if neither of you are selfish arseholes.

user1471452428 · 02/11/2022 18:41

I don't know- do you really believe this? Although I can think of many practical reasons for separate finances, the idea of a family with children doing this rigmarole of moving money about - even worse if mention is made of "spends" (shudder) - seems so wrong. I can't put my finger on it; it's almost like you can share a home, a life, even children, but money comes above all this. That is what it feels like to me.

howdoyougethingsdone · 02/11/2022 18:36

A friend's husband earns substantially more than her. They split all bills. She can't easily afford to go on holiday whilst he can! He has lots of spare money and she has none.

Another friend and her husband just have a joint account that both their salaries are paid into, all bills come out of, and what is left technically belongs to both of them. They buy what they want out of this but discuss very big purchases.

I think the second option works best.

CFLandlordStory · 02/11/2022 18:34

Early 30s and joint account
We also have our own accounts for equal spending money (which we would use to buy each other gifts)
We both have our own savings accounts which hold our fuck off funds that we had before our relationship.

Roselilly36 · 02/11/2022 18:23

DH & I have been married 28 years, we have never had a joint bank account, and neither would I.

BiasedBinding · 02/11/2022 18:18

alwaysmovingforwards · 02/11/2022 13:13

@MandalayFray

It's easy to make these decisions either together or independently.

Either:
"I'm going away that weekend"
<cost not discussed>
"Ok, have fun!"

Or:
"Seen this holiday, fancy going together?"
"How much?"
"£2k each"
"Yes, I'll ping you the money, please boom it!" or "No, not for me, but don't let that stop you if you want to check it out".

How complicated do some people make things?!?

It’s genuinely hilarious how niche that is

“I can’t possibly share finances because I wouldn’t be able to book holidays without discussion with my partner”

Grin
BiasedBinding · 02/11/2022 18:17

ChristmasCurry · 02/11/2022 13:24

When I first got married, we were in the Halifax BS and there was a middle-aged guy in there crying his eyes out - his wife had left him and emptied out all their joint accounts and he had nothing to live on.

We have always had separate accounts from that day but do have some joint savings accounts.

There are risks associated with both ways of doing things, everyone knows that.

I worked with a woman whose husband forced her to pay half of all the bills and everything for the baby throughout her maternity leave, including when she was on statutory pay. He earned a lot more than her. My husband and I decided on shared finances when we decided to have children.

mast0650 · 02/11/2022 14:30

We've had entirely shared finances ((no separate bank accounts) ever since I came back from doing a PhD abroad (already married and pregnant at that point). Obvoiusly before then I need my own bank account in the country where I was living, but DH paid for most things when we were together as he earned much more than my student grant. He was also already paying all the costs of the house that I then moved into full time. At that point I saw no reason not to just pay the salary I started earning into the common pot (his bank account became a joint account). To be honest, I didn't even consider it an option to keep my money separate, perhaps because my parents always had entirely joint money - and also used to laugh a little at my grandmother asking my grandfather for 99p for some shoe polish she'd bought for his shoes, as she was given her own housekeeping/allowance money.

Clearly different systems work for different people and there is no right or wrong. The only thing I find a bit odd is when couples obsess about fine details of who owes whom for small amounts of money. But then I don't even do that with my family or friends. I also feel that in a couple both partners should normally have equal access and influence over money, so any system that leaves one partner with more than the other (eg where a higher earning partner puts the same amount or the same income share into a common household pot) feels wrong to me. It also seems inconvenient to have to keep adjusting shares of household costs every time circumstances change. DH has at times earned quite a lot more than me, but I have now slightly overtaken him and that gap will get bigger as he moves towards retirement before me. I could imagine that if budgeting is an issue then it could be helpful to give each partner their own (equal) discretionary spends once household costs have been taken out. We're extremely lucky that our tastes and spending habits have always run cheaper than our income so we've never felt any real financial constraints. We rarely discuss money or expenditure at all. Except in the context of eg building work on the house. I realise that isn't entirely normal. As for the "how do you buy gifts" argument? The gift isn't the expenditure, it's the thought and the time that goes into it. And I've almost never spotted exactly what the gift is in advance by spotting an item on the bank account. Definitely not worth overhauling entire financial arrangements for!

ChristmasCurry · 02/11/2022 13:24

When I first got married, we were in the Halifax BS and there was a middle-aged guy in there crying his eyes out - his wife had left him and emptied out all their joint accounts and he had nothing to live on.

We have always had separate accounts from that day but do have some joint savings accounts.

alwaysmovingforwards · 02/11/2022 13:13

@MandalayFray

It's easy to make these decisions either together or independently.

Either:
"I'm going away that weekend"
<cost not discussed>
"Ok, have fun!"

Or:
"Seen this holiday, fancy going together?"
"How much?"
"£2k each"
"Yes, I'll ping you the money, please boom it!" or "No, not for me, but don't let that stop you if you want to check it out".

How complicated do some people make things?!?

BiasedBinding · 01/11/2022 20:20

MandalayFray · 01/11/2022 16:25

I don’t understand how those with joint finances can make big purchases but also on the same hand say they don’t need to speak to their partner about it.

I booked an additional holiday on a whim last week, that was £4k, if I had paid that from a mysterious joint account how would I not have to speak to DH about that before doing it, as what if he also spent a few grand at the same time.

Seems so unnecessarily complicated.

same applies to gifts, it’s so much easier to just transfer a set amount into a joint account than faffing with paying pocket money out from a joint pot etc.

I’ve never said we don’t talk about it. We would absolutely discuss a £4k holiday, whoever was taking it.

but we also have very small children so booking things on a whim without discussion is less of a thing generally at this stage in our lives.

It’s just as easy to transfer a small amount (automatically setup in fact) from a joint account that wages are all paid into as it is to transfer money paid into separate accounts to somewhere joint.

I have never said everyone should do the same as me and I am fully aware it won’t work for everyone, but you are saying that other people doing something different to you doesn’t make sense, when clearly it does just as much as your way

PinkiOcelot · 01/11/2022 19:06

You’ve got separate finances OP.

Ponderingwindow · 01/11/2022 19:06

Whether the money is in separate or joint accounts, if we are making a large purchase, we check in with one another. DH and I are a complete financial unit, but because of our age and because we both have jobs, pensions, and life histories, we have many accounts of many types. Some of those are joint, some of them are not. Whenever one of us makes a significant financial decision, we discuss that decision.

For example, DH just got a large bonus. We sat down over lunch and decided how to make sure it was used wisely. DH got something he had been wanting for quite some time, we bought dd a nice Christmas gift, I didn’t want anything because I already got very spoiled recently, and we invested the bulk of the money in two long term accounts of equal size, one in each of our names. We had researched what type of investment to make and made that decision together.

MandalayFray · 01/11/2022 18:52

Simonjt · 01/11/2022 17:14

Why couldn’t you spend it at the same time? If you have the money and the mortgage etc is covered, why couldn’t one of you book a holiday and the other on something else they fancy? If you can afford it with a joint account, you can afford it without surely, you have the same family income afterall.

Because the money might not be in there?

We invest a lot, so having all our disposable income sitting in a single account wouldn’t be beneficial, but it would have to be, as what if on the same day DH wanted to spend £7k on something and used the joint account without having a look or checking first.

It’s so much easier knowing how much is there and only needing to care about how much of that pot I am planning to spend. Then wondering if DH is also planning to use the pot.

Blip · 01/11/2022 18:31

I'd say you have separate finances OP.
To me shared finances means all income is paid into a joint account and all savings accounts are joint.

DP and I have no joint accounts. We have our own assets, investments and savings. We have been together for 25 years so effectively it's all family money and we make big financial decisions together, but our finances are separate.

MrsMontyD · 01/11/2022 17:51

InstaHun88 · 01/11/2022 16:16

I think if you have ever experienced a long term relationship breaking down, you will be a lot more careful in the future. Most people are a lot more aware nowadays that relationships often don't last a lifetime.

I think if you're coming into a relationship (living together) when you're both older, you've been married before, you both have assets, you have dc that aren't shared etc. etc. it's different to two people setting up home together in their 20s and starting a family.I'm not going to start, at my age, discussing all my purchases with anyone, I'm also not going to start tracking DPs spending, to make sure there's enough to cover bills.

We'll agree what's an appropriate amount for us both to contribute to a bills account and a savings account and the rest will stay in personal accounts.

PlumPudd · 01/11/2022 17:48

DotDotaDash · 01/11/2022 16:59

Well you seem to think because you don’t keep tabs that’s a good thing? It jus shows you are each comfortable with you own total spend at the moment.

Your chilled out attitude could come back to bite you if you apply it to rental contracts, house purchases etc if you ever split. or if either of the you ever become a SAHP when it will feel very different.

So my question is should one of you be out of work for 12 months, you for example as you buy the clothes - would no one have new clothes? Or DP would you just not pay the bills? Would you expect paying back when DP earning again?

I think it also shows that we’re happy with the others’ total spend. Yes we don’t keep tabs on amounts going out, but if DP’s habits suddenly became very extravagant or vice versa the other would notice and probably instigate a conversation.

An example of this is that DP used to like to offer to pick up the bill when we were out with friends for dinner. After a few times of this I asked why, and DP thought about it and said it was polite and generous and what their dad used to do, so it just felt like the right way to end a meal. That it felt awkward not to offer. I asked whether DP’s parents friends did the same (aka picked up the whole bill sometimes), and DP said they did and thought it was a bit rude that our friends didn’t. I said it was probably just different expectations, and that as our friends weren’t reciprocating, could DP restrict the offers to get the whole bill just to someone’s birthday or for a special treat, and DP said it’d still feel odd as not what they grew up with but that as our friends clearly all didn’t feel this way, yes offers to treat people would only come on birthdays etc.

To answer your question about what we’d do if one of us was out of work for 12 months. We’d have a conversation and decide together what to cut back on. I think letting the one still in work continue to have treats and new things while making the other scrimp would be pretty mean and quickly lead to resentments. Unless the one not in work was making no effort to find work, but that would be a larger problem.

I think if one of us became a SAHP we’d do the same and make it a shared decision and a shared cost. After all, whichever one was parenting, would be raising our kid, not off on a jolly.

OP posts:
DontMakeMeShushYou · 01/11/2022 17:30

@DotDotaDash So my question is should one of you be out of work for 12 months, you for example as you buy the clothes - would no one have new clothes? Or DP would you just not pay the bills? Would you expect paying back when DP earning again?

I can probably answer this since I've said we have completely separate finances and don't really keep tabs or work out who spends the most. Obviously you just make some adjustments. A few years ago I took a temporary 50% pay cut. DH just automatically took on paying for a few more bits and transferred some extra money over to me each month as the mortgage comes out of my account. We didn't sit down with bits of paper and a calculator. He just said do you need me to give you a bit extra money while you're not working so much? Is x amount enough?
As simple as that.

Simonjt · 01/11/2022 17:14

MandalayFray · 01/11/2022 16:25

I don’t understand how those with joint finances can make big purchases but also on the same hand say they don’t need to speak to their partner about it.

I booked an additional holiday on a whim last week, that was £4k, if I had paid that from a mysterious joint account how would I not have to speak to DH about that before doing it, as what if he also spent a few grand at the same time.

Seems so unnecessarily complicated.

same applies to gifts, it’s so much easier to just transfer a set amount into a joint account than faffing with paying pocket money out from a joint pot etc.

Why couldn’t you spend it at the same time? If you have the money and the mortgage etc is covered, why couldn’t one of you book a holiday and the other on something else they fancy? If you can afford it with a joint account, you can afford it without surely, you have the same family income afterall.

mydogisthebest · 01/11/2022 17:03

I think a joint account also works well for us as neither of us are really spenders.

I rarely buy clothes and when I do it is usually from a charity shop. I do buy books sometimes but, again, often from charity shops or else from Amazon as they are usually the cheapest.