Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised that so many people have separate finances?

266 replies

PlumPudd · 01/11/2022 11:22

DP and I pretty much share out the paying of our costs, with perhaps a bit of accounting for the fact that we’re on different incomes. The main costs, mortgage, bills, shopping, childcare etc. we broadly split by income, so we have direct debits set up and DP pays a bit more than me. For more discretionary things like clothes, meals out, toiletries, memberships etc. we sometimes pay for our own and sometimes get for both, for example the Amazon account is in DP’s name and we both just get things from there when needed. If I’m doing a clothes shop from H&M DP will add a few bits and I’ll just pay to save on the cost of two deliveries.

Savings are also seen as broadly common e.g. we’re about to move and I’m putting in a bit more than DP just because I’ve ended up with more in the bank, and DP covered some other big costs from their account earlier in the year.

We don’t really keep count, or get pissed off if one pays for more than the other on a particular month as we see the money as our shared money, that’s financing our shared life, regardless of whose income it originally came out of. DP also doesn’t expect me to spend less on discretionary things because my income is a bit lower. It probably helps that neither of us has exorbitant hobbies and that we have a broadly similar view of what’s reasonable to spend on what.

I thought until recently that this is how most couples were, (assuming they are in a committed and happy relationship - different if things are rocky of course) but a few friends have been quite shocked and said that no, they keep their finances very separate. And pay 50 50 or some other carefully calculated split for shared cost like rent / mortgage and then pay for everything else out of their own salary and have their own savings.

So what do you do and why?

OP posts:
AuntieMarys · 01/11/2022 11:59

We have separate bank accounts ( in our 60s) ...each pay certain bills.
We have a joint credit card for holidays/ meals out/ drinking plus separate ones for personal use. Works for us.

sst1234 · 01/11/2022 11:58

It’s a generational thing. And as another poster said, it’s based on modern couples having two incomes and works mostly in favour of women. Financial independence is the most important thing and if women can more of it by being fully in control of their own income, that’s a good thing.

Polkadotties · 01/11/2022 11:57

meateatingveggie · 01/11/2022 11:51

Everything joint since we got married 40 years ago.

We're married. We're a team.

My husband and I are a team. Doesn’t mean we need to share finances though. We pay for our bills in a way which suits us and then whatever is left is our own money.

Halloweenshock · 01/11/2022 11:57

Late 30s. We just put both salaries in a joint account moving any excess to a joint saving account. Doing it any other way sounds like a monumental hassle. Neither of us has our own money. It probably helps that we trust each other 100%.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 01/11/2022 11:57

MandalayFray · 01/11/2022 11:27

I personally think it’s a generational thing, the only people I know with ‘family’ money are older couples. Which is also why it’s a bit of a ‘thing’ on MN (as most posters on AIBU for example are 55-75)

I don’t know one couple under 35 that does this, finances are kept separate and joint expenses are split (either 50:50 or dependent on salary %)

I think the attitude of joint money comes from times where one parent didn’t work, or worked PT.

Most posters are 55-75? Where did you get that from?

Noviembre · 01/11/2022 11:57

Joint accounts can be cleaned out by the first person who wants to be a dick.

Trust no one. My accounts and my money are my own. Always have secret accounts. Always have savings. Never put your finances in someone else's hands.

Bananamaman · 01/11/2022 11:55

I think the number of posts on here about separate finances probably misrepresent the reality- there are endless posts about couples trying to keep things separate and pay only their own share while simultaneously one parent has gone PT or is paying all child-related expenses etc. I don't think that necessarily means this is a common arrangement, only that it's an arrangement that gives rise to problems that people then post about.

We pool everything. Our big decisions about money (such as buying houses, retirement planning etc) are made jointly so it wouldn't work well to keep things separate. And generally speaking, I think separate finances often cause problems unless you earn very similar amounts (how do you go on holiday if one of you has a budget of £20k and the other £20?) and if you're earning similar amounts why not just pool it and save a load of admin?

sst1234 · 01/11/2022 11:55

BIWI · 01/11/2022 11:36

Nice bit of casual ageism there, @MandalayFray Hmm

We're in our 60s, married 30+ years and we've always had separate finances.

We have a joint account that we both pay into, the same amount each, for all household expenses. The rest is our own money.

We do this because we have very different attitudes to money. DH hates the idea of being overdrawn whereas I'm much more relaxed. If we had tried to pool everything, we would have been long-since divorced!

It’s not ageism, it’s an observation. Stop trying to be a victim.

iratepirate · 01/11/2022 11:55

Married and we have a joint account which we pay an amount into each month to cover all bills and household expenses. We also both add the same amount to savings each month. Other than that our remaining money is in our own accounts and kept separate to do with as we wish. We both work but earn quite different salaries.

Medoca · 01/11/2022 11:53

wemovedfromthere · 01/11/2022 11:40

Maybe we are the exception that proves the rule but we are mid-thirties and everything is joint. All of our bills come from a joint account and our savings are joint too.

We’ve been married nearly ten years and over that time have worked various working patterns and earned different amounts and it’s always been the same.

Yes same for us. When we bought our house, we just put all wages into a joint account. We buy what we want from it, would probably consult on purchases over £1k, but neither of us has ever been bothered by each other’s spending. We have a similar attitude to money so that help. I just could’ve bothered with the faff, especially when we had children and took parental leave. Friends our age who’ve married or have children do the same. I can only think of one couple that don’t, but they’re not married and they both own separate properties.

cptartapp · 01/11/2022 11:52

We pay into a joint pot proportionate to earnings. So DH earns five times what I earn and puts five times into the pot for our shared and child related expenses.
He is a spender and I a saver. That way as long as he's paid his share he can spend the remainder of his salary however he wants. No need to ever discuss or run anything past each other.

MandalayFray · 01/11/2022 11:52

notmyrealmoniker · 01/11/2022 11:49

@MandalayFray

personally think it’s a generational thing, the only people I know with ‘family’ money are older couples. Which is also why it’s a bit of a ‘thing’ on MN (as most posters on AIBU for example are 55-75)

On what precisely do you base that generalisation?

Maybe if you read my comment you’ll understand

I clearly state - the only people I KNOW

Plus combined with it being common on AIBU (where the base of posters are older) adds to my PERSONAL view.

meateatingveggie · 01/11/2022 11:51

Everything joint since we got married 40 years ago.

We're married. We're a team.

Colinthecaterpillar35 · 01/11/2022 11:50

Lates 30s and we have a joint account where both salaries go in and all bills/spending comes out. I earn nearly 3 times as much as DH but I see it as just a pot of money for us both; we're married with one DS and my money is his and his money is mine. My parents have always lived this way so to me it seemed the norm to do this. I never realised how many people keep things so separate even when married.

Hankunamatata · 01/11/2022 11:50

We have transparency but completely separate finances. If dh walked tomorrow I'd be OK and visa versa.

notmyrealmoniker · 01/11/2022 11:49

@MandalayFray

personally think it’s a generational thing, the only people I know with ‘family’ money are older couples. Which is also why it’s a bit of a ‘thing’ on MN (as most posters on AIBU for example are 55-75)

On what precisely do you base that generalisation?

MandalayFray · 01/11/2022 11:48

BIWI · 01/11/2022 11:42

Yes. Ageism is attributing a specific behaviour to a general sector of the population.

That’s not what ageism means

here you go, from age uk -

what does ageism mean - Ageism, also called age discrimination, is when someone treats you unfairly because of your age

No one has been treated unfairly or discriminated against by stating a fact. Just like it’s not sexism to state more women than men go PT after having kids

AMorningstar · 01/11/2022 11:46

qpmz · 01/11/2022 11:44

Yep the thought of buying gifts from shared money kills it for me.

Just withdraw the cash and pay that way? Then they can't see it on the app or statement.

MuggleMe · 01/11/2022 11:45

We have a joint account where salary goes in and all bills and general spend goes out. Joint savings accounts for holidays and car costs, and separate personal accounts for our monthly discretionary spends (same amount each).

qpmz · 01/11/2022 11:44

Yep the thought of buying gifts from shared money kills it for me.

PlumPudd · 01/11/2022 11:43

luxxlisbon · 01/11/2022 11:39

I thought until recently that this is how most couples were, (assuming they are in a committed and happy relationship - different if things are rocky of course)

There is nothing about shared finances that makes you a better, more committed or happier couple.

Some people share finances because it works for them, some don’t because that works for them. That’s it really.

Yes I wasn’t implying that shared finances make you happy or better as a couple. Just that I could understand why a couple that wasn’t that happy or committed would chose to keep finances and spending much more separate and calculate the cost of shared expenses a lot more carefully - so that if they split they’d be able to do so with each having their own money and without feeling like one had been over contributing up until the split.

OP posts:
DuoLingoMakesMeBingo · 01/11/2022 11:42

We have one account, DH has a credit card for security for large purchases so I use it when needed. Otherwise debit card from same account. Savings account shared. Same values, always both slightly towards frugal /not wasting money/ not loving consumerism side and never argue about money.

BIWI · 01/11/2022 11:42

Yes. Ageism is attributing a specific behaviour to a general sector of the population.

AMorningstar · 01/11/2022 11:41

PlumPudd · 01/11/2022 11:22

DP and I pretty much share out the paying of our costs, with perhaps a bit of accounting for the fact that we’re on different incomes. The main costs, mortgage, bills, shopping, childcare etc. we broadly split by income, so we have direct debits set up and DP pays a bit more than me. For more discretionary things like clothes, meals out, toiletries, memberships etc. we sometimes pay for our own and sometimes get for both, for example the Amazon account is in DP’s name and we both just get things from there when needed. If I’m doing a clothes shop from H&M DP will add a few bits and I’ll just pay to save on the cost of two deliveries.

Savings are also seen as broadly common e.g. we’re about to move and I’m putting in a bit more than DP just because I’ve ended up with more in the bank, and DP covered some other big costs from their account earlier in the year.

We don’t really keep count, or get pissed off if one pays for more than the other on a particular month as we see the money as our shared money, that’s financing our shared life, regardless of whose income it originally came out of. DP also doesn’t expect me to spend less on discretionary things because my income is a bit lower. It probably helps that neither of us has exorbitant hobbies and that we have a broadly similar view of what’s reasonable to spend on what.

I thought until recently that this is how most couples were, (assuming they are in a committed and happy relationship - different if things are rocky of course) but a few friends have been quite shocked and said that no, they keep their finances very separate. And pay 50 50 or some other carefully calculated split for shared cost like rent / mortgage and then pay for everything else out of their own salary and have their own savings.

So what do you do and why?

I find it weird as well. We have joint everything. Why be married if youre not a team 🤷🏻‍♀️

Nottodaty · 01/11/2022 11:40

It was a bit of a surprise to me as well!
Husband & I have always put the money in one pot. At the start of our relationship we earned similar. Some 20 years later I’ve had two maternity leaves (1 yr & 18months) after my second I changed my role to be more available at home as I did travel a lot. It did mean a pay cut, then a period of part time work & now I do 30 hours a week.

During this time husband pay has increased more than double of mine - he still helps picking up children & helps around the house. All the money goes into joint bank account.
We both pay the same % of our salary into our pensions, though my amount a lot less so have a separate isa in my name where we try to even the amount.

Savings are in both names as well.

Works for us, but I guess it may not work in all circumstances.

Swipe left for the next trending thread