Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not having alternatives for trick or treaters?

182 replies

mummydoris2006 · 01/11/2022 10:41

Last night we had lots of kids trick or treating and was very busy answering the door. It was lovely to see all the different costumes and all the excited kids but at around 7pm we sat down to eat our tea so didn't want to be disturbed.

I decided to leave a bowl of mini haribo and squashems out next to the pumpkins and also inserted some lollipops into a pumpkin too. I figured that way the parents could see they were lollies and could decide if their kids were allowed them and also the younger kiddies had already been earlier on in the night.

Around 7.30pm there was a knock on the door and I answered to find a woman and her son stood on the doorstep. She said she knocked to tell me the bowl was empty! I was a bit taken aback and thanked her for letting me know and said her son was welcome to help himself to a lolly instead, it was at that point she said he wasn't really allowed lollies so she'd knocked for an alternative!!!!!

I explained there was no alternatives if the bowl was empty, and she stomped off in a huff. Even though my DC is too old to trick or treat we still put out pumpkins and welcome trick or treaters but surely, we're now not expected to have a never-ending supply of sweets!?!

OP posts:
TooOldToBeAGoth · 02/11/2022 18:26

Just point out we’re not in America next year.

Angrywife · 02/11/2022 18:26

majorcamaiden · 01/11/2022 13:38

Why is a lolly an unsuitable option for trick or treaters? I took my 4yr old out and those are her favourite. She was choosing lollies over chocolates and Haribo packs.

My mum once witnessed a young boy choke after his lolly came off the stick and slipped down his throat. They weren't able to save him.

I also hate seeing kids with lollies in the mouths while their walking or running, and not holding on to the stick. If they trip it could go straight down their throat

pollymere · 02/11/2022 18:24

I never leave the bowl out, just answer the door. Otherwise one greedy kid will just take all the sweets. I thought they'd knocked to ask for apples or something! (I did have fruit as an option one year!)

SlickShady · 02/11/2022 16:39

Are you seriously asking whether you were BU for not catering to specific requirements of a random candy beggar, or is it just worded that way?

mam0918 · 02/11/2022 15:41

Autumnnewname · 01/11/2022 17:46

Candy is hun language for sweets

Sweet is generic candy is a TYPE of sweet.

You never had candy canes, candy rock, candy sticks???

All perfectly common and British

Brigante9 · 01/11/2022 20:46

I am reading in amazement that some people are saying lollies are choking hazards and implying that they shouldn’t be offered. Don’t take, don’t let your toddler snatch-aren’t you keeping hold of their hands? H&S at its best! There are no doubt older kids who’d like a lolly!

PollyAmour · 01/11/2022 18:52

Autumnnewname · 01/11/2022 17:46

Candy is hun language for sweets

Don't be silly, it's an Americanism. Lots of children say candy when they mean sweets because of American TV programmes.

Hun language indeed. How snobby are you!.

stuntbubbles · 01/11/2022 18:21

Oh god, DP took DD out last night, his first time doing it and he knocked on an empty bowl door thinking he was being helpful by telling them it was empty. Mortifying. Thankfully it was dark and pissing it down and DD had a mask on so they can’t trace this CF behaviour back to our house.

Everyone was generally polite round our way, from the very sweet little girl who tried to return her two sweets as she thought it was a mistake (no, I’m just trying to burn through them so I can stop answering the door and sit down) to the frankly TERRIFYING pack of giant lads with scarves wrapped round their faces who seemed like marauders out of The Purge but then kept nudging each other and saying “Just take one, it’s one each yeah? Merry Christmas!” Grin

sailinginthemed · 01/11/2022 18:09

This is why we turn the lights off and sit in the dark 😂

Caramelsmadfuzzytail · 01/11/2022 18:07

I'm extremely lucky. I've lived in my flat for 11 years and had someone knock once. Although I don't put out a pumpkin because my front door opens onto a fairly busy street so some wonderful teenager person would nick it.

Autumnnewname · 01/11/2022 17:46

Candy is hun language for sweets

Autumnnewname · 01/11/2022 17:45

Like fuck are love hearts and swizzles "candy"

They're sweets

mam0918 · 01/11/2022 17:41

Autumnnewname · 01/11/2022 17:34

Candy

Are you in America?

Candy is a legitimate type of sweet even in the uk... candy rock, candy canes, love hearts and swizzlers and a lot of 'chalky' halloween sweets are 'candy'.

I would say nearly half what my kids got was candy, then half haribo and one or 2 chocolates... we avoided chews mostly as my kids would struggle with them.

mam0918 · 01/11/2022 17:38

Tomtit · 01/11/2022 14:19

No, you read it again, it says there wasn’t candy.

I don’t believe it was, I think that poster was complaining and is now doubling down. I’m entitled to believe what I read, especially as I read it correctly and you didn’t.

No you have DEFINATELY read it wrong it says:

'I thought they had ran out of candy'

'but it turned out they did have candy as well but my Daughter picked the orange'

No one was complaining and you CLEARLY read it wrong and got offended over nothing.

Also the person you quoted doesnt need to read it again, she IS the person who wrote it and your 'I dont believe thats what the poster meant' to the poster herself who is telling you your wrong is bizaare lol.

You are litrally arguing with yourself and look a bit silly.

Autumnnewname · 01/11/2022 17:34

SpinningFloppa · 01/11/2022 14:14

And she obviously did want it as she picked it over the candy I thought it was hilarious and that’s what I thought the point was as a few of the houses were pulling pranks, someone put out a box saying candy inside and you had to put your hand in and it was just a bowl of water. Once again I didn’t mean it in a “cheeky fucker” way cheeky has more than one meaning and can also mean jokey/playful/mischievous I thought it was a prank so kids come knocking for candy and get fruit that’s all!!!!

Candy

Are you in America?

Penguinsaregreat · 01/11/2022 17:31

I’ll be honest it got on my nerves last night. I’ve spent years handing out sweets when my dcs were young. We live elsewhere now and don’t decorate at all. The number of people knocking on my door was insane.
Tell your kids not to knock on random strangers houses! It’s bloody annoying and also dangerous.
I so wish I could a afford a house with a big private drive and solid, lockable gates.

mam0918 · 01/11/2022 17:21

QuebecBagnet · 01/11/2022 14:11

There’s a house in our village which has a pumpkin out but when the kids knock they get given a pamphlet about Christianity. 😂. I’d be happy enough with an orange compared to that!

This is great.

Like reverse Jehovahs Witnesses where you knock on their door lol.

PollyAmour · 01/11/2022 17:15

Homemade treats are never going to go down well with people you don't know. It sounds really spiteful, but people are wary of food hygiene and the food being contaminated in some way, not necessarily deliberately poisoned - although I guess we've all heard the urban myth about the chocolate coated sprouts.

I only ever give out individually wrapped packets of commercially bought sweets on Halloween, but I did used to make treacle toffee and toffee apples for my own children and their friends on Bonfire Night. They always went down well. One of my adult son's friends asked me the other day if I still make my amazing treacle toffee. :D D

BaffledShopper · 01/11/2022 16:48

My grandmother, bless her soul. used to take great pleasure in making homemade fudge and toffee apples to give out to the kids at Halloween. Then one year she saw an article in the paper about how people should immediately discard anything home-made in case it has been poisoned! From that year onward she turned all the lights off and sat in the basement on Halloween night.

BaffledShopper · 01/11/2022 16:45

QuebecBagnet · 01/11/2022 14:11

There’s a house in our village which has a pumpkin out but when the kids knock they get given a pamphlet about Christianity. 😂. I’d be happy enough with an orange compared to that!

There's always one of those!

Ivyy · 01/11/2022 15:32

There are some cf's out there for sure. Someone even posted on the local community FB page asking if people were going trick or treating or giving out sweets on Sunday instead of Monday, because it was a school night on Monday night. Some people joined in saying that was a good idea as their young kids would be tired for school the next day. Some responses were very annoyed by this suggestion, pointing out Halloween is the 31st October and always has been, whether it's a school night or not. I was just baffled really, as surely the same would apply to Sunday evening seeing as there's also school on Monday morning?!

Most kids and parents that came to ours last night were nice and polite, lots of happy Halloween wishes, smiles and thank you's. We did have a couple of very persistent callers after we'd run out of sweets and so taken our pumpkins indoors and turned off the lights outside and in the hallway. I always thought the code was if a house has a pumpkin outside then you can call to trick or treat. That if there isn't a pumpkin / pumpkins then you don't call. Even once the pumpkins were back indoors and lights off we had some ringing the doorbell, with one lot they then tried banging and hammering on the front door for ages and shouting trick or treat through the letterbox! My dd had a look through the blind in the front room and said there was a group of mums on the drive just stood chatting while their kids were doing this, seemingly oblivious Halloween Confused
Final caller at 8 ish who rang the bell several times, dh thought it might be our takeaway coming half an hour early so answered, one child and their mum stood there in the dark so dh put the lights on so they could see, and felt bad saying there weren't any sweets left so asked dd to go and get something of hers to give them!

ProFannyTea · 01/11/2022 15:16

People have totally lost touch with the point of Halloween. These days it's just a big self indulgent commercialised orgy of crap for one night then all forgotten about. Fireworks on Halloween? Really?? We drum into our kids not to take sweets from strangers then take them round the streets one night a year to take sweets from strangers. Like Christmas people desperately try to stretch it out with decorations a week before and a week after but ffs, demanding specific sweets that suit them? Entitled? Much? Yeah I'll stick a bowl of lactose intolerant treats out with the vegan ones next year! Fuck right off love, and take your Poundland skeleton costume clad kid with you. Nobody asked you to knock on the fucking door!! Alternative sweets my arse! 🤬

LondonJax · 01/11/2022 15:04

We had over 100 visitors last night. They all got exactly the same sweets as 100 is our normal number and I'm not second guessing who would want what. If they don't like what they're given, they can swap with their mates across all the other sweets they've got. DS gives one packet per person - none of this 'help yourself' malarky since one kid grabbed a huge handful when we first started 15 years ago! We had got through all our packets of sweets by 7.30pm.

I usually make up a little rhyme that we stick on the door saying all the ghosts and witches have had their sweets, there's nothing left so don't ring the bell, there's no sweets in the house - Happy Halloween! Or, 'help yourself' if we've got any sweets left over by about 7.30pm.

We leave the porch light on so they can read the note and see the bowl (if we've any sweets left) take the decorations down (we tend to go a bit OTT at Halloween) and get on with our evening. No one's ever knocked and they'd soon be put right if they did.

MavisChunch29 · 01/11/2022 15:02

DD1 is veggie so we certainly had gelatine and non gelatine sweets. For ourselves, as it turned out 😂

Floomobal · 01/11/2022 15:01

My DP gave a sopping wet, sad looking little skeleton an umbrella last night. His mum popped back this morning to drop the umbrella back.

Nicer neighbours here than that CF that knocked on @mummydoris2006 ‘s door!