Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eating with a knife and fork in the wrong hands

468 replies

Getabloominmoveon · 01/11/2022 10:30

Just sat in a cafe next to a whole family eating with their fork in the right hand and knife in the left. On the other side a young guy was struggling to chop up his food with just a fork. A few weeks ago an adult friend of mine admitted she didn’t know which way to set a table.This is In the UK btw.

When did this start? Have they never eaten with a table set with cutlery? Don’t people teach their kids how to eat properly any more?

At the risk of sounding like Hyacinth Bouquet AIBU to think that this is a basic life skill and people should eat with their cutlery in the right hands (unless left-handed, different cultures, Americans and all the other caveats of course).

OP posts:
NotAnotherPylon · 04/11/2022 12:19

For the hard of reading.. Bit rude @WiddlinDiddlin, but anyway, I politely read your vast post and conclude that the history of setting tables doesn't help us here. I can't imagine anyone expects tables to be laid in a bespoke manner for the individual. I lay my own humble little table in the traditional way because it's uniform and pleasing to the eye, but once everyone gets their hands on their own cutlery, it's a feckin free-for-all and I, for one, am alright with that.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 04/11/2022 12:17

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/11/2022 11:42

Am I dreaming that I have explained the origins of eating with ones fork/knife in particular hands TWICE now?

No, it wasn't for 'lazy waiters' either, and I am pretty sure waiting staff in large homes didn't get much opportunity to be lazy.

For the hard of reading..

Organising place settings all in the same direction looks neat, means you can organise who sits where the moment they enter the room, won't confuse guests.

If you have not seen a full formal place setting for 7 courses or 5 courses... I include a photo..

Trying to set that out, or even the slightly less complicated 5 course setting, some right handed and some left handed, would be a nightmare, would be very confusing.

Sitting at that setting and trying to swap cutlery over at each course would be disruptive and risk dropping stuff, clattering stuff, which disturbs conversation and draws attention.

And finally, sitting close together as one would be at a large but full, long table with place settings that big, in big bustly dresses or fluff sleeves - matching up left handed and right handed people the wrong way and you'll get elbows clashing and people feeling uncomfortable.

And there was a view that left handedness was just wrong and something to be corrected - and there were lots of shitty reasons for that and a few good ones (draw your sword with the left hand against a right handed opponent = die!)

I am not saying all this applies now, it doesn't, but this faux bafflement at the reasons behind these rules is ridiculous!

As for them being a weird British affectation... ha!

The Italians started this business with multiple forks in the 1500's, the French eventually caught on after several decades of dislike, and the British didn't go for the idea until 1633 as it was too effeminate! Up to that point, they were stabbing things with their knives and using their hands instead of a fork.

From there things went crazy and as the trend for banquets with piles of food laid out on the table passed, the one for huge amounts of cutlery and ceramic and eventually porcelain dining sets took off, as with food served by staff, there was now room on the table for billions of plates, forks knives, glasses, spoons etc. Mass production also meant that achieving matchy-matchy perfection became a thing.

Some of the rules don't matter so much now, we aren't eating at long tables, packed in like sardines with 9billion forks and knives to contend with. But I think those that involve not pinging food at one another or avoiding knocking stuff over are probably still worthwhile!

You're missing the point. Yes, I know it looks neat. But real life is not 'neat'. And neatness should be irrelevant when a person is left handed and simply cannot manage a fork with their right hand. That's the point. That the convention should no longer be used in today's society, as we're, well mostly, more educated today regarding people's abilities or inabilities.

evilharpy · 04/11/2022 12:06

Quartz2208 · 01/11/2022 10:43

This is me. I could have been left handed but the belief that right handedness is somehow better meant that I write with my right hand as that is what was drilled into me at school. For other tasks I am left handed.

My Grandad was left handed and forced his life to be right handed.

But I do think cutlery use is very much falling away. I barely have meals that use a knife anymore - especially now as a family we are vegan/vegetarian and no meat to cut!

This is me exactly too. Even in the 1980s when I went to primary school I had the pencil removed from my left hand and put into my right hand. I can write with both hands but some things I can only do right handed and some only left handed. Operating a cutlery knife is one of the left handed things (although no problems chopping stuff up right handed).

I don't talk with my mouth full, I don't have my elbows on the table, I can set a table for a formal meal with multiple courses and I'm a stickler for which beverage goes in which glass. I have also raised a child with decent manners who can be taken to any restaurant without annoying other diners. But I hold my cutlery in the "wrong" hands. I fail to see how that adversely affects anyone's life, and would judge the hell out of the OP for raising the point or even noticing.

phoenixrosehere · 04/11/2022 11:55

mathanxiety · 03/11/2022 22:59

Very amused that the hand you hold a fork in makes a difference in how well a child will do as an adult.
All the right handed fork users are destined to fail in life.
I know I did.... I'm just typing this from my lovely little cardboard box, on a.side street, watching the rats nibble my toes just waiting for my next fix of fork deviant eatitng

@00100001

It absolutely can affect your chances.

When your offspring has got to the point where an interview process involves dinners with potential future colleagues in restaurants where other people are going to be following the cultural norms, it does make a difference.

People saying it doesn't matter what others think of their table manners are wrong. How well you fit in with social expectations in the working environment is part of the evaluation process for many careers. It's nice to have the confidence that at least your table manners are not going to hold you back.

Most of the people DD works with use their forks with their right hand after initially using the knife in the right hand to cut up food, followed by a switch of hands: we are in the US and that's the (clunky) norm here. DD has studied and worked in Europe, the UK and Ireland, and has been able to adapt without any need to take down her well thumbed copy of Miss Manners' Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behaviour and do cutlery-related homework.

It would be nice if people who live in the US who aren’t American would just say the region they are in vs saying the US. It is not the norm for all of the US. It’s regional like certain things are in the UK.

darisdet · 04/11/2022 11:48

The fork fourth from the left looks like a pickle or egg fork?

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/11/2022 11:42

Am I dreaming that I have explained the origins of eating with ones fork/knife in particular hands TWICE now?

No, it wasn't for 'lazy waiters' either, and I am pretty sure waiting staff in large homes didn't get much opportunity to be lazy.

For the hard of reading..

Organising place settings all in the same direction looks neat, means you can organise who sits where the moment they enter the room, won't confuse guests.

If you have not seen a full formal place setting for 7 courses or 5 courses... I include a photo..

Trying to set that out, or even the slightly less complicated 5 course setting, some right handed and some left handed, would be a nightmare, would be very confusing.

Sitting at that setting and trying to swap cutlery over at each course would be disruptive and risk dropping stuff, clattering stuff, which disturbs conversation and draws attention.

And finally, sitting close together as one would be at a large but full, long table with place settings that big, in big bustly dresses or fluff sleeves - matching up left handed and right handed people the wrong way and you'll get elbows clashing and people feeling uncomfortable.

And there was a view that left handedness was just wrong and something to be corrected - and there were lots of shitty reasons for that and a few good ones (draw your sword with the left hand against a right handed opponent = die!)

I am not saying all this applies now, it doesn't, but this faux bafflement at the reasons behind these rules is ridiculous!

As for them being a weird British affectation... ha!

The Italians started this business with multiple forks in the 1500's, the French eventually caught on after several decades of dislike, and the British didn't go for the idea until 1633 as it was too effeminate! Up to that point, they were stabbing things with their knives and using their hands instead of a fork.

From there things went crazy and as the trend for banquets with piles of food laid out on the table passed, the one for huge amounts of cutlery and ceramic and eventually porcelain dining sets took off, as with food served by staff, there was now room on the table for billions of plates, forks knives, glasses, spoons etc. Mass production also meant that achieving matchy-matchy perfection became a thing.

Some of the rules don't matter so much now, we aren't eating at long tables, packed in like sardines with 9billion forks and knives to contend with. But I think those that involve not pinging food at one another or avoiding knocking stuff over are probably still worthwhile!

Eating with a knife and fork in the wrong hands
Peashoots · 04/11/2022 11:24

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 04/11/2022 06:40

@Witsendwilly Does your bigoted and backward company also have staff who are not allowed to be seen writing left handed? Or be seen in a wheelchair? Table manners, and the hand you hold your fork with are two entirely different things. Being left handed is not 'bad manners'.

I don’t believe this is true. I believe they choose people who are polite and have good manners, but I simply don’t believe that the company choose people based on which hand they hold the fork in. Calling absolute BS, I believe she is lying.

Conkersareback · 04/11/2022 10:53

TheBirdintheCave · 04/11/2022 09:11

What I find most confusing about this whole argument is the people insisting that those who eat the other way around must have no table manners at all. It's like they view it like this:

Fork in right hand: Spits at dinner, talks with mouth full, waves cutlery about, spills drinks.

Fork in left hand: Perfect grace at all times at the table.

Why can't they see how batshit crazy that is? There will be PLENTY of people who eat with their fork in their left hand who have no table manners at all. The two are not synonymous.

And then people referring to following high society dinner etiquette from long ago... If this is how you operate in your day-to-day life, then I hope you also admonish your SO's if they dare to come to dinner wearing anything other than white tie.

Dinner etiquette changes over time. It evolves. We don't all still lounge on couches Roman style or send dinner invitations to the gods so why are you clinging on to the idea that holding the fork in your left hand is vital?

GrinGrin

Frankola · 04/11/2022 10:16

My dd is a lefty and according to you she holds her cutlery "wrong". It's not actually "wrong" at all for left handed people. What a pointless moan.

TheBirdintheCave · 04/11/2022 09:58

@Morestrangethings Haha why not? Or how about serving up some dormice to symbolise how wealthy we are?

Morestrangethings · 04/11/2022 09:47

TheBirdintheCave · 04/11/2022 09:11

What I find most confusing about this whole argument is the people insisting that those who eat the other way around must have no table manners at all. It's like they view it like this:

Fork in right hand: Spits at dinner, talks with mouth full, waves cutlery about, spills drinks.

Fork in left hand: Perfect grace at all times at the table.

Why can't they see how batshit crazy that is? There will be PLENTY of people who eat with their fork in their left hand who have no table manners at all. The two are not synonymous.

And then people referring to following high society dinner etiquette from long ago... If this is how you operate in your day-to-day life, then I hope you also admonish your SO's if they dare to come to dinner wearing anything other than white tie.

Dinner etiquette changes over time. It evolves. We don't all still lounge on couches Roman style or send dinner invitations to the gods so why are you clinging on to the idea that holding the fork in your left hand is vital?

TheBirdinTheCave,

🤣🤣🤣

I’m thinking a sacrifice before we feast.

naemates · 04/11/2022 09:30

This reminds me of being nightshift and my friend who said I was lazy because I'd be asleep in the afternoon. "I've been up for hours!" she'd say, incredulous.

The few times I attempted to explain to/argue with her, her reasoning came down to 'because you should'

TheBirdintheCave · 04/11/2022 09:24

@00100001 Seemingly so!

00100001 · 04/11/2022 09:15

TheBirdintheCave · 04/11/2022 09:11

What I find most confusing about this whole argument is the people insisting that those who eat the other way around must have no table manners at all. It's like they view it like this:

Fork in right hand: Spits at dinner, talks with mouth full, waves cutlery about, spills drinks.

Fork in left hand: Perfect grace at all times at the table.

Why can't they see how batshit crazy that is? There will be PLENTY of people who eat with their fork in their left hand who have no table manners at all. The two are not synonymous.

And then people referring to following high society dinner etiquette from long ago... If this is how you operate in your day-to-day life, then I hope you also admonish your SO's if they dare to come to dinner wearing anything other than white tie.

Dinner etiquette changes over time. It evolves. We don't all still lounge on couches Roman style or send dinner invitations to the gods so why are you clinging on to the idea that holding the fork in your left hand is vital?

Because they're twats.

TheBirdintheCave · 04/11/2022 09:11

What I find most confusing about this whole argument is the people insisting that those who eat the other way around must have no table manners at all. It's like they view it like this:

Fork in right hand: Spits at dinner, talks with mouth full, waves cutlery about, spills drinks.

Fork in left hand: Perfect grace at all times at the table.

Why can't they see how batshit crazy that is? There will be PLENTY of people who eat with their fork in their left hand who have no table manners at all. The two are not synonymous.

And then people referring to following high society dinner etiquette from long ago... If this is how you operate in your day-to-day life, then I hope you also admonish your SO's if they dare to come to dinner wearing anything other than white tie.

Dinner etiquette changes over time. It evolves. We don't all still lounge on couches Roman style or send dinner invitations to the gods so why are you clinging on to the idea that holding the fork in your left hand is vital?

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/11/2022 07:40

Only absolute idiots insist there is a correct hand to hold a knife and fork in thereby denying basic biology.

Its hilarious that a small few have chosen to highlight their own stupidity on here.

They must be trolls because honestly is anyone really that dumb?

blackheartsgirl · 04/11/2022 06:49

@CallieQ

why?

I’ve always called myself a leftie? As do most of the (few) left handed people I know.

I like it. I’m proud of it.

tunthebloodyalarmoff · 04/11/2022 06:46

But who says that's the right way. People should eat how they are comfortable there's no right or wrong. And you definitely need to get out more. Bore off

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 04/11/2022 06:44

blackheartsgirl · 04/11/2022 05:42

Actually I’m wrong 😂 I eat with the fork in my left and the knife in my right (it’s early, I’m sleep deprived)

however I do struggle to cut things with my knife in my right hand, I just can’t do it very well, I tear at the food but I blame school for that. My mum didn’t care which hand I ate with but school did.

@JennyNotFromTheBlock like you I am predominantly left handed, very strongly in fact. I do everything apart from 2 things with my left hand because I physically can’t do them with my right and I thought in the 21st century we’d left left handed discrimination behind but reading this thread we obviously haven’t.

being left handed has caused me problems in school and at work. I seriously injured my hand and needed surgery 4 years ago because my employer refused to take into consideration how my left handed ness affected my ability to operate a piece of machinery.

my late husband was a leftie, but he wrote excruciatingly slowly with his right hand, he was forced to by his teacher back in the seventies when he was five. As a result he had severe dyslexia and a stutter.

some of the comments on this thread are ridiculous

I seriously injured my hand and needed surgery 4 years ago because my employer refused to take into consideration how my left handed ness affected my ability to operate a piece of machinery.
my late husband was a leftie, but he wrote excruciatingly slowly with his right hand, he was forced to by his teacher back in the seventies when he was five. As a result he had severe dyslexia and a stutter.

Yes it is incredibly shameful that there are still people who have such abusive, bigoted and prejudiced attitudes on this thread. I would never choose to associate with such compassionless hateful bigots in real life.

00100001 · 04/11/2022 06:40

Witsendwilly · 04/11/2022 04:40

I can’t believe how many people don’t seee this as important.

At home eating in front of the TV I guess it’s not an issue. At work we have a number of staff we no longer send to client events or to business dinners. Guess which ones they are? They are the ones who are of course entitled to eat as they wish at home, but who because they have never adopted proper table manners simply cant represent the company at certain functions.

it’s such a simple thing, that whether some people like it or not does make people stand out in certain situations if they can’t eat “properly”

Because it ISN'T important which hand you hold your fork.

It's important to eat neatly, make interesting conversation, be tidy etc

Bit it makes fuck all difference if you lift a fork with the handle pointing left or right.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 04/11/2022 06:40

Witsendwilly · 04/11/2022 04:40

I can’t believe how many people don’t seee this as important.

At home eating in front of the TV I guess it’s not an issue. At work we have a number of staff we no longer send to client events or to business dinners. Guess which ones they are? They are the ones who are of course entitled to eat as they wish at home, but who because they have never adopted proper table manners simply cant represent the company at certain functions.

it’s such a simple thing, that whether some people like it or not does make people stand out in certain situations if they can’t eat “properly”

@Witsendwilly Does your bigoted and backward company also have staff who are not allowed to be seen writing left handed? Or be seen in a wheelchair? Table manners, and the hand you hold your fork with are two entirely different things. Being left handed is not 'bad manners'.

CallieQ · 04/11/2022 06:39

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 10:33

Who said a knife has to be in your right hand. How do you know they weren't a family of leftys.

Stop being so judgemental about people you know nothing about

Leftys?? That sounds a bit non pc could we be called people who use their left hand instead

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 04/11/2022 06:37

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/11/2022 03:58

Maybe for some... but the origins of it were there for generally good reason.

If everyone uses their cutlery the same way round when you have got three forks on one side, two spoons and a knife the other side, side plates, water glasses, wine glasses, dessert fork and spoon above... then thats tidy.

You avoid elbow clashing, people passing their knife/fork over their plate potentially clattering or dropping them, knocking their water or wine over the table.

Doesn't matter of course if you have one course or two courses and everyones got lots of room, but at a big table with everyone sat close and a huge place setting for each person, it does make a difference.

I don't understand why people pretend these dining and cutlery etiquette rules were invented for no reason or to upset others - they weren't at all.

It was about eating politely in a way that didn't infringe on others spaces, didn't ping food across the table, clatter cutlery or drop stuff or knock things over, or increase the risk of anyone dribbling soup down their fronts.

Some things were an effective code so that waiting staff could do their job without interrupting conversation - for example, indicating you've finished your course by putting your knife and fork on the plate, tines of the fork upwards, together, in the six oclock position, rather than putting them down apart, at an angle which indicates you are not yet finished with them.

Some were polite manners - salt on the side of the plate rather than sprinkled over, meaning you salted individually, and suggesting you had tasted it first rather than rudely assuming your meal to be under-seasoned by salting all of it.

Not scraping or mopping up the last scraps of food with a spoon or bit of bread - to do so risks you splatting it about, scraping noises that detract from conversation and suggests you are still ravenous and your host has underfed you (which would be VERY rude indeed).

Keeping elbows off the table/not leaning on the table - one I see commonly quoted as unnecessary and pointless.. again, at a tightly packed long table, someone doing this would be encroaching on the space of the persons either side of them, blocking their view of the table in general and likely meant they were attempting to converse with someone several seats down, which means talking across someone, which is very unpleasant for that person!

These things were also there so one could make a point if necessary! If you wanted to, you COULD indeed scrape at your plate or oversalt the whole dish, should you want to indicate to your host that they are undercatering and mean, or underseasoning and thus lacking taste and also, mean. To do these things didn't mean you were common... it might mean you're rude though (but being rude has never been a disqualifier for the upper classes has it!)

As far as I know from the time I have spent with the truly and genuinely posh upper class set.. it is the HEIGHT of poor taste and manners to remark upon (or giggle at, stare at or smirk at) someone elses lack of education in etiquette - such errors are down to lack of opportunity, and to remark on anothers poor fortune is a cheap shot indeed.

@WiddlinDiddlin So you've confirmed that was for convenience of lazy waiters. Take what you've said, and apply it to left handed writers in classrooms. We no longer do that now (although I have no doubt a few on here would still do that). Also we had no facilities for wheelchairs back then, it would have been 'untidy' us having wheelchair tracks or lanes.

Generally the origins of these 'conventions' arose from laziness and bad manners. Nothing else.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 04/11/2022 06:31

mathanxiety · 04/11/2022 01:48

@TheBirdintheCave
Yes indeed. Many people have tried to convince me that disregarding the cultural norm at the dining table is perfectly fine.

It only demonstrates that an astonishing number of people have no idea what table manners consist of and are quite happy to let their children grow up without any idea that there are certain conventions around eating that have been observed for several hundred years at this point, and they're not as optional in polite society as is believed on this thread.

@mathanxiety Wow, you're a real piece aren't you. 'Convention' does not equate to manners. In fact, quite the contrary, many conventions arose from and contain bad manners. I am so sorry that you are so closed-minded you cannot understand this. It was the 'convention' to try and turn left handers into right handers. That wasn't 'good manners', either. It was pure ignorance and bigotry. Just like you are displaying with the 'but it's CONVENTION!' narrow-minded and ignorant bs. Some 'conventions' are not good, and should be eradicated.

I don't know what horrible backwater you're from, given you said you're in America I can only guess. But the 'convention' to force left handed eaters into being right handed eaters stopped being a convention a long, long time ago in most of the civilised western world. We no longer judge; gay people, people with disabilities, or left handers. Sorry that your ignorance, your hatred, your bigotry and lack of class and education is not shared by most people.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 04/11/2022 06:24

mathanxiety · 03/11/2022 22:59

Very amused that the hand you hold a fork in makes a difference in how well a child will do as an adult.
All the right handed fork users are destined to fail in life.
I know I did.... I'm just typing this from my lovely little cardboard box, on a.side street, watching the rats nibble my toes just waiting for my next fix of fork deviant eatitng

@00100001

It absolutely can affect your chances.

When your offspring has got to the point where an interview process involves dinners with potential future colleagues in restaurants where other people are going to be following the cultural norms, it does make a difference.

People saying it doesn't matter what others think of their table manners are wrong. How well you fit in with social expectations in the working environment is part of the evaluation process for many careers. It's nice to have the confidence that at least your table manners are not going to hold you back.

Most of the people DD works with use their forks with their right hand after initially using the knife in the right hand to cut up food, followed by a switch of hands: we are in the US and that's the (clunky) norm here. DD has studied and worked in Europe, the UK and Ireland, and has been able to adapt without any need to take down her well thumbed copy of Miss Manners' Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behaviour and do cutlery-related homework.

It absolutely does not affect your chances because most people are not backward, narrow-minded bigots. It is not the norm to have interviews in restaurants, unless you're interviewed for a restaurant position.

Just as it's not the norm for employers to ask you to write something down in front them to check your 'penmanship'.

And I would not want to work for such a hateful, compassionless, backward, narrow-minded, bigoted company if they judged me on something that I CAN'T HELP, such as what hand I write with or my dominant eating hand. Anyone who judges another human being by something they can't help, is lowlife scum imo. I wouldn't be seen dead working for lowlife scum like that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread