Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rough' tax rises on the way

209 replies

Violashift · 01/11/2022 10:13

What does this even mean? I can't take much more. Not with the rising energy prices and the absolute mess up of the mortgage interest rates rising.

How will people survive? Already we have not had pay rises and now we will all probably be taxed more.

I feel at the end of my tether. It's really affecting my mental health.

OP posts:
Threadkillacilla · 01/11/2022 11:57

Kendodd · 01/11/2022 10:38

It's more cuts to public services that worry me the most. I've been saying for a while that the biggest thing the government could do to reduce poverty in the UK is a massive social house building project, make council housing landlord of first resource not last. Hasn't Tory brexit cost the economy 4% or something ax well?

I do think, on all of these poverty, poor public services etc threads, if you consistently vote Tory, you have no right to complain, this is what you voted for, you can own the consequences.

Absolutely.
lower standards of services plus lower income plus more poverty will be so destructive and damaging long term it will take decades to recover.

I can't shake the feeling that the Tories know the next GE is lost so will just have a fire sale on their way out.

Booklover3 · 01/11/2022 11:54

It’s looking increasingly bleak

hellesbells · 01/11/2022 11:42

YuzuP · 01/11/2022 10:18

We need tax rises unfortunately - I felt a red mist descend on reading the details of the mini budget. We can’t furlough people and businesses over what turned out to be a bad flu (why oh why was it not just the vulnerable who stayed at home and were furloughed?) and then not pay it back as a society. The books have got to be balanced.

OR - everyone who received furlough can pay it back. I don’t think that would be popular.

You mean companies should pay back furlough right? The people who were furloughed had no choice

Grumpybutfunny · 01/11/2022 11:36

Hopefully they get rid of the triple lock and benefits rises if public sector pay is to be frozen. Our main pay will be frozen but our sideline can make up for some of the shortfall.

What annoys me about the help the bottom the most, is it takes away the pay premium of the higher paid who shoulder the tax burden. Whats the point in doing a high stress job for not much more than someone doing a much less stressful job. To me that part for the Tory plan doesn't work as it doesn't stimulate growth and aspiration. I could accept say a 1% tax rise across the board as that is fair, along with cutting all unessential spending.

In effect the country needs a debit management plan, I wish they would put it out to a public vote of where they want to see the cuts;

My priorities would always be
Education
Health
Defence
emergency services
Including fair pay to retain the best staff in these sectors.

What is left can then be divided amongst the other things that are nice to have in a western society but we really can't afford. Things like free bus passes, warm home grants, universal free school meals and things like council spending on potted plants need to stop. Our local council includes pest control as a free service.....it's called a cat and paying for any other issues (we are rural it happens)!!!

Why they gave everyone £600 for energy is also beyond me, our rebate paid the entire energy bill last month as we invested in solar power. Paying for solar panels/ground source heat pumps for homes would be a much more long term solution and could even be as the form of a loan added to council tax of a property.

It's time for reform of something's being extras provided by the government that you pay for if you want them. So say remove refuge collection from council tax the you can pay the council X for it or a private company Y

WorrieaboutFIL · 01/11/2022 11:30

TAX THE RICH
TAX THE MEGA CORPORATIONS

Kendodd · 01/11/2022 11:27

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 01/11/2022 10:45

Agree the complete lack of accountability is doing me in. I am beginning to lose faith in the social contract. I work hard, higher rate tax payer and have no problem paying tax. But increasingly I feel like saying "fuck that" because this government just pisses it up the wall. My kids' school has no money, the NHS is on its knees, our local bus route has just had its timetable halved.

I'm not paying tax for the likes of Truss and Kwarteng to pretend its Monopoly money. Shame on them; there should be some kind of criminal charges against them.

Instead of criminal charges, Truss is going to get nearly 200k a year from us.

Kendodd · 01/11/2022 11:23

Hyperion100 · 01/11/2022 10:45

Feels crazy when you could add 4% to GDP overnight which would recoup 40 billion in tax revenue just by rejoining the single market.

Infact, if we fully rejoin the EU we wont have to pay 35 billion in divorce payments.

Then windfall tax the oil companies to raise another 5 to 7 billion

Then go after the 16 billion lost in covid lion and contract fraud

Then go after the large corps who pay next to no tax.

But no...they will squeeze the middle yet again. Just like they always do.

Completely agree.
Rejoining the EU won't happen though because they won't let us (I don't blame them).
Rejoining the SM won't happen because Brexit voters would sooner we all starve. Plus, we won't be free to dump shit in the sea anymore.
Tories won't go after big business because the whole party is in the pocket of big business and they have to deliver for their sponsors.

Ifailed · 01/11/2022 11:22

This country has been living on the never never for decades. We make very little now, relying on importing goods from countries with low or no protection for their workforce, import most of our food, have sold off most of our infrastructure to foreign governments and in return offer the world "services".

A lot of these "services" are somewhat dubious, relying on sleight of hand and financial shenanigans to magically create "wealth" which can easily come tumbling down (see recent wobble over pension funds where a trillion pounds nearly disappeared - did it fall down the back of a sofa?).

AI will soon replace a lot of these wonderful "services"; what's left to bring in the desperately needed Dollar, Euro and Renminbi - an end-of-pier show based on the ludicrous Royal Family?

We can't go on like this. We are not a Global power, it's time to stop swaggering around interfering with other countries conflicts & dutifully following the USA into all of it's mismanaged, military-led interventions. We don't need any aircraft carriers, let alone two new ones that break down, much to the amusement of the 100s of countries that get by with none.

We can't treat our sick, we can't care for our frail, we can't house our homeless and we can't warm our cold. I hate to think how things will look in 10 or 20 years time.

Verbena87 · 01/11/2022 11:12

luxxlisbon · 01/11/2022 10:33

Personally I can’t get on board with a low tax economy. I don’t know why tories like Truss bang on about it so much. It’s at complete odds to what most people expect in a modern society in terms of healthcare, welfare state, education and public services.
Public services have been crippled for the last 12 years, this isn’t just covid or the mini budget, it’s a decade of Tory rule decimating services.
I think a progressive tax increase is necessary. Probably something like 1% rise starting at about 35k/40 and rising up the bands.
What we do not need is a tax cut to those over 150k.
Given the energy crisis and the gross profits from the likes of shell and BP a tax should be placed on them to deal with the current situation.
We should also stop pissing about and being squashed by big companies like Amazon and go after them for the tax they owe.

yes, this!

ifonly4 · 01/11/2022 11:12

We've had it easy for a long time, and sadly didn't know it. My Mum literally grew up on bread and jam, crumpets once a week as a treat and Sunday roast was homegrown veggies and whatever they could shoot. Only heat was from cooking stove and they had a bath once a week, all children dipping in the same water. Feels like many more will be living like this soon. We've also got used to having lots of gadgets, tv, gaming products, mobile phones, laptops - all cost and use energy, as well as holidays, meals or day trips out - these were all things that people didn't pay for years ago.

YuzuP · 01/11/2022 11:07

I am most certainly not some Tory plant! I name change every so often and don’t post all that much. I just thought tax cuts was a dumb way to restore public finances! And the markets agreed with me! the Toryest of Tory policies is not my idea of fixing a huge deficit.

Everyone wants everyone except them to pay more tax. We will all have to. I want them to raise the tax free threshold to whatever would be sensible for the lowest earners then up the rest a bit.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 01/11/2022 11:07

Unfortunately the markets do mind a fiscal gap, so the old it’s not like running a household budget line that gets used a fair bit is defunct.

Even so, if somebody turned up in a brand new Ferrari to the food bank and sobbed about how impoverished they were, and how urgently you needed to jump to help them.... what would you think?

Whizzi24 · 01/11/2022 10:58

I would happily pay more tax if it resulted in better public services. I do not want to lay more tax if it is just to pay off government debt caused by their own mismanagement.

MarshaBradyo · 01/11/2022 10:53

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 01/11/2022 10:39

I also don't buy the 'the books have to be balanced' story. It sounds obvious, but running a country's finances is nothing at all like running a household budget.

Whatever they claim, there is ALWAYS plenty of money for what they want to spend it on - be it nuclear willy-waving, HS2 or whatever.

Global money supply is all about control and manipulation and nothing to do with actual money - if it were, why would the wealthiest countries be the heaviest in debt? Can you imagine that at household level - where the people with family incomes of a quarter of a million were also the same ones queuing up outside Cash Converters early on a Monday morning? How can it be real when there's so much money supposedly in existence but no countries seem to actually own any of it and all of them owe it?

I also don't buy the 'the books have to be balanced' story. It sounds obvious, but running a country's finances is nothing at all like running a household budget.

Unfortunately the markets do mind a fiscal gap, so the old it’s not like running a household budget line that gets used a fair bit is defunct.

Bestcatmum · 01/11/2022 10:49

So that will be more money out of my pocket. I was just congratulating myself on finally being solvent and not doing too badly after years of struggle when bang I'm back down where I was before. If I had debt I'd be completely stuffed. At least I've paid it all off.

MarshaBradyo · 01/11/2022 10:49

YuzuP · 01/11/2022 10:18

We need tax rises unfortunately - I felt a red mist descend on reading the details of the mini budget. We can’t furlough people and businesses over what turned out to be a bad flu (why oh why was it not just the vulnerable who stayed at home and were furloughed?) and then not pay it back as a society. The books have got to be balanced.

OR - everyone who received furlough can pay it back. I don’t think that would be popular.

No it wouldn’t but I don’t think it would fair as it was a decision made for them. So everyone sharing the payback it is…

OminousBirdAWing · 01/11/2022 10:47

I'm not paying tax for the likes of Truss and Kwarteng to pretend its Monopoly money. Shame on them; there should be some kind of criminal charges against them.

This - in a massive bloody nutshell.

They are playing with our lives and never having to face the consequences themselves. To them this is all one big game while we scrabble about to try to construct some kind of happiness in the mud pie they made.

DrManhattan · 01/11/2022 10:47

@DazzlePaintedBattlePants you should add Sunak to that list, splashing the cash around during Covid. He must think we are all stupid. He's as much to blame for this shower.

cosmiccosmos · 01/11/2022 10:46

I think this is going to be interesting and not in a good way. The gap between benefits and those who are working full time is too small. If they start to tax those working more, especially those that fall just outside getting all those extra things provided, coupled with increase in mortgages then the shit really is going to hit the fan.

On top of that people seeing the crisis and costs associated with the migrants, people just won't accept it.

So much wastage, millions of pounds of fraud in the furlough, addiction to HS2, test and trace - the list goes on. It's a shocking state of affairs.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 01/11/2022 10:45

Agree the complete lack of accountability is doing me in. I am beginning to lose faith in the social contract. I work hard, higher rate tax payer and have no problem paying tax. But increasingly I feel like saying "fuck that" because this government just pisses it up the wall. My kids' school has no money, the NHS is on its knees, our local bus route has just had its timetable halved.

I'm not paying tax for the likes of Truss and Kwarteng to pretend its Monopoly money. Shame on them; there should be some kind of criminal charges against them.

Hyperion100 · 01/11/2022 10:45

Feels crazy when you could add 4% to GDP overnight which would recoup 40 billion in tax revenue just by rejoining the single market.

Infact, if we fully rejoin the EU we wont have to pay 35 billion in divorce payments.

Then windfall tax the oil companies to raise another 5 to 7 billion

Then go after the 16 billion lost in covid lion and contract fraud

Then go after the large corps who pay next to no tax.

But no...they will squeeze the middle yet again. Just like they always do.

luxxlisbon · 01/11/2022 10:44

CrushedPistachios · 01/11/2022 10:37

the trouble is as I see it though @luxxlisbon is that what is being suggested is an increase in taxation in conjunction with social welfare and infrastructure cuts. So basically, pay more and expect worse services.

Oh I agree with that entirely. The Conservative party are not the party of you expect high quality public services.

It just frustrates me that the tories have managed to convince a whole loads of people that a low tax economy is in their best interest, which it isn’t.

OminousBirdAWing · 01/11/2022 10:41

There is a £50bn financial hole to be filled and we are told it has to be filled somehow.

There was a £30bn budget surplus when Sunak left the Chancellor post (due to increased tax revenues as a result of things like Petrol price hikes). That has vanished and would have filled a huge chunk of this.

£4bn PPE was burned as it was bought even though it didn't meet standards and cannot be used.

£37bn on Test and Trace. To quote the Chair of the Public Accounts Committee:
"Test and Trace cannot point to a measurable difference to the progress of the pandemic, and the promise on which this huge expense was justified - avoiding another lockdown – has been broken, twice."

£4.3bn pandemic business support thta was written off as was fraudently claimed/paid out.

£4bn MoD waste under the current Minister of Defence.

Abd let's not forget the big kicker: the £50bn budget hole and these stark warnings of tax rises did not exist before Truss and Kwarteng's little experiment. They played a game, lost and trashed our credit rating, making UK borrowing far ore expensive than it was.

They should get those involved in all those decisions to pay that £50bn in. How fucking dare they come with their begging bowls to the people and tell them the country is broke.

They broke it. Financially and metaphorically.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 01/11/2022 10:39

I also don't buy the 'the books have to be balanced' story. It sounds obvious, but running a country's finances is nothing at all like running a household budget.

Whatever they claim, there is ALWAYS plenty of money for what they want to spend it on - be it nuclear willy-waving, HS2 or whatever.

Global money supply is all about control and manipulation and nothing to do with actual money - if it were, why would the wealthiest countries be the heaviest in debt? Can you imagine that at household level - where the people with family incomes of a quarter of a million were also the same ones queuing up outside Cash Converters early on a Monday morning? How can it be real when there's so much money supposedly in existence but no countries seem to actually own any of it and all of them owe it?

Kendodd · 01/11/2022 10:38

It's more cuts to public services that worry me the most. I've been saying for a while that the biggest thing the government could do to reduce poverty in the UK is a massive social house building project, make council housing landlord of first resource not last. Hasn't Tory brexit cost the economy 4% or something ax well?

I do think, on all of these poverty, poor public services etc threads, if you consistently vote Tory, you have no right to complain, this is what you voted for, you can own the consequences.