Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rough' tax rises on the way

209 replies

Violashift · 01/11/2022 10:13

What does this even mean? I can't take much more. Not with the rising energy prices and the absolute mess up of the mortgage interest rates rising.

How will people survive? Already we have not had pay rises and now we will all probably be taxed more.

I feel at the end of my tether. It's really affecting my mental health.

OP posts:
Ziegfeld · 01/11/2022 18:26

icelolly12 · 01/11/2022 18:04

There should have been far more checks and restrictions on Furlough - why were multi million/billion companies subbed even when their businesses were booming for example? So many companies automatically just put their workers on furlough despite having millions/billions in the pot themselves!

Also, billions was given out in business 'loans' that will never be recovered due to fraud and people taking the loans using them on home improvements or whatever and then going bankrupt. Again there were no proper checks. It's eye opening yet seems to have been brushed under the carpet. Imagine if Corbyn had got in power and done this ... there'd be absolute outrage by the tabloid press!

www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/06/covid-bounce-back-loans-paid-for-cars-watches-and-even-porn

Another glib punter with a short memory. Give me a break.

If the Govt had delayed or withheld furlough payments and business loans to allow detailed means testing (a massive and probably impossible job which would have costed more than it saved - how exactly can anyone tell confidently whose business is really “booming” until they have published audited accounts - which takes months even when you aren’t in mid-pandemic) then you would have been complaining that the Government was oblivious to the plight of workers being made redundant in their tens of thousands, families going starving and thousands of businesses going to the wall.

Pursue the fraudsters after the fact by all means. Lock em up, and shame the big companies into giving back the money, as some have done.

But don’t sit there and LIE about what you would have said at the time if the Government had acted differently.

DonnaBanana · 01/11/2022 18:14

There is plenty of money out there. Just add up the house and car prices on your street and you will be in mega millions. Millions of streets. They should put the higher rate of tax up to 60-70% like in Belgium.

MarshaBradyo · 01/11/2022 18:09

Ziegfeld · 01/11/2022 17:31

People have incredibly short memories

The same people who said lockdowns should be faster/longer/more draconian are now moaning about the cost of furlough and bounce back loans. Who do they think was going to pay for all that - the fairies?

The same people who pre COVID complained the Government wasn’t borrowing enough and should be maxing out its credit card to pump money into infrastructure, education and the NHS are now criticising it for financial imprudence and stoking inflation!

Yep especially first part

walkinginsunshinekat · 01/11/2022 18:06

YuzuP · 01/11/2022 17:49

I can’t see how anything BUT tax increases will get us out of this. Labour would increase them too. And rightly IMO. If Labour thinks there’s a way out of this mess then they’re free to share and Rishi is centrist enough to appropriate any good ideas. I hope.

This mess isn't on Labour, its on the Tories, 12 years of Austerity and still going, its certainly not on Labour to assist Sunak.
Tories are smaller state, less Govt, this why we are where we are plus some terrible decisions and 10s of billions poured down the drain.

Sure there is global events etc but its the UK that the markets are wary off, our borrowing costs are still double that of Germany's and a 1/3rd higher than France.

As for Sunak being a centralist? he is a hardcore Brexitier & is from the right of the party.

icelolly12 · 01/11/2022 18:04

There should have been far more checks and restrictions on Furlough - why were multi million/billion companies subbed even when their businesses were booming for example? So many companies automatically just put their workers on furlough despite having millions/billions in the pot themselves!

Also, billions was given out in business 'loans' that will never be recovered due to fraud and people taking the loans using them on home improvements or whatever and then going bankrupt. Again there were no proper checks. It's eye opening yet seems to have been brushed under the carpet. Imagine if Corbyn had got in power and done this ... there'd be absolute outrage by the tabloid press!

www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/06/covid-bounce-back-loans-paid-for-cars-watches-and-even-porn

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 17:58

If Labour thinks there’s a way out of this mess then they’re free to share

And help the Tories stay in power? They’re better advised to keep their ideas to themselves until a GE is called.

Aishah231 · 01/11/2022 17:57

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/11/2022 13:56

We could put a 10% wealth tax on the country's 177 billionaires and clear the fiscal hole and have enough left over to fix social care too

We could try, but it's been attempted before and doesn't work - because the very wealthy have the wherewithal to protect their money via schemes which would tie the rest of us in knots

The government could close tax loopholes so they can't do this. It just doesn't want to. I agree with much of the above about the amount of wasted money during lockdown. Can we add the billions spent on a mostly useless vaccine to that list.

Girasoli · 01/11/2022 17:54

I'm a bit worried about the planned changes to childcare funding...the proposed £2000 per family doesn't sound like it'll go as far as the 30 free hours.

YuzuP · 01/11/2022 17:49

I can’t see how anything BUT tax increases will get us out of this. Labour would increase them too. And rightly IMO. If Labour thinks there’s a way out of this mess then they’re free to share and Rishi is centrist enough to appropriate any good ideas. I hope.

Kendodd · 01/11/2022 17:42

Aleaiactaest · 01/11/2022 17:17

“Another driver for growth would be to accelerate house building, especially energy-efficient affordable homes for rent or sale, combining significant public resources alongside private funding including from pension funds,
and facilitating the compulsory purchase of sites not in use, or suitable for conversion from office to apartments, alongside simplified and time-limited planning procedures.

This is not popular with Tory donors and voters. Property developers resist stricter controls over the quality of build or to oblige the respect of affordable housing quotas. Tory voters tend to oppose relaxation of planning procedures. And there is a deep attachment to a perverse, but a familiar model for growth based on the accumulation of unearned wealth and rentier income from a stagnant pool of property assets.”

Successive governments have been told for many years that we need to build more. That is super important for England, and also the green and technology revolution. We could do so much in the technology sector.

I would also really welcome suitable old age housing. Would be so much better for the very elderly. We do need to focus on dignified dying as a society rather than medicating unnecessarily until the very end.

The private sector has completely and utterly failed and failed for decades, to provide safe, good quality, affordable homes. The state should take over and build itself.

Ziegfeld · 01/11/2022 17:31

People have incredibly short memories

The same people who said lockdowns should be faster/longer/more draconian are now moaning about the cost of furlough and bounce back loans. Who do they think was going to pay for all that - the fairies?

The same people who pre COVID complained the Government wasn’t borrowing enough and should be maxing out its credit card to pump money into infrastructure, education and the NHS are now criticising it for financial imprudence and stoking inflation!

Aleaiactaest · 01/11/2022 17:17

“Another driver for growth would be to accelerate house building, especially energy-efficient affordable homes for rent or sale, combining significant public resources alongside private funding including from pension funds,
and facilitating the compulsory purchase of sites not in use, or suitable for conversion from office to apartments, alongside simplified and time-limited planning procedures.

This is not popular with Tory donors and voters. Property developers resist stricter controls over the quality of build or to oblige the respect of affordable housing quotas. Tory voters tend to oppose relaxation of planning procedures. And there is a deep attachment to a perverse, but a familiar model for growth based on the accumulation of unearned wealth and rentier income from a stagnant pool of property assets.”

Successive governments have been told for many years that we need to build more. That is super important for England, and also the green and technology revolution. We could do so much in the technology sector.

I would also really welcome suitable old age housing. Would be so much better for the very elderly. We do need to focus on dignified dying as a society rather than medicating unnecessarily until the very end.

luckylavender · 01/11/2022 17:14

YuzuP · 01/11/2022 10:18

We need tax rises unfortunately - I felt a red mist descend on reading the details of the mini budget. We can’t furlough people and businesses over what turned out to be a bad flu (why oh why was it not just the vulnerable who stayed at home and were furloughed?) and then not pay it back as a society. The books have got to be balanced.

OR - everyone who received furlough can pay it back. I don’t think that would be popular.

I can't believe people are still trotting out the 'bad flu' line. Seriously. Maybe ask the government what happened to the 37b they spent on Track and Trace and the billions wasted on PPE via the VIP lane. Or the amounts they spend on government private jets. Eye watering. We're not all in this together.

hesbeingabitofadick · 01/11/2022 17:12

Cancelling HS2 would be a start.

walkinginsunshinekat · 01/11/2022 17:02

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/11/2022 14:03

I confess I'm no expert in other european countries' economies, walkinginsunshinekat (or in the UK's come to that) so honestly can't say exactly what they spent and whether it was wise

The "Why are we helping the rich with their energy costs?" is an easy one though - as with the so-far-retained triple lock on pensions it's so they'll keep backing the Tories

You re qualified to be the next Chancellor then!!!

Well, i m not talking about even higher rate tax payers, some whom aren't actually that well off.
I'm talking about millionaires (2.4m in the UK) & corporations like Amazon.

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 16:54

We can't afford the welfare state as it is that for sure

We can’t afford it to get any worse either, it’s on life support as it is.

Grumpybutfunny · 01/11/2022 16:32

Jaxhog · 01/11/2022 14:39

Yes, it's going to be rough, but it's always been clear that government spending during the pandemic was going to have to paid for somehow. There are lots of things we, and the government, could have done differently, but we can't change that now. No-one expected the Ukraine war either, with its impact of fuel prices.

All we can do now is to look forward, plan as far as we can for that future, and help those who are struggling. We are all in this together. But we do need to take responsibility for our own needs, and not rely on 'someone else' to pick up the pieces for us. Harping on about 'what could have been' won't help us either.

It's not just COVID that could be treat like a war loan if we were in a surplus in normal years. However the last government surplus was 2000 so we need to cut spending we are in effect spending more than we earn. We can then use that surplus to pay off the debit, we've tried to spend our way out of it for years and it isn't happening.

It's where those cuts fall that's the question. We can't afford the welfare state as it is that for sure

OnBoardTheHeartOfGold · 01/11/2022 15:00

I see @OminousBirdAWing already gave us some figures. It makes me so angry.

OnBoardTheHeartOfGold · 01/11/2022 14:58

Some of the spending was ridiculous. £8.7 billion wasted on unusable PPE. All to companies with links to government ministers. And how much for that app that didn't even work?

Jaxhog · 01/11/2022 14:39

Yes, it's going to be rough, but it's always been clear that government spending during the pandemic was going to have to paid for somehow. There are lots of things we, and the government, could have done differently, but we can't change that now. No-one expected the Ukraine war either, with its impact of fuel prices.

All we can do now is to look forward, plan as far as we can for that future, and help those who are struggling. We are all in this together. But we do need to take responsibility for our own needs, and not rely on 'someone else' to pick up the pieces for us. Harping on about 'what could have been' won't help us either.

MotherofPearl · 01/11/2022 14:27

Unfortunately, reading the various news stories these last few weeks, the realisation has hit me that we are now going to have to:

Worker harder
Have lower pay
Pay more tax
Have (even) worse public services

At least for the next few years. Though I loathe the Tory government and hold them responsible for a lot of the mess we're in, even if we got a Labour government tomorrow, there's not all that much they could do differently about our economic plight - at least not in the short term. Unless they were willing to take us back into the Single Market, which I don't think they would be.

I hear you about the toll it takes on your MH, OP. It is extremely stressful and worrying.

GreyElephantsWearingYellowPyjamas · 01/11/2022 14:16

It’s not going to be worth going to work soon.

Aleaiactaest · 01/11/2022 14:15

Sadly the non dom billionaire types are very mobile people. Getting them to pay some tax is all most governments can hope for. Frankly, the power some of these people wield is mind boggling, subversive and frightening to me.

The left off centre goodie type billionaires like Warren Buffet or Bill Gates are the exception.
In the current world there are people who have more money and power than many governments and that is a problem.

OminousBirdAWing · 01/11/2022 14:06

The money for all the stuff the government pays for has to come from somewhere.

That's just the point - they have been wasting OUR money on shit, over and over and over again. Greed and incompetence at a level that has cost us billions upon billions of wasted pounds.

And now they have the nerve to say we're in a serious financial situation and we're all going to have to pay higher taxes because of it.

THEY put us in that situation and conveniently made themselves rich while they were doing it.

By God, I'm starting to think we're celebrating the wrong side on Nov 5th.