Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rough' tax rises on the way

209 replies

Violashift · 01/11/2022 10:13

What does this even mean? I can't take much more. Not with the rising energy prices and the absolute mess up of the mortgage interest rates rising.

How will people survive? Already we have not had pay rises and now we will all probably be taxed more.

I feel at the end of my tether. It's really affecting my mental health.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aleaiactaest · 04/11/2022 22:06

Having watched my darling grandmother suffer with dementia for many years, I don’t really believe in keeping people alive in this state anymore. I think it should be compulsory for people to fill in a form in their early sixties stating their wishes in this regard. It isn’t necessarily being kind keeping them alive, everyone should choose for themselves.
If we had better antenatal and maternity care and extensive gene testing we would also end up with a more healthy overall population. So technology in that regard is constantly developing.
In reality, our economies rely on people still having children or immigrants coming to work here. Better education and free childcare really is a must. Kids don’t get a vote though.
The NHS is on its knees. I am going to make sure I have clear medical instructions to not medicate me beyond a certain point. I know it will be hard for my children to accept but if it is written clearly the doctors will need to follow my wishes. Many old people actually feel this way too, some of course don’t. It is high time society starts having discussions along this line. Dying in peace with some dignity is just as important as being born in a safe environment.

Kendodd · 04/11/2022 17:43

Are there any care tasks that can be automated?

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 16:20

Alexandra2001 · 04/11/2022 14:36

See this is what i don't understand... i don't know anyone who has packed Granny off to a home before she really did need to go.
I helped to look after my Mum until her stroke...my friend has pretty much given up his job to care for his mum, other friends did similar.

BUT what few do is the personal (i.e turning, lifting & toilet) & dementia care, thats 24/7 and you'd need a team of perhaps 8 people to do it (2 for every 8 hrs)

No one can expect family to do this and tbh they never really have, hence the huge geriatric wards of yesteryear.

My DD worked as a carer.... its back breaking work and the 4 x 45min max anyone gets, can only be done with some family support.

If we want more social carers, then 1: we have to pay more and 2 - open up migration routes.... Brexit decimated social care.

I've worked in social care, it's not just Brexit. Some of my fellow country people are still here, they've just upskilled, like myself. In addition, The EU is now a more attractive place to go for 3rd generation migrants, the EU is paying more. Even home has modernized somewhat.

Lastly, there's not a cat in hells chance the government nor the private sector is able to fulfill the social care needs of up to 30% of the population. It's impossible.

Alexandra2001 · 04/11/2022 14:36

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 12:10

Indeed, however, this country is not going to fundamentally change, in addition, the ticking demographic timebomb of an aging population is a global issue.
The UK quite clearly has an issue with support networks for groups. Tax will not solve the problem.

See this is what i don't understand... i don't know anyone who has packed Granny off to a home before she really did need to go.
I helped to look after my Mum until her stroke...my friend has pretty much given up his job to care for his mum, other friends did similar.

BUT what few do is the personal (i.e turning, lifting & toilet) & dementia care, thats 24/7 and you'd need a team of perhaps 8 people to do it (2 for every 8 hrs)

No one can expect family to do this and tbh they never really have, hence the huge geriatric wards of yesteryear.

My DD worked as a carer.... its back breaking work and the 4 x 45min max anyone gets, can only be done with some family support.

If we want more social carers, then 1: we have to pay more and 2 - open up migration routes.... Brexit decimated social care.

L1ttledrummergirl · 04/11/2022 12:35

My point is they pretty much doubled that debt overnight with nothing to show for it.

Xenia · 04/11/2022 12:22

L1ttledrummergirl · - the problem with the KK and Liz Truss plans were they were going to borrow money ( vast amounts of additional debt) to pay for tax cuts. It was not that they had found the money after all the covid debt was still sitting there to be repaid.

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 12:10

Alexandra2001 · 04/11/2022 12:06

I don't believe this.
I ve lived in other countries with far higher tax burdens than the UK..... who manage just tickety boo.

We could mitigate (not totally prevent).... no one needs 100s of millions in the bank & there are several million in the UK with vast wealth.

It comes down to political choices... wealth taxes, reverse Brexit.. all make a huge difference.

Indeed, however, this country is not going to fundamentally change, in addition, the ticking demographic timebomb of an aging population is a global issue.
The UK quite clearly has an issue with support networks for groups. Tax will not solve the problem.

Alexandra2001 · 04/11/2022 12:06

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 09:02

The point is. No amount of tax rises are going to avoid the tough choices coming imminently this decade. This isn't a feminist issue this is a financial and time issue. There isn't enough of both.

I don't believe this.
I ve lived in other countries with far higher tax burdens than the UK..... who manage just tickety boo.

We could mitigate (not totally prevent).... no one needs 100s of millions in the bank & there are several million in the UK with vast wealth.

It comes down to political choices... wealth taxes, reverse Brexit.. all make a huge difference.

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 09:02

The point is. No amount of tax rises are going to avoid the tough choices coming imminently this decade. This isn't a feminist issue this is a financial and time issue. There isn't enough of both.

walkinginsunshinekat · 04/11/2022 08:52

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 08:13

The problem with the UK especially socially is the ideal of independence and chasing careers, materialism has fragmented the close family and the wider family. Now we're scrabbling around for the basics, childcare, housing, and care for the sick and elderly. I too come from a culture where the family unit all live near and take care of one another. My siblings and I shared a bed, and rooms, we weren't given to strangers to bring us up, nor did we have our own private bedrooms. How many parents push for babies, and children to be left in their own rooms? It's madness.
In the UK we expect this family unit to include organizations and strangers, we also expect others to pay for these facilities. We've outsourced basic human necessities and actions.
To be quite frank the economy cannot generate enough money or value to pay for these basic needs. It's NOT sustainable nor is it affordable. There are so many people for whom the family unit is either non-existent or very, very fragmented.
Independence, and individualism from one another have come at a huge cost.

Was ever thus.

Human nature is based on greed and self interest, kids have been farmed out in poorer areas since time began or in my childhood, we just let out, with the oldest child looking after the youngest.

Most parents have always worked in poor families/areas.

Maybe look at why other countries manage with so much cheaper childcare?

UK has the least availability and most expensive in Europe.

People live longer (maybe 10 or 15 years more) & caring for elderly parents with dementia and incontinence is terrible.

My Gran did it for her mum and it almost killed my Gran - people who espouse this course of action, haven't a clue.

UnderHisPie · 04/11/2022 08:49

All of these wonderful cultures where it’s about family just involve the woman sacrificing themselves.*

Yup. It's very rarely the men doing it. It's just women, giving up their lives for someone else.

It's no coincidence that multi generational living tends to reduce when girls get the same education and chances as boys.

I think there is a lot to be said for multi-gen living (I moved my mum in with me a few years back) but it needs to come about as a result of everyone making a choice and everyone mucking in.

Endlesssummer2022 · 04/11/2022 08:46

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 08:13

The problem with the UK especially socially is the ideal of independence and chasing careers, materialism has fragmented the close family and the wider family. Now we're scrabbling around for the basics, childcare, housing, and care for the sick and elderly. I too come from a culture where the family unit all live near and take care of one another. My siblings and I shared a bed, and rooms, we weren't given to strangers to bring us up, nor did we have our own private bedrooms. How many parents push for babies, and children to be left in their own rooms? It's madness.
In the UK we expect this family unit to include organizations and strangers, we also expect others to pay for these facilities. We've outsourced basic human necessities and actions.
To be quite frank the economy cannot generate enough money or value to pay for these basic needs. It's NOT sustainable nor is it affordable. There are so many people for whom the family unit is either non-existent or very, very fragmented.
Independence, and individualism from one another have come at a huge cost.

Funnily enough many women in these type of cultures are beginning to refuse to have kids as they realise they will have no life.

If you want to spend your life wiping your kids and parents arses cooped up in one house then crack on. I’m sure your DDs and DILs will also look forward to spending their adult lives wiping your grandkids and your arse.

All of these wonderful cultures where it’s about family just involve the woman sacrificing themselves. Fuck that, I’d rather live in a materialistic UK and am bringing up my DD with a western individualistic culture.

RedAppleGirl · 04/11/2022 08:13

Artygirlghost · 04/11/2022 07:39

@Grumpybutfunny
''I'm very much from the Asian view point that social care comes down to families''

You mean a view point where women are expected to spend their life caring for others, whether they really want it or not, or face stigma and family rejection?

We have an ageing society, people living longer with complex needs that often require 24 hour care.

It is rather unrealistic to think that this can be dealt by a few frazzled middle aged women who are already dealing with caring for kids and having to work to keep a roof over their heads and who are suddenly supposed to become 24 hour nurses and carers with little say in the matter.

We need to fund social care properly and stop peddling this nonsense about ''families'' which is really about women having to give up their ow lives for the benefit of everyone else.

The problem with the UK especially socially is the ideal of independence and chasing careers, materialism has fragmented the close family and the wider family. Now we're scrabbling around for the basics, childcare, housing, and care for the sick and elderly. I too come from a culture where the family unit all live near and take care of one another. My siblings and I shared a bed, and rooms, we weren't given to strangers to bring us up, nor did we have our own private bedrooms. How many parents push for babies, and children to be left in their own rooms? It's madness.
In the UK we expect this family unit to include organizations and strangers, we also expect others to pay for these facilities. We've outsourced basic human necessities and actions.
To be quite frank the economy cannot generate enough money or value to pay for these basic needs. It's NOT sustainable nor is it affordable. There are so many people for whom the family unit is either non-existent or very, very fragmented.
Independence, and individualism from one another have come at a huge cost.

walkinginsunshinekat · 04/11/2022 08:01

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/11/2022 23:02

This is what you get for voting Tory. I hope the idiots that do are happy.

When will people ever see them for what they are....morally bankrupt, inept, self serving c*nts.

Truss should face charges.

Listened to BOE Gov Andrew Bailey yesterday, he said we were hours away from financial collapse due to the mini budget and the damage, though halted and in ways reversed, is permanent.

Truss and Kwarteng did this, deliberately - i think they should both face criminal charges, as should anyone else who assisted them.

Iceland jailed people after the global financial crash.

Can't really charge people for Brexit, we voted for it and in the main, still support it, or at least our political parties currently do.

Endlesssummer2022 · 04/11/2022 07:49

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/11/2022 23:02

This is what you get for voting Tory. I hope the idiots that do are happy.

When will people ever see them for what they are....morally bankrupt, inept, self serving c*nts.

Truss should face charges.

Only Truss? She was the inevitable consequence of voting for Brexit in 2016 or even Cameron before it. She was also the only one to ever be honest about her intentions.

The original sin was Cameron turning his parties internal fight into the Referendum. He sowed the seeds for resentment against the EU by bringing in a ruinous austerity plan then blaming the EU for the consequences. The average reading age in this country is 7 so of course the Daily Mail and Sun headlines cut through and Leave won.

He ran away. The pound started to slide and the debts started to mount.

We then got May, who was useless and poorly advised. She then announced her ridiculous red lines and backed herself into a corner triggering Article 50 without having a plan for now it would work.

She lost complete control and was booted out after losing her majority. The pound continued to slide and the debts continued to mount. Productivity stalled.

We then got Johnson, a complete bumbling, lazy tit who presided over corruption in an epic scale. This included Rishi writing off about £40bn in fraud during Covid and helping accelerate the spread of covid through his duly Hell out to Eat Out scheme.

Boris was chased out.The pound continued to slide and the debts continued to mount. Inflation start to climb and productivity went backwards.

Truss came in for 5 minutes and did what she said she would do to kick start creativity. It flopped as the markets were spooked.

She was chased out. The pound crashed and the debt climbed.

We now have Rishi and apparently he’s going to make it all better. However, having looked today, the pound slightly fell this week, inflation and debt is still climbing and productivity has moved nowhere.

Artygirlghost · 04/11/2022 07:39

@Grumpybutfunny
''I'm very much from the Asian view point that social care comes down to families''

You mean a view point where women are expected to spend their life caring for others, whether they really want it or not, or face stigma and family rejection?

We have an ageing society, people living longer with complex needs that often require 24 hour care.

It is rather unrealistic to think that this can be dealt by a few frazzled middle aged women who are already dealing with caring for kids and having to work to keep a roof over their heads and who are suddenly supposed to become 24 hour nurses and carers with little say in the matter.

We need to fund social care properly and stop peddling this nonsense about ''families'' which is really about women having to give up their ow lives for the benefit of everyone else.

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/11/2022 23:02

This is what you get for voting Tory. I hope the idiots that do are happy.

When will people ever see them for what they are....morally bankrupt, inept, self serving c*nts.

Truss should face charges.

AloysiusBear · 03/11/2022 22:49

DH and i are high earners. We're assuming we'll take the bit big time, we can live with that. Needs must.

L1ttledrummergirl · 03/11/2022 22:27

We spent £70 billion on furlough as a country, and Truss and Kwartang spent £60 billion overnight on ???

We apparently had a surplus before that budget. It's not furlough we are paying for, it's tory hubris.

Xenia · 03/11/2022 22:15

Someon asked about the debt. We took on massive debt due to paying furlough money etc. Many countries did and in the UK 91% hhave had at least one vaccine. I am in a very rare category in that since March 2020 I was against the state spending all that money so am particularly unhapyp I will be paying it back for 20 years through extra tax but it is no surprise - we knew from early 2020 that if we went down this magic money tree route then there would be debts for a generation. We made the wrong choice.

walkinginsunshinekat · 03/11/2022 19:30

Capri3 · 03/11/2022 15:14

The top 10% of earners pay over 60% of all income tax, with the top 1% (aka the rich) paying 28% of that. Who are these rich people who are apparently avoiding paying tax?

So what? they will have to pay more, e.g dividends, CGT, IHT avoidance - all will have to change.

TBH these figures actually show how little real earnings have increased, rather than the wealthy pay too much.

In 2015, UK had approx 720k millionaires, today we have 2.4m millionaires.
During the pandemic, the UK gained an additional 24 billionaires (they didn't move here)

So whatever you think of the Tax system, it's not holding back the rich from getting richer.

We simply cannot tax people who have little i.e lower middle earners when they are also struggling.

On cash in hand with sole traders - yes its problematic but that money will be spent in local shops/pubs etc not put in investment funds, many of which have very large overseas holdings.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/11/2022 18:36

We know from HMRC stats that tax avoidance is a huge problem

Are you sure you mean avoidance rather than evasion, Believeitornot? - after all the first is perfectly legal and the second not

Given the way it's wasted only a fool would pay more tax than they have to, and if folk want to support whatever cause we can do it privately
FWIW I do agree that some sail very close to the wind between what's allowed and what isn't, but the answer to that is to close loopholes rather than blame those who utilise legitimate ones

WatchoRulo · 03/11/2022 17:42

Ifailed · 01/11/2022 11:22

This country has been living on the never never for decades. We make very little now, relying on importing goods from countries with low or no protection for their workforce, import most of our food, have sold off most of our infrastructure to foreign governments and in return offer the world "services".

A lot of these "services" are somewhat dubious, relying on sleight of hand and financial shenanigans to magically create "wealth" which can easily come tumbling down (see recent wobble over pension funds where a trillion pounds nearly disappeared - did it fall down the back of a sofa?).

AI will soon replace a lot of these wonderful "services"; what's left to bring in the desperately needed Dollar, Euro and Renminbi - an end-of-pier show based on the ludicrous Royal Family?

We can't go on like this. We are not a Global power, it's time to stop swaggering around interfering with other countries conflicts & dutifully following the USA into all of it's mismanaged, military-led interventions. We don't need any aircraft carriers, let alone two new ones that break down, much to the amusement of the 100s of countries that get by with none.

We can't treat our sick, we can't care for our frail, we can't house our homeless and we can't warm our cold. I hate to think how things will look in 10 or 20 years time.

That's a very bleak view but I tend to agree with most of it, sadly.

Capri3 · 03/11/2022 17:23

Believeitornot · 03/11/2022 15:37

They don’t pay tax. So why would they show up on these stats?

Plus that’s income tax - ie from PAYE. People in that 10% include people earning over £61,000.

We know from HMRC stats that tax avoidance is a huge problem. It’ll be people with interesting tax schemes or who claim to be overseas resident.

So you mean overseas residents who pay tax in their country of residence? The only interesting tax schemes are used by the likes of Starbucks, so still not “rich people” not paying tax. Anyone living in the UK full time, and earning money in the UK pays tax, even “rich people”. A lot of tax avoidance is from individuals working cash in hand. That’s not top CEO’s of companies who earn hundreds of thousands of pounds (who a lot on here seem to hate), they’re all PAYE and paying hundreds of thousands of pounds in tax too.

Believeitornot · 03/11/2022 15:38

Sorry the top 10% earn over £62k not £61k.

If salaries were higher then the tax take would be higher across the board. Instead we have companies paying shit wages subsidised by universal credit.