Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is unfair or should I just accept it as I’m an adult too?

318 replies

Shortslothdancing · 01/11/2022 08:20

I had some time out of work when my children were little as a sahm (biggest regret ever) and I’ve gone back to work in the last couple of years, 25 hours a week. I pick up about £1100 a month. Not great.
DH picks up (after tax) approx £5500 a month, he has a company car, a petrol card and a work mobile phone. Although he pays tax on those benefits. We don’t have a mortgage but he does cover the bills from his wages - around £1800 a month, including some of the food bill.
From my £1100 I pay for my phone, my petrol (I still do all the schools runs and taking the kids to clubs etc), my road tax / insurance, about £250 a month of food, kids’ clothes, birthday / Christmas presents (obviously an annual cost, but I try and save a bit each month) and the childcare bill for wrap around - it’s not that much, usually about £60 a month.
phone - £45
petrol - £200
tax / insurance - £50
food - £250
saving for birthdays and Christmas - £50
childcare - £60
clothes for children - varies but I usually allow approx £50 a month as one child is now a teenager and there are three of them.

pocket money for all three dc - £80
This comes to around £800 leaving me about £300 a month. DH is now refusing to pay for school lunches for oldest dc. Two younger ones have sandwiches. The oldest likes to get lunch with his mates at school. This is about £15 a week, so it’ll be another £60 a month.

this will leave me with about £240. I’m sure that is loads to a lot of people at the moment and I probably shouldn’t be complaining but it feels unfair that I am tracking every leftover penny vs DH with his £3.5k left after household bills.
I do all the housework and childcare even though I work 25 hours.
yanbu - yes it’s unfair
yabu - you’re an adult and responsible for yourself and should increase your hours / work harder / take a second job and count yourself lucky that you are overall in a fortunate financial situation.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 01/11/2022 11:21

OP, DH and I have never had a joint account. He was bybfar the bigger earner. After a break to look after the DC I went back to work 20 years ago and cleared £600. I can honestly say working part-time, 7 hours less than you and juggling home and hearth was the hardest I have ever worked and I always had a cleaner.

From the £600 I bought the DC's and my clothes, plus haircuts and personal.spends. DH started giving me a £500 monthly allowance for food and household expenses.

Over the years and as I earnt more, I picked up things like my car and the DC's activities.

I think that was fair and it never bothered me that DH had stacks more personal money. Mainly because he didn't spend it but rather stashed it away for the family.

You and your DH need a serious talk.

Nc4this2 · 01/11/2022 11:21

Also, without you doing these things your dh wouldn't be earning what he does now as you've facilitated his career by taking time out of yours to raise his (your) dc.

If he'd been the one to do that it would have stalled his career so he wouldn't be as far along as he is, and if (god forbid) you weren't around, he'd have to pay someone a lot more than you're getting to look after his kids/house; or he'd have to give up his job to do it himself.
Either way, he wouldn't be earning (or keeping as much of it) as he does at the moment.

MrKlaw · 01/11/2022 11:19

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:46

A lot of people are getting a bit carried away here, you do not have to divorce him you just have to educate him financially 🤣

Set up a spreadsheet with the monthly outgoings. Include EVERYTHING, all income and all expenditure. Then split it so that you bear 1/5 of it and he bears 4/5 of it (which is roughly your earnings) and you and he can keep whatever’s left, i.e.

Joint income is £6,600 (5,500 him, 1,100 you)
Outgoings are £3,160 (1800 him, 660 you plus the 500 for holidays)

So he should bear £2,528 of the outgoings, leaving him with £2,972 a month.

You should bear £632 of the outgoings, leaving you with £468 a month.

Then discuss what he’s doing with the £2,972. Hopefully saving it for a rainy day/pension/projects.

Oh, and he’s a complete d*ck for not wanting to pay for his children’s lunch - that bit I do agree with 🤣

honestly the difference is so great either OP should pay nothing towards bills, DH should provide more to OP to help with disposable, or DH should contirbute towards a private pension for OP.

NukaColaQuantum · 01/11/2022 11:17

You have been financially abused your entire marriage OP.

NKFell · 01/11/2022 11:17

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 01/11/2022 08:25

YANBU he needs to step up and pay for his kids. Can you track it all on a spreadsheet and show him?

I came to suggest this so, this!

WorrieaboutFIL · 01/11/2022 11:15

He pays absolutely nothing for his children? What am I reading?

Ponderingwindow · 01/11/2022 11:14

Your husband got to his wage by having you there taking care of his children and letting him focus on work. He didn’t have to balance work and child care for a young child. He didn’t have to miss out on work to recover from childbirth. He continues to be able to maximize his earnings by you being the parent that takes care of more child related issues. Those things don’t just impact earning power on the moment, they are cumulative over and entire career.

Your current financial setup is monumentally unfair.

it won’t be solved with small adjustments. It needs to be completely reset.

beastlyslumber · 01/11/2022 11:09

monsteramunch · 01/11/2022 11:07

He knows she has £3,000 a year disposable income. He knows he has £42,000 a year disposable income.

Someone capable of commanding a £100,000 doesn't need a spreadsheet to see how unfair and cruel that is. They need a moral compass.

Exactly. He's not an idiot, he knows exactly what he's doing.

What sort of a man refuses to pay for food for his children?

It's not because he doesn't understand that he can afford it. He's financially abusing his family and people saying he just needs to be told that he earns more money than his wife are being spectacularly naive.

Mardyface · 01/11/2022 11:08

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:59

@xogossipgirlxo because honestly, why is the MumsNet default to threaten to divorce him, remove his children from the family home, claim CMS and live a lonely life?

This is 100% fixable. I have been the lower earner and the breadwinner. They just need to talk to each other. He earns roughly £100k - give the man a spreadsheet and some strong words.

I’ve never been a SAHM, but I did burn through my savings on my first maternity leave because I kept contributing to bills. I then told my husband that was unfair and would never happen again. And it hasn’t.

I don't think people expect to say 'ltb' and that the OP will immediately comply. The OP will always make their own decision of course. But the knowledge that they COULD and CAN leave is a powerful thing if they are being financially abused. It's about the power you have to make your own decisions.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 01/11/2022 11:07

Reading threads like this makes me so angry. This utter shit of a man not paying for his own children. I would divorce the cunt and take him for every penny - he is fucking scum.

monsteramunch · 01/11/2022 11:07

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:59

@xogossipgirlxo because honestly, why is the MumsNet default to threaten to divorce him, remove his children from the family home, claim CMS and live a lonely life?

This is 100% fixable. I have been the lower earner and the breadwinner. They just need to talk to each other. He earns roughly £100k - give the man a spreadsheet and some strong words.

I’ve never been a SAHM, but I did burn through my savings on my first maternity leave because I kept contributing to bills. I then told my husband that was unfair and would never happen again. And it hasn’t.

He knows she has £3,000 a year disposable income. He knows he has £42,000 a year disposable income.

Someone capable of commanding a £100,000 doesn't need a spreadsheet to see how unfair and cruel that is. They need a moral compass.

YeahmetooJill · 01/11/2022 11:06

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:46

A lot of people are getting a bit carried away here, you do not have to divorce him you just have to educate him financially 🤣

Set up a spreadsheet with the monthly outgoings. Include EVERYTHING, all income and all expenditure. Then split it so that you bear 1/5 of it and he bears 4/5 of it (which is roughly your earnings) and you and he can keep whatever’s left, i.e.

Joint income is £6,600 (5,500 him, 1,100 you)
Outgoings are £3,160 (1800 him, 660 you plus the 500 for holidays)

So he should bear £2,528 of the outgoings, leaving him with £2,972 a month.

You should bear £632 of the outgoings, leaving you with £468 a month.

Then discuss what he’s doing with the £2,972. Hopefully saving it for a rainy day/pension/projects.

Oh, and he’s a complete d*ck for not wanting to pay for his children’s lunch - that bit I do agree with 🤣

The naivety here is astonishing.

It really is not that he lacks basic mathematical skills.

He understands exactly what he is doing both financially and in terms of benefiting from domestic and childcare labour from OP. How you can acknowledge he is a dick for refusing to pay for his children's lunches, yet see that as an aberration and not part of his system, is utterly beyond me.

And 2,972 disposable income compared to 468 is not fair.

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:59

@xogossipgirlxo because honestly, why is the MumsNet default to threaten to divorce him, remove his children from the family home, claim CMS and live a lonely life?

This is 100% fixable. I have been the lower earner and the breadwinner. They just need to talk to each other. He earns roughly £100k - give the man a spreadsheet and some strong words.

I’ve never been a SAHM, but I did burn through my savings on my first maternity leave because I kept contributing to bills. I then told my husband that was unfair and would never happen again. And it hasn’t.

Nc4this2 · 01/11/2022 10:59

@Shortslothdancing forgot to add..... This is unfair and it doesn't seem as though your dh values you at all, or the contribution you've made in raising his (your) dc and keeping his (your) house running and all other life admin.

I'm not sure what the answer is though, but it certainly seems as though he doesn't care about you at all and sees you as lesser than him.

balconyoasis · 01/11/2022 10:58

monsteramunch · 01/11/2022 09:27

Currently, here's the crux of it.

You have £3000 disposable income a year,

He has £42,000 disposable income a year,

Let that sink in.

I genuinely don't think that someone who loves and respects you could want that disparity.

This. Absolutely horrendous.

beastlyslumber · 01/11/2022 10:56

Newnameoclock · 01/11/2022 09:11

Divorce him, sell the house, split the proceeds, get CMS set up and live happily ever after. You'll be in a far better position financially than you are now.

Honestly, this.

xogossipgirlxo · 01/11/2022 10:53

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:46

A lot of people are getting a bit carried away here, you do not have to divorce him you just have to educate him financially 🤣

Set up a spreadsheet with the monthly outgoings. Include EVERYTHING, all income and all expenditure. Then split it so that you bear 1/5 of it and he bears 4/5 of it (which is roughly your earnings) and you and he can keep whatever’s left, i.e.

Joint income is £6,600 (5,500 him, 1,100 you)
Outgoings are £3,160 (1800 him, 660 you plus the 500 for holidays)

So he should bear £2,528 of the outgoings, leaving him with £2,972 a month.

You should bear £632 of the outgoings, leaving you with £468 a month.

Then discuss what he’s doing with the £2,972. Hopefully saving it for a rainy day/pension/projects.

Oh, and he’s a complete d*ck for not wanting to pay for his children’s lunch - that bit I do agree with 🤣

I don't think I get why you put two laughing emojis, because it's not funny at all. This guy just doesn't care. He's comfy having lots of money for himself.

Nc4this2 · 01/11/2022 10:52

My dh now earns 20x my wage (before tax), and we've had long periods where I wasn't able to contribute at all (illness and when dc were young).

Not once has my dh ever made me feel as though it's his money.

We have joint accounts only and although I'm naturally not a big spender, my dh has never questioned what I spend money on and has actually encouraged me to spend more on myself.

He's of the opinion that we are a couple and what's his is mine (as am I).

But, we had discussed our attitudes to money, dc, religion, etc, etc, before we got too serious so we knew that we were on the same page in regard to the important things.

@Shortslothdancing Did you not ever do this, or has he changed?

Janie143 · 01/11/2022 10:52

Also he left her in poverty when she was sahm looking after his kids

Appleblum · 01/11/2022 10:51

That's not good. What is he doing with all the money he has left over? Is it in a savings pot for the family? Would you have access to this money if you needed it? Ideally both your salaries should go into a joint pot, but at the very least he should be contributing more towards the monthly expenses.

Janie143 · 01/11/2022 10:50

Come off it. He's can't hold down a job where he gets the salary and benefits that he does and need "educating" by a fucking spreadsheet

b8tes7sw · 01/11/2022 10:50

What on earth is he doing with the £3.5k! Does he know your exact outgoings?

monsteramunch · 01/11/2022 10:48

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:46

A lot of people are getting a bit carried away here, you do not have to divorce him you just have to educate him financially 🤣

Set up a spreadsheet with the monthly outgoings. Include EVERYTHING, all income and all expenditure. Then split it so that you bear 1/5 of it and he bears 4/5 of it (which is roughly your earnings) and you and he can keep whatever’s left, i.e.

Joint income is £6,600 (5,500 him, 1,100 you)
Outgoings are £3,160 (1800 him, 660 you plus the 500 for holidays)

So he should bear £2,528 of the outgoings, leaving him with £2,972 a month.

You should bear £632 of the outgoings, leaving you with £468 a month.

Then discuss what he’s doing with the £2,972. Hopefully saving it for a rainy day/pension/projects.

Oh, and he’s a complete d*ck for not wanting to pay for his children’s lunch - that bit I do agree with 🤣

Come off it, he earns £5.5k after tax - so he's not stupid.

He's not unaware of his wife having no money.

He just doesn't care.

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:46

A lot of people are getting a bit carried away here, you do not have to divorce him you just have to educate him financially 🤣

Set up a spreadsheet with the monthly outgoings. Include EVERYTHING, all income and all expenditure. Then split it so that you bear 1/5 of it and he bears 4/5 of it (which is roughly your earnings) and you and he can keep whatever’s left, i.e.

Joint income is £6,600 (5,500 him, 1,100 you)
Outgoings are £3,160 (1800 him, 660 you plus the 500 for holidays)

So he should bear £2,528 of the outgoings, leaving him with £2,972 a month.

You should bear £632 of the outgoings, leaving you with £468 a month.

Then discuss what he’s doing with the £2,972. Hopefully saving it for a rainy day/pension/projects.

Oh, and he’s a complete d*ck for not wanting to pay for his children’s lunch - that bit I do agree with 🤣

thenightsky · 01/11/2022 10:46

monsteramunch · 01/11/2022 10:26

I don't know how you can look at this man and think he loves you? Nobody who genuinely loves their partner would be comfortable with this disparity in disposable income when they share children and a home.

There's a lot of men out there that need to realise they are actually worth more to their wives and kids dead.