Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is unfair or should I just accept it as I’m an adult too?

318 replies

Shortslothdancing · 01/11/2022 08:20

I had some time out of work when my children were little as a sahm (biggest regret ever) and I’ve gone back to work in the last couple of years, 25 hours a week. I pick up about £1100 a month. Not great.
DH picks up (after tax) approx £5500 a month, he has a company car, a petrol card and a work mobile phone. Although he pays tax on those benefits. We don’t have a mortgage but he does cover the bills from his wages - around £1800 a month, including some of the food bill.
From my £1100 I pay for my phone, my petrol (I still do all the schools runs and taking the kids to clubs etc), my road tax / insurance, about £250 a month of food, kids’ clothes, birthday / Christmas presents (obviously an annual cost, but I try and save a bit each month) and the childcare bill for wrap around - it’s not that much, usually about £60 a month.
phone - £45
petrol - £200
tax / insurance - £50
food - £250
saving for birthdays and Christmas - £50
childcare - £60
clothes for children - varies but I usually allow approx £50 a month as one child is now a teenager and there are three of them.

pocket money for all three dc - £80
This comes to around £800 leaving me about £300 a month. DH is now refusing to pay for school lunches for oldest dc. Two younger ones have sandwiches. The oldest likes to get lunch with his mates at school. This is about £15 a week, so it’ll be another £60 a month.

this will leave me with about £240. I’m sure that is loads to a lot of people at the moment and I probably shouldn’t be complaining but it feels unfair that I am tracking every leftover penny vs DH with his £3.5k left after household bills.
I do all the housework and childcare even though I work 25 hours.
yanbu - yes it’s unfair
yabu - you’re an adult and responsible for yourself and should increase your hours / work harder / take a second job and count yourself lucky that you are overall in a fortunate financial situation.

OP posts:
Flowersonthewall6 · 01/11/2022 12:25

I would suggest one joint account for all bills / kid related payments and separate accounts that your wages get paid into.

Work our all costs and bills and spilt that into a percentage of your take home pay.

if your take home is 1500 and his is 3000 (for easy maths) you put in 1/3 off the bills and he puts in 2/3 bills. Then what ever you have left over is your money to do what you want. Ideally the total bill costs should include a buffer.

DuoLingoMakesMeBingo · 01/11/2022 12:25

You are an adult, you can manage with what you have, you can change your circumstances. That doesn’t stop it being unfair, which it is.
Why don’t you suggest only having a joint account? How is he going to disagree with paying for lunches?

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 12:25

@Noviembre What are you talking about? How do you “see” that?

You’ve read two posts from an OP and have decided she’s married to a financially abusive bully who deserves to be divorced and taken to the cleaners. I’m saying, from experience of financial disparity, that they should talk to each other. But yes, I’m completely unreasonable and have no idea how to deal with “bullies” 🤷🏻‍♀️

Mamma80 · 01/11/2022 12:17

Its completely unreasonable, and if he doesnt understand that then Id be questioning my marriage.
Send him an invoice for childcare and school runs. If he thinks ita your job he can pay you for it! Joint responsibility, joint lifestyle.

MichaelFabricantWig · 01/11/2022 12:15

Your husband is a wanker

you would probably be better off divorced

3peassuit · 01/11/2022 12:11

He’s got it too good. What decent parent with 3.5k disposable income refuses to pay for school lunches? He sounds irredeemably stingy. It does sound like financial abuse to me. If you can’t sit him down and get him to understand this, I really don’t think the marriage can continue to work.

Coffeepot72 · 01/11/2022 12:09

This reminds me of (one of) the reasons I'm no longer with my ex. He earned a LOT more than I did, but everything was split 50/50, leaving me with practically nothing left once I'd paid my half. I used to borrow petrol money off my parents.

CristinaNov182 · 01/11/2022 12:03

What is he doing with the rest of the money?!

why don’t you two have a shared account?

why are you paying for so many things?

does he have a second or third family?

I”d ask for a shared account right away and stop paying for Christmas presents etc, you’re the one paying allowance, for gifts etc, when he earns so much?!

btw my sister was in this kind of marriage, he was counting every penny of hers while earning 3x her salary. She divorced him. He was not treating her well in general, this is a huge red flag 🚩 for a selfish & worse character

icelolly99 · 01/11/2022 12:00

Totally shocked at this. You're married with children; all earnings should be pooled!

Noviembre · 01/11/2022 11:55

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:59

@xogossipgirlxo because honestly, why is the MumsNet default to threaten to divorce him, remove his children from the family home, claim CMS and live a lonely life?

This is 100% fixable. I have been the lower earner and the breadwinner. They just need to talk to each other. He earns roughly £100k - give the man a spreadsheet and some strong words.

I’ve never been a SAHM, but I did burn through my savings on my first maternity leave because I kept contributing to bills. I then told my husband that was unfair and would never happen again. And it hasn’t.

I see you have no experience of attempting 'strong words' with a bully.

Noviembre · 01/11/2022 11:53

porridgecake · 01/11/2022 08:26

You are married.Surely your earnings are family money? What you are describing is very unfair IMO. What does your DH do with his left over money every month?

The concept of family money is dead for many many people. It is very easy for high earners to keep the low earner in a very poor lifestyle whilst enjoying their free cook/cleaner/childminder and hoarding their savings for a healthy retirement. These people don't want spouses. They want servants.

It also prevents the poorer person leaving, as the rich ones can hide their money and stay such after divorce while the poor ones get declared homeless and shunted to a hotel 50 miles away.

NoNameNowAgain · 01/11/2022 11:53

It’s horrible. He’s horrible. My grandmothers would have gone home to mother in a situation like that. Does he think the children aren’t his?
Take legal advice.

SilverGlassHare · 01/11/2022 11:47

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:59

@xogossipgirlxo because honestly, why is the MumsNet default to threaten to divorce him, remove his children from the family home, claim CMS and live a lonely life?

This is 100% fixable. I have been the lower earner and the breadwinner. They just need to talk to each other. He earns roughly £100k - give the man a spreadsheet and some strong words.

I’ve never been a SAHM, but I did burn through my savings on my first maternity leave because I kept contributing to bills. I then told my husband that was unfair and would never happen again. And it hasn’t.

Do you really, honestly, believe he's floating along unaware that he's financially abusing her? I mean, yes, ok, he might not agree it's financial abuse. But he's obviously not unaware that she's coughing up for everything for the children and earns far less than him, and he has loads more disposable income. Some strong words and a spreadsheet isn't going to make him suddenly stop being a selfish dick.

bettyfreddy · 01/11/2022 11:47

Just to add - if you ever left him I would imagine you would get quite a decent amount of maintenance from looking at his wage. It sounds like he's employed which would work in your benefit.

xogossipgirlxo · 01/11/2022 11:47

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:59

@xogossipgirlxo because honestly, why is the MumsNet default to threaten to divorce him, remove his children from the family home, claim CMS and live a lonely life?

This is 100% fixable. I have been the lower earner and the breadwinner. They just need to talk to each other. He earns roughly £100k - give the man a spreadsheet and some strong words.

I’ve never been a SAHM, but I did burn through my savings on my first maternity leave because I kept contributing to bills. I then told my husband that was unfair and would never happen again. And it hasn’t.

But he knows it very well. He must be completely daft otherwise to not to realise that he needs to provide for his children and start sharing his salary with his close family. They're married, it's not his money, why does he keep it on separate account anyway? I didn't tell her she should divorce him, but it's good to know she has options if he keeps being such a dick after she talked to him.

guinnessguzzler · 01/11/2022 11:46

Where on earth does this money go? What is the point of having thousands of pounds to spare each month and not spending it on your nearest and dearest? What can he possibly be spending it on?! I genuinely don't get it!

bettyfreddy · 01/11/2022 11:44

Absolutely ridiculous op, sorry your in this situation. Shared finances only works when it's fair - this isn't in any way.

To me this goes way past finances, he is zero lack of respect for his family. What an absolute loser.

Im absolutely fuming for you!

girlmom21 · 01/11/2022 11:44

Janie143 · 01/11/2022 10:52

Also he left her in poverty when she was sahm looking after his kids

Presumably when they first had children his income was lower and their outgoings were higher, considering their eldest children are now teens and they have no mortgage.

It's not beyond the realms of possibility he wasn't particularly well off then either.

livethelifeofyourdreams · 01/11/2022 11:40

IAmAReader · 01/11/2022 11:38

Right I don’t understand the whole idea of married with separate finances. It’s weird to me the idea of my husband having more disposable income than me or I had more than him. If/when I get married I’ll definitely be discussing expectations regarding this to make sure we are on the same page.

Yup, having financial security the best thing about being married. I can use my husband's card for anything I want but I make a bit of money for personal treats without ever having to worry about our bills. Best way to live in my opinion.

IAmAReader · 01/11/2022 11:38

weepingwinnie · 01/11/2022 09:36

I voted YABU, @Shortslothdancing, for the sole reason that neither you nor your husband seems to understand what marriage actually means - namely that money is shared. If you left him, he'd have to share it at least 50:50 (more likely 60:40 in your favour). It absolutely beats me that there is post after post on MN about married couples who have separate money.

Right I don’t understand the whole idea of married with separate finances. It’s weird to me the idea of my husband having more disposable income than me or I had more than him. If/when I get married I’ll definitely be discussing expectations regarding this to make sure we are on the same page.

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 11:35

It’s financial abuse. He’s got 3 children and is not paying a penny for childrens’ childcare, activities, lunch or clothes.
I couldn’t live like that. what example is it setting children.
What happens if teen gets an opportunity to go on a school holiday - you say no as you can’t afford it meanwhile dad has thousands spare. What about uni? Your dc can’t borrow enough to cover their halls as maintenance loan goes on family income and parents are expected to make up difference. You can’t afford to pay and he won’t.
If you get some legal advice and check cm and benefits position I suspect you’d be much better off.

Zingy123 · 01/11/2022 11:26

I never understand how this situation occurs. He's a cockwomble and needs telling.

Topsyturvy78 · 01/11/2022 11:25

He's a financial controlling ass. It's a type of domestic abuse. He can't expect a teenager to take a pack up for school. It's not cool to do that. My mum couldn't afford school dinners for me when she was told we were no longer entitled to free school meals second year seniors. I chose to go home and make my own dinner rather than take a pack up.

livethelifeofyourdreams · 01/11/2022 11:24

You are not responsible for yourself in a family. That's the entire point of a family, it's like a business. You don't hire people in a company to all do a bit of each job, you hire a manager, a cleaner, etc. etc.

I'm the cleaner, the school runner, the cook, the tidier, the organiser, the first aider, animal carer, and a few other things.

He's the bill payer and we are both the parent and partner.

You're not financially independent if you're a wife, you're in a family and a marriage and not single.

livethelifeofyourdreams · 01/11/2022 11:22

Doesn't sound like your marriage is a partnership at all.
Did you agree to be a housewife with him? What was the deal?

Mine makes half what yours does and I make just under what you do and consider myself a housewife because all that money is mine and he pays all the bills.

That's what HE wants. It's what I want.

How has it got to this? Where is all his money going if not on his family?

Swipe left for the next trending thread