Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is unfair or should I just accept it as I’m an adult too?

318 replies

Shortslothdancing · 01/11/2022 08:20

I had some time out of work when my children were little as a sahm (biggest regret ever) and I’ve gone back to work in the last couple of years, 25 hours a week. I pick up about £1100 a month. Not great.
DH picks up (after tax) approx £5500 a month, he has a company car, a petrol card and a work mobile phone. Although he pays tax on those benefits. We don’t have a mortgage but he does cover the bills from his wages - around £1800 a month, including some of the food bill.
From my £1100 I pay for my phone, my petrol (I still do all the schools runs and taking the kids to clubs etc), my road tax / insurance, about £250 a month of food, kids’ clothes, birthday / Christmas presents (obviously an annual cost, but I try and save a bit each month) and the childcare bill for wrap around - it’s not that much, usually about £60 a month.
phone - £45
petrol - £200
tax / insurance - £50
food - £250
saving for birthdays and Christmas - £50
childcare - £60
clothes for children - varies but I usually allow approx £50 a month as one child is now a teenager and there are three of them.

pocket money for all three dc - £80
This comes to around £800 leaving me about £300 a month. DH is now refusing to pay for school lunches for oldest dc. Two younger ones have sandwiches. The oldest likes to get lunch with his mates at school. This is about £15 a week, so it’ll be another £60 a month.

this will leave me with about £240. I’m sure that is loads to a lot of people at the moment and I probably shouldn’t be complaining but it feels unfair that I am tracking every leftover penny vs DH with his £3.5k left after household bills.
I do all the housework and childcare even though I work 25 hours.
yanbu - yes it’s unfair
yabu - you’re an adult and responsible for yourself and should increase your hours / work harder / take a second job and count yourself lucky that you are overall in a fortunate financial situation.

OP posts:
VollywoodHampires · 01/11/2022 13:51

girlmom21 · 01/11/2022 08:29

It's not financial abuse if it's what you agreed to.

Sit down and review your finances together. Review incomings and outgoings and decide what's fair.

Of course it’s bloody financial abuse

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 13:51

He is supporting his family. That's kind of a given since he's paying the bills and they have a house to live in. It's only "family money" if that is what's been agreed.

I agree that the fact that the OP is paying for "Child related" costs doesn't seem fair but by the same token, even if the husband paid for everything there would still be a disparity in their post bills pay. One that is easily rectified by the OP working full-time and the husband working part-time

There is also nothing to indicate that his "ability" to earn has been as a result of his wife looking after the children. In terms of salary - most people are rewarded for what they bring to the workplace. Not by the children they have.

PurplePixies · 01/11/2022 13:50

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 13:36

So, if the OP's husband went part-time (halving his salary) and the OP went FT (doubling hers) it seems they would earn roughly the same money (assuming some rough figures)

Everything could then get split 50-50 including spending money

Husband then does all the things that the OP does for the family as he now has the time and OP does not

Or is it that the husband has to work a full time job and give away half his money? Where is his motivation to work full time in that case?

I agree that the contributions seem a little skewed but it's not financial abuse. The husband is not keeping her destitute or even making her currently live the life of a pauper whilst he has a different lifestyle. It would appear (unless she's living in the shed) that she also benefits from the house and the bills he pays. I assume (since there is nothing in the OP that states otherwise) he is not preventing her from working more or getting better paid work. Whether her skills allow her to or not does not constitute financial abuse on his part

Do I think he's a bit of a prick given the information we have? Quite possibly. But to shout "Financial abuse" given the information we do have, quite frankly denigrates those people who are actually on the receiving end of it

‘His money’ WTF does that mean??

They’re also HIS CHILDREN.

I’d never marry a man who felt so entitled to view his wife as his personal housekeeper/sex slave.

I’ve been a SAHP for 13 yrs now. DH is the sole earner and spends far less on himself than I do. His hobbies are inexpensive compared to mine but he would never treat me as a second class citizen just because I’m no longer going out to earn money.

OP, go and visit a solicitor and look at how much better off you’d be if you got divorced from this selfish prick.

ShouldIdo · 01/11/2022 13:45

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 13:36

So, if the OP's husband went part-time (halving his salary) and the OP went FT (doubling hers) it seems they would earn roughly the same money (assuming some rough figures)

Everything could then get split 50-50 including spending money

Husband then does all the things that the OP does for the family as he now has the time and OP does not

Or is it that the husband has to work a full time job and give away half his money? Where is his motivation to work full time in that case?

I agree that the contributions seem a little skewed but it's not financial abuse. The husband is not keeping her destitute or even making her currently live the life of a pauper whilst he has a different lifestyle. It would appear (unless she's living in the shed) that she also benefits from the house and the bills he pays. I assume (since there is nothing in the OP that states otherwise) he is not preventing her from working more or getting better paid work. Whether her skills allow her to or not does not constitute financial abuse on his part

Do I think he's a bit of a prick given the information we have? Quite possibly. But to shout "Financial abuse" given the information we do have, quite frankly denigrates those people who are actually on the receiving end of it

Give away half his money?

Or share it with his family? This is a man with ££££s of spare income who will not pay for his son's school lunch,

So what is he doing with the money, spending it all on him or saving it and looking at all the money in his account each month and will end up the richest man in the graveyard!

Christ, I am so glad I am not with a person that says that shit and yes, I am the higher wage earner!

It is financial abuse and because you think he is right, does not mean he is right and therefore you need to consider how you are being treated and how you treat others!

Chesure · 01/11/2022 13:41

Iflyaway · 01/11/2022 08:37

DH is now refusing to pay for school lunches for oldest dc.

Let that sink in OP.

A man refusing to pay for food for his child.....

I can't believe this man (obviously I believe you but I can't believe how this man thinks this attitude is OK)

Why are the kids clothes, food and childcare coming out of your wages rather than the family pot?

This man is financially abusing you. He did it when he made you 'properly poor' as a SAHM. He's continuing to do it now.

Bekindnotarsey · 01/11/2022 13:39

My husband always gives me all his money, I pay all the bills combined with both monthly pay.. whatever is left we half it, has worked for us over 34 years.. he trusts me to deal with it. He should be paying half of everything you do really.

MichaelFabricantWig · 01/11/2022 13:38

Or is it that the husband has to work a full time job and give away half his money? Where is his motivation to work full time in that case?

to support his family?

it’s not just his money, it’s family money. And no doubt his ability to earn that has been facilitated by OP giving up her own career for a time to raise his children.

jollygoose · 01/11/2022 13:37

Well it`s perfectly obvious you would live a much more comfortable life it you divorced this abusive prick.

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 13:36

So, if the OP's husband went part-time (halving his salary) and the OP went FT (doubling hers) it seems they would earn roughly the same money (assuming some rough figures)

Everything could then get split 50-50 including spending money

Husband then does all the things that the OP does for the family as he now has the time and OP does not

Or is it that the husband has to work a full time job and give away half his money? Where is his motivation to work full time in that case?

I agree that the contributions seem a little skewed but it's not financial abuse. The husband is not keeping her destitute or even making her currently live the life of a pauper whilst he has a different lifestyle. It would appear (unless she's living in the shed) that she also benefits from the house and the bills he pays. I assume (since there is nothing in the OP that states otherwise) he is not preventing her from working more or getting better paid work. Whether her skills allow her to or not does not constitute financial abuse on his part

Do I think he's a bit of a prick given the information we have? Quite possibly. But to shout "Financial abuse" given the information we do have, quite frankly denigrates those people who are actually on the receiving end of it

Conkersareback · 01/11/2022 13:34

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:59

@xogossipgirlxo because honestly, why is the MumsNet default to threaten to divorce him, remove his children from the family home, claim CMS and live a lonely life?

This is 100% fixable. I have been the lower earner and the breadwinner. They just need to talk to each other. He earns roughly £100k - give the man a spreadsheet and some strong words.

I’ve never been a SAHM, but I did burn through my savings on my first maternity leave because I kept contributing to bills. I then told my husband that was unfair and would never happen again. And it hasn’t.

Oh yes, just tell him! Like OP hasn't tried!

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 01/11/2022 13:33

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/11/2022 13:23

How can 4% of people think YABU? He is financially abusive. Please get a shit hot lawyer and a forensic accountant and take you fair share of this wealth.

I seriously did wonder who the 4% were. I feel sad for OP. Shes being financially abused by her "D" H

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 01/11/2022 13:33

Divorce him.

Allsnotwell · 01/11/2022 13:25

I’ll come back later

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/11/2022 13:23

How can 4% of people think YABU? He is financially abusive. Please get a shit hot lawyer and a forensic accountant and take you fair share of this wealth.

Hillary17 · 01/11/2022 13:22

No this doesn’t seem completely fair. We worked out what our outgoings were for the house and then what percentage we each pay towards them. Husband earns a lot more than me so he covers 65% of the household outgoings (mortgage, car, food etc.) and I cover the other 35%. It means we’re left with a similar amount of disposable income each month although he is slightly better off. Just means he pays for more dates etc. I wouldn’t say your system is totally off though - he covers household but you probably need an account or amount which covers child expenses.

PhillySub · 01/11/2022 13:20

You think that you are in a relationship called marriage where everything is shared. Really you are just sleeping with and caring for a selfish git who doesn't want to take on his share of family responsibility.

Milesty1 · 01/11/2022 13:17

Two words… financial abuse! Sorry you have this OP. Could you call Womens Aid for advice?

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 12:58

guinnessguzzler · 01/11/2022 11:46

Where on earth does this money go? What is the point of having thousands of pounds to spare each month and not spending it on your nearest and dearest? What can he possibly be spending it on?! I genuinely don't get it!

He could well have an expensive hobbies eg bikes costing thousands, golf holidays and personal trainer. Meanwhile wife scrimps Clubcard vouchers to take kids out at half term.

Jenasaurus · 01/11/2022 12:58

I was in your situation for 28 years, when we split up, he has come out of it well (we never married) but he has a massive pension, whilst I am still struggling, make sure you sort out a fairer dynamic, or consider your options.

I left with the relationship with lots of debt whilst he had savings, one of his comments when our middle son got into Uni, was "well dont expect any support from me" our joint finances were taken into consideration so he got a very low grant and I took out a loan to help him, he also took 2 jobs while at Uni and as a result his studying sufferred, some men are just selfish with their money

ReneBumsWombats · 01/11/2022 12:48

You'd probably get more of his money if you divorced. You'd certainly be rid of a fucking arsehole who doesn't care about his family.

deeperthanallroses · 01/11/2022 12:39

He is obviously an asshole and whether he realises it or not it’s financial abuse. Practice in a mirror and every time you and he are together and meet someone say something like oh and if you hear of any jobs going I need a bit more hours John here refuses to pay for the childrens lunch. Etc etc. see what he thinks having it put right out there. I bet he won’t like it.
and if he won’t change, divorce him and go for as much as you can.

ChampagneLassie · 01/11/2022 12:29

I'd suggest a divorce will cost him a lot more! Seriously though I'd recommend having a proper talk through about your finances now and longer term. And if he isn't willing to be fair, if it were me I'd be planning towards separation.

Twattergy · 01/11/2022 12:29

You can either do the all earnings are pooled and same spending money approach. Or a proportional approach rather than equal spending money approach (i prefer this myself so its down to what you as a family prefer) e.g.

Your collective family basic outgoings are £2600 a month. You earn a fifth of what he does so you should contribute a fifth of outgoings and he covers rest. Each month you put £520 into a joint bills account and he puts in £2080. Then conversations about who pays for what disappear. Everything is covered from the bills account.

If he can't accept this sort of arrangement then he is totally unreasonable.

Jessstar · 01/11/2022 12:28

I am in a remarkably similar set up to you. Was a sahm, back at work PT with relatively low pay, no mortgage. My DH’s take home is slightly higher.

My DH pays all the bills. Everything. Including my phone, all expenses for both cars, all food, everything the DC need. We have savings split equally between us. My salary is my own to do what I want with. I do typically save it or use it for nice family treats but there is never any expectation on his part.

his opinion is that he can only earn his salary because I was a sahm and because I still work fewer hours and take on more responsibility with the house and kids.

geonosis · 01/11/2022 12:28

With such a high salary he should cover everything - your much smaller income should just go on whatever treats or savings you want. I would use it for days out, things for the kids. As said your husband needs sorting out!