Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is unfair or should I just accept it as I’m an adult too?

318 replies

Shortslothdancing · 01/11/2022 08:20

I had some time out of work when my children were little as a sahm (biggest regret ever) and I’ve gone back to work in the last couple of years, 25 hours a week. I pick up about £1100 a month. Not great.
DH picks up (after tax) approx £5500 a month, he has a company car, a petrol card and a work mobile phone. Although he pays tax on those benefits. We don’t have a mortgage but he does cover the bills from his wages - around £1800 a month, including some of the food bill.
From my £1100 I pay for my phone, my petrol (I still do all the schools runs and taking the kids to clubs etc), my road tax / insurance, about £250 a month of food, kids’ clothes, birthday / Christmas presents (obviously an annual cost, but I try and save a bit each month) and the childcare bill for wrap around - it’s not that much, usually about £60 a month.
phone - £45
petrol - £200
tax / insurance - £50
food - £250
saving for birthdays and Christmas - £50
childcare - £60
clothes for children - varies but I usually allow approx £50 a month as one child is now a teenager and there are three of them.

pocket money for all three dc - £80
This comes to around £800 leaving me about £300 a month. DH is now refusing to pay for school lunches for oldest dc. Two younger ones have sandwiches. The oldest likes to get lunch with his mates at school. This is about £15 a week, so it’ll be another £60 a month.

this will leave me with about £240. I’m sure that is loads to a lot of people at the moment and I probably shouldn’t be complaining but it feels unfair that I am tracking every leftover penny vs DH with his £3.5k left after household bills.
I do all the housework and childcare even though I work 25 hours.
yanbu - yes it’s unfair
yabu - you’re an adult and responsible for yourself and should increase your hours / work harder / take a second job and count yourself lucky that you are overall in a fortunate financial situation.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:51

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:50

When did all this happen? Did I miss a post?

No just guessing type of things op will be paying out based on 3 kids 2 in primary and 2 in secondary.

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:50

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:47

I honestly can’t see how anyone can view this as ok. Ops eldest comes home tonight with sole hanging off his school shoe. He’s in adult size that’s at least £40 gone. Middle one brings home letter for his yr 6 leavers hoodie £20 - everyone is getting one mum. Little one is going to panto with school £15. Next week it’s bring money to school for a poppy. Week after bring a bottle of wine for Christmas fayre. Each time her heart sinks. Mid month she’s already spent up. Meanwhile he’s able to buy whatever he fancies.

When did all this happen? Did I miss a post?

daisy46 · 01/11/2022 15:48

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 10:46

A lot of people are getting a bit carried away here, you do not have to divorce him you just have to educate him financially 🤣

Set up a spreadsheet with the monthly outgoings. Include EVERYTHING, all income and all expenditure. Then split it so that you bear 1/5 of it and he bears 4/5 of it (which is roughly your earnings) and you and he can keep whatever’s left, i.e.

Joint income is £6,600 (5,500 him, 1,100 you)
Outgoings are £3,160 (1800 him, 660 you plus the 500 for holidays)

So he should bear £2,528 of the outgoings, leaving him with £2,972 a month.

You should bear £632 of the outgoings, leaving you with £468 a month.

Then discuss what he’s doing with the £2,972. Hopefully saving it for a rainy day/pension/projects.

Oh, and he’s a complete d*ck for not wanting to pay for his children’s lunch - that bit I do agree with 🤣

he's not stupid. he knows his wife is barely scraping by. And your "equal divide" doesn't take into account any of the value that she provides by working part time in order to care for his children/his home.

askmenow · 01/11/2022 15:48

skyeisthelimit · 01/11/2022 09:24

Make a spreadsheet of all income and expenses to include annual costs as well, there is a great budget planner on MSE

www.moneysavingexpert.com/banking/budget-planning/

It's really great as it prompts you to enter all sorts of costs that you don't think about and includes presents, Christmas, haircuts, etc.

You can also record your monthly income. You can then start to work out what would be a fair split, and that includes both of you being able to save money into savings and into a pension.

It is shocking that he is prepared to put £500 a month into a holiday fund yet leave you potentially short.

If he won't agree then you might need to reconsider your options.

I don't suppose we can even hope he's been putting money aside for the loss of your pension as a sahm.
As many others have said, you need to wise up and investigate thoroughly where his money's going/held/deposited/spent.
Do it secretly so you're armed with info before instigating any discussion.
Compile the information and lodge it safely elsewhere in preparation.

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:47

I honestly can’t see how anyone can view this as ok. Ops eldest comes home tonight with sole hanging off his school shoe. He’s in adult size that’s at least £40 gone. Middle one brings home letter for his yr 6 leavers hoodie £20 - everyone is getting one mum. Little one is going to panto with school £15. Next week it’s bring money to school for a poppy. Week after bring a bottle of wine for Christmas fayre. Each time her heart sinks. Mid month she’s already spent up. Meanwhile he’s able to buy whatever he fancies.

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:46

Have already agreed on paying for kids but am adding my agreement on the cleaner!

Blankscreen · 01/11/2022 15:38

I don't the DH will reduce his hours.
OP probably knows that even if she ups her hours she'll be left doing everything for the kids.

You need to sit down and run through accounts with your DH.

What does he do with the excess money.

If he doesn't want to share his cash he should as bare minimum be paying for the children and a cleaner if he doesn't value the op doing it.

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:34

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:26

Thanks for the clarification on the segregation of school lunches - it doesn't work like that where we are! And I still agree that he should be paying for his children

But I'm also not understanding what's wrong with the OP working FT and the husband PT. So that money/time/care is more evenly split

He doesn’t sound like type to want to be a hands on dad. To go from doing no childcare to 2 school runs a day to two different schools and ferrying 3 kids to various activities is not everyone’s cup of tea. Plus 100,000 a year jobs often aren’t the sort that can be done pt with a guaranteed leave time.

BankseyVest · 01/11/2022 15:33

You should pool any money left over following paying for bills, Christmas, food, phones, holidays and the split the remainder 50/50. Your dh is being selfish and greedy

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:27

Her clothes budget for 3 children is £600 a year. She will be spending more than that. 3 growing children needing shoes, school uniforms/sports kit, clothes for activities.

PollyAmour · 01/11/2022 15:27

Your husband is a selfish entitled wanker. Tell him I said so.

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:26

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:10

He’s not paying a penny for his kids. If he was paying towards rest and just had an issue with school lunch (eg objects to junk) then that’s a different conversation.
If everyone has a school lunch (free school meals get money in lunch account) and at DDs secondary school almost everyone did he’s going to stick out like a sore thumb. Only school lunch could eat in dining room at her school so he probably can’t be with his mates. When you are 13 stuff like that matters. Obviously if a family can’t afford bills then kid has to suck it up but to do that when you have thousands and aren’t paying a penny towards his scouts, football, clothes, school activities, Christmas or birthday present is horrendous.

Thanks for the clarification on the segregation of school lunches - it doesn't work like that where we are! And I still agree that he should be paying for his children

But I'm also not understanding what's wrong with the OP working FT and the husband PT. So that money/time/care is more evenly split

Jaxhog · 01/11/2022 15:18

Totally unfair. We allocate the bills so each of us has the same 'spending' money left over. Regardless of who earns the most.

Hayliebells · 01/11/2022 15:16

It is beyond unreasonable that you're left with £240 a month and he has £3500. It's an indicator of financial abuse, it's not necessarily abuse given what you've put, but given he's refusing to pay for the DCs dinners, it could well be. How would you be financially if you split? It sounds to me like he engineering a situation where you can't afford to leave, and that's very worrying.

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:16

There was a thread on here recently about sheer amount of money schools were asking for. I suspect Op is vastly underestimating amount she spends on children meaning nothing spare for her. Sounds like 2 at primary and 1 at secondary. Plus they do activities. All paid by Op.

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:10

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:00

Not remotely money motivated

All I have said that I don't agree this is financial abuse. The OP has the option to earn more. Her husband could go part-time and share the chores and childcare. Whilst there is no indication that he would do this, there's no indication that he wouldn't

The OP doesn't indicate that either she or her children go without

If the OP had stated that her husband earns a lot of money and she is given housekeeping of £X a week and when it's gone it's gone then I would agree. But in the scenario we're being given it's simply that he earns more than she does. Which doesn't equal financial abuse

I'd still like to know what the problem with a packed lunch is though

He’s not paying a penny for his kids. If he was paying towards rest and just had an issue with school lunch (eg objects to junk) then that’s a different conversation.
If everyone has a school lunch (free school meals get money in lunch account) and at DDs secondary school almost everyone did he’s going to stick out like a sore thumb. Only school lunch could eat in dining room at her school so he probably can’t be with his mates. When you are 13 stuff like that matters. Obviously if a family can’t afford bills then kid has to suck it up but to do that when you have thousands and aren’t paying a penny towards his scouts, football, clothes, school activities, Christmas or birthday present is horrendous.

kilo · 01/11/2022 15:07

This doesn't sound fair to me. I have a similar set up at home in terms of DH's salary, company car etc, except I earn less than you. We have a joint account which both have access to and DH pays into every month. That is used for all food, petrol, bills and school trips, also Christmas and birthday presents. DH also pays £250 into my account each month (self employed so my salary goes up and down) and I buy all kids clothes and toys, holiday outings etc from this. The money should be shared in whatever way is practical for you, but I think most of it should go into a joint account so that you can both see what is being spent on what and can have conversations about that if necessary. It helps to keep things transparent.

monsteramunch · 01/11/2022 15:03

@DifferentPlanet

The OP doesn't indicate that either she or her children go without

Did you not read the first post?

it feels unfair that I am tracking every leftover penny vs DH with his £3.5k left after household bills.

Does this sound like someone who doesn't 'go without'?

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:02

IwasToldThereWouldBeCake · 01/11/2022 14:41

Why isn't the young lad who likes to eat out....paying for himself? Is he old enough to have a part time job? Why can't he pay for his lunches (if he doesn't want sandwiches) out of his pocket money?

Did DH pay off the mortage....has he sorted that out himself, meaning he contributed the house?

To be fair it's a bit much to expect a schoolchild to pay for his own lunch

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 15:01

It’s norm in our area for children to buy lunch at secondary school at least a few times a week. His Dad is on £100,000 a year. I bet the other lads with dads earning that aren’t having to do a paper round so they can buy a chicken burger with their mates on a Friday lunchtime. It’s horrible.

monsteramunch · 01/11/2022 15:01

@TomTraubertsBlues

In cases where the disparity is as big as this, he would be left with £1,833, and she'd be left with £333. Not particularly fair, is it, when she is also doing 100% of the housework?

Exactly! And all the childcare!

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 15:00

ShouldIdo · 01/11/2022 14:44

So, the child having a packed lunch - no big deal

The OP has very little personal money - no big deal

The "D"H has thousands (literally) to himself?

And you honestly think this is the way that family life and marriage works?

You sound incredibly money motivated and have no idea of what is right or wrong in a marriage.

Not remotely money motivated

All I have said that I don't agree this is financial abuse. The OP has the option to earn more. Her husband could go part-time and share the chores and childcare. Whilst there is no indication that he would do this, there's no indication that he wouldn't

The OP doesn't indicate that either she or her children go without

If the OP had stated that her husband earns a lot of money and she is given housekeeping of £X a week and when it's gone it's gone then I would agree. But in the scenario we're being given it's simply that he earns more than she does. Which doesn't equal financial abuse

I'd still like to know what the problem with a packed lunch is though

TomTraubertsBlues · 01/11/2022 14:59

essex42 · 01/11/2022 14:49

We used to contribute 2/3 of our income to the join account and keep the remaining third for personal use. Seems a fair solution

A fair solution?

In cases where the disparity is as big as this, he would be left with £1,833, and she'd be left with £333. Not particularly fair, is it, when she is also doing 100% of the housework?

IAmAReader · 01/11/2022 14:57

IwasToldThereWouldBeCake · 01/11/2022 14:41

Why isn't the young lad who likes to eat out....paying for himself? Is he old enough to have a part time job? Why can't he pay for his lunches (if he doesn't want sandwiches) out of his pocket money?

Did DH pay off the mortage....has he sorted that out himself, meaning he contributed the house?

If OP's eldest prefers to have a hot meal at school and his Dad has 3.5k disposable income every month I think that's very unreasonable to expect a teenager to pay for his own school lunches. It would be a different matter if the was from a single parent, low income household where the parent simply didn't have the money.

I don't know if her son works but many teenagers can't find a part-time job. Even if he does have one, I'd expect it to be spent on fun stuff/luxuries like bowling, cinema, going out for something to eat with friends, a savings account...but certainly not for his school lunch which I wouldn't quite describe as 'eating out'.

essex42 · 01/11/2022 14:49

We used to contribute 2/3 of our income to the join account and keep the remaining third for personal use. Seems a fair solution