Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is unfair or should I just accept it as I’m an adult too?

318 replies

Shortslothdancing · 01/11/2022 08:20

I had some time out of work when my children were little as a sahm (biggest regret ever) and I’ve gone back to work in the last couple of years, 25 hours a week. I pick up about £1100 a month. Not great.
DH picks up (after tax) approx £5500 a month, he has a company car, a petrol card and a work mobile phone. Although he pays tax on those benefits. We don’t have a mortgage but he does cover the bills from his wages - around £1800 a month, including some of the food bill.
From my £1100 I pay for my phone, my petrol (I still do all the schools runs and taking the kids to clubs etc), my road tax / insurance, about £250 a month of food, kids’ clothes, birthday / Christmas presents (obviously an annual cost, but I try and save a bit each month) and the childcare bill for wrap around - it’s not that much, usually about £60 a month.
phone - £45
petrol - £200
tax / insurance - £50
food - £250
saving for birthdays and Christmas - £50
childcare - £60
clothes for children - varies but I usually allow approx £50 a month as one child is now a teenager and there are three of them.

pocket money for all three dc - £80
This comes to around £800 leaving me about £300 a month. DH is now refusing to pay for school lunches for oldest dc. Two younger ones have sandwiches. The oldest likes to get lunch with his mates at school. This is about £15 a week, so it’ll be another £60 a month.

this will leave me with about £240. I’m sure that is loads to a lot of people at the moment and I probably shouldn’t be complaining but it feels unfair that I am tracking every leftover penny vs DH with his £3.5k left after household bills.
I do all the housework and childcare even though I work 25 hours.
yanbu - yes it’s unfair
yabu - you’re an adult and responsible for yourself and should increase your hours / work harder / take a second job and count yourself lucky that you are overall in a fortunate financial situation.

OP posts:
Harrysmummy246 · 01/11/2022 17:30

Don't have a joint account with DH for a variety of reasons, but he has significantly more income than I do. I have a card that he pays off to use for things such as dog daycare (which is because I work, part time but it's a long day for them both otherwise), all the dog food etc, the supermarket shops etc. He uses the voucher tax relief to put money aside for wraparound care but I top up on months we are over that amount (again my PT work).
I currently pay for the storage unit our possessions are in until the garage is finally rebuilt and we give notice on that.

But he would always transfer to me if I need something and wasn't too proud to ask e.g. a big car repair etc. He also tops up my pension to its limit each year.

It is very unfair to expect you to do all the child and house stuff, catch up after a career break etc and sit on that pot of money,

lannistunut · 01/11/2022 17:28

Newnameoclock · 01/11/2022 09:11

Divorce him, sell the house, split the proceeds, get CMS set up and live happily ever after. You'll be in a far better position financially than you are now.

This is what I was going to say. This man is an absolute dickhead.

tootiredtospeak · 01/11/2022 17:22

Fuck that all in one pot. All bill's paid then savings then what's rest is split evenly. Your are a family and they are his kids what justification does he give for not paying for his own childrens lunches. I would be livid with him

Brigante9 · 01/11/2022 17:21

Why is he refusing to pay for his own child’s lunches? Why is he keeping the OP in such a vulnerable position? Does he not care that she’s on the breadline?!

Shaniice · 01/11/2022 17:19

OP my dh comes out with similar amount after tax and because of this he pays the house, kids clothes, nights out, holidays and spending money etc I think your husband is in the wrong why should he have thousands of disposable cash while you’re watching the pennies, it’s not on.

KatieBell12 · 01/11/2022 17:17

I've never understood married couples who keep separate finances. Surely you a family unit?

BlancmanegeBunny · 01/11/2022 17:15

I'm a sahm and carer for our disabled 15 year old.
In our family all money goes into one pot, I couldn't live any other way.
We are married, we have children together and we are a team who both contribute in different ways!

Dacadactyl · 01/11/2022 17:10

Dear oh dear, what a stingy, stingy git he is!!

Unbelievable. I wouldn't be able to look at him.

Mirabai · 01/11/2022 17:07

BoredWithLife · 01/11/2022 16:16

"It’s this kind of silly attitude that lands women up shit creek financially without a pension."

Wouldn't this all be avoided if the people in a similar position to the OP didn't get themselves into these situations by remaining financially independent, insisting childcare/etc be split, stayed in FT employment and ensured they could take care of their own pension contributions without even agreeing up front that someone else will take care of all the pesky money things?

but anyway to weigh on in the actual topic, the DH is coming across as a prick. I'm unclear how him having more money than the OP is abuse (she's said nothing to imply she is ever left without or has to beg for money etc, only that she's careful with her money), it just looks like he's selfish.

Have you ever actually ran out of money in a month? What happened? We have separate finances (with joint account for shared bills/child stuff) and I end up with more left over at the end of each month as I'm the higher earner. I've tried to give my DP access to my accounts etc but they couldn't be bothered to setup security questions etc with the bank and didn't respond when they got sent a letter asking for details etc. am I financially abusing them?

So all parents should stay in FT employment to protect themselves from their partner’s selfishness and potential financial abuse? What do parents of SEN or disabled kids do?

If you’re contributing adequately and proportionately to bills/domestic/childcare costs then you’re not financially abusing your DP. OP’s partner is not contributing enough. HTH.

Allsnotwell · 01/11/2022 16:50

And to add I don’t feel abused because it’s all important the open and discussed.

Allsnotwell · 01/11/2022 16:50

DH earns more than me and he pays all the bills and transfers some to me for shopping and kids stuff.

Bugger things we agree on are generally shared or take turns.

We have money and savings - neither of us are bothered by who has more anyone year (usually him with hobbies and nights out - me less so)

Benjispruce4 · 01/11/2022 16:43

*earns

Benjispruce4 · 01/11/2022 16:43

DH warns much more than me. Both our salaries go into our joint account. We both withdraw the same agreed amount to our own personal accounts. I’m on a lowers wage because I took time out to be a sahm which I wanted to do and he agreed. We have all benefitted from the situation so why should I lose out now?

Mummybud · 01/11/2022 16:43

@daisy46 I didn’t say it was an equal divide, no idea where you got that from. I said they should bear their pro rata share based on the amount of income they bring in. If you want to start putting a price on housework and childcare you can, but it’s minimum wage and will move the needle only slightly.

A spreadsheet is the only way to get to the bottom of their finances together. It seems to me that the OP pays for a lot of things her husband just hasn’t appreciated rack up (childcare, a chunk of the food bill, clubs, some clothes, saving for Christmas etc). People have taken this to mean that only she spends on the kids and he doesn’t contribute to them at all - I’m not convinced that’s true, but we really don’t have the details to comment. Also, how don’t they have a mortgage? If he paid that off while she was a SAHM that puts a different spin on it the whole “she lived in poverty” thing. People really don’t have enough info and are making some very bold assumptions!

DifferentPlanet · 01/11/2022 16:40

BoredWithLife · 01/11/2022 16:16

"It’s this kind of silly attitude that lands women up shit creek financially without a pension."

Wouldn't this all be avoided if the people in a similar position to the OP didn't get themselves into these situations by remaining financially independent, insisting childcare/etc be split, stayed in FT employment and ensured they could take care of their own pension contributions without even agreeing up front that someone else will take care of all the pesky money things?

but anyway to weigh on in the actual topic, the DH is coming across as a prick. I'm unclear how him having more money than the OP is abuse (she's said nothing to imply she is ever left without or has to beg for money etc, only that she's careful with her money), it just looks like he's selfish.

Have you ever actually ran out of money in a month? What happened? We have separate finances (with joint account for shared bills/child stuff) and I end up with more left over at the end of each month as I'm the higher earner. I've tried to give my DP access to my accounts etc but they couldn't be bothered to setup security questions etc with the bank and didn't respond when they got sent a letter asking for details etc. am I financially abusing them?

Wouldn't it be better to just transfer money to your DP's account until they are able to easily access your account?

BoredWithLife · 01/11/2022 16:33

DucklingDaisy · 01/11/2022 16:30

I can’t believe how some men treat their wives and children. Joining mumsnet has been a real eye opener. You aren’t being remotely unreasonable you are just married to a complete dickhead.

This I can agree with! no matter how you split it up, I cant understand how the OPs scenario is even remotely fair, she brings in around 15% of income, put pays around 30% of bills - the DH is a selfish dick and I'm amazed at what other women seem to put up with based on posts here.

DucklingDaisy · 01/11/2022 16:30

I can’t believe how some men treat their wives and children. Joining mumsnet has been a real eye opener. You aren’t being remotely unreasonable you are just married to a complete dickhead.

theremustonlybeone · 01/11/2022 16:20

You struggled financially whilst being a SAHM and saving a fortune on childcare expenses and your sat here again now working and doing the grunt work and your husband thinks it is perfectly acceptable to be left with £3.5k and you £240

I would leave him and claim CMS and universal credits. He is financially abusiver and not part of your team

BoredWithLife · 01/11/2022 16:16

"It’s this kind of silly attitude that lands women up shit creek financially without a pension."

Wouldn't this all be avoided if the people in a similar position to the OP didn't get themselves into these situations by remaining financially independent, insisting childcare/etc be split, stayed in FT employment and ensured they could take care of their own pension contributions without even agreeing up front that someone else will take care of all the pesky money things?

but anyway to weigh on in the actual topic, the DH is coming across as a prick. I'm unclear how him having more money than the OP is abuse (she's said nothing to imply she is ever left without or has to beg for money etc, only that she's careful with her money), it just looks like he's selfish.

Have you ever actually ran out of money in a month? What happened? We have separate finances (with joint account for shared bills/child stuff) and I end up with more left over at the end of each month as I'm the higher earner. I've tried to give my DP access to my accounts etc but they couldn't be bothered to setup security questions etc with the bank and didn't respond when they got sent a letter asking for details etc. am I financially abusing them?

ivykaty44 · 01/11/2022 16:07

in what world does he think this is anything but unfair?

you need to tell your dh he is being a tight arse git

askmenow · 01/11/2022 16:05

I would be getting all my ducks in a row cos he's a selfish b...tard and must be doing this knowingly.
Refusing £15 weekly for teens school lunches FFS...when its important the child fits in with their mates!
In life, never fail to have a backup plan or a getout clause cos you never know what's round the corner. And never allow yourself to be at a potential disadvantage over the long term.
As primary caregivers, women are most often disadvantaged and don't the threads on here prove just that.

Happyhappyday · 01/11/2022 16:04

Not fair. DH earns 1.5x what I do unless it’s a good bonus year for me. Absolutely everything goes into one account. We agree together on big purchases.

when I was on mat leave I spent what I wanted as long as it was within our agreed household budget.

xogossipgirlxo · 01/11/2022 16:04

daisy46 · 01/11/2022 15:55

This. This is the appropriate response when someone values the contribution their partner is making.

Exactly. I bet OP does school commitments, most of childcare, housekeeping, because she "only" works part time. If her husband can't put value on this and thinks she doesn't deserve to use money he makes, there's no hope for him as a husband and father.

Mirabai · 01/11/2022 16:01

@DifferentPlanet

If the OP had stated that her husband earns a lot of money and she is given housekeeping of £X a week and when it's gone it's gone then I would agree. But in the scenario we're being given it's simply that he earns more than she does. Which doesn't equal financial abuse

It’s not either/or.

He earns more than she does and he’s not even giving her housekeeping.

She’s covering too much household expenses comparative to her income. He needs to step up and pay more for his kids.

They need a joint account that she can pay for the kids stuff from.

It’s this kind of silly attitude that lands women up shit creek financially without a pension.

daisy46 · 01/11/2022 15:55

Jessstar · 01/11/2022 12:28

I am in a remarkably similar set up to you. Was a sahm, back at work PT with relatively low pay, no mortgage. My DH’s take home is slightly higher.

My DH pays all the bills. Everything. Including my phone, all expenses for both cars, all food, everything the DC need. We have savings split equally between us. My salary is my own to do what I want with. I do typically save it or use it for nice family treats but there is never any expectation on his part.

his opinion is that he can only earn his salary because I was a sahm and because I still work fewer hours and take on more responsibility with the house and kids.

This. This is the appropriate response when someone values the contribution their partner is making.