Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think those who complain about online parents' evenings ...

116 replies

dinaminion · 31/10/2022 23:26

... because they want to "get to know" the teachers, and don't like being cut off after their 5 minutes, are probably the same people who made face-to-face parents' evenings a nightmare for the rest of us, by hogging the teachers' attention, and over-running on their appointment slot, so everyone else was seen late, and the poor teachers were run ragged?

Long live the online parents' evening!

OP posts:
stayathomer · 01/11/2022 13:56

Hate online- first teacher late so was late to each teacher and every single one commented that it was ok I was a little late!!

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 01/11/2022 13:52

I hate online. I much prefer face to face to be able to communicate properly with the teacher. Yes, it’s a faff in a way, and I can see why there is a call for both, but I like to see my DC’s school, and see teachers face to face, including the new head who we didn’t meet for the first year due to covid. I definitely don’t cause meetings to overrun, we’re usually done in 5 minutes. If I have had any concerns, I address them with the teacher at the time rather than save them for parents’ evening.

Zingy123 · 01/11/2022 13:44

I love the idea of the online ones. They don't always work in practice though. My DD is in Year 13. We just had her last parents evening with three teachers. Due to WiFi issues with the school two of the teachers were late joining our slot meaning we got 1 minute with each one. Not really enough time to discuss anything.

custardbear · 01/11/2022 13:36

I LOVE online ones! Far better .... plus a glass of wine out of shot if necessary 😂

MerryMarigold · 01/11/2022 13:23

@parameter - online is similar in that you have to book early and once the slits are finished, they are finished. The point I was making about having a whole day in person (or indeed online) is that there is enough time for you to see all the teachers even if they teach 3 classes in the year.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 01/11/2022 13:12

I would like to add that I am also neurodiverse. And being at home, alone, not surrounded by a ton of background noise and the worry of getting to next appointment, and making small talk with other parents and standing around in queues is such a massive massive benefit to me. To be honest, if they go back to in person I am likely to completely avoid them and not go. I have never been to the my children's high school. My husband did the open evening with child1, and child2's was during covid so online.

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/11/2022 13:03

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 31/10/2022 23:52

I'm disabled and online parents evenings are so easy for me. We can get round all dd's teachers on time, at home and it's a joy. Dd has autism and it's a hell of a lot easier for her too.

Am also disabled and thought I’d never be able to do secondary parents evening, which worried me greatly as dh would never have obtained let alone retained the information I get. I love online with a passion!

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 01/11/2022 12:59

In person at high school will mean taking annual leave and running around from teacher to teacher finding them. I hate them with a passion. Online has been so perfect for us as working parents. The slots cut off after 5 minutes, it all runs to time and we don't need to schlep to the school getting stressed and sweaty. As you say, long live the online parents evening. I don't even need to wear a bra for it

lalaloopyhead · 01/11/2022 12:56

Online is much better in my opinion - face to face involved standing around in a hall for ages waiting for your appointment while someone chats away far exceeding their time slot - then missing your next slot and having to try and jump back in somehow when Freds parents think its their turn next because they are after Arthurs, who took your slot bcause you were still waiting for the last one!
And all this when there generally isn;t much to day anyway.

Being able to sit at my dining table and have very brief conversations with each teacher within the space of half a hour seemed like absolute genius and why hadn't someone thought of this precovid anyway...

Manchestermummax3 · 01/11/2022 12:50

My eldest is secondary, I've had 1 successful 5 min zoom since covid.
There system is a load of bollocks. I booked 4 meetings each time, 3 core subjects, math, English & science & 1 other as its a subject he loves & thrives at. Everytime, connection doesn't work, teacher is not there & I'm in a waiting room... then my slots up & I'm told I didn't attend.
Last 1 the mic wasn't working & good on the teacher he rang me in the traditional way of an actual phone call to discuss my sons education. I had to hold up a piece of paper with my number on because in 5 min slots he couldn't look up at reception my contact details.
I could only tell you his science teachers name & that's it!

HammerheadCorvette · 01/11/2022 12:46

Face to face in a large secondary is a fucking nightmare. The kids used to have to make their own appointments - to be made in class time only, first come first served, when they have a fortnightly timetable which meant either no appointments or one at 3.30pm and two at 7pm.

If you ever got an appointment you then only had a 50% success rate of actually seeing the teacher as although your appointment was at 5pm and it was now 5.20, you'd have to argue the toss with another parent that you'd been waiting next to that teacher since 4.50 and if you didn't see them now then you'd miss your next appointment.

Then put an 8 form year group plus parents and siblings in a small hall and you could never hear anything anyway.

Online is soooooo much better.

Wishyfishy · 01/11/2022 12:40

We’re back to face to face at our school.

I did get more from the meeting in all honesty and I felt like the teacher and I both understood what each other was trying to say better and it was lovely to look through DC’s school work as we chatted… BUT, it was also quite difficult arranging childcare. The online one last year DH joined remotely from work and I could just leave the DC in front of the TV for 5 minutes, whereas this time it was just me and I needed to call on favours from friends. So very much six of one, half a dozen of the other for me.

CoffeeWithCheese · 01/11/2022 12:36

I'm team face to face firmly for primary. And no, it's not a social opportunity with the teachers - I know them well enough! It's being able to see the star writer work on the wall that DD2 is incredibly proud of, and having DD1 get the chance to point out her artwork on the classroom door... and it's things like school having the ability to have the CAMHS early support team running a drop-in and picking up a lot of low-level issues that parents might not have raised this early on if they had to book a specific slot to see her.

I've found that if you have an approachable school as a general rule you get far less of one parent overrunning - it's when issues have been allowed to fester and not be addressed that things get lengthy. We did find with our previous school that the class teacher very much used the timed online ones as a way to try to dodge any actual discussion about the fact our child's SEN had been utterly ignored for an entire year - invited us into the room, ran straight into her little script then booted us out without any right to reply. Online was a fucking gift to that particular nightmare teacher!

Oblomov22 · 01/11/2022 12:31

No. What a presumption. I don't do that. But I'd prefer to meet in person. That is the norm you know. Post covid we should be getting back to that.

Tdcp · 01/11/2022 12:30

I get a phone call, I prefer it in a lot of ways as it's less rushing about from work / leaving work early. Plus I hate crowds etc.

TheaBrandt · 01/11/2022 12:23

Really hope they stick with online. That said one teacher got Dd mixed up with another child and was effusive at her amazing textiles skills. When it ended Dd admitted she was talking about the girl she sat next to who was really talented at textiles Dd ahem is not 😁

Tiredoftiers · 01/11/2022 10:35

I HATED online parents evening, both times the software the school used was awful. We endured struggling to hear about our children and then when it eventually worked we were just cut off as we'd reached the 7 minute limit. It was extremely frustrating, and in my opinion created a negative opinion of the school. When we complained to the school we were told it was our fault, due to the technology we were using. ( fibre broadband, and a 1 year old top spec laptop, that was used for teams, zoom, etc with no issues)
This year it was lovely being in class at a time that suited us, meeting the teacher and being able to hear what they were saying and getting to look at examples of their work. I learnt a lot more about them in that evening than I have in the previous 2 years. Our children also loved that we had been in their class, and looked at their jotters etc.

Athenen0ctua · 01/11/2022 10:29

madnesss · 31/10/2022 23:38

I hated the online ones because I'm autistic and face to face is better for me. I find video communication extremely uncomfortable and it affects my ability to process and respond.

Same

underneaththeash · 01/11/2022 10:28

luckily they’ve been scrapped in all our schools. There’s always IT issues, teachers seem to talk without enough time for questions, sometimes you don’t need 5 minutes, sometimes you need 7.
it’s really impersonal.

starfilledsky · 01/11/2022 10:27

I am a secondary school teacher and much prefer the online parents evenings. The cut offs have been wonderful as, more often than not, some parents can really go on and on (so can some teachers)! Sometimes we have more classes in a particular year group so the timings help to limit the time we are working. I once had 4 classes in one year group for a F2F parents evening. Whilst parents evening ended at 7:30, I was still sat in the hall at 8:30 with a huge queue of parents. Didn't get home till 10pm that night and had a very hoarse voice the next day. The same thing happened 2 weeks after with another year group.

Understandably there will be some students where more time may be needed or they weren't able to log in so depending on the type of conversation needed, I will offer a phone call on another day or send an email home with my feedback. Or if it's more serious, I'm happy to have a F2F meeting with the family on another day.

I think it's nice to be able to meet teachers F2F but don't think it's doable when some teachers do have literally hundreds of kids to see in one evening, and multiple year groups of parents evenings in the space of a few months (on top of open evenings etc). Perhaps it's more doable in primary school as they only have one class?

Also, some teachers are more than happy and understanding to have a longer conversation over the phone or in person on another day if you let the school know if your needs.

girlfriend44 · 01/11/2022 10:26

No because its a slippery slope to everything going online.

What next no school
Just learn online?
People managed Parents Evenings before Computers.

RedHelenB · 01/11/2022 10:23

I disagree. I learned a lot more about my ds when things were back to face to face.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2022 10:21

Online works really well imo, especially for secondary which is a bit of a logistical nightmare. With online everyone knows the teacher WILL move on after 5 mins (or whatever it is) so no over running, which then affects everyone else’s appointments, has a knock on for other teachers etc.

I think there can be a benefit in face to face for primary where it’s quite nice to go in to the school, see their books etc, and meet their one and only main class teacher (obviously I know there are TAs and cover). But everyone needs to understand the teacher has to stick to time.

EarlofShrewsbury · 01/11/2022 10:17

madnesss · 31/10/2022 23:38

I hated the online ones because I'm autistic and face to face is better for me. I find video communication extremely uncomfortable and it affects my ability to process and respond.

This a million times over.

I can't do online. I ask then to call me instead. Calls aren't great either because I'm also deaf but it's better that zoom.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 01/11/2022 10:00

Yes YABU why would you assume they are the parents you describe? I expect there are many different parents who prefer face to face and many different parents who prefer online.
Horses for courses.

Yes, you can't just assume that each parent only has one vector that's driving their preference - nor that anybody is being deliberately selfish by expressing a preference, even if it's not the same as other people's preferences.

I can see the good side to both: it's handy not having to go out at all; but at the same time, it seems so cold. We've had previous years with tech issues, so it's so easy to just arbitrarily lose your valuable parents' evening just like that - gone.

Also, the auto cut-off is really unfriendly. I realise that they have to keep to time, but you can end up gabbling in the closing seconds and there's no leeway for literally two or three more seconds to close things off properly like humans would do. Granted, it's 10 times as long, but It always reminds me of phone a friend on Who Wants To Be A Millionaire, where you have to get straight to the point, without any real niceties, and then you can still get cut off before you can even fully say "Thank you - bye" at the end.