Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MN HQ Really needs to do something about disablist threads on here!

153 replies

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 31/10/2022 21:30

As a disabled person, this site makes me despair at times! Sad

OP posts:
JennyNotFromTheBlock · 01/11/2022 11:43

The unfair deletion of @Mariposista 's post proves my point (I'm sorry @Mariposista , your post did not deserve to be removed and would never have been removed in any of the support groups I am on) It's walking on eggshells here, even fair comment is not allowed. Way to prove our points. Hmm

Chouetted · 01/11/2022 11:33

Ablelism can arise from ignorance.

I am both autistic and hearing impaired. I wear special noise cancelling headphones in public. They cut out background hums and so on, but allow human speech through. They're incredibly expensive, and incredibly nifty. They allow me to hear people better, and reduce sensory overload in loud environments

Sometimes people tell me I'd be able to hear them better if I took them off. They're often very rude about it. One or two have even shouted at me about my rudeness in wearing them. I try to explain that they don't affect my ability to lipread, and that I will in fact hear worse with them off. Sometimes they apologise, sometimes they just go off on a rant about all the other people wearing headphones who play music through them. One lady shouted at me just because I walked past her on the street wearing them.

I don't believe that any single one of them saw me coming and decided to be an ableist dickhead, but the overall effect of having to justify my assistive technology is very much ablelism. And makes me anxious in shops, new environments etc.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 01/11/2022 11:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes, I've been trying to recall a saying I wanted to use but couldn't remember, I just remembered it: walking on eggshells. I was very reticent to comment on this thread, even though I myself have ASD and other disabilities (my ASD affects me mostly). That was what I meant to say in my first post, I think this site is very report-happy/ban-happy, and seeing even well-meaning and important discussions shut down about disabilities is frustrating because any conversation on this topic, which is over-moderated on, on here, is like walking on eggshells. When even people with disabilities are too scared to comment on here because we are immediately silenced/reported/deleted by someone far too sensitive, it's scary. I mainly post on my online support group, rather than here, because even for me, posting on here is like walking of bloody eggshells. A sensible discussion can't be had because of the No Debate 'you're all ableist' crowd.

There has to be a balance. There has to be common sense. Not everything is ableist. Most of the examples given, are not remotely ableist, in my eyes. Some are important to discussions to be had, others show ignorance of disability/blue badge laws. But not actually deliberately ableist. I still say, from my experience, that it is extremely rare to find any ableist threads on this site, and rare to find ableist, actually ableist, comments. People seem to have an inability to understand ableism and what it is, and what it is not. Although, granted, not all people with disabilities are a homogenous group. So what one sees as ableist, another doesn't see it remotely ableist.

It is a shame though that even people with disabilities like myself, feel like we are walking on eggshells with some of the uber PC No Debate crowd on here to the extent, so much so I'm afraid to even come on here and discuss things or my experiences. Maybe it's gone too far the other way OP? Maybe the OP can take into mind that what she thinks is ableist is not actually ableist, and people with disabilities are not a homogenous group, so don't assume OP you speak for everyone. Hopefully this thread has given the OP food for thought. It's great that they speak against ableism, but most of the experiences I've seen put forward are not ableist, some not even remotely, and it demeans our lived experiences if the word ableist is made so meaningless. Then no one will take actual ableism seriously.

Sorry for my long post, I do like to talk a lot (I don't in person to person in real life, lol).

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:24

of course, it's hard for most people to assume positive intent when they've had sufficient amounts of bile and idiocy thrown at them. I struggle with this myself quite a bit - it's a very normal, human reaction.

Indeed, I do it all the time (I also sometimes just enjoy arguing with idiots) but when we get like that it's our responsibility to log off and go eat cake do some exercise.

Chouetted · 01/11/2022 11:22

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:08

There's a massive clash between the "it's not up to the people experiencing the discrimination to do all the work to challenge it" people and the "how dare you speak for them instead of allowing them a voice" people, and I fear that, like loo brushes, this may just be an unbridgeable divide between opposing viewpoints.

Assuming positive intent, being polite and speaking with goodwill fixes most of that IMO. There is nothing wrong with speaking about a problem which doesn't directly affect you.

There is something very wrong about doing so in a way that assumes you know best and demonises anyone who disagrees with you. Those things are stupid, even if you are right, they are just especially ridiculous when describing something outside your experience and getting it wrong.

I completely agree, but of course, it's hard for most people to assume positive intent when they've had sufficient amounts of bile and idiocy thrown at them. I struggle with this myself quite a bit - it's a very normal, human reaction.

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:21

There's nothing wrong with healthy debate of course but I honestly fear that many people don't seem to get that it's ok for other people to think differently to them.

I agree that's a probblem with the world but I think the examples on here are things that really do need challenging.

The thing is that to challenge an idea in someone's head you need to understand what that idea is in the first place. It may be that you actually agree and the person expressed themselves poorly or you leapt to conclusions. Even if they are dead wrong you won't persuade anyone if you don't actually understand the point they are making.

ilovesooty · 01/11/2022 11:20

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:18

Apologies for the lack of clarity. I was referring to a previously quoted post referring to a large child with "dyspraxia".

I think it's clear they are quoting that person to show that they use the dyspraxia as an excuse to climb on shelves (not seen the thread, so no clue if that's an accurate quote). They quote several other things as well to make that point so it isn't a matter of just putting dyspraxia in quotes.

As I've said before: I think if we want to have difficult conversations we need to assume possitive intent on the part of others and not infer meanings which aren't explicit.

That's an interesting point. I think we may have interpreted it differently but thank you for that perspective.

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:18

Apologies for the lack of clarity. I was referring to a previously quoted post referring to a large child with "dyspraxia".

I think it's clear they are quoting that person to show that they use the dyspraxia as an excuse to climb on shelves (not seen the thread, so no clue if that's an accurate quote). They quote several other things as well to make that point so it isn't a matter of just putting dyspraxia in quotes.

As I've said before: I think if we want to have difficult conversations we need to assume possitive intent on the part of others and not infer meanings which aren't explicit.

MightyOaks · 01/11/2022 11:15

*That my opinion

MightyOaks · 01/11/2022 11:14

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:08

There's a massive clash between the "it's not up to the people experiencing the discrimination to do all the work to challenge it" people and the "how dare you speak for them instead of allowing them a voice" people, and I fear that, like loo brushes, this may just be an unbridgeable divide between opposing viewpoints.

Assuming positive intent, being polite and speaking with goodwill fixes most of that IMO. There is nothing wrong with speaking about a problem which doesn't directly affect you.

There is something very wrong about doing so in a way that assumes you know best and demonises anyone who disagrees with you. Those things are stupid, even if you are right, they are just especially ridiculous when describing something outside your experience and getting it wrong.

Exactly. I was always taught to respect the fact that other people will have opinions which I may or may not agree with. I don't have to respect their opinion itself, but respect the fact that they're entitled to it. That may opinion & others' can live side by side quote happily with a little respect on both sides.

There's nothing wrong with healthy debate of course but I honestly fear that many people don't seem to get that it's ok for other people to think differently to them. That they must CHALLENGE anyone who has any kind of varying viewpoints or opinions.

ilovesooty · 01/11/2022 11:14

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:11

I can't see this. Do you mean the poster who is quoting several satements by someone from a previous thread to illustrate a point and using quote marks to indicate that?

Apologies for the lack of clarity. I was referring to a previously quoted post referring to a large child with "dyspraxia".

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:11

ilovesooty · 01/11/2022 11:00

I think a poster putting a disability in inverted commas sounds as though they're questioning the reality of that disability.

I can't see this. Do you mean the poster who is quoting several satements by someone from a previous thread to illustrate a point and using quote marks to indicate that?

ilovesooty · 01/11/2022 11:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

"Too sensitive"
"PC"

Why not throw "woke" in while you're at it?

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:08

There's a massive clash between the "it's not up to the people experiencing the discrimination to do all the work to challenge it" people and the "how dare you speak for them instead of allowing them a voice" people, and I fear that, like loo brushes, this may just be an unbridgeable divide between opposing viewpoints.

Assuming positive intent, being polite and speaking with goodwill fixes most of that IMO. There is nothing wrong with speaking about a problem which doesn't directly affect you.

There is something very wrong about doing so in a way that assumes you know best and demonises anyone who disagrees with you. Those things are stupid, even if you are right, they are just especially ridiculous when describing something outside your experience and getting it wrong.

MightyOaks · 01/11/2022 11:07

Brefugee · 01/11/2022 11:03

Although I do have a small child. But if she's not with me then no, I would not park in p&c.

meh. I park in the p&c if I'm with my elderly mum who can't walk very well and needs to have the car door opened to its fullest extent to get out. I got shouted at by a woman who jumped out with her 2 teenagers who also jumped out without any problems. So no, i'm not going to say "sorry" because those spaces where you can be sure to open your car door properly are vital to my mum when we need to go out.

This situation wouldn't bother me at all. To be clear, I have never ever challenged anyone on their parking validity. I have myself, had my car whacked with a walking stick and been grabbed hold of, by angry people who assume because I'm under 50 that I must be 'blagging it'

ilovesooty · 01/11/2022 11:07

MightyOaks · 01/11/2022 11:02

@ilovesooty If your reading comprehension was up to par, you'd see that I've already acknowledged this in that very post you are quoting! 😂

Nothing wrong with my reading comprehension thank you.

MightyOaks · 01/11/2022 11:06

girlmom21 · 01/11/2022 11:02

Absolutely! Although I do have a small child. But if she's not with me then no, I would not park in p&c. However my badge will always be reissued sadly. Such is the nature of my disability, but I know what you meant.

I don't mean this to be a dick, but presumably if you have a blue badge it's because you need an accessible space, so how would you cope without that extra space? If that's an intrusive question please don't answer

But my blue badge will always be reissued as I have a degenerative, progressive condition and I'm dying, so it's a moot point. I probably wouldn't go out but I certainly wouldn't be the sort of person who makes life difficult for others and currently makes life harder for people like myself. If I did, I'd be as bad as them. I'm NOTHING without my principles and my stubbornness Halo
Also, as I said, I have a small child currently so it's doubly a moot point!

Mariposista · 01/11/2022 11:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 11:05

Even after explained, several were adamant they were in the right.

Some people are stuborn in their mornitude. I still think the conversation has value and that's not a reason to ban people.

Chouetted · 01/11/2022 11:05

donquixotedelamancha · 01/11/2022 10:57

and then be told it's their responsibility to tackle it

Who told you it was your responsibility to tackle it? I challenge lots of stuff on here. Sometimes I find myself getting tired (or often annoyed and combative in tone) so I stop and leave the site for a few days.

Your only responsibility is to exercise self care and do things that make you happy.

in reality it's just really tiring and depressing for a marginalised person to have to see discriminatory stuff about them regularly

It's not about you personally. Most people in the world harbour many, many foolish views because we are not all psychic. People may be venting or leaping to concusions but that doesn't mean they are inherently awful- those same people are probably lovely most of the time, when they are exercising their better judgement and dealign with people as individuals rather than stereotypes.

There's a massive clash between the "it's not up to the people experiencing the discrimination to do all the work to challenge it" people and the "how dare you speak for them instead of allowing them a voice" people, and I fear that, like loo brushes, this may just be an unbridgeable divide between opposing viewpoints.

With the unfortunate consequence that it's the very people advocating for change that get pissed on in the resulting clash.

ClaudineClare · 01/11/2022 11:04

Re: not Te:

ClaudineClare · 01/11/2022 11:03

Te: expecting disabled people to challenge threads - this was one of MNHQ's poor excuses for letting an ableist thread run:

We left this thread to run today as many posts were challenging (what appears to be) common misconceptions about benefits and disabled people.

We think it's gone beyond anything potentially useful or informative now

Brefugee · 01/11/2022 11:03

Although I do have a small child. But if she's not with me then no, I would not park in p&c.

meh. I park in the p&c if I'm with my elderly mum who can't walk very well and needs to have the car door opened to its fullest extent to get out. I got shouted at by a woman who jumped out with her 2 teenagers who also jumped out without any problems. So no, i'm not going to say "sorry" because those spaces where you can be sure to open your car door properly are vital to my mum when we need to go out.

girlmom21 · 01/11/2022 11:02

Absolutely! Although I do have a small child. But if she's not with me then no, I would not park in p&c. However my badge will always be reissued sadly. Such is the nature of my disability, but I know what you meant.

I don't mean this to be a dick, but presumably if you have a blue badge it's because you need an accessible space, so how would you cope without that extra space? If that's an intrusive question please don't answer

MightyOaks · 01/11/2022 11:02

@ilovesooty If your reading comprehension was up to par, you'd see that I've already acknowledged this in that very post you are quoting! 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread