Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout groups not enough Volunteers

310 replies

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:24

Local Scout group has lots of children signed up but enough volunteers do in danger of closing.

Is this the same everywhere?
What stops people from volunteering?

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 01/11/2022 10:27

A friend's found it easier volunteering in a village community rather than a modern suburb. There is more sense of the village community working as its own little society that hasn't developed in the suburb.
The suburb has easier access to a range of accessible professional alternative activities too.

Meseekslookatme · 01/11/2022 10:24

bighairbigdreams · 31/10/2022 20:30

I am an ex scout volunteer and I quit because of the politics.

Same.
And the parents too.
Too many of them are selfish assholes that treat you with utter contempt.
(Most were lovely)

slowquickstep · 01/11/2022 10:22

Many volunteers get fed up dealing with pushy entitled parents who can't be arsed to pick their children up on time.

BogRollBOGOF · 01/11/2022 10:21

The more people in the team, the more the background load can be spread out so it's managable.

The real problem is when you're stuck in a survival cycle where someone steps up to save a unit from closing and has minimal support and it's often not sustainable for long before they burn out and the cycle repeats.

I joined one of my units many years ago. I'm the only leader currently not working but still carried on through the days when my young DCs were dropped off at 8am at childcare, a full day of work, pick DCs up, straight to unit and not home until past 8pm. Then parents would whinge that they couldn't possibly help in anyway because they were busy. Busy can be a matter of perspective.

Aside from busyness there is a split between those who volunteer and those who don't. When you get someone willing to help there normally is a background where they'll have form for helping out/ volunteering with other things. It's rare to pull in someone totally new to helping out. A lot of people just won't give their time for free and will just take what is offered. When too many people have that attitude the system breaks because you can't have more takers than givers.

Many also misinterpret the subs as being a salary for the volunteers and think their £2.50 per night is enough to pay 4+ people on top of room hire, resources and the census administration costs.

I've always given what I can spare because I realised as a teenager that my life was better because people gave up their time to create opportunities that enriched my life, and I continued that cycle to keep it working (and most of the time I enjoy it and am enriched by that)

girlfriend44 · 01/11/2022 10:18

RedToothBrush · 01/11/2022 09:30

Uk scouting had a problem for a long time because of the ages for the units. It meant that kids got bored at a certain age and dropped out of scouting never to return. There is a gap between about age 50 and age 30 (ish). This also is when they had a bunch of scandals come to light.

More recently they've changed the air banding which makes more sense and they are getting better long term retention within younger groups who then are more likely to go on to be young leaders and leaders in their own right.

There are also issues with economics and scout groups and how they need to raise money to continue and to run day to day. Some groups in district have struggled with doing things like buying food up front for camp (and then getting the money back a while later through expenses after the fact) so have relied in help from us to help them run camps. It's quite common for the group to owe DH a couple of hundred quid on a regular basis.

We had found before the pandemic that groups in left well off areas were able to get volunteers more easily and the groups in well off areas struggled. It was affordable for less well off kids and the better off parents just thought they could throw money at groups.

Now even though it's one of the cheapest out of school activities, the less well off areas just aren't able to find people who can afford to help and the penny has dropped in better off areas with the closure of loads of stuff over covid and them being more conscious of cost.

Also many groups just didn't run during covid and a lot of the older leaders saw their opportunity to jack it in.

Just at the time where it said that more and more people are wanting to attend.

OP posts:
alloalloallo · 01/11/2022 10:05

I used to run our local Rainbows pack several years ago. I started as a volunteer helper so my oldest daughter could join and then ended up running it.

I quit for lots of reasons. No one would help. Parents thought that their £1 a week subs meant they were paying for childcare so it was perfectly fine to rock up to pick their little darlings up 15/20 minutes late.

My own children had long since left so it got to the point where I just got pissed off putting all this effort in running a group for the benefit other peoples’ kids when their own parents wouldn’t spend an hour and a half once a year helping out.

DH used to run a scout group and quit for much the same reasons as I did.

RedToothBrush · 01/11/2022 10:04

rookiemere · 01/11/2022 09:51

Apologies as Ive only skim read the thread, but I think this problem is going to get worse in the coming years as people are forced to work until 67, rather than 60.

In our scouts there are a few scouting families where there is an ethos of being involved in scouting and volunteering. However there's a big issue because the older generation are now mid 70s+ and finding the overnight camps etc. too much for them. The generation behind is involved but there isn't enough of them and people's lives are busier than they used to be with most people in demanding full time jobs and no chance of retirement until late 60s.

I was group secretary for a couple of years when DS was a member of cubs. It was fine but there was this perennial push to get you to do more and a slight lack of recognition of what you were actually doing.

I honestly don't know how they're going to survive over the coming years and I totally respect any group leaders - its a huge task and so valuable for the DCs. On a similar thread to this, someone suggested getting the older teens involved actively as being the way forward and that's maybe the way to go.

The eldest person involved in running our troop is 55. He doesn't lead weekly anymore. This was a deliberate strategy, that once your kids are done you can carry on helping around the edges and supporting but you don't take the lead. You have to develop parents coming through for a few years then hand over gradually. Where we've had a leader had to leave and dump on someone who hasn't had that support there's been problems.

The plan is simply to avoid being run by pensioners as it's inappropriate for most of the more physical stuff in scouting! Having seen people well into their 70s being sole leaders, im dead against it for a lot of reasons.

The second oldest guy in the group was the one who saved it from extinction due to it being run by pensioners. It just doesn't work for the kids. There been a plan in place for over 10 years now to make things work and bring back parents to the group.

SusanPerbCallMeSue · 01/11/2022 09:57

I've been a volunteer for nearly 10 years. First with Beavers, now with Scouts.

I'm autistic so sometimes find it hard. I try not to talk to parents, leave it to the other leaders. I don't like running meetings, so mainly go to stand around awkwardly and to make up leader numbers.

I love the admin (love doing OSM badge records) and planning though. So I come up with lots of ideas and then the other leaders do what I tell them. Grin Mostly. They're not keen on the admin so it all works out well.

Our district lost around 100 volunteers over Covid, so many groups have had to join up to keep going. We have hardly any district team atm. With the lack of leaders for all sections opening Squirrels is not even an option.

I'm a single parent carer so don't work, and my children are older so I don't need someone else to look after my disabled son as his siblings are around to help. If I'd have been single when he was younger I wouldn't have been able to volunteer.

rookiemere · 01/11/2022 09:55

Oh and I do agree about the terminology being off putting. I got roundly criticised for not knowing correct names for a few levels. TBH I didn't care, other than making sure the minutes were correct, what with having my own paid job to worry about.

RedToothBrush · 01/11/2022 09:51

YerAWizardHarry · 01/11/2022 09:34

@PuttingDownRoots we sent two at 10 just before the half term as we were at capacity for our group. Now the “main” leader is saying we aren’t sending the next lot until at least 10.5, means my son is “stuck” without his friends (he’s a late birthday) for 10 months. the double standards are annoying

Official age is 10.5 unless you have a good reason (eg leaders child). They can move up early, but it's generally discouraged at 10.

The problem with them going up as early as 10 is the younger kids mean the older ones tend to end up leaving sooner for various reasons. I genuinely don't think its helpful to put them up at age 10. The extra 6 months does make a difference at that age.

DS started Beavers and Cubs early and thats thrown things a bit for him as he is eldest in the year so is with the year above and older most of the time rather than with his friends in his own year who are some of the youngest. It ended up with him leaving Beavers after 2 years when some of his friends in his own year were just starting as they didn't get a space immediately on turning 6. It will work out in the end but the worry is that he will get bored before he hits 14.

I think we will probably try and hang on til 10.5 with cubs if we possibly can.

rookiemere · 01/11/2022 09:51

Apologies as Ive only skim read the thread, but I think this problem is going to get worse in the coming years as people are forced to work until 67, rather than 60.

In our scouts there are a few scouting families where there is an ethos of being involved in scouting and volunteering. However there's a big issue because the older generation are now mid 70s+ and finding the overnight camps etc. too much for them. The generation behind is involved but there isn't enough of them and people's lives are busier than they used to be with most people in demanding full time jobs and no chance of retirement until late 60s.

I was group secretary for a couple of years when DS was a member of cubs. It was fine but there was this perennial push to get you to do more and a slight lack of recognition of what you were actually doing.

I honestly don't know how they're going to survive over the coming years and I totally respect any group leaders - its a huge task and so valuable for the DCs. On a similar thread to this, someone suggested getting the older teens involved actively as being the way forward and that's maybe the way to go.

antelopevalley · 01/11/2022 09:47

RedToothBrush · 01/11/2022 09:30

Uk scouting had a problem for a long time because of the ages for the units. It meant that kids got bored at a certain age and dropped out of scouting never to return. There is a gap between about age 50 and age 30 (ish). This also is when they had a bunch of scandals come to light.

More recently they've changed the air banding which makes more sense and they are getting better long term retention within younger groups who then are more likely to go on to be young leaders and leaders in their own right.

There are also issues with economics and scout groups and how they need to raise money to continue and to run day to day. Some groups in district have struggled with doing things like buying food up front for camp (and then getting the money back a while later through expenses after the fact) so have relied in help from us to help them run camps. It's quite common for the group to owe DH a couple of hundred quid on a regular basis.

We had found before the pandemic that groups in left well off areas were able to get volunteers more easily and the groups in well off areas struggled. It was affordable for less well off kids and the better off parents just thought they could throw money at groups.

Now even though it's one of the cheapest out of school activities, the less well off areas just aren't able to find people who can afford to help and the penny has dropped in better off areas with the closure of loads of stuff over covid and them being more conscious of cost.

Also many groups just didn't run during covid and a lot of the older leaders saw their opportunity to jack it in.

I think the opportunity to jack it in is a big driver. I have always volunteered in children's activities, and as you know once you start, it is hard to leave. Groups closed over lockdown and I left, it was an easy break. I miss some of the kids, but I do not miss the hassle from some parents.

CakeCrumbs44 · 01/11/2022 09:45

antelopevalley · 01/11/2022 09:36

Most people who volunteer work full-time and are incredibly busy people. This idea that everyone volunteering is not working and has loads of time, simply is not true.

My experience is the same as yours. Thinking about the guide/brownie/rainbow volunteers in my town - many of us work full time, many of us have children, some have both, yet we all manage to find time to volunteer.

I'm lucky with my Brownies group as the parents are great and if we asked them to volunteer infrequently, most would, although not many people choose to do it on a regular basis.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 01/11/2022 09:44

I think some of it is that it's outside the norm for the UK kids activities to be volunteer run. I have lots of American family and there almost everything is volunteer run - if you want your kid to play a sport, you are signing up to volunteer. They find the fact that we just pay for some activities and that's it quite strange. I think it means that you get into that mindset with everything.

For us, I freely admit it's not that we absolutely couldn't volunteer, it's just not very convenient. My DH takes ours while I put the little one to bed, he uses the time to log back onto work in a local cafe. If he volunteered instead, he would have to pick up work in the evening instead. We would reconsider if they were desperate for volunteers but weirdly they have volunteers but not enough children!

PuttingDownRoots · 01/11/2022 09:44

One of the reasons she may move at Easter is she is currently the eldest with one other a similar age (who will also get the chance). The next one isn't 10 until end of August. They might move up at 10 as well to create space. Weve got an uneven bulge in age created by Covid.

Origamicranes · 01/11/2022 09:41

I have and do still volunteer but not with children. I was contemplating it.

My friend works with school age teenagers and the legislation plus the amount of complication because so many kids have identity issues has made her job become incredibly difficult. She does actually have volunteers, they are retired teachers, it’s an educational charity. A volunteer lent a child a pound in front of a huge group of other children so they could buy a drink from a vending machine as had forgotten their money. Some little know it all accused them of grooming. The volunteer was devastated. I’m not putting myself at risk from shit like that.

I welcome children having voices these days but something has gone wrong somewhere.

toomuchlaundry · 01/11/2022 09:41

@Swissnotswiss I don’t camp but happy to help during the day. However, if a trowel is involved (no toilets) I don’t help!

YerAWizardHarry · 01/11/2022 09:40

Ah Scouts is our smallest section by far! Think they have less than 20. We are at 36 for both Cubs and Beavers

ParsleySageRosemary · 01/11/2022 09:40

If I hadn’t had to waste 20 years of my life paying rent to private landlords, I wouldn’t now be having to work as hard to overpay an inflated mortgage, and I would have time to volunteer as well as more time to help my own child.

Are the middle and upper classes beginning to have the faintest glimmerings of an idea about the impact of impoverishing most of Britain’s non-inheriting working class, so that they could waste it on their overseas experiences??

toomuchlaundry · 01/11/2022 09:39

@YerAWizardHarrymany groups near us are struggling to move cubs up into scouts as the scout section is full and scouts stay on for 4 years not 2 like cubs. In the past a number of scouts leave early as it is not seen as ‘cool’ but we haven’t had that this year. Scout leaders are leaving instead!

Swissnotswiss · 01/11/2022 09:39

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/11/2022 09:32

Time. Most working age people just don’t have enough. Scouting is pretty full on and I imagine some older volunteers just aren’t physically up to the demands. Camps, etc. are a huge commitment.

I think this is true. I like camping but they had a week hiking in the mountains, no bathrooms! I couldn't cope and they wouldn't want me there anyway. 😁

antelopevalley · 01/11/2022 09:36

Most people who volunteer work full-time and are incredibly busy people. This idea that everyone volunteering is not working and has loads of time, simply is not true.

YerAWizardHarry · 01/11/2022 09:34

@PuttingDownRoots we sent two at 10 just before the half term as we were at capacity for our group. Now the “main” leader is saying we aren’t sending the next lot until at least 10.5, means my son is “stuck” without his friends (he’s a late birthday) for 10 months. the double standards are annoying

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/11/2022 09:32

Time. Most working age people just don’t have enough. Scouting is pretty full on and I imagine some older volunteers just aren’t physically up to the demands. Camps, etc. are a huge commitment.

PuttingDownRoots · 01/11/2022 09:31

YerAWizardHarry · 01/11/2022 09:27

@PuttingDownRoots Scouts is technically 10.5 so you might have longer with her than you think

My head is blissfully buried in the sand and fortunately its been pretty much agreed she can go at minimum age for several reasons. 😁

Swipe left for the next trending thread