Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout groups not enough Volunteers

310 replies

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:24

Local Scout group has lots of children signed up but enough volunteers do in danger of closing.

Is this the same everywhere?
What stops people from volunteering?

OP posts:
NecklessMumster · 17/11/2022 05:47

My DP offered to be a volunteer when DS was in scouts. He was asked if he was Christian and when he said 'no' (atheist) they argued with him, said 'but for instance, when you look at a beautiful flower don't you see gods work?' No.

toomuchlaundry · 01/11/2022 20:57

I’m on the committee as I don’t camp! Will help on camp as long as I don’t have to sleep in a tent! DH loves camping and hiking but doesn’t have time to be a leader but will be an extra adult if required. Both of us DBS checked

anyolddinosaur · 01/11/2022 20:55

used to be a volunteer in guiding. Couldnt be now because I dont agree with the attitude to safe guarding. Considered being a Scouts volunteer instead but feel I've done my bit, the regular commitment is too much when I want to be free to do other things at a moments notice and I really dont like one of the local volunteers.

Kite22 · 01/11/2022 20:54

I very much agree with @budgiegirl

Kite22 · 01/11/2022 20:52

@emptythelitterbox

Do you still have to have DC in scouting to volunteer or be a leader?
My DC loved being in scouts in their youth.
I'm a grandma who would love to do this.

You have never had to have dc in Scouts to volunteer. All mine have taken on Leadership roles at 18.
I became a Leader when I became too old for Venture Scouts many decades ago. We have lots of volunteers that don't have dc at all, let alone dc who are of an age to be Scouts.

Grandmas are definitely welcome in my District.

Kite22 · 01/11/2022 20:49

Because I can't volunteer until DS's can both get a space.
Because you can't get a space until there are more volunteers.

@ChristmasCakeAndStilton - try a different group. Overwhelmingly groups will move any child up the waiting list if the parent is willing to step forward as a Leader. To the extent I am really surprised to hear of a Group that doesn't have that as a Policy.

budgiegirl · 01/11/2022 20:45

scouting is a harder thing to volunteer for than other volunteer options

I think that can be true of some other volunteer options, but I can think of plenty that are much harder. I'm a Cub Leader, and while it's time consuming, I don't think it's particularly hard in the way that volunteering for an emergency service, or the Samaritans etc would be. I don't think I could ever do that.

The good thing about scouting is that there are roles to suit everyone. Being the Cub Leader is full on, but I was an assistant leader previously, and it wasn't nearly as time consuming. I have an assistant who attends every other week, due to his shift patterns. My DH is the Group Chair, and it's mostly an admin job, and he finds it easy to fit in. Most people could probably find some way to help, if they just asked, without it being all consuming.

LimeCheesecake · 01/11/2022 20:27

Reading this thread has made me realise one issue - while most people split into those who will and will not volunteer, scouting is a harder thing to volunteer for than other volunteer options.

I don’t help out at my ds’s scouts routinely (bar when they put out appeals to help pack vans before camp, or set up for events - we’ll be helping set out for the fireworks on Saturday), I do, however volunteer with other organisations locally. Scouts is tough. It’s a big commitment of time and you do need to be fit and healthy.

many people feel they’ve “done their bit” helping elsewhere, but I’m not sure how you’d make scouts easier to volunteer for without making it a bit shit for the kids attending.

Stegosaurusesrock · 01/11/2022 19:33

15 years as a Brownie and Guide leader means I need a break, plus I can't bring toddler DS with me and have no childcare.

That said, when DS2 is older I've said I'll help with outdoor cooking as I miss the woodsmoke. But no more risk assessments, no more stupid Go! and no more politics.

balalake · 01/11/2022 19:10

A lot of reasons have been given which I won't add to. I think one small one may be that the range of other volunteering options have increased over the years.

budgiegirl · 01/11/2022 19:09

Its 100% about attitude not time. If people want to do it, they will find a way to find the time

I totally agree. Of course, there will always be a few who genuinely just can't help out for whatever reason, but there's usually a way around most things, including bringing younger children to the meeting if need be.

However, parent rotas are not too hard to get together, in my experience. Recruiting full time leaders is a whole other ball game. But saying that, I have 5 cub leaders and a parent assistant. They all have full time jobs, but still find time to help out most weeks (one does shifts, so does every other week).

We have 20 Scouts, 24 Cubs, 24 Beavers. So for a camp, that's 3 leaders for Beavers, 2 for Cubs, 1 for the Scouts and 1 in charge so technically we are in ratio

Sorry if I've misunderstood, but the ratios here are off. It's one adult for up to 6 beavers, one adult for up to 8 cubs, and one adult for up to 12 scouts. Plus a leader in charge.

So for a camp for 20 scouts, you'd need 2 adults, 24 cubs needs 3 adults and 24 beavers needs 3 adults. Plus the leader in charge. 9 adults in total

moggerhanger · 01/11/2022 19:08

Heronatemygoldfish · 01/11/2022 14:32

Wow that's quite a thread to wade through, but I didn't want to skip anything. Sorry this is longer than I intended!

I'm an assistant Beaver Leader. I work F/T in a professional position. I'm the last person on the planet who thought they'd like working with small children.

I volunteered on odd weeks to begin with, usually when my Beaver DC had a hike, and because I like walking. When DC moved to Cubs, I volunteered to be a sectional assistant at Beavers which meant one weekend's basic training and a DBS, no uniform. 10 months later I was in uniform and am now nearly 7 years in the colony and I'm well north of 50. I'm likely autistic. I can't organise stuff easily. I used to say I couldn't bear dealing with loud groups of children, but mine turned out autistic and I figured if I could cope with 24 Beavers in an echoey hall I could cope with one stroppy DC. I was right.

What I didn't anticipate was how much it's helped my job. The need to be the adult in a situation and just Get On With It has bigger effects than just managing to survive an hour a week of small smurfs running about or learning to light fires or put up tents or cook. I find dealing with groups of recalcitrant adults at work fairly straightforward now and wish I'd joined Scouting years earlier. It was a case of making time to do it, and suddenly I had some. (Ok, sometimes I've changed into uniform in the disabled loo after only just getting back in time...)

I'm happy being assistant. I don't want the leader position because that might be a challenge too far, but because there's two of us working together we can take weeks off if necessary and plan around absences. As a PP said up thread, I can come up with ideas, and make sure we're covering badges, and I'm in it for the long haul. But it shows that if you can't or don't want to do the main leader stuff, you don't have to! Just helping on the outside stuff is great as that's where we need the ratios.

And once a group grows, then a good district leadership should make sure that help will be found. We've now got two of every section and at least two uniformed leaders per colony/pack/troop.

Stroppy DC is now an Explorer, and learning life and social skills there. I really wish I'd been able to be a scout when I was young but better late than never! And it is fun. But no way it is just an hour a week once you're in uniform!

Your Scouting journey (sorry for using that word!) sounds vaguely similar to mine. 6 years ago, my autistic DS was a Beaver. It was the only thing he could cope with doing outside of school, and he was making really good progress. So when the leader said she was going to retire, and that the Colony would close if they couldn't find someone to step forward, I thought that I'd give it a go - selfishly, as I wanted DS to stay in Scouting. I collared a couple of other parents and said that I'd do it if they did it with me! I'd never been in Scouts as a kid and had no idea what I was doing, but from somewhere I dredged up enough courage.

Spool forward to the present day. I am still there, a Beaver Scout Leader but now also an Assistant District Commissioner for Beavers. I absolutely love it. It's given me skills I never thought I'd have, and shown me that I have unexpected talents in organising fun and educational things for a bunch of kids to do. My confidence has grown both within and outside Scouting - when you've faced down a room full of 6-8 year olds who are about to go feral, very few workplace situations hold similar fear!

But. It is a big amount of work to do it well. (To do it badly would be fairly easy IMO.) It helps that I am shit hot at admin; I'm one of those weirdos who loves filling in forms and keeping nice neat records. I also work 0.8 FTE so I do have a bit more spare time than someone who works FT. Plus I have a very good team of Assistant Leaders who more than pitch in when needed. But the bulk of the thinking falls to me.

As to why people don't volunteer for Scouts specifically (as opposed to volunteering generally), I think some of it is feeling like you have to be a special kind of person to do it, and that you need to love working with kids. I certainly felt that way before I joined (and I didn't much like kids - especially other people's). Some of it will also be down to time constraints, childcare issues or physical limitations. And some of it, sad to say, is that some people CBA to volunteer, even if they were able to.

It's also worth remembering that behind each team of kid-facing Scout Leaders, there's another team of trustees who do things like manage the Scout Group finances, sort out the building maintenance if you have your own premises, head up fundraising initiatives, and generally ensure that the kid-facing volunteers can fulfil their roles. No child contact required! But it's often equally as difficult to find people willing to be Group trustees.

Sorry for the essay!

Theskyisfallingdown · 01/11/2022 15:28

(Not troll hunting, I mean a weird variety of question subjects and ponderings 😄)

Theskyisfallingdown · 01/11/2022 15:25

@girlfriend44 you start some volume of weird threads.

Floralnomad · 01/11/2022 15:06

I'm the only leader in our Group who has children in the Group. Only requirement is passing DBS and completing stuff like your safeguarding training
in our group that wasn’t deemed necessary , hence why I left , although that was a number of years ago , hopefully things will have been tightened up by now .

emptythelitterbox · 01/11/2022 14:54

PuttingDownRoots · 01/11/2022 11:47

I'm the only leader in our Group who has children in the Group. Only requirement is passing DBS and completing stuff like your safeguarding training.

Thank you. This is great news!

Heronatemygoldfish · 01/11/2022 14:32

Wow that's quite a thread to wade through, but I didn't want to skip anything. Sorry this is longer than I intended!

I'm an assistant Beaver Leader. I work F/T in a professional position. I'm the last person on the planet who thought they'd like working with small children.

I volunteered on odd weeks to begin with, usually when my Beaver DC had a hike, and because I like walking. When DC moved to Cubs, I volunteered to be a sectional assistant at Beavers which meant one weekend's basic training and a DBS, no uniform. 10 months later I was in uniform and am now nearly 7 years in the colony and I'm well north of 50. I'm likely autistic. I can't organise stuff easily. I used to say I couldn't bear dealing with loud groups of children, but mine turned out autistic and I figured if I could cope with 24 Beavers in an echoey hall I could cope with one stroppy DC. I was right.

What I didn't anticipate was how much it's helped my job. The need to be the adult in a situation and just Get On With It has bigger effects than just managing to survive an hour a week of small smurfs running about or learning to light fires or put up tents or cook. I find dealing with groups of recalcitrant adults at work fairly straightforward now and wish I'd joined Scouting years earlier. It was a case of making time to do it, and suddenly I had some. (Ok, sometimes I've changed into uniform in the disabled loo after only just getting back in time...)

I'm happy being assistant. I don't want the leader position because that might be a challenge too far, but because there's two of us working together we can take weeks off if necessary and plan around absences. As a PP said up thread, I can come up with ideas, and make sure we're covering badges, and I'm in it for the long haul. But it shows that if you can't or don't want to do the main leader stuff, you don't have to! Just helping on the outside stuff is great as that's where we need the ratios.

And once a group grows, then a good district leadership should make sure that help will be found. We've now got two of every section and at least two uniformed leaders per colony/pack/troop.

Stroppy DC is now an Explorer, and learning life and social skills there. I really wish I'd been able to be a scout when I was young but better late than never! And it is fun. But no way it is just an hour a week once you're in uniform!

VoluptuaGoodshag · 01/11/2022 13:24

Throughout my kids life I’ve volunteered at whatever they were doing.

Playgroup had paid staff but was run by a committee and I was secretary. It was hard to get folk to volunteer on the committee but there was a dishwashing rota that everyone was on, and it worked well.

Spare pair of hands at primary school things, fine. The teachers took the responsibility, I was happy to make up the ratios.

Cycling proficiency - changed from being a spare pair of hands to running the whole thing, whereas before it had been the teacher and a specialist council worker with the police doing the test at the end. Was glad to give that up.

High School - secretary of PTA and helped out at Duke of Edinburgh expeditions.

my kids didn’t do too many extra curricular stuff but what they did do, I was happy to give lifts and such like to sports events etc.

But what I found was this.
Most folk have to be coerced into volunteering and usually do so when it’s obvious the group will fold if no-one steps in and begin to plan their escape immediately.
Everything takes up a lot more time than you realise.
Many things volunteers are being asked to do we’re once done by paid staff.
The bureaucracy is a suffocating nightmare.
There are always trouble makers who either do eff all but happy to complain, a lot or those who go on power trips and make life difficult for all the other volunteers.
For a couple of hours a week, you have to do so much training, it makes no sense.

RedToothBrush · 01/11/2022 13:07

MajorCarolDanvers · 01/11/2022 11:22

Rather than all the reasons why people don't volunteer it would be so much better to discuss why we do.

And more likely to encourage others to come forward.

I volunteer because

It's fun
I've made great friends with the other volunteers
It's great on my CV
I've had opportunities to do things I've never done before
It's really rewarding to see the children and young people learn new skills, have brilliant experiences and achieve things

This is exactly how we push it now.

We deliberately do things to involve parents and to make it fun for them.

We've found that by doing activities that parents themselves would like to do as part of helping out they want to help out!!

The whole attitude of 'I can't do that because [insert excuse here]' tends to disappear if there is something in it for the adults.

I'd argue that we have more volunteers who are professionals who work long hours and commute further than the average group too.

We do have a strong community in our area so there is perhaps more of a mentality that goes with that, but there's also a lot of people who think their responsibilities end the second the leave the house and shove the kids off somewhere. They close the door at night and you don't see them in the evenings.

Its 100% down to whether people want to do things. People who want to, find a way or they will explain their situation and we are sympathetic if its more than 'oh I don't have time'. The time one is the cast iron bollocks excuse.

iratepirate · 01/11/2022 12:59

Same everywhere. I volunteer for Girlguiding, DH volunteers for Scouts. I don’t know of any groups within our county which aren’t crying out for more assistance, be that with admin, running units or events etc.

alanabennett · 01/11/2022 12:58

deliverooyoutoo · 01/11/2022 12:54

But I kept up my volunteering, just not with scouts?? I kept on as much as I could cope with.

So you're clearly an adult who can be bothered. Far too many are not.

deliverooyoutoo · 01/11/2022 12:57

For a physical scout group?

I already do volunteer with other things that I did and do over the internet and I kept those on?

RedToothBrush · 01/11/2022 12:57

deliverooyoutoo · 01/11/2022 12:39

I was a single parent.

I'm disabled.

I work(Ed) full time.

I studied part time.

I also continued with other volunteering, but we are discussing Scouts?

Well clearly if you are volunteering with other things you have other priorities which isn't scouting...

RedToothBrush · 01/11/2022 12:56

deliverooyoutoo · 01/11/2022 12:36

How do I do that when I moved 30+ miles away?

Using the Internet that you get MN on...

deliverooyoutoo · 01/11/2022 12:54

But I kept up my volunteering, just not with scouts?? I kept on as much as I could cope with.