Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout groups not enough Volunteers

310 replies

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:24

Local Scout group has lots of children signed up but enough volunteers do in danger of closing.

Is this the same everywhere?
What stops people from volunteering?

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 17/11/2022 23:41

I was a Woodcraft Folk leader for 3 years with some other parents so that ds and friends could have a group. I was pretty bad at it, didn't often enjoy it and my favourite part of every week was walking away from the session. It was exhausting beyond belief and i think doing it alongside full time work damaged my marriage. There was a genuine sense of satisfaction at providing something that otherwise wouldn't have run.

There was literally almost no help at all from the central organisation to make the groups genuinely inclusive- we had children with learning disabilities and limited language skills in the group - WF and its ethos is very verbal.

What i do believe is that there were far fewer of these sorts of opportunities in the past - maybe one per area. It wasn't expected when I was growing up that every child would be part of these sorts of activities imo.

budgiegirl · 17/11/2022 23:31

It really isn't. We taught DS the secular promise for Beavers - his leader told him that was silly and he should say God instead. DS is only just turned 6 so he felt pressured into it

That's very wrong of the Beaver leader, and completely against the ethos of scouting - scouting is open to all faiths, including those with none, that's why there's a secular promise available! In my experience, it's not the way most groups are run.

I'm a cub leader, and the only time we mention religion is if we are finding out about different faiths as part of one badge, or when a cub makes their promise (and not always then, if they choose the secular version). We do take part in Remembrance Parade once a year, which includes a church service, but that is part of a larger community event, with many different groups taking part, and is totally optional.

Totey · 17/11/2022 23:19

It’s time. The amount a leader is expected to do is ridiculous now. This just spills out to the parents and the kids, and as a parent I find it SO rare to find a unit with organised leaders. My kid is giving it a few more weeks before she decides to quit - she’s been in for 7 years.

I also refuse to personally get involved with Guiding anymore. A shit show from the top and an organisation being destroyed, not sure about Scouts.

AloysiusBear · 17/11/2022 23:18

Oh and I'd agree in many areas its still heavily influenced by the church. All the groups where i live are dominated by church going families, the few none parent volunteers are always very churchy types so there's a lot of church related activities.

SusanPerbCallMeSue · 17/11/2022 23:10

I'm atheist. So are the other scout leaders in my troop. We give all the kids a choice of promises. I was asked at my first appointments interview if I was Christian. I said no, and there was no problem. My second one (I left, forever. And returned to a different group 6 months laterGrin) never mentioned religion.

Our GSL is Christian, so there are church parades at the local church. No one has to go, very few do, usually those who go to that church anyway.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 17/11/2022 23:10

When my DM was a Brownie leader, there were no mobile phones or email. If parents wanted to moan or be otherwise demanding, they had to turn up in person. Plus no GDPR, DBS, health and safety, risk assessments, etc. She and the other leader spend a max of an hour a week on planning. It was a different world.

NecklessMumster · 17/11/2022 23:09

MyLovelyPen · 17/11/2022 23:05

@NecklessMumster that must have been years ago - they’ve let atheists into scouts for nearly 10 years, we even have our own promise!

I know it's supposed to be, we checked, maybe that group in our weird small town, it was about 8 years ago

AloysiusBear · 17/11/2022 23:09

I have zero time. I also don't like entertaining/looking after children that aren't mine.

DS would probably like scouts. They will not being going to it because the local groups require you to join a rota to volunteer to keep it going. Its basically an enlarged childcare swap - you look after however many kids 3 times a term in return for someone having your child the other weeks.

What I would prefer is something in the same vein but with paid, trained staff and no obligation for me to help. I would happily pay significantly higher fees for this to be made available.

I just don't want to help out at a scout group.

RedSoloCup · 17/11/2022 23:06

Same in our area too.

DH did for a while 17 years ago and even then it was seriously hard work and I was sorting ideas and buying things out of our money every week to do (thinking of ideas is hard).

A teacher friend was running Beavers and gave it up last year she said just the paperwork now is too much it's not the fun informal club it once was (not Scouts fault just insurance etc and the way of the world).

MyLovelyPen · 17/11/2022 23:05

@NecklessMumster that must have been years ago - they’ve let atheists into scouts for nearly 10 years, we even have our own promise!

UsingChangeofName · 17/11/2022 23:04

I'm musing with starting my own non religious, non woo organisation when my kids are old enough

It's already been invented - look up Woodcraft Folk

UsingChangeofName · 17/11/2022 23:02

Tomorrowisalatterday · 17/11/2022 07:36

It really isn't. We taught DS the secular promise for Beavers - his leader told him that was silly and he should say God instead. DS is only just turned 6 so he felt pressured into it

As an organisation, it really is.

If one of the thousands upon thousands of volunteers has gone rogue, that is the one volunteer - obviously it is up to you if you want to follow that up with the Group Scout Leader, or even at District Level or not. If no-one tells them they won't necessarily know.

UsingChangeofName · 17/11/2022 22:59

Poopoolittlerabbit · 17/11/2022 06:11

And as for the whole ‘higher power’ thing … there are just better activities for modern kids to be a part of than a quasi military organisation that has a belief in a god at the heart of it.

You are clearly confusing 21st century Scouting with Scouting in the 1920s.

None of what you have written describes Scouting today.

UsingChangeofName · 17/11/2022 22:57

NecklessMumster · 17/11/2022 05:47

My DP offered to be a volunteer when DS was in scouts. He was asked if he was Christian and when he said 'no' (atheist) they argued with him, said 'but for instance, when you look at a beautiful flower don't you see gods work?' No.

Wow. that is very weird, and completely against Scouts Policy, and has been for a long time. I mean, even putting aside the daft question which 99.99999% of Christians wouldn't ask people anyway Hmm

SleepingStandingUp · 17/11/2022 16:11

FreakyFrie · 17/11/2022 08:53

Better things to do with my time then volunteer and look after other peoples kids.

Which is fine cos presumably you don't send your kids to any volunteer led groups.

I volunteer but I took on the role with the least commitment because I also have several roles volunteering with Samaritans. If some of us don't do it, none of our kids can go so I figure it evens out of everyone does what they can

Pythonese · 17/11/2022 10:10

It’s not just Scouts, volunteering in general is becoming more a burden than a pleasure. I gave up because it was being run on the same lines as a commercial business. The final straw was being told to report to my “manager” when I told them that I wasn’t able to commit my time anymore. I was then told I was letting myself and the charity down. Never again.

CakeCrumbs44 · 17/11/2022 09:38

FreakyFrie · 17/11/2022 08:53

Better things to do with my time then volunteer and look after other peoples kids.

That's totally up to you. As long as you don't then complain that the scout/guide/sports club run by volunteers isn't run the way you like it, or has to close due to lack of volunteers.

FreakyFrie · 17/11/2022 08:53

Better things to do with my time then volunteer and look after other peoples kids.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 17/11/2022 08:51

I used to volunteer for guides when I had an office job and had some time to give. The prep was pretty intense and I ended up doing it in my paid job on the sly. Not good.
When I changed sectors to education I realised it was going to be impossible to do both. I would assume that a lot of people who like children and are therefore willing to do voluntary work with them are in the same sector and to be honest, our jobs sprawl into our free time enough were lucky if we get to sleep and eat and keep our houses running let alone anything else. My partner who ran it with me got a job in social services and couldn't commit to the time involved for similar reasons.

I left before guides abandoned safeguarding so I won't go back until that has been resolved. As it is they seem to be doubling down on their idiotic decisions.

I also ran my unit in my own way and ignored all the boring 'wife training' activities. As a result we were popular, but equally I wouldn't want to join in an established group who place emphasis on how to be a 'proper girl' which is so based on stereotypes they welcome males who like sewing over football and ignore the safeguarding implications of claiming to be single sex when they are not.

Similarly I'm an atheist and basically ignored the god part, gritted my teeth through the promises and did rememberable Sundays etc from a non religious pov. I'm not willing to put the kind of religious judgement and pressure I suffered through as an atheist child in the organisation and again, another group might operate that way. I don't think they are truly inclusive as yet because they cling to the old ways.(I mean inclusive in the true sense of the word, not pandering to sexist stereotypes- guides still do that, not sure about scouts).

So basically it comes down to life commitments and unwillingness to push beliefs on children in exchange for providing fun opportunities. Feels a bit culty.

I'm musing with starting my own non religious, non woo organisation when my kids are old enough but again it will depend if I can keep up with the time commitments. It's not a small thing to ask people to volunteer for. I volunteer for local playgroups and the prep and time consuming nature of it is worlds away from scouts and guides, the responsibilities of which could easily be a full time job.

I find it quite astounding that grown adults are deeming others lazy for not volunteering in the cost of living crisis.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 17/11/2022 07:36

PuttingDownRoots · 17/11/2022 06:16

Scouts is multifaith, including atheist and humanist, these days.

It really isn't. We taught DS the secular promise for Beavers - his leader told him that was silly and he should say God instead. DS is only just turned 6 so he felt pressured into it

GeorgeorRuth · 17/11/2022 06:36

We were scout and cub leaders 30 years ago. We could see the shift coming then. We took the group over then to stop it closing.

It's actually, as others have said, more than rock up once a week and keep kids busy! There is planning, and these days, risk assessments training, accounts, etc. There are so many restrictions on what you can and can't do. Going mixed sex whilst giving a new lease of life also added its own challenges. We lost boys who didn't want to have their sisters there! telling parents what they were up to Apparently, there are more girls in our old troop than boys now. I can imagine that fewer men will come forward to run groups that are predominantly girls.
We kept it going until somebody better came along and then bowed out.

PuttingDownRoots · 17/11/2022 06:16

Scouts is multifaith, including atheist and humanist, these days.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 17/11/2022 06:11

And as for the whole ‘higher power’ thing … there are just better activities for modern kids to be a part of than a quasi military organisation that has a belief in a god at the heart of it.

OrigamiOwls · 17/11/2022 06:09

I was a scout leader for a while (I didn't have a child in the unit, but I got roped in by an old friend as they couldn't get any female leaders). I left as I was fed up of being treated like shit the parents scraped off their shoe.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 17/11/2022 06:08

‘Too many feckless parents see it as a baby sitting service’

get a grip. In our case it was Because I couldn’t commit to the time they wanted for my DS to be able to join, on the night they held it. There aren’t many grass roots organisations that say your child can join if you immediately volunteer and here’s all the hours you need to put it.

I have a fulltime job, 2 kids in various activities, I coach one of their sports as a volunteer which takes up 2 eves a week already, and I also volunteer at a charity.
DW travels for work, worlds fulltime and volunteers at her own sport.

it’s a shame but if your child joins a grass roots football team, while you may be asked to lift share, help out with fundraising, or putting up goals or even reffing occasionally no-one is after an immediate, complicated commitment in the same way.

for many parents it’s already a commitment just helping their child take part in a sport or activity as it is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread