Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout groups not enough Volunteers

310 replies

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:24

Local Scout group has lots of children signed up but enough volunteers do in danger of closing.

Is this the same everywhere?
What stops people from volunteering?

OP posts:
Diorama1 · 18/11/2022 11:27

People always say they dont have the time to volunteer but some of the volunteers I know are the busiest people I know.

I have volunteered in a number of organizations over the years and I have had a few adults who are always critical of the clubs, when I suggest they join and assist in changing things, they always look at me in disbelief and say they work full time and are too busy - right like I dont work full time too!

toomuchlaundry · 18/11/2022 11:13

@boredOf what an intelligent response

Dotjones · 18/11/2022 11:01

I think it's a combination of the following:

  • Time - people are busier nowadays. Jobs are more stressful and we can't just switch off.
  • Money - volunteering isn't free.
  • Parents - people who don't want to run things themselves don't necessarily shy away from criticizing those who do.
  • Red tape - there are so many rules and regulations to follow, and serious penalties for errors.
  • The creep/pervert factor - many people are suspicious of people who actively choose to surround themselves with random children.
boredOf · 18/11/2022 10:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CoffeeHousePot · 18/11/2022 10:40

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow yes both worked evenings and weekends. My DM in particular. She use to work school hours in the office and then do her remaining hours in the evening and weekend. My DF had to travel lots for work.

They also didn't have the benefit of the internet for things like shopping, banking etc, so they had a lot more demands on their time that way.

I am not saying they were better because they did all this then my generation, but just I think there was a real sense you had a duty to volunteer in your community, which I don't think there is now.

Beamur · 18/11/2022 10:07

I don't know about Scouts but DD is in Guides and enjoys it, but several units Leaders locally have closed and more are vulnerable as the Leaders get older and no new, younger Leaders are coming through.
Parent volunteers, or lack of are part of the problem, but so is having a cohort of younger people wanting to do this.
I think that the push towards running units on a more business like basis and the focus on safety and inclusion is good but another nail in the coffin for the burden of expectations on volunteers.
If people had to pay the actual cost in fees of running a Guide or Scout unit it would be unaffordable for many.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 18/11/2022 09:54

I am an ex scout volunteer and I quit because of the politics

This. I considered volunteering with a similar organisation but it was heavy handedly pushing political messages I did not agree with, so I didn't bother.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 09:33

It would be very sad if scouts just became another paid for activity that only well off people can afford.

PuttingDownRoots · 18/11/2022 09:32

Money is an interesting point... DH runs a Scout group in a more affluent area than my Cub group (His is near work). The parents pay more and expect more.

Our parents pay less and are often shocked by what we achieve with it. Helped by the fact we own a reasonable amount of land. But we had to put Subs up this year, first time in 15years, and it did cause some families a rethink. Going "professional" would price out those who most need it.

We are trying to raise our alternative revenue streams again.. pre Covid it was hut/grounds hire. But even that needs volunteer time for administration and opening/closing/checking for damages and cleaning.

cadburyegg · 18/11/2022 09:28

My ds1 is in beavers, when he first joined there was a rota which I happily joined and helped out a few times but they stopped asking for volunteers a year ago. when I asked, apparently they have enough helpers there now with people training so don't need anymore. I'd happily volunteer to go on the rota again but I wouldn't be able to commit every week because I'm a single working parent with ds2 to look after. People also have other commitments and might volunteer for other things so don't want to commit to doing something else - for example I ran the village toddler group before ds2 started school.

AloysiusBear · 18/11/2022 09:22

There's seems to be a vibe that many parents/people generally are somehow inadequate because they do not wish to give their time for free, and an assumption that this means those people are "takers" not "givers".

I am not a "taker". I want to pay for the cost with money not time.

Interestingly we have the opposite problem with our school pta. A hell of a lot of people think offering their time is a fair substitute for offering money. But actually, we need money. We can actually help the school far more if everyone simply hands over cash, than if we run god knows how many events at a low profit margin.

I'd imagine scouting could be the same. I would expect the only way it can survive is to get people to pay the real cost of the activity and pay leaders.

Sealily · 18/11/2022 08:59

I am a regular parent volunteer at my DS’ Beaver group for a year now and don’t enjoy it anymore. I leave after the hour feeling like I’ve had sensory overload with the relentless screeching, running around and not listening that a significant minority do each week. Of course I’m not told if there is a medical reason that some kids behave like this but I have to say I’m done in after an hour. I could never be a primary teacher!

DS is due to move up to Cubs in the next few months and I won’t volunteer anymore (although I volunteer in two other places already) except to be an occasional helper. The Beaver Leader asked me if I could continue to volunteer there and just bring DS along even after he’s moved to Cubs - absolutely not, we have a busy life and it’s time that other parents stepped up. I have also wondered if they will delay offering my DS a Cub place so they can keep me volunteering at Beavers for longer, however I have just found out that his classmate with a January birthday has been offered a place starting then so as my DS is February I will be contacting them if I haven’t heard by early January.

There has been nothing remotely religious about this group, nor was I asked any such questions by the interview panel either. Ultimately the Scout movement will probably die out because everyone wants it their own way and won’t compromise.

Swissnotswiss · 18/11/2022 08:34

mn29 · 17/11/2022 23:43

My DS is a scout and loves it. We work long days and are only just home in time to get him there let alone organise activities and get there early. I appreciate the people who run it mostly have jobs too, I’m hugely grateful to them as we’re really not camping/outdoors/adventurous people but ds is so it scratches that itch for him. We certainly don’t use it as babysitting like a pp suggests. I think it’s such a shame that it’s dying out somewhat due to lack of volunteers but I can see why with long working days and commutes.

I don't think it's dying out everywhere. In Italy it's very lively! Perhaps the UK organisation needs a shake up.

RedToothBrush · 18/11/2022 08:05

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 18/11/2022 07:19

My parents both worked full time, but both volunteered for various things (meals on wheels, church accounts, PTA etc)

Were they doing work emails in the evenings and at weekends?

Working life has changed utterly in a generation. My DF had quite a high-powered job and did work long hours but, once he has home, he was home. Emails and mobiles existed for the last 10 years of his career, but it hadn't become the norm for everyone to be constantly available.

I do voluntary work with a charity for disabled people, but I have to do it during annual leave - it would be impossible at other times. I couldn't commit to anything needing regular input. I think many people are the same.

And I wouldn't touch the Scouts/Guiding anyway because of safeguarding concerns.

DH regularly answers work emails in evenings and weekends. He's been known to send them at 2am. He has a very high power job and can work really funny hours. But he does it around scouts.

In terms of the gender woo, I'm GC and all the leaders know, they know the issues and also know the rules. But the rules are more flexible and discretionary in scouts so safeguarding can be kept an eye on all the same. DH wouldn't do it if he thought it had gone like guiding to the core...

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 18/11/2022 07:49

Sadly it looks like woodcraft and dropped safeguarding in favour of gender woo, so they're out too.
#no thank you.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 18/11/2022 07:19

My parents both worked full time, but both volunteered for various things (meals on wheels, church accounts, PTA etc)

Were they doing work emails in the evenings and at weekends?

Working life has changed utterly in a generation. My DF had quite a high-powered job and did work long hours but, once he has home, he was home. Emails and mobiles existed for the last 10 years of his career, but it hadn't become the norm for everyone to be constantly available.

I do voluntary work with a charity for disabled people, but I have to do it during annual leave - it would be impossible at other times. I couldn't commit to anything needing regular input. I think many people are the same.

And I wouldn't touch the Scouts/Guiding anyway because of safeguarding concerns.

PermanentTemporary · 18/11/2022 06:55

For parents with literally no other support, an hour of someone else looking after their child is childcare all right.

When ds was at Beavers I did the termly support slot, it wasn't a lot though it was a struggle to get anyone to do it. But the leader was ridiculously stressed because there were far too many kids. I think groups should be max 12-15 tbh.

SchrodingersKettle · 18/11/2022 06:07

Hello just to cheer you up ive just volunteered! I am DBS checked for my job and i LOVE admin and accounts so im hoping to start with a back office role while i figure it all out.

My mum was an arkela and died last year so although i work FT and have two kids, i now don't have any relatives to care for

CoffeeHousePot · 18/11/2022 05:34

Same problem round here.

I do think there has been a decline in a sense/obligation you “should” volunteer.

My parents both worked full time, but both volunteered for various things (meals on wheels, church accounts, PTA etc). They still volunteer now (as do my aunts and uncles).

AloysiusBear · 18/11/2022 05:20

It's an hour a week and you have to drop and collect, it's hardly childcare 🙄

Not the point. The biggest reason scouts is so popular is its SO cheap. Compared with music lessons (30 quid an hour) or sports clubs (a tenner or so) its usually affordable to far more, purely because of the volunteer element.

I'll be controversial saying this, but i actually don't think its massively "valuable" as an extra curricular activity to kids who are from homes with active outdoor lifestyles either. Very few kids continue it to an age where it becomes valuable in terms of extra curricular on ucas etc, and the skills learned in the can easily acquired at home, few of them are developed to any level of tangible proficiency. Its predominantly just a fun, undemanding social activity.

RambamThankyouMam · 18/11/2022 05:17

stealtheatingtunnocks · 17/11/2022 23:52

i left because of the gender stuff.
im not taking that safeguarding risk. I won’t be complicit.
I miss the kids and the comaraderie. I’d go back if they dropped the stonewall claptrap and got proper advice about the law and kids needs.

guiding is fucked. Scouts is a year or two off of being fucked.

they don’t see it at all.

idiots.

This.

SleepingStandingUp · 18/11/2022 00:13

AloysiusBear · 17/11/2022 23:09

I have zero time. I also don't like entertaining/looking after children that aren't mine.

DS would probably like scouts. They will not being going to it because the local groups require you to join a rota to volunteer to keep it going. Its basically an enlarged childcare swap - you look after however many kids 3 times a term in return for someone having your child the other weeks.

What I would prefer is something in the same vein but with paid, trained staff and no obligation for me to help. I would happily pay significantly higher fees for this to be made available.

I just don't want to help out at a scout group.

It's an hour a week and you have to drop and collect, it's hardly childcare 🙄

Oodlesandoodles · 17/11/2022 23:56

As a former leader, the bottom line is loads of kids want to do it, not enough parents want to volunteer as leaders, add in lack of experience of activities, hiding to nowhere. Also now parents want to pay for camps of dubious qualities for outdoor activities!

stealtheatingtunnocks · 17/11/2022 23:52

i left because of the gender stuff.
im not taking that safeguarding risk. I won’t be complicit.
I miss the kids and the comaraderie. I’d go back if they dropped the stonewall claptrap and got proper advice about the law and kids needs.

guiding is fucked. Scouts is a year or two off of being fucked.

they don’t see it at all.

idiots.

mn29 · 17/11/2022 23:43

My DS is a scout and loves it. We work long days and are only just home in time to get him there let alone organise activities and get there early. I appreciate the people who run it mostly have jobs too, I’m hugely grateful to them as we’re really not camping/outdoors/adventurous people but ds is so it scratches that itch for him. We certainly don’t use it as babysitting like a pp suggests. I think it’s such a shame that it’s dying out somewhat due to lack of volunteers but I can see why with long working days and commutes.