Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout groups not enough Volunteers

310 replies

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:24

Local Scout group has lots of children signed up but enough volunteers do in danger of closing.

Is this the same everywhere?
What stops people from volunteering?

OP posts:
Beamur · 31/10/2022 21:38

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Absolutely. About half of our Leaders have kids, the other half don't.

AlleeBee · 31/10/2022 21:37

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:34

No I haven't got a child in Scouts. I do other volunteer work though.

Having a child isn't a pre-requisite!

AlleeBee · 31/10/2022 21:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Beamur · 31/10/2022 21:35

I volunteer for Guides and to be fair,.if we ask for help, it's generally forthcoming.
Some kids do need time away from their parents and I would say that parents help especially when it's their only or last child. People often don't volunteer because they have other kids..
If you have enough volunteers it spreads the load. There's a lot of responsibility in looking after other people's children and for Scouts/Guides there's the additional expectations of being outdoorsy and camping etc..
I do it because it's great fun and I get a lot from seeing the girls enjoy their time and gain confidence and have good experiences. I'm well aware of the wider issues and some of the limitations of the organisation but still think that the benefits are worth it.

lifeinthehills · 31/10/2022 21:34

I offered to volunteer for an organisation. I withdrew when they told me all the training, sometimes for whole weekends, involved. Volunteer positions often require a lot these days. That's more than I can give.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 31/10/2022 21:31

I'm a Cub leader. Time and politics are the main ones. The politics can be hell, especially when you have the old timers who rule the roost or the super scout husband and wife who live and breathe scouting and do everything and think they are right about everything and that everybody else does it wrong.

But time mainly. It isn't just an hour a week or even the planning or staying on top of your essential training. The camps and day events very quickly take up time. Then pressure to do additional training to be an archery instructor or climbing instructor so you can run events for your kids but then you are expected to volunteer for other groups too.

Usually you'll have enough leaders in your section to do meetings but not camps or outings so you rely on other sections to support and in turn support them. So it isn't just my Cub camps and weekends events and district events that I support, it is the Scout or Beaver ones too. So all of a sudden all my weekends are gone. Where does my family fit in?

I do it for the kids and I do enjoy it. But bloody hell it is hard work.

Tromboncini · 31/10/2022 21:30

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/10/2022 21:17

The thing is, it's not necessarily working full time in a "demanding/high powered" job that makes it hard to volunteer. It's often those where one partner works around the other, or those with shift work, or unreliable hours, or those working a second job who will struggle to find the time- i.e. those at a different end of the socio-economic scale. Equally, there are also some jobs which are just really inflexible.

If you have a two parent family with both parents home in the evening, obviously it's possible- but lots of people have lots of different circumstances, and more and more people are taking on additional work due to the CoL crisis. So it's not actually that simple/straightforward.

FWIW, I've volunteered with a sports group before, and I get all the challenges, but I do think some people on this thread are a bit unsympathetic as to how other people's lives work. And I do wonder about the ethics of turning kids away because their parents can't, rather than won't volunteer?

What about children of disabled parents, etc?

As a regular volunteer at both Brownies and Guides over many years I can assure you we get to know the children/families, and parents who genuinely can’t volunteer for some of the reasons listed are not the ones being referred to.

Rather than posters being ‘unsympathetic’ and unaware of differing circumstances (like those of volunteers you mean?) I’d suggest there is also a huge amount of ‘whataboutery’ from posters on MN.

The reality is these are volunteers who also have all the challenges of Joe Average parent: jobs, multiple children, SEN, shift work, multiple jobs, elderly parents etc. If people want to live in communities where these sort of groups run and the benefit they bring, they also need to bring something to it. I stand by in my community most parents can volunteer 2-3 times per year most of the time. I know the demographic - yet some won’t.

LolaSmiles · 31/10/2022 21:28

We don't do scouts but I do volunteer at other children's groups.

For me I like to volunteer at groups DC use and where there's a rota of other parents who do their turn as well. It's much easier for parents to sign up to volunteer when they know it's a once a month/once every 6-8 week commitment.

TheFallenMadonna · 31/10/2022 21:27

Actually indoors for scouts is just min 2 adults (although usually run as 12:1). Outdoors is 12:1.

rhowton · 31/10/2022 21:26

I volunteer for my DD Rainbows. I said that I would come weekly if I had to do nothing but turn up every week for an hour. I don't have the mental capacity for anything more. They said yes please, and I do.

whiteroseredrose · 31/10/2022 21:25

somewhereovertherain · 31/10/2022 20:26

Too many feckless parents see it as a baby sitting service

This.

I stopped being a Rainbows leader when the dads would turn up 10 minutes late as they'd been finishing their pint. Bloody infuriating.

TheFallenMadonna · 31/10/2022 21:25

Scouts is 12:1 (but there must be min 2 adults), and cubs is 8:1.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/10/2022 21:22

Tromboncini · 31/10/2022 21:16

I’m thinking dance clubs and gymnastics and that sort of thing. Certainly more expensive but also a business so perhaps shouldn’t have said ‘leaders’.

I think there's a difference between paid for classes, which will be out of budget for many, and evening groups which are more affordable. I do get what you are saying, and I do understand the challenges of trying to run a group when no-one wants to volunteer and help.

Most sports groups to me locally are volunteer based. I think there are one or two paid for dance schools, but if your child isn't into dance, that isn't really much help, is it?

TBF, most of the sports groups have adults who are interested in the sport/part of the club, who give up their time to introduce young people to the sport- I've done this in the past, when I was able to. But they are members of the club, so get something out of it that way- and this probably attracts more younger adults than something that's really solely being provided for children.

I'm also curious about the ratios that scouts/guides are saying are needed- because it sounds like they may be quite high if multiple additional adults are needed to stay at every session?

Ekerty72 · 31/10/2022 21:19

I run a Brownie group. The responsibility is huge. You have to organise every single thing including term planning, safeguarding, risk assessment, trips out, resources, finances, correspondence with parents, up to date with courses, division meetings, local meetings, badges, uniform, new starters, it goes on and on. It is utterly overwhelming so I'm leaving in a few weeks at the end of this term.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/10/2022 21:17

The thing is, it's not necessarily working full time in a "demanding/high powered" job that makes it hard to volunteer. It's often those where one partner works around the other, or those with shift work, or unreliable hours, or those working a second job who will struggle to find the time- i.e. those at a different end of the socio-economic scale. Equally, there are also some jobs which are just really inflexible.

If you have a two parent family with both parents home in the evening, obviously it's possible- but lots of people have lots of different circumstances, and more and more people are taking on additional work due to the CoL crisis. So it's not actually that simple/straightforward.

FWIW, I've volunteered with a sports group before, and I get all the challenges, but I do think some people on this thread are a bit unsympathetic as to how other people's lives work. And I do wonder about the ethics of turning kids away because their parents can't, rather than won't volunteer?

What about children of disabled parents, etc?

Tromboncini · 31/10/2022 21:16

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/10/2022 20:48

I struggle to imagine many families with 2 working parents who can coordinate drop off/pick ups yet can’t stay for 2 hours, when it’s only 3 times a year and you’d have weeks/months notice. In that case I would think for whatever you really don’t have time to commit for your child to be involved in Scouts/Guides who encourage community type things and and working to badges in their own time. Perhaps another group might be more appropriate where the leaders are paid.

There are pretty few groups where leaders are paid. Sports groups etc are normally run mainly/solely by volunteers too. Youth groups can sometimes have paid staff, but are increasingly rare.

FWIW, I agree 3 times a year is manageable for most BUT realistically if you have multiple children, it is much easier to drop off (with the other child/ren in the car etc) than commit to staying during an evening. Many people do evening work now, as well, so there is one parent caring for the children, whilst the other works etc. It also potentially excludes those with parents with caring responsibilities.

I do get what you are saying, and I think it's good to share the burden, because everyone has a reason as to why they can't do it.

But I can't think of many evening groups where the leaders are paid.

I’m thinking dance clubs and gymnastics and that sort of thing. Certainly more expensive but also a business so perhaps shouldn’t have said ‘leaders’.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 31/10/2022 21:15

I was a Cub leader- 5 years service, including during lockdown - until the end of last year. I gave a term's notice of my resignation and it wasn't until I actually didn't turn up in January that anyone at all stepped forward as leader. 36 Cubs - that's got to be 50+ parents! My children weren't even Cubs any more at this point and I was criticised by parents for resigning!

JamSandle · 31/10/2022 21:12

Volunteering is a lot to take on. I have no kids but work full time and volunteer (not in this area) and it's a big mental load.

notdaddycool · 31/10/2022 21:10

I volunteer in several other ways and the pack is run so closely with the local church that it’s not for me.

rachrose8 · 31/10/2022 21:09

Regarding a parents rota and other children, it may be that some parents might have to pay a babysitter in order to help with their place on a helpers rota. I’ve run Guides for 30 years and on a few occasions, if my husband has been working, I’ve needed to pay a babysitter to enable me to run the meeting. Most parents are grateful and appreciate the effort that goes into running meetings and camps and holidays, but these thanks are very rarely passed on.
Volunteering is hard work but is very rewarding and fun, particularly taking the girls away. But the increasing amount of paperwork is making it more difficult.

TheFallenMadonna · 31/10/2022 21:09

Most of the leaders in our local Scout group work full time, including my husband. Our kids are past scouting age, so he does it for fun, and that's the key. It's something he does that he enjoys and which is a break from his (busy and demanding) job. If it's not fun for the leader, then it's not going to work. Weekly parent volunteers are another matter.

OwwwMuuuum · 31/10/2022 21:06

I’m sure groups differ then @RedToothBrush but OP asked and this was my experience. It was like joining a big clique where everyone has done scouts themselves as kids and knew what was going on and I just found it all a bit awkward and very cringe. Why insist on calling yourself Elm or Stoat or whatever instead of Steve!?

Taswama · 31/10/2022 21:06

Some groups don't make it easy to volunteer. A list of planned activities and dates and a request for volunteers is fine. I will choose wild games over Christmas crafts on a date that suits me and make sure I'm ok to bring younger DC or arrange childcare. But a vague 'volunteers needed' doesn't help much as you have no idea what is involved.

RedToothBrush · 31/10/2022 21:01

OwwwMuuuum · 31/10/2022 20:58

I tried to volunteer with DS’s Beavers. I really did try to get involved, do the training and actually help. My god, it was impossible. (I also volunteer at my kids school and at another organisation so it’s not the volunteering or me that’s the problem)

The leaders “emergency” WhatsApp group was maybe 50 messages a day which you had to pick through and read to find the actual actions rather than just gossip/drivel…every day.

The endless talking in secret code that’s never explained (I didn’t do Scouts myself as a kid).

The weirdness of it all…the weird names for the leaders, the odd fawning on the grand high leader (a Middle Aged man in shorts and knee socks whose sole responsibility it seemed was unfurling a flag at random intervals)…

Nothing ever being explained or introduced, you’re just expected to magically know what’s going on without ever being briefed or told.

I stuck at it for one academic year when thankfully DS got fed up with Beavers (the actual meets were chaos, parent helpers standing round chatting while the boys went feral)

This is not a description I vaguely recognise!!!

RedToothBrush · 31/10/2022 21:00

DH is a scout leader. The excuse he hears most is 'I don't have time'. Which when he's worked a 70hr+ week in the past in a high pressure job and then done volunteering for something else and done two nights of scouting, he doesn't particularly thing holds up.

He isn't asking them to do it every week like him, he's asking for occasional help. The troop has had a rule since before he was there that if you dont help out when it's your turn and do the fundraisers, then your kid gets the boot. That tends to focus minds a bit. The group couldn't function without a strict policy like that.

It comes down to certain parents not wanting to put in any effort and then hiding behind the 'well I've got a very professional and difficult job' shite. As if DH doesn't.

Parents who make excuses, therefore, don't get a lot of sympathy most of the time (they aren't arseholes either, if there is a genuine reason why someone can't - eg health or family circumstances beyond control or certain emergency workers). But 'I don't have time' generally is not good enough.

The system works well. The parents sign up on the understanding of the commitment involved. There's a massive waiting list, so if that set of parents aren't up for it, the next on the list might be.

The biggest trick has been to make it a social group for the adults, with beers after sessions and to discuss the evening/plan future sessions. The group expanded over lockdown which is counter to the trend. They've now got more volunteers to help regularly, not just occasionally. Happy adults make all the difference as they feel they are getting something from it not just the kids.

DH is now doing less than he was which is something of a relief to me! And he's working less hours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread