Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout groups not enough Volunteers

310 replies

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:24

Local Scout group has lots of children signed up but enough volunteers do in danger of closing.

Is this the same everywhere?
What stops people from volunteering?

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 01/11/2022 05:16

I am a Cub leader. Just to cover a few things...

I often take my "wrong age" child with me. Not so much now they are older, but younger DD did a whole extra 18 months in Beavers as she started at 4. (Then Covid hit, so the last time she actually went she was still 6 then returned a Cub). This only works if the ages are slightly out.

You definitely don't need to have kids. DH has been a leader since he was 18! Above DD actually did her first Scout camp at 3 months old (day time only) as I helped with cooking.

Ratios... there are different ratios home and away. Its 1:12 +1 for Cubs away from your meeting place for example. We do have 3 leaders for 24 Cubs at home, but it means one of us can be ill without calling in reinforcements.

In our Group we currently have 5 leaders plus GSL. We make up our numbers for camps with other Scout DBSed adults from the Committee. We have 20 Scouts, 24 Cubs, 24 Beavers. So for a camp, that's 3 leaders for Beavers, 2 for Cubs, 1 for the Scouts and 1 in charge so technically we are in ratio. But its very tight and exhausting! We are not even looking at opening a Squirrrels section anytime soon.

Personally I am now counting the weeks until younger DD turns 10 and can go to Scouts. I hate being her leader. She's very silly towards me that she isn't to the other leaders. I fully understand why parents don't want to volunteer with their own children

Squirrels... thats another bone of contention. When so many groups are struggling, why open a section requiring 3 additional adults?

Overall... I love it. I hope our group continues to flourish when our two mid 70s leaders decide to retire.

Redterror · 01/11/2022 04:49

I quit volunteering for the PTA after I realised it was a task which people expect someone to do but had absolutely no appreciation for that person. Some people would openly criticize decisions made on Facebook just to be mean. They would suggest things the PTA could do without realising the work involved and with zero intention of giving up any of their time to help. In the end I was done.

YerAWizardHarry · 01/11/2022 00:47

Remember Cubs are between the ages of 8 and 10. When I did out of school care with a qualification I could only ratio 1:10 children. Often we are doing things like cooking on open flames, hikes, camps, scavenger hunts, rope and knot work.. even just having 36 Cubs playing what would seem like a simple game in the hall can turn nasty very quickly if there aren’t enough eyes and hands around

gleegeek · 01/11/2022 00:31

My dh volunteered to help at scouts. The leader left 6 months later and he was left running the whole thing! He is not your organised type, great at suggesting activities and interacting with the kids but no good at all the paperwork. There was no support, he became more and more miserable and eventually resigned. It was awful.

Unseelie · 01/11/2022 00:21

I volunteered at mine for a while but found it really weird. No one told me what to do, or how to manage the appalling behaviour of the boys (all the local ‘problem families’ dumped their boys there as cheap childcare 😐) all the children had to call us fake names and had to do weird rituals like ‘swimming up’ - I felt like I was grooming them into a cult 👀

DS lost interest fortunately so that was end of that.

Kite22 · 31/10/2022 23:07

The groups which have leaders who stay doing it for 30 years are more odd and have more issues with leaders. They can be weird.

What an odd generalisation Hmm
Not my experience across all the Groups I work with.

@SweetSakura Lots of adults who live as part of families where both parents go out to work, also volunteer. I mean, I don't know everything about the lives of every Leader in our District, but, off the top of my head I'd say this applies to the majority of Leaders. There are many couples where both of them volunteer as well.
I mean this doesn't just apply to Scouts - it applies in different things I have been involved in or that my dc have attended too.

Back to the OP - yes, we have a real volunteer shortage, and SO many enquiries for spaces we don't have - most of which are from folk who feel unable to offer any support to the Groups, even in a non-child-facing volunteer role.

WellTidy · 31/10/2022 22:37

There are huge amounts of organisations and charities that people volunteer with. I’ve volunteered with something or other on a weekly basis (at least) for most of my adult life and I’m late 40s. Never volunteered with scouts though, and if my Dc ever wanted to do scouts, I wouldn’t volunteer. But I more than pull my weight elsewhere.

Floralnomad · 31/10/2022 22:35

There definitely is massive differences between groups and the way they are run , myself and my assistant leader signed our cub pack up for all the district events which the other cub pack in our group never did and when you went to these events you often came across other leaders who had started at our group and then moved on because of the exec team and other leaders .

Chaiandchocolate · 31/10/2022 22:31

I am the only regular weekly parent helper at DS’ Beaver group and when he moves to Cubs in a few months time I won’t continue to volunteer at Cubs (except if there is a parent roster).

The Beaver Leader and the two Assistant Leaders do an amazing job and our group is known for how much effort is put into the activities and experiences, but from a volunteer standpoint a major detraction for me is how much behaviour management dominates each session.

We have up to 24 boys and girls and there is always a significant minority who are disruptive, don’t listen, and/or run riot. Of course I have no idea if these children have issues or are just poorly behaved but I’ve discovered that this type of volunteering is not for me. I will stay and help until DS leaves because getting parents to turn up for the roster is difficult and I don’t want to leave them in the lurch, even though they have asked me to stay on once my DS moves to Cubs.

I volunteer in two other places and really enjoy them so I’m afraid I’ve discovered that helping with children isn’t really my thing sadly.

Earthworms · 31/10/2022 22:26

I used to volunteer with Girl Guiding

Pulled out due to several factors, mainly the admin (oh god I HATED GO with a passion). This I could possibly overlook or delegate but there’s the recently arising safeguarding issues — there is no way on earth I will ever take on a position of responsibility with that organisation until they sort that out. Some poor fucker is going to have something bloody awful happen on their camp and it sure as shit isn’t going to be me. Or my daughter for that matter.

antelopevalley · 31/10/2022 22:18

Did it before the pandemic, and I would never go back. Too many parents are totally ungrateful. You do not do it for that, but being treated badly by some parents simply ends up making the whole experience shit.

lifeinthehills · 31/10/2022 22:09

I was about to sign up to a group (not Scouts) as they were desperate for someone to lead. Then I was told that there were 3-4 training weekends away from my family each year, and I'd be expected to attend at least 2 camps a year. That's in addition to the weekly meeting, planning times, group meetings, other misc activities. It was at that point I said no thanks.

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 31/10/2022 22:06

Me and my partner were discussing this only the other night;
We both work and tend to not overlap too much as childcare is so expensive.
However with the Cost of Living Crisis - I've got a temporary job at a supermarket 3 nights a week so my time will be zapped as we need to support our family.
I do however support our local foodbank and volunteer for 3 hours inbetween school drop offs on a day I can but I literally turn up there and help whoever needs helping!!!

RedToothBrush · 31/10/2022 22:04

SweetSakura · 31/10/2022 21:51

A couple of really twatty men run out local group. They speak down to everyone. They thought my son's allergies were some kind of joke so I had to pull him out.

Also, the reason fewer people can volunteer is surely linked to so many families needing both parents to work full time.

We currently have two cub groups.

We have 10 adults who help regularly with parent helpers in addition. The recent comment was we almost have too many for cubs right now! (There is some shuffling around planned to keep people from getting bored)

House prices mean most families need two incomes.

Its bullshit to say its about parents working. It's about willingness to do stuff.

Many of the core leaders all volunteer for other activities on top of scouts.

Its 100% about attitude not time. If people want to do it, they will find a way to find the time.

We find that those people involved tend to be busy people. The joke is, if you want something done, find a busy person round our way!

Tromboncini · 31/10/2022 22:03

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/10/2022 21:48

Like I say, I've volunteered with other sports groups in the past. Maybe it fits with your demographic, but equally, I know plenty of parents who can't commit. Maybe it's because of the nature of the activities I've done, but we'd never turn a child away because their parents couldn't volunteer (it's not the sort of thing all parents would want to be involved with, for starters)- and it doesn't sit right with me.

I get the groups can't run at all if people can't volunteer, and that's difficult too- but excluding children because of something outside of their control isn't ideal.

Where did I say any children have been excluded?

SweetSakura · 31/10/2022 21:51

A couple of really twatty men run out local group. They speak down to everyone. They thought my son's allergies were some kind of joke so I had to pull him out.

Also, the reason fewer people can volunteer is surely linked to so many families needing both parents to work full time.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/10/2022 21:48

Tromboncini · 31/10/2022 21:30

As a regular volunteer at both Brownies and Guides over many years I can assure you we get to know the children/families, and parents who genuinely can’t volunteer for some of the reasons listed are not the ones being referred to.

Rather than posters being ‘unsympathetic’ and unaware of differing circumstances (like those of volunteers you mean?) I’d suggest there is also a huge amount of ‘whataboutery’ from posters on MN.

The reality is these are volunteers who also have all the challenges of Joe Average parent: jobs, multiple children, SEN, shift work, multiple jobs, elderly parents etc. If people want to live in communities where these sort of groups run and the benefit they bring, they also need to bring something to it. I stand by in my community most parents can volunteer 2-3 times per year most of the time. I know the demographic - yet some won’t.

Like I say, I've volunteered with other sports groups in the past. Maybe it fits with your demographic, but equally, I know plenty of parents who can't commit. Maybe it's because of the nature of the activities I've done, but we'd never turn a child away because their parents couldn't volunteer (it's not the sort of thing all parents would want to be involved with, for starters)- and it doesn't sit right with me.

I get the groups can't run at all if people can't volunteer, and that's difficult too- but excluding children because of something outside of their control isn't ideal.

Taswama · 31/10/2022 21:47

Your DH's group sounds very forward thinking @RedToothBrush .

MorningPlatypus · 31/10/2022 21:44

I was an assistant brownie leader and resigned for a bunch of reasons. The main ones were parents regularly turning up late +always the same ones), and the time the GGA wanted. I was happy to commit to 2 hours a week, but not willing to do more.

And some of the parents were just bloody rude.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/10/2022 21:43

TheFallenMadonna · 31/10/2022 21:25

Scouts is 12:1 (but there must be min 2 adults), and cubs is 8:1.

That seems quite high for cubs? I get it is needed sometimes for certain activities/trips/overnights etc, and I understand it'll be set nationally due to insurance etc. But it seems like potentially quite a lot of adults if it's just a standard session in a hall? So if the organisation is struggling for volunteers in general, it's perhaps something that could be considered?

pinkysmum · 31/10/2022 21:43

Scouts treasurer here. It is quite hard to get new parents involved. Many of us on the executive committee have children who are now adults but we are still involved. I've found in recent years no one wants to help.
There are loads of ways to help - you don't just have to be a leader. Most groups would be keen to create a role for anyone that wants to help. We need many admin people - treasurer, chair, secretary, transport manager, membership secretary. None of us were involved with scouts as kids so that isn't a prerequisite.
When I became treasurer I took as much off the leaders as I could with regards to subs and money management. This left them to concentrate on being great leaders and giving the kids a great experience. Being part of the "back room staff" is just as important to the group.

itsjustnotok · 31/10/2022 21:42

Me and DH work back to back. I can’t guarantee the same day off, plus it’s the same night as my other daughters activity night so I can’t be in 2 places at once.

RedToothBrush · 31/10/2022 21:42

AlleeBee · 31/10/2022 21:37

Having a child isn't a pre-requisite!

DH started before we had DS!

RedToothBrush · 31/10/2022 21:41

OwwwMuuuum · 31/10/2022 21:06

I’m sure groups differ then @RedToothBrush but OP asked and this was my experience. It was like joining a big clique where everyone has done scouts themselves as kids and knew what was going on and I just found it all a bit awkward and very cringe. Why insist on calling yourself Elm or Stoat or whatever instead of Steve!?

They definitely differ in my experience. Every group has its own culture and there's a big difference across the district.

There are no stupid names at ours and all the leaders and volunteers are parents or had kids there recently. So that makes it much more normal as it's literally parents you'd see at the school gates.

They've been keen to have conscious succession planning to bring through parents as new kids join so they don't have to stay forever or be faced with the group closing. They've also done a lot to bring through kids as young leaders. The leaders who no longer have kids within the group have moved to support roles to do the more difficult 'scouty' activities which they love doing and you need more experience / permits for.

The groups which have leaders who stay doing it for 30 years are more odd and have more issues with leaders. They can be weird.

By making it a parents group everyone learns with each other and goes through the different sections together. It becomes about parental development as well as the kids. It's collaborative. If we don't engage with the parents and make efforts to involve them, it doesn't work. That does not happen in groups where its just 3 leaders who have done it without parental support for 30 years.

Usernamqwerty · 31/10/2022 21:41

I would love to volunteer with our local Cubs / Brownies groups, but the times don't work well for me 😬.

Swipe left for the next trending thread