Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scout groups not enough Volunteers

310 replies

girlfriend44 · 31/10/2022 20:24

Local Scout group has lots of children signed up but enough volunteers do in danger of closing.

Is this the same everywhere?
What stops people from volunteering?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Frederick12 · 08/12/2022 00:58

Joining a bit late but wanted to leave perspective of a scout group that has overcome this issue. We have grown from apps 30 kids 10 years ago to 300, with a solid 60 adults leaders and helpers and it is huge fun!
I guess some of the contributors are a very welcoming GSL, got everyone to contribute with small jobs, then group instructions on training (which several of us newbies did together) and constant support from experienced leaders.
We also reached out to other established scout groups (they were amazing, giving up time and resources to train us). Now we have a good structure, a good mix of experienced and new leaders, even young leaders joining us from our explorers and even a new hut. We also have a massive waiting list and not enough space - we literally run activities with multiple groups every day except Sunday.

Please don't give up. I know the paper work, training, risk assessment sometimes feels like a pain - but they are there for good reasons.
Find likeminded parents and helpers and look to each other for support. Get help from other scouts - most importantly have fun.

AnneElliott · 23/11/2022 08:48

Agree @moggerhanger - the a district and County should enable the work - but it doesn't. It's an old boys club full of blokes with no career, family, friends or other hobbies and they spend their time inventing new rules or commiserating over old ones they can no longer enforce.

Those of us that work with the kids and deliver scouting are mainly female, younger with full time ions, kids etc but we can see the benefit and so put ourselves out.

Granddadwentdownthepit · 21/11/2022 09:57

UsingChangeofName · 19/11/2022 14:54

I totally agree with this post.
I think what most people aren't aware of is that there are at least as many volunteers working behind the scenes in Scouts (and probably all voluntary organisations) that parents don't see, as there are the 'public facing' volunteers.
All the folk that put on the training that the section Leaders need to do, for example. Those that do the administration for that. Those that cut the grass. Those that lock and unlock the hut, put new toilet rolls in and empty the bins. Those that welcome and interview new Leaders. Those that put the DBS checks through. Those that do the accounts. Those that plan, set up, run and break down every single camp - that's from your 24 hour indoor sleep over, to your Gillwell24 type event, where 500 older teens have a phenomenal weekend every year, and even your World Scout Jamboree where 40 000 people from countries across the World meet once every 4 years. The quartermasters that dry the tents after camp, sort repairs or replacements. The person that does the shopping to feed100 people on a weekend camp. The people that run the weekends that volunteers go on, to get permits for activities such as climbing, hill walking, archery, and all the water activities. The list is endless.

I don't agree with getting cross with people that can't volunteer.
I do however roll my eyes when people say "I can't volunteer because I have 3dc and we both work outside the home", as that is the profile of huge numbers of people who do volunteer. I know it isn't for everyone - particularly running a section - BUT, if people were to say "I can't do meeting nights, but if you can think of something else I can do to help you out, please ask", it just gives off a completely different vibe.

This in absolute spades. Doesn't matter if you can't volunteer as a full time leader, just volunteer.

Help out on the hikes. Do the washing up. Help for an hour at a camp. Help out behind the scenes.

People don't really appreciate that a scout group (beavers, cubs, scouts and possibly squirrels going forward) will involve a premises and a pretty decent number of children and adults (my group is single pack but has around 90 kids and adults). There is always room for an extra pair of hands.

Budgiegirlbob · 21/11/2022 09:23

And it was easier years ago to get more support (& respect) from parents

I think this is true, I think some of the problem these days is that parents are often working longer hours than they were in the past, and children go to many more clubs than they did in the past. A perfect storm of wanting more for your child, but not enough time to help provide it.

I’m not sure quite when the disrespect started to creep in. Most of the parents of my cubs are lovely, and do support us. But there’s always one or two who grumble if we’re 2 minutes late back from an activity, or if their child got less badges than others (due to non attendance!) or criticise us for lack of communication (when I sent 3 emails giving the information, but they didn’t know they had to read them!)

Ragwort · 21/11/2022 08:51

I volunteered in Scouting for over 30 years (yes, I got a medal!), it was a huge commitment with training, updating your skills, paperwork, recruiting volunteers etc etc and that was before even spending the evening with the young people. I loved it and it was my main 'hobby' but clearly a lot of people don't feel the same about volunteering. And it was easier years ago to get more support (& respect) from parents. I gave it up a few years ago to do other volunteering.

RedToothBrush · 21/11/2022 08:33

Where are the people without jobs who would be able to lead these activities for a paid fee?

These mythical people who don't exist.

As i said before, it would be the same group of parents, but they would get more grief from parents who could not be bothered and they'd get less support from parents.

The net result would be much the same.

The idea that you could employ people on part time minimum wage, to work unsocial hours to fit with school children across the country is just deluded.

At best you would get inexperienced and disinterested teenagers who would be massively out of their depth.

RedToothBrush · 21/11/2022 08:26

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 20/11/2022 22:50

So for many, it's less 'I can't', and more 'I don't want to'.

But there is nothing wrong with this if it's a paid-for activity even if it would make the waiting list shorter and things run better. People make their choice one way or the other. Of course people with limited time or want-tos will come in the summer or when the activity is something they like.

If you can't get volunteers as an organisation, year around, then the organisation needs to look at changing in some way or another to be more appealing, as others have been saying, no?

Not if that defeats the point and purpose of the organisation.

The organisation effectively ceases to exist anyway if you start to do that.

Oodlesandoodles · 20/11/2022 23:35

The problem is that some of the activities require leaders to be skilled, ie bushcraft, mountaineering,kayaking, sailing, and so on, so there is a skill shortage, outdoor activities are the backbone of scouting.

budgiegirl · 20/11/2022 23:18

But there is nothing wrong with this if it's a paid-for activity even if it would make the waiting list shorter and things run better. People make their choice one way or the other

I wouldn't really expect parents to have to help at a true 'paid-for' activity, such as dance lessons, music lessons etc, if they are being run by paid staff. But I think it's not unreasonable to expect a small amount of help from parents who's child attends a volunteer run group such as scouts, even if they pay subs. Subs are only kept low by having full time volunteers, and parental help where necessary.

We actually don't often ask for parent help, as we have quite a few volunteer leaders, but I have run parent rotas in the past. I'd never make the parent rota compulsory, as I don't think that's fair to children if their parents won't help. But it really does grate, when I'm giving up hours each week, and I don't think I'm unreasonable to feel this way. I know don't have to volunteer, but neither do parents have to send their kids to scouts.

Of course people with limited time or want-tos will come in the summer or when the activity is something they like

Of course. But my point is that parents say they don't have the time, couldn't possibly help, until it's something that they think it's worth making the time for. Which shows that they could make time, they just won't. It makes me feel like they see me and my leaders as childcare, rather than a worthwhile activity.

If you can't get volunteers as an organisation, year around, then the organisation needs to look at changing in some way or another to be more appealing, as others have been saying, no?

Perhaps, but we do have around 160 000 volunteers in Scouting in the UK. But modern life style / modern attitudes mean that demand for child places at scouting, and other activities such as kids football etc means that demand almost always outstrips supply. Too many parents want their child to attend lots of clubs/activities, but aren't willing to put in much effort, past dropping their child at the door, to make sure this can happen. As a few upthread have said, they'd rather throw money at it. Unfortunately this just isn't how volunteer led clubs work.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 20/11/2022 22:50

So for many, it's less 'I can't', and more 'I don't want to'.

But there is nothing wrong with this if it's a paid-for activity even if it would make the waiting list shorter and things run better. People make their choice one way or the other. Of course people with limited time or want-tos will come in the summer or when the activity is something they like.

If you can't get volunteers as an organisation, year around, then the organisation needs to look at changing in some way or another to be more appealing, as others have been saying, no?

twelly · 20/11/2022 22:47

I used to volunteer in the scouting/guiding movement for about 20 years. I enjoyed it, felt it was worthwhile but gradually in my view political correctness and politics just began to take over. I feel sad as I think children used to get so much out of it all.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 20/11/2022 22:47

What stops people from volunteering?

  • don't agree with the ethos of the organisation
  • don't like helping out with kids (or horses or over 75s or whatever it may be)
  • haven't got time due to work / caring
  • haven't got the energy
  • prefer other hobbies
  • hours are better spent in 2nd job or on overtime or side hustle (especially now)
  • messes up the family timetable / too much of a commitment
moggerhanger · 20/11/2022 22:43

AnneElliott · 20/11/2022 20:16

I've considered it @moggerhanger but I actually like working with the kids and not with the other adults that quite frankly are more childish than my teenager!

In my section we just get on and ignore the District and County nonsense. But it is a reason why we have issues with volunteers- they can't be bothered with some of the stupid drama and leave.

That's a real pity, that your District/County are a barrier rather than an enabler. I'm lucky in that my (female) DC is very pragmatic and can-do, and brooks no nonsense. But I can imagine how a culture develops that loses sight of what Scouting is for. (The arguments I've had with some fellow leaders about uniform are a small snapshot!)

AnneElliott · 20/11/2022 20:16

I've considered it @moggerhanger but I actually like working with the kids and not with the other adults that quite frankly are more childish than my teenager!

In my section we just get on and ignore the District and County nonsense. But it is a reason why we have issues with volunteers- they can't be bothered with some of the stupid drama and leave.

moggerhanger · 20/11/2022 19:53

AnneElliott · 20/11/2022 08:16

No not just my district @UsingChangeofName - but both of those that I've been involved in.

And no one is 'tearing anyone down'. I'm answering the ops question. I'm glad if you've never had that experience but it doesn't mean that I'm wrong in what I'm saying. It's my experience which lots of us actual leaders in those districts agree with.

Stand for a District role, perhaps? Thinking of Gandhi's dictum about being the change you want to see?

AnneElliott · 20/11/2022 08:16

No not just my district @UsingChangeofName - but both of those that I've been involved in.

And no one is 'tearing anyone down'. I'm answering the ops question. I'm glad if you've never had that experience but it doesn't mean that I'm wrong in what I'm saying. It's my experience which lots of us actual leaders in those districts agree with.

UsingChangeofName · 19/11/2022 23:55

AnneElliott · 19/11/2022 23:25

Unfortunately a big part of it is the crappy management of the organisation. They often treat the leaders (those of us that actually work with the kids) like crap while the management swan about patting each other on their back and giving each other awards!!

It needs a complete shake up and modernisation in my view.

Maybe that is specific to your District ? As it's not my experience in any of the District's I've worked in over all the decades I've been involved. Some of the people who work behind the scenes work incredibly hard, and I've never come across any of them treating any Leaders like crap. Hmm

I don't get this need on MN threads to tear people down so much.

UsingChangeofName · 19/11/2022 23:52

Oodlesandoodles · 19/11/2022 23:42

The harvest is great but the labourers are few

Ooh. I love this

Oodlesandoodles · 19/11/2022 23:42

The harvest is great but the labourers are few

AnneElliott · 19/11/2022 23:25

Unfortunately a big part of it is the crappy management of the organisation. They often treat the leaders (those of us that actually work with the kids) like crap while the management swan about patting each other on their back and giving each other awards!!

It needs a complete shake up and modernisation in my view.

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 19/11/2022 23:09

If I am being honest, I find my local scout leader a bit scary. She is rather bossy with the kids, but it is very well organised and she does a great job.

I finish work 20 minutes before the group and have another preschooler with SN, so not possible for me to wind down from work, eat, get changed and travel there and do the group in that time. I don't really have other time outside of work and other commitments to do it either.

Floralnomad · 19/11/2022 22:38

Yet the trip to the sealife centre in the summer term required parent volunteers from 8-5 and they were inundated with offers
this with bells on , when I was the cub leader we had one or two dads that helped on a regular basis but struggled for other volunteers until it came to the canoeing night or climbing night when suddenly 15 dads could be free to help .

budgiegirl · 19/11/2022 21:47

Yet the trip to the sealife centre in the summer term required parent volunteers from 8-5 and they were inundated with offers

This is my main peeve. I do understand that for many, it's definitely a juggling act to get to a meeting. But usually, we are only asking for one or two evenings a year. If everybody helped, it would be less than that. I know many have younger children (although we alway say they can bring them), or difficulty rearranging things. But most people seem to be able to rearrange things for an interesting trip, or for a personal night out. So for many, it's less 'I can't', and more 'I don't want to'. Of course, there will always be one or two who genuinely can't, but they are much fewer and far between than many would have you believe.

cadburyegg · 19/11/2022 16:20

that being said, I do agree that there are more volunteers for some things than others.

Last winter school did a trip to the local church, it only took an hour, yet they really struggled for volunteers, it had to be rearranged. I was able to volunteer as I wfh flexibly, it was only an hour out of my day, and it was on a day that ds2 was in preschool.

Yet the trip to the sealife centre in the summer term required parent volunteers from 8-5 and they were inundated with offers

whojamaflip · 19/11/2022 16:11

I run a scout troop and have done for the last 15 years. I gave notice in January that I would be stepping down at the end of the summer term as were 2 others (out of a team of 4)

This left 1 trained leader and parents were all told that the troop would not reopen in September if we couldn't recruit new leaders. Out of 30 parents only 2 contacted me to say Thankyou and sorry you are leaving. Not one stepped up to help.

I've agreed now to stay until Christmas and we have put a parent rota in place - someone not connected to the troop has come forward to be a leader and is doing really well and I'm in the background more as support.

Despite reminders parents "forget" they are due to help and many are now dumping their kids in the carpark and speeding off. This backfired a few weeks ago as I was the only adult that turned up to run the evening (other leader was out sick and parent helpers just didn't show) I had no choice but to phone parents to come back and collect their kids as I'm not allowed to run a troop meeting in those circumstances. Major complaints from parents but it hasn't made any difference.

I'm tired to trying to keep the show on the road. I'm tired of dealing with parents who don't show up in time to collect their kids. I'm tired of trying to put on a decent program with kids who are there but have no interest so ruin it with their behaviour. But mostly I'm tired of giving up my time for no thanks or support from parents.

I'm not looking for praise or any accolades but a simple Thankyou and an acknowledgement of what we do goes a long way.

I started with scouting when my eldest dc was in beavers and the colony was going to be closed due to a lack of leaders.

I will walk away at Christmas.