Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband won’t do any night wakes with new baby

157 replies

Chumbibi · 31/10/2022 20:17

We have DD who is 2.4 and DS who is 5 months. DS been in room with me since birth and since then DH has moved into spare room. DD and DS both EBF so DH has NEVER had to do a night feed. DD has always been a good sleeper, slept through at 6 months and has always done a solid 12 hours. Maybe one or two nights a week she will wake up, and a couple of phases where she’s woken once a night for a couple of weeks here and there.

since DS born DH has insisted sleeping in the spare room. He says he needs to sleep to not be disturbed so he can get up with toddler DD early (usually wakes around 6am but often later) and not be disturbed for work. We’ve just been away for the weekend and in the same room with DS and said he won’t move back into our room until DS is in his own room.

I will probs move him at 6 months but beforehand we need to move DD into spare room so DS can go in her cot in her old room, but want to do this a few weeks beforehand so she doesn’t feel like her brother has turfed her out. DH refusing to sleep in our room and says he will sleep on sofa. Told him I’m upset and that I miss him in our room and feel it deprives of us connection and intimacy. He doesn’t get it and says he needs his sleep to help me in the day.

I’m severely sleep deprived. Full of cold and mouth ulcers. He says I don’t know how lucky I am given that he helps so much. Which he does but I think he’s lucky he doesn’t have to do nights! AIBU?

OP posts:
Somethingsnappy · 01/11/2022 10:47

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/10/2022 23:24

I would have found night feeding my two so much easier if I didn’t have to do the winding and resettling part.

If I could have just done the feeding part - even if I was doing the initial nappy change bit too (obviously this comes before the feed as you don’t want to ruin the post feed sleepiness!). If my exh had then taken them from me to do the seemingly endless job of getting their wind up and properly resettling them - not a half arsed job and then thinking it because my job again once their are allegedly “down” again. Then I wouldn’t have been nearly so sleep deprived.

So I think yanbu!

This is exactly how dh and I have always done things with four EBF babies!

Goldbar · 01/11/2022 10:39

RedHelenB · 01/11/2022 10:17

I think he's being reasonable, sorry. No point both of you losing sleep.

What about when the OP is back at work? Does that still hold then?

RedHelenB · 01/11/2022 10:17

I think he's being reasonable, sorry. No point both of you losing sleep.

jellybe · 01/11/2022 10:04

I would be more concerned about what he is doing when he gets home from work and in the morning before he leaves. If he is getting up with the toddler and doing all toddler care when he gets home from work and having the baby so you can sleep/ shower leave the house for a bit with out a child attached to you then I'd say him not getting up in the night isn't an issue.

However, if he is doing the bear minimum with the kids when he is home and expecting you to have his dinner sorted, do bath and bed with toddler then tidy up the mess from a day at home with the toddler whilst he relaxes after work then He is being a knob.

Unseelie · 01/11/2022 09:51

Goldbar · 31/10/2022 21:33

The problem with "there's no point you both being sleep-deprived" is that there's usually only one person who ends up sleep-deprived (the mother) and it's rare that the father helps sufficiently the rest of the time to compensate. As a result, you start to grow apart since one of you is at the coal face of parenting and experiencing the biggest lows (and sleep deprivation is torture) alone without support. While the other parent is relatively unaffected and doesn't necessarily understand what they are going through. Difficult to come back from the resentment this can cause.

This. I am several years into the resentment!! Once you’ve struggled so hard for so long and had your spouse basically not give a shit, it’s very hard to look at them the same way.

That said, to be fair, on the rare occasions that DH attempted to deal with a night waking, baby was livid and screamed the house down til I came. I suspect sharing night waking doesn’t work well with ebf but perhaps other dads are much better at it.

Daisychainsx · 01/11/2022 09:46

I didn't think there was much of an issue until the 'you don't know how lucky you are' comment. They're his kids too. I'd have gone berserk if my DH said something like that to me.

But if you're breastfeeding this is kinda how it goes... you're only one who can do it so there's no point in him being up all night too if he is working the next day. Maybe express if that's an option? Then on a Friday you can have the spare room and he can have the baby? Maybe then he will realise how lucky HE is that you're doing that every night to let him rest!

Lullabies2Paralyze · 01/11/2022 09:41

O said UANBU but that’s about him refusing to sleep in same room rather than help at night. Unless you express then he can’t help out with feeds

SassyPants87 · 01/11/2022 09:39

OP what does your husband do for work? Does he wfh therefore can help you a little? My husband slept in a separate room because he couldn’t be tired for work! (Still did the early mornings with toddler and bedtimes when he was back). It was actually dangerous for him to be tired as he operated heavy machinery so I’d rather he was rested than at risk of seriously injuring himself

Sceptre86 · 01/11/2022 09:33

If he can see you struggling with a lack of sleep but won't pitch in then he isn't much of a partner in my view. You need to sit down and be clear about exactly what you need from him and see what he does.

Beautiful3 · 01/11/2022 09:31

Your baby's being breast fed, so your husband cannot really help. There's no point you both having broken sleep. He has to go to work. I used to have a lie in and have nap in the day.

Sceptre86 · 01/11/2022 09:30

To be complete honest I would have talked about this before you had your ds. I also wouldn't be having anymore children with him based on his behaviour. Empathy is important in a relationship, if he can see you struggling wi

ABJ100 · 01/11/2022 09:25

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2022 09:09

I also don’t get the argument the working parent should have all the sleep.

And bringing you a cup of tea (would be decaf for me at night) and biscuit, making sure you have water etc, need not disturb the baby or involve putting a light on.

A working parent can get ENOUGH sleep without necessarily having a full 8 hours per night, and can help the parent at home enough that they’re not horrifically sleep deprived.

Sorry but waking up at 2am to go make a cup of tea just to prove a point is ridiculous. Op can pack or keep a variety of other snacks at hand. That's what my dh did, there was no need for him being up watching me bf and making me tea at 2am! He was much more useful the next morning sorting things out.

Confusion101 · 01/11/2022 09:23

I think the night feeds thing always leads to a strong discussion. I'm the one that does them here, although admittedly if I was wrecked DP would step up and take over winding, nappy, whatever. U say your DD wakes in the night occasionally, does he get up with her?

But 2 things scream out from your post. Firstly, you are missing the connection and intimacy. This was the main reason I moved back into room as soon as DC stopped waking every 3 hrs (DP drives to work and was worried beforehand about him falling asleep). I really missed the intimacy but so did he. Could u suggest him coming back to u at weekends first to see how that goes?

2ndly... Hate the phrase "You are so lucky I help". Those dickhead fathers that do fuck all are not setting the standard. They are useless pricks. "Helping" is the bare minimum required. I appreciate how much my DP "helps" but we both understand that it's required in order to parent his child!

AMorningstar · 01/11/2022 09:11

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2022 09:09

I also don’t get the argument the working parent should have all the sleep.

And bringing you a cup of tea (would be decaf for me at night) and biscuit, making sure you have water etc, need not disturb the baby or involve putting a light on.

A working parent can get ENOUGH sleep without necessarily having a full 8 hours per night, and can help the parent at home enough that they’re not horrifically sleep deprived.

Yeah. It's not like the non working parent in this scenario is doing nothing. You can both have an "okay" amount of sleep rather than one parent getting it all and one getting nothing.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2022 09:09

I also don’t get the argument the working parent should have all the sleep.

And bringing you a cup of tea (would be decaf for me at night) and biscuit, making sure you have water etc, need not disturb the baby or involve putting a light on.

A working parent can get ENOUGH sleep without necessarily having a full 8 hours per night, and can help the parent at home enough that they’re not horrifically sleep deprived.

funtycucker · 01/11/2022 09:06

AMorningstar · 31/10/2022 20:25

He's a dickhead. He works, so what, so do you, looking after young children us just as valid and arguably more difficult than some jobs. Men are just as capable of doing night feeds.

Men have worthless nipples so aren't capable of doing night feeds

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2022 09:06

Get some sleep. Today, tonight. Dh is on every sort of duty because you are in crisis.

He calls in sick or takes some kind of parental leave or whatever.

Also yes you can pay for night nannies to take the load off for a bit and to help sleep train.

EdithGrantham · 01/11/2022 09:02

I don't understand the attitude that the working parent should get all the sleep, what happens when maternity leave is over in that case?

The argument that if you're working FT you need a good night's sleep goes out the window if you have a wakeful baby, I'm still feeding my 15mo on and off through the night and am back at work FT, it's tough but manageable, albeit with co-sleeping.

My DH has stayed in our room the whole time and it's so helpful and supportive emotionally just to have him put a reassuring hand on my shoulder and ask if I need help, more often than not I say no as my DD only really settles with a feed but having the option there makes it easier.

Bonatos · 01/11/2022 08:48

There are ways DH can help other than feeding, which he obviously can't do. I'm EBFing my 4 month old who still wakes every 3ish hours. DS will usually fall asleep during feeds but if he doesn't, my DH will take him and settle him back to sleep. He also gets up with our toddler.

Yes I agree there's no point in both parents being sleep deprived, but in this case it's one parent is severely sleep deprived and the other is well rested. There has to be a compromise.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 01/11/2022 08:46

I actually don't think he is being unreasonable though not wanting to sleep in the same room as you though. Unless he would actually be doing anything to help you, there is no point both of you being knackered. My husband used to sleep in a separate room. But would take the baby in the night and try and re settle, would drive or walk around with them to try and give me a break from feeding when we knew they couldnt be hungry yet again, and would take the baby after the early morning feed so I could go back to bed. He managed to help me as much as he could have, but didmt see the point in him sleeping next to me, I was feeling awful and didn't want him to be that tired too

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 01/11/2022 08:42

"OP, I'm shocked at some of these replies. Regardless of the EBF issue your 'DH' clearly has a shit attitude. Not sterilising the bottles, thinking of parenting his own kids as helping and stating that you should think yourself lucky. He clearly regards parenting as your job and not his. He sounds like a twat."

I agree with this. My second was an awful sleeper. It ruined my mat leave, I was so tired and anxious about sleep, I didnt do anything. Woke every 90 min at night. Co sleeping didn't work. It was not a pleasant time. We sleep trained at 7 months (got in a professional and did the disappearing chair method). PM me if you want and I'll dig out some details. I think 5 months is too young to refuse to feed them if they get up in the night. At 6-7 months you can just stop because it's a habit not a need.

ChristmasCakeAndStilton · 01/11/2022 08:37

Seems like there are 2 things here:
Support overnight
Sleeping arrangements.

I think you have wound them up into one thing, where as actually they can be split.
DH can help whichever bed he is sleeping in.
DD can have a bedroom set up when the furniture arrives. Where DH chooses to sleep after that is a further discussion.

Hope you get a nap later today.

NiceParkingSpotRitaThanksJanet · 01/11/2022 08:30

OP, I'm shocked at some of these replies. Regardless of the EBF issue your 'DH' clearly has a shit attitude. Not sterilising the bottles, thinking of parenting his own kids as helping and stating that you should think yourself lucky. He clearly regards parenting as your job and not his. He sounds like a twat.

I had a difficult baby who is now a toddler. When I was attempting BF in the early months (it didn't work out) my partner was up, changing baby's nappy and settling him so I could express afterwards. Depending on what you need during the night he either needs to be up with you, doing his bit - or, he needs to be up with the 'on duty' early so you can get a block of sleep before he goes to work. He should have been up at 3.30am this morning if baby was awake. If baby needs feeding during this time he can bring them to you.

I'm shocked and quite disappointed at the 'you want your husband to be sleep deprived just because you are' comments. So the mum gets fuck all sleep and dad gets a full night? Bullshit. There are many ways he can do his fair share and support BF. To me, his attitude is the worst bit, that seems to have been missed by most people posting.

creideamhdóchasgrá · 01/11/2022 08:04
creideamhdóchasgrá · 01/11/2022 08:00

Chumbibi · 31/10/2022 20:17

We have DD who is 2.4 and DS who is 5 months. DS been in room with me since birth and since then DH has moved into spare room. DD and DS both EBF so DH has NEVER had to do a night feed. DD has always been a good sleeper, slept through at 6 months and has always done a solid 12 hours. Maybe one or two nights a week she will wake up, and a couple of phases where she’s woken once a night for a couple of weeks here and there.

since DS born DH has insisted sleeping in the spare room. He says he needs to sleep to not be disturbed so he can get up with toddler DD early (usually wakes around 6am but often later) and not be disturbed for work. We’ve just been away for the weekend and in the same room with DS and said he won’t move back into our room until DS is in his own room.

I will probs move him at 6 months but beforehand we need to move DD into spare room so DS can go in her cot in her old room, but want to do this a few weeks beforehand so she doesn’t feel like her brother has turfed her out. DH refusing to sleep in our room and says he will sleep on sofa. Told him I’m upset and that I miss him in our room and feel it deprives of us connection and intimacy. He doesn’t get it and says he needs his sleep to help me in the day.

I’m severely sleep deprived. Full of cold and mouth ulcers. He says I don’t know how lucky I am given that he helps so much. Which he does but I think he’s lucky he doesn’t have to do nights! AIBU?

You could show him this (skip the adds)

Swipe left for the next trending thread