Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that restaurant service charges are getting out of hand?

83 replies

Comcor · 31/10/2022 14:05

Does anyone else object to a service charge being added to their restaurant bill? I’m more than happy to tip, and would usually leave around 10 percent. If it was crap then I won’t.

I have noticed that “discretionary” service charges at restaurants are going up and up (as well as food prices).

I recently ate out and it was a 15% service charge PLUS they charged for water.

OP posts:
NoDairyNoProblem · 01/11/2022 14:13

Excited101 · 31/10/2022 15:40

Totally agree. It’s awkward to ask for it to be taken off. Everyone knows that- it’s what they’re banking on.

I got charged 12.5% tip on a hot chocolate a few weeks ago. I’d had to go up to order and to pay. I bloody well had that taken off- it was already over £8!

Thats just taking the piss - counter service service charge.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 01/11/2022 13:58

reigatecastle · 31/10/2022 14:51

I’m embarrassed for you ridiculous comment

You're conflating two separate issues /countries.

So do you beleive in the UK that tipping should be the norm?regardless of whether I have :

Had good service?
Enjoyed the meal?
Can afford it (after my local nice pub - now charges 19£.for roast that was 12.00 pre pandemic?)...

MyOnlyDays · 01/11/2022 13:51

One thing to watch out for with tipping is whether staff who are in their probationary period are eligible for the tips. At many places they aren't and if the restaurant or cafe is in an area with high staff turnover then you end up basically just tipping management.

One of my sons worked at a coffee shop (big chain) and despite working far more hours than the managers wasn't allowed any of the tips for months. One of the long term employees only worked four hours but still took their share of the tip whilst my son was often working 60 plus hours a week and getting nothing. They were happy for him to have the responsibility to open the store but not to share the tips.

It was cafe Nero.

Another example was when I went to a newly opened chain restaurant in Birmingham. I asked about the tips and the waiter (who was a manager) said they were divided between all the staff but when I asked about staff in the probationary period if they were eligible he grudgingly admitted they wouldn't get tips. It turned out only a couple of the staff were eligible for the tips as they had been bought in from other branches. They must have been raking it in.

Third, similar but different, example was when my daughter worked for an extremely busy Buffet restaurant. The manager kept all the tips and sacked any staff who told customers that they didn't receive tips. This was a good few years ago when wait staff weren't as in high demand.

I leave tips but I'm not shy to ask for details!

Rosenotred · 01/11/2022 02:40

I would rather tip the waiter in their hand for the simple fact I know where the money is going

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/11/2022 02:32

Don't get me started on the prompt to "double tip". When the full amount of the bill, plus service charge is added to the card machine, and then you are prompted "do you want to add tip?". Erm, it's already added....

That's the one that gets my goat too; I've no problem with tipping if all's gone well, but object to being taken for a mug who might pay repeatedly

Can't agree about asking the servers if they get any of the charges though, firstly because that's between them and their employer, and secondly because there's just too much incentive to lie if they think there's a chance of more coming their way

NickEccles · 01/11/2022 00:39

The establishment would be told!! What a fucking cheek! Glad I no longer eat out.......

WallaceinAnderland · 01/11/2022 00:18

What service is the 'service charge' for though? Something additional to what you are already paying for?

startfresh · 31/10/2022 19:55

I got asked if I wanted the bill the other day; we said yes, came over with the card machine and asked if we were splitting it. We said yes. Gave us each the machine with an amount on (the second one asked if they wanted to add a tip, so the card tip became the whole problem of the second person.

Came away, have since realised we haven't even seen the bill!!

Theraffarian · 31/10/2022 16:59

Restaurants that add a tip automatically get my goat . Lots of service industries have people that work hard at minimum wage and get no recognition at all . To my mind it’s a very outdated system that only really applied pre minimum wage .

One of the last places we ate didn’t even provide a bill , you just got told the final price when you went to pay . I queried if they had added a service charge which they had , but I worked it out later that it was a ridiculous 17.75% , we aren’t going back even though the food was good as I feel like they were taking the proverbial.

Just price up the food at the cost you need , pay a fair wage and then people can chose if they want to eat there with no nasty surprises. Although from previous threads this does seem a divisive subject .

MyOnlyDays · 31/10/2022 16:35

We noticed this at a local restaurant with water. They've called it something else but it's tap water.

To think that restaurant service charges are getting out of hand?
Kite22 · 31/10/2022 16:35

BlueBar · 31/10/2022 16:22

I've never understood why it's a percentage. Why does the service deserve more for and expensive meal than a cheap one? IME staff are more likely to be run off their feet in a cheaper restaurant.

Agree

SlickShady · 31/10/2022 16:32

Unless it's a very small amount I never tip a percentage - even when I do leave a tip. Why should the waiter get more just because I ordered the £30 main instead of the £15 one? If I feel the need to tip it'll be a couple of quid up to a fiver, regardless of what kind of expensive crap I ate.

Hereyeah · 31/10/2022 16:28

Last time were out we were shocked at the price and the service charge was much higher than we would have left as a tip. I don't like to make a fuss but I think that, in future, we will be asking for the service charge to be removed and then adding our own tip as we see fit.

hattie43 · 31/10/2022 16:28

I tip for good service and I decide how much . I agree tipping used to be an incidental extra now it's almost as much as part of the menu it's gone up so much .
I also give it straight to the waiting staff who served us .

Nosleepforthismum · 31/10/2022 16:27

I’ve not had this locally (south west) and not ever where they’ve charged over 10%. Yikes. It would put me off visiting I have to say. As a general rule, we always tip. Unless food plus service was really dreadful. For something exceptional we would tip over 10% but everyone is different. We’ve been out for dinner with some tight fuckers before that don’t believe in tipping (we don’t see them anymore) but I think a lot is to do with your upbringing and following what your mum and dad did.

Laiste · 31/10/2022 16:26

BlueBar · 31/10/2022 16:22

I've never understood why it's a percentage. Why does the service deserve more for and expensive meal than a cheap one? IME staff are more likely to be run off their feet in a cheaper restaurant.

Yes i was going to say the same.

It's to acknowledge good service, not supplementing the cost of the ingredients.

drpet49 · 31/10/2022 16:24

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 31/10/2022 14:19

There was a thread about this not long ago and the op was called tight for not leaving a tip.
Yanbu I avoid places that do this and 1 star review them.
Too me it comes across as a scam. Just put prices up and pay your staff more. Simple solution.

This. I’ve stopped eating in restaurants where there is a mandatory service charge.

BlueBar · 31/10/2022 16:22

I've never understood why it's a percentage. Why does the service deserve more for and expensive meal than a cheap one? IME staff are more likely to be run off their feet in a cheaper restaurant.

MovingOnUpp · 31/10/2022 16:20

I am going to ask to have it taken off the next time I go somewhere expensive. I’ve decided I really don’t want to pay an extra £25 on top of what I’ve ordered.
I am happy to tip in the regular way, I never been to a hairdresser or out for a meal and not tipped unless it’s an order at the bar time of place.

samstownsunset · 31/10/2022 16:16

Yes I dislike it too. I ask for it to be taken off every single time and I don't care about the reaction.
If good I ask the waiting staff if they get to keep the tips, if they do I give them cash, an amount I decide on. If not I leave nothing at all.

I used to waitress at a gastro pub years ago in an affluent area for £7.50 an hour. My tips at the end of the week used to be more than my wages!
No service charge was added at all and people left what they liked.
We had a great boss and every penny would be split between the staff at the end of the week.

I worked briefly at a small chain establishment after that which added service to the bill (same affluent area so they always paid it without question). They had a system where the tips were actually paid to to top up your wages!
So on pay slip it said for instance, hourly rate £6 + £1.50 tips = £7.50/hour.

A customer personally placed a tenner in my hand once and I was told I couldn't keep it. I'm pretty sure the manager used to skim the cash tips and keep them for herself.
Anyway...that's why I don't pay service charge without question.

Laiste · 31/10/2022 16:09

I suppose the point of adding it to the receipt is so that the service charge can be divided amounts waiting staff and kitchen staff. The person washing the dishes is providing just as much a service.

True, they do. But how do you know it's filtering down to anyone below management/owner level?

Better for the norm to be that the restaurant pay a decent wage to ALL their staff in the first place. We shouldn't be happy to be led into this culture of hoping for random amounts of tip money to filter down.

Obki · 31/10/2022 16:04

MovingOnUpp · 31/10/2022 16:01

I am happy with service charge if it’s day 10% on a £50 lunch but when it’s 12.5% on an expensive meal I find it a bit steep. I’ve never actually asked to have it removed but I would prefer to hand the waiting staff a tenner than pay for example £25.

I suppose the point of adding it to the receipt is so that the service charge can be divided amounts waiting staff and kitchen staff. The person washing the dishes is providing just as much a service.

rookiemere · 31/10/2022 16:03

MovingOnUpp · 31/10/2022 16:01

I am happy with service charge if it’s day 10% on a £50 lunch but when it’s 12.5% on an expensive meal I find it a bit steep. I’ve never actually asked to have it removed but I would prefer to hand the waiting staff a tenner than pay for example £25.

Yes I used to tip 10% religiously but then realised that drinks are a lot more expensive in pricier restaurants so often , you're not getting more service as it were. So we do cash and sometimes round down a little- but will tip more than 10% if the service is exceptionally good.

MovingOnUpp · 31/10/2022 16:01

I am happy with service charge if it’s day 10% on a £50 lunch but when it’s 12.5% on an expensive meal I find it a bit steep. I’ve never actually asked to have it removed but I would prefer to hand the waiting staff a tenner than pay for example £25.

Laiste · 31/10/2022 16:00

I'm embarrassed for those stupid enough to blindly pay whatever fantasy ''service charge'' the restaurant fancy adding.

90% of the time there's nothing exceptional about ANY service these days. Especially in restaurants. Half the time i'm surprised and grateful if the order's right.

Pay for decent staff, train them to give good service, and the tips will roll in without having to rely on stealth charges or weird embarrassment or guilt from people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread