Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that restaurant service charges are getting out of hand?

83 replies

Comcor · 31/10/2022 14:05

Does anyone else object to a service charge being added to their restaurant bill? I’m more than happy to tip, and would usually leave around 10 percent. If it was crap then I won’t.

I have noticed that “discretionary” service charges at restaurants are going up and up (as well as food prices).

I recently ate out and it was a 15% service charge PLUS they charged for water.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Avocadoseed · 26/09/2023 23:46

I wouldn’t say this is most restaurants at all, I have worked In 5 in the past 5 or so years and it’s always gone to the staff. It does happen in some restaurants though but definitely not most.

Cheshiresun · 26/09/2023 23:42

Also I don't always think tipping is fair. Prices are high enough in this country, everyone gets a minimum wage, unlike for example the USA. So if you ordered an expensive bottle of wine, rather than several individual cheap drinks, the tip would be more as it is on percentage, although arguably bringing over separate drinks all the time is more work.

Also to me it seems a generational thing. I tip as feel it's the done thing, as I child I never remember my parents tipping (other than a token amount sometimes) and my in-laws currently don't often tip and probably wouldn't think anything of it if they didn't. I do feel some places ramp up the prices of drinks and desserts, compared to main courses, that's where they seem to make the money.

Cheshiresun · 26/09/2023 23:36

I'm quite a generous tipper but if I see they've added a service charge/gratuity I don't add a tip, as they've decided on the amount, so be it.

Sometimes though I haven't realised that they've added their own service charge and I've inadvertently tipped them too!

user1477391263 · 26/09/2023 23:33

In the country where I live, there is no tipping and no service charges. Meals are priced high enough to include the cost of staff pay, and restaurants who don't pay enough won't get the staff, end of. It makes things easier for customers. I also don't see why waitstaff get tipped and kitchen staff don't? Horrible patronizing custom.

DyslexicPoster · 26/09/2023 23:26

We went out to a Indian and they added services charge, I didn't realise then tipped them too! Put me right off. They didn't point out my mistake either.

Eating out except as say a birthday treat is getting prohibitly expensive. We went for a pub dinner which came to £170. I was si shocked at how fast amd much eating out has got. Can't ifford takeaway either now. I know everything is going up, but wages fir us hasn't so can't magic up that money. I'd rather heat the house

SlightlyJaded · 26/09/2023 23:15

DD and DS have part time waiting jobs in the same local restaurant as they are full time students. They are on just over minimum wage (fair enough) but there is a 12.5% service added to every bill. Unless you opt out, all the service payments are divided equally between all waiting staff and kitchen porters at the end of every week. It broadly takes their pay up from around £6.50 p/h to £8.50 p/h.

Ideally the restaurant would pay them the £8.50 to start with but they don't. It's busy, the staff there work hard and that extra £2 p/h (on average) makes a big difference, so I don't begrudge paying it when we eat somewhere else (unless something is really wrong/bad/unacceptable).

Surveyking · 26/09/2023 22:54

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Hillbilly · 09/03/2023 22:57

I worked in london restaurants for 20 years from mid 80s as wait/bar staff and manager and there was always an optional 12.5% service charge. It wasn't always fairly distributed but with tips we always did well. I always pay service charge unless there have been specific issues

Densol57 · 09/03/2023 22:57

Makes it far easier to just pay the 10%
I usually tip more if not included.
I paid £17.50 for tonights dinner ( solo)
I gave the waitress £3 - so more than 10%
I like to tip

snitzelvoncrumb · 09/03/2023 22:53

I would assume the service charge was the tip.

JudgeRudy · 09/03/2023 22:49

It can be a tricky one. I think the price stated should be what you pay and that should include 'service', or let me know when it's ready and I'll pop into the kitchen myself....a tip I'd different. I consider this optional. I'm not awkward/fussy enough to require exceptional service, I just want my order to be taken correctly and then the meals I've ordered to be brought over in a timely manner. When I've finished take away my empty plates. My friends/family would each chip in to the nearest fiver/tenner. That's your tip.
I think the fact that we mostly pay by card makes a difference. I don't. I generally take cash unless I'm expecting to pay for others.

RainbowBrightside · 09/03/2023 22:25

whenimakeithome · 31/10/2022 14:50

I’m embarrassed for you

Why? I totally agree with @AMorningstar

Plainsailing1 · 09/11/2022 13:10

Yes totally wrong to add it especially when the don’t mention it on the menu before hand - if they do this to me it will be removed and I probably won’t be back as it’s extremely cheeky
in France the service must be included in the price by law much better system imo
if they feel they need to charge more to cover staff wages then put the prices up so customers can see what they will be charged up front rather than being sneaky - I work for minimum wage and don’t get tipped so I really don’t like the whole concept of service charges tbh

GentleparentJ · 05/11/2022 21:34

I think it’s so cheeky that they are adding on service charges - we just had one added today and we needed to rush out so I've only just seen it. I agree with others though it’s awkward to ask for it to be removed.

A few years back we were in California and were using up change in a restaurant before heading back for a flight. I used $1 notes and coins and we had double checked what we had before the meal - somehow $10 went missing..! Still a mystery but I think they didn’t like the fact the tip was on the low side - more like 10% than the 25% they were hoping for. The waitress actually said - you haven’t got another $10? We will have to put it that you have underpaid your meal 😮I felt bad at the time but when we were driving away I realised what they had done! Very cheeky. California pay minimum wage too - so the tip should have been whatever I wanted it to be.

BeanieTeen · 03/11/2022 12:54

YANBU.
I’ve never really understood percentage tipping really. Why give a greater tip because you ordered the most expensive steak rather than the burger or an alcoholic drink rather than a coke? How does that affect the service?
I’ve asked for service charges to be removed plenty of times and then just given cash tips and tip as I see fit or what I feel I can afford - which on occasion has actually been more than the service charge. It gives me a really bad impression when this is done and puts me off frequenting again. 15% is taking the piss - I wouldn’t pay it and I wouldn’t return, I think it’s quite insulting to the customer. It’s just a bit silly and unnecessary really, this isn’t the US.

extramile · 03/11/2022 12:25

I have been caught out by the 12.5% thing recently too. It seems so much more painful than a 10% tip, which I’ve always given as standard.

I also think that the assumption that it must be affordable if you’re eating out anyway is not true. I will take my kids out for a meal as a treat, and in this case a percentage tip on the whole bill falls very differently than if you are eating out with friends - with friends you can split the tip, but with your kids the parent is paying the tip for several people’s meals. I will often just drink tap water and have the cheapest thing on the menu myself so that the kids can have a nice drink and pudding. But sometimes I wonder why I bother when that extra 2.5% on the tip cancels it out.

Capri3 · 01/11/2022 21:28

LadyApplejack · 01/11/2022 17:28

I'll nearly always tip and find it easier if added to the bill. But I agree it is awkward to have it removed, and maybe it should only be applied automatically to larger parties.

I think where service charge is added the restaurant shouldn't "assume" more than 10%, which is a fair tip as a proportion of any bill, IMO. A customer can always choose to increase (I sometimes do).

I agree, it is awkward to ask to have it removed. We also always tip, but if it’s for example somewhere expensive at lunchtime, 10% is probably enough. That doesn’t necessarily seem to mean that any of the restaurant staff will be getting the tip though.

Maybe calling it a “service charge” should be banned? Call it a tip, and it has to go to the staff, instead of possibly the restaurant/owner.

LadyApplejack · 01/11/2022 17:28

I'll nearly always tip and find it easier if added to the bill. But I agree it is awkward to have it removed, and maybe it should only be applied automatically to larger parties.

I think where service charge is added the restaurant shouldn't "assume" more than 10%, which is a fair tip as a proportion of any bill, IMO. A customer can always choose to increase (I sometimes do).

SleeplessInEngland · 01/11/2022 16:43

I don't mind 10-12.5% being added automatically because it saves me having to work it out, but you're perfectly at liberty to only pay for the food.

CluelessParent · 01/11/2022 16:40

If it comes on the receipt as a service charge I refuse, then leave a cash tip to the actual person who served us. I’m not sure how it works through the til, but I want to leave a tip for the employee who actually served us, not split tips, shared or out through into wages then taxed on.

WaltzingWaters · 01/11/2022 16:37

I only tip for exceptional service from one wait staff, and most places I’ve been recently you end up with many members of staff waiting on all tables. I ask rarely have cash and the tip rarely goes to the waiter when paying by card.

I work in care getting barely more than minimum wage. My job consists of clearing up bodily fluids and behaviour that can become very challenging and aggressive, sometimes downright dangerous whilst giving my all to give my residents a good level of care. I am not allowed to accept any tips.

Pleasebeafleabite · 01/11/2022 16:22

whenimakeithome · 31/10/2022 14:50

I’m embarrassed for you

Me too. And it’s not an American import, the UK has had fixed service charges for decades.

I always tip unless the service is poor. Where I go regularly I always get a better table and better service as a result - win-win

WhatAboutGiraffes · 01/11/2022 16:15

Tipping doesn't sit right with me. I used to work in food and our managers used to take a big share of the tips at the place where we got them. At another place we never saw the tips; the boss said it was tips "for the restaurant" not for us.

At a third place we weren't allowed to accept any tips but we were sent home if it wasn't busy enough on sales and when customers tried to give me a tip, I'd have to put it in the charity box wishing they'd all just bought a donut or something so I wouldn't get sent home early due to low sales.

I think what I don't like about it is, it's a very capitalist solution to the fundamental inequality of people on a lower wage serving people on a higher wage, and the assumption is that the person eating out is on a higher wage and therefore can afford to tip, which isn't necessarily the case.

Capri3 · 01/11/2022 16:09

Similar to PP’s. We went to a local expensive restaurant. They had changed to 10% service charge automatically added. When we asked the waitress if she would actually get any of the 10%, she said that the management had said there was no way to work out the tips from the bills, so they didn’t get anything! You would think that they could just take 10% of the total bills, and split it between the staff, but I guess that some people refuse to pay it?

Twilight7777 · 01/11/2022 15:42

rookiemere · 31/10/2022 15:33

But there is something a bit unfair about the fact that a table of 10 for example, is less likely to tip well than 5 tables of 2.

I think it's sensible enough to put a 10% service charge on for larger tables as long as they are advised when booking.

I agree with this! Recently went for a meal with 6 of us and we tipped quite well. The table next to us with 16 people on it actually underpaid! Because they are regulars the restaurant let them get away with it 😳 I was shocked that they wouldn’t even pay the full price let alone a tip!