Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we solve the social care crisis ?

334 replies

Worriedddd · 31/10/2022 13:33

We have complex needs patients being stuck in hospital for up to 2 years. Some even more they are ready to leave just there's no social care placements and they can't get the right staff anyway. For minimum wage carers will have support people with very challenging needs. There is high risk of assault in many care settings employers don't offer the right training like de-escalation and breakway. . You could get more money working for Lidl and aldi. Even with immigration people leave and find another job. What's the solution to this ?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 31/10/2022 20:05

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 31/10/2022 19:53

Add that to thousands of frail elderly insisting in staying in unsuitable living accommodation, falling about all over the place, refusing to pay for carers and in and out of A&E like a revolving door.

Yeah that needs fucking off. It is not an indulgence we are going to be able to retain for long.

But how would you do it? At what point do you deny someone with capacity their autonomy?

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 31/10/2022 19:59

And it goes back to the issue of consent. People in that state have had it imposed on them. We need to talk about whether facilitating that as an alternative to death ought to be such a default assumption and, which will be more difficult, how best to avoid that happening.

heretohelp22 · 31/10/2022 19:54

RedAppleGirl · 31/10/2022 13:38

Modern medicine is to blame for this, the ethics of keeping people alive is a desperately needed public discussion. I don't believe it's tenable anymore.

This!!! It sounds awful but people are heavily medicated to draw out their already suffering life. Elderly people who have lived a long fulfilling life are in vegetated states but pumped with medicines to keep then alive. It's basically torture in my eyes

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 31/10/2022 19:53

Add that to thousands of frail elderly insisting in staying in unsuitable living accommodation, falling about all over the place, refusing to pay for carers and in and out of A&E like a revolving door.

Yeah that needs fucking off. It is not an indulgence we are going to be able to retain for long.

runjy · 31/10/2022 19:51

I said upthread a wealth tax, increased CGT, increased IHT

cptartapp · 31/10/2022 19:48

Over thirty years of nursing, many as a district nurse tells me that too many people live too long. At great expense. Cure this, cure that. Many oncologists for example will tell you they wouldn't put their own family through challenging and often futile treatment they are expected to give to some patients.
Add that to thousands of frail elderly insisting in staying in unsuitable living accommodation, falling about all over the place, refusing to pay for carers and in and out of A&E like a revolving door.
I was the only patient in a four bedded bay in hospital recently that wasn't waiting for discharge due to social care issues. That, after a 24 hour wait in A&E to get a bed where young diabetics lay on the floor with infusions due to overcrowding.

Worriedddd · 31/10/2022 19:46

runjy · 31/10/2022 19:42

Yes birth rates have plummeted & people often live far away from families. It's unrealistic to expect people to care for their own parents, many would want too but won't have the resources or time.

People can spend the last 10 years of their lives with huge care needs. How will this be funded ?

OP posts:
runjy · 31/10/2022 19:42

Yes birth rates have plummeted & people often live far away from families. It's unrealistic to expect people to care for their own parents, many would want too but won't have the resources or time.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 31/10/2022 19:40

Of course if parents and offspring pooled their resources in terms of housing then a lot more people would be able to afford places that would allow them to care for their parents and it would also reduce intergenerational inequality.

Such places would also need to exist in areas where people are able to live, ie as well as being of suitable size and with the necessary facilities, they would also have to be in the vicinity of schools, childcare and, for those whose work isn't remote, jobs. There is no point pretending that we currently have anything like the societal structures necessary to facilitate this, especially given that most people don't actually have a great many children. The elderly now had what, 2.4 each?

runjy · 31/10/2022 19:39

That’s not going to be of any use to the thousands of people who don’t own their house. The state will have to continue to fund their care.

who claimed otherwise? still plenty of people do own their own homes.

You may remember the response when May proposed that in 2017

A negative one I'm sure because everyone wants someone else to pay...

86Emily · 31/10/2022 19:34

I agree that people should take responsibility for caring for their family, but only if they want to. My father (thankfully now dead) was a horrible, horrible man and I would not have provided care for him. I didn't even go to his funeral (in fact, I'm not even sure whether he was buried or cremated). Being forced to provide care for him would have been in neither his nor my best interests. Conversely, I have taken annual leave to tie in with family members needing care (eg post-op or during chemo). I appreciate not everyone can do that.

I disagree with the poster who said carers should be seen as equal to nurses but I do think they need to be better-trained and they should be regulated by some professional body. I think it's currently too easy for a bad carer to leave one job and walk into another within the care industry.

I do agree that social care should be state run and that homes should be purpose-built buildings. Too many homes are in lovely old houses with narrow corridors and sharps corners. Carers are often trained in-house meaning that bad habits just get passed down. It's not the fault of the carers who are trained in poor manual handling techniques for instance. For someone who said that the old system of SEN and SRN should be brought back, it sort of has, to an extent. Nursing associates have been employed on England for the last few years (I'm not sure about Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland).

I think if we did have a state run social care service, care homes should not have the ability to firstly have direct referrals from patients likely to be admitted there (eg elderly people choosing to move in to a care home self-funded because they are lonely at home but have no actual care needs) or have the ability to decline referrals from hospitals or social workers who have deemed the home a match for a person's needs. I have seen this at work (admittedly a few years ago when I was a ward nurse), we would have 'difficult patients' who would be reviewed by several care home managers who would deem them unsuitable. These patients would get difficult to place and would be in a hospital bed unnecessarily.

Social care needs better funding. Of course the NHS is underfunded but diverting money to social care would help the NHS, patients could be discharged to an appropriate placement if needed or have carers in place freeing up NHS beds, hopefully getting patients out of A&E and out of the back of ambulances quicker.

Building retirement complexes would help with home carers. People could have their own place but have support nearby (wardens) and companionship in shared spaces, but community services such as carers or visiting healthcare professionals (district nurses, podiatry etc) would be able to do several calls at one visit.

Finally, I think that all care homes should employ nurses. My sister currently works in a care home. She seems dedicated (she goes in fairly often on her days off to take her dogs to visit and has gone in again on her days off to take residents to weddings or hospital appointments) but some of what she tells me about isn't right. People also aren't moved on appropriately to nursing homes. If there were nurses employed, residents could be appropriately assessed for whether the home can meet their needs, and people with more complex needs could stay in the place they have hopefully come to view as their home.

Blossomtoes · 31/10/2022 19:30

runjy · 31/10/2022 19:22

which is why I said equity is going to need to be tapped into, not just for those who going into a care home.

That’s not going to be of any use to the thousands of people who don’t own their house. The state will have to continue to fund their care.

You may remember the response when May proposed that in 2017.

ancientgran · 31/10/2022 19:29

Winter2020 · 31/10/2022 17:41

@ancientgran
The model of expecting carers to be available at all times has contributed to care being an unattractive career and it's clearly not working out as agencies can't take on clients because they can't staff the care.

There are not enough people who are either willing or able to be available at all times for the money on offer so employers need to try something different. Either better money, better terms and conditions or even both.

Have you done care rotas? The only reason I could get enough people to do nights and weekends was because they also got more sociable shifts. If there were enough candidates looking for care jobs and enough of them wanted nights/weekends it would be great but years of doing care rotas tell me it isn't going to work now. Well it wouldn't work where I am, maybe you have more candidates for jobs where you are. I was able to offer regular hours to a limited number of people e.g. students wanting to work weekends, experienced staff who wanted to reduce hours but funnily enough I never had anyone who permanently wanted to do nights, late shifts or 6 am starts. I'd have had a stampede if I'd been offering everyone permanent days Monday to Friday but wouldn't have actually provided round the clock care for our residents.

Better money for unsocial hours would be great, shame the LAs or NHS won't actually pay enough for that.

runjy · 31/10/2022 19:22

which is why I said equity is going to need to be tapped into, not just for those who going into a care home.

RippleQueen · 31/10/2022 19:21

Open new care homes be run as not for profit.
Some big care groups pay directors nearly a £1m a year. Also some take out loans in tax havens in order to reduce their UK tax liability. The govt should crack down on those practices but we know the current incumbents won't do that. Maybe they are party donors? Who knows?

Blossomtoes · 31/10/2022 19:18

runjy · 31/10/2022 19:03

@Blossomtoes but does a charge get put on it then?

No.

Runningintolife · 31/10/2022 19:15

Hyper local teams of community doctors, nurses, OTs and carers who are responsible for managing the care needs of their locality and receiving patients home from hospital. With community group involvement and volunteer community resilience teams to back them up at surge times.

pumpkinscoop · 31/10/2022 19:15

ConsuelaHammock · 31/10/2022 17:13

We need to be more willing to look after our elderly ourselves ?

I've been caring for DParent for almost 3 years, having given up a good job to do so. I claim £67 per week carer's allowance. DH and I have just had a difficult conversation because we thought we'd be able to manage financially on his salary. Due to cost of living increases and the sight of our pensions disappearing into the sunset I'm now going to have to try and find a job.

DParent will probably end up in a care home, funded by the local authority costing far more than the £67 I'm currently receiving. I'm devastated by this - I've seen what happens to people in care homes, even with amazing staff.

Perhaps if family carers were paid £300 per week it would help, keeping people out of care homes, not putting families in the position of not being able to keep their family members at home for financial reasons.

RippleQueen · 31/10/2022 19:04

ConsuelaHammock · 31/10/2022 17:13

We need to be more willing to look after our elderly ourselves ?

Don't forget the state pension age has been increased to 66 and will be going higher very soon. People can't live on the paltry Carer's Allowance. Most people only go into care when it is no longer possible for them to be cared for at home or for them to be kept safe. Carers get burnout and often end up dying before their time due to the stress and lack of sleep over a period of months and years. We need to consider quality of life not quantity.

Sparklybutold · 31/10/2022 19:04

More pay
Sick pay covered with normal pay
Better training in terms of actually providing client-led holistic care

runjy · 31/10/2022 19:03

@Blossomtoes but does a charge get put on it then?

helpfulperson · 31/10/2022 19:00

We are getting a national care service in Scotland. It'll be interesting to see how it works out.

Blossomtoes · 31/10/2022 18:56

runjy · 31/10/2022 18:45

@Blossomtoes so someone who isn't moving into a care home but has care in the home needs to sell their home to pay for that care now?

Not yet. That was what May’s “dementia tax” wanted to achieve. Thing is, if you’re living in your home, you can’t really sell it because where would you live?

runjy · 31/10/2022 18:52

We need care to be seen as an actual profession. With progression, training, with a proper salary and sick pay scale. It is far too easy for (forgive me) absolute idiots to get into the care sector and fly under the radar whilst hard working, skilled and compassionate colleagues pick up the slack.

agree

albapunk · 31/10/2022 18:49

Care Assistant here.

We need care to be seen as an actual profession. With progression, training, with a proper salary and sick pay scale. It is far too easy for (forgive me) absolute idiots to get into the care sector and fly under the radar whilst hard working, skilled and compassionate colleagues pick up the slack.

We as people, and our families need to start thinking long and hard about our future and how much treatment we realistically want. Modern medicine keeps many people alive but often with no quality of life, and for emotional and sometimes selfish reasons families insist on pushing with treatment rather than allowing a comfortable passing. Visitors to care homes only often see snippets of a person's day, and not the harrowing, undignified and sad side of their life. No matter how much we promote excellent care standards, there is nothing dignified about aome of the lives people are left to live because of medical intervention.

Younger people with care needs also need to be seriously considered, care isn't always for old, sick people. We have many clients who could safely live at home, if a home was safe for them but there is a huge lack of supported or assisted living housing.

I also believe people who can pay for care, should do so.

The whole system needs to be picked apart and started again, with money spent in the right place. A National Care Service.