Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we solve the social care crisis ?

334 replies

Worriedddd · 31/10/2022 13:33

We have complex needs patients being stuck in hospital for up to 2 years. Some even more they are ready to leave just there's no social care placements and they can't get the right staff anyway. For minimum wage carers will have support people with very challenging needs. There is high risk of assault in many care settings employers don't offer the right training like de-escalation and breakway. . You could get more money working for Lidl and aldi. Even with immigration people leave and find another job. What's the solution to this ?

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 16:04

@Eastangular2000 I don't agree 65 year olds should be relying on family. Some 65yos might not have any family or some who had their children in their 40s those children are just starting out in life, potentially just left Uni or have very young children of their own.

We need a proper safety net for people of all ages who need it nobody should be fighting the system for care.

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 15:54

@cptartapp they'll be a whole host of reasons why someone who is mentally astute will refuse to pay for carers. From wanting to save money, fear of money running out to simply not wanting to admit or believe they need them.

Carers should be publicly funded then it removes the 'I'm not paying for something I don't think I really need' mentality and probably allows some off-spring to continue working.

Someone who is mentally astute even if their body is done still as some quality of life they are able to engage in conversation, watch TV etc. Therefore I dont think euthanasia is the right answer for those people but then I've never watched someone be in a care home long term with body issues, so I might be talking shite.

Rafferty10 · 01/11/2022 15:43

Eastangular2000 · Today 14:59
These are exactly the situations where family support should be the default. 65 year olds should not need to be in nursing homes to recover from an op unless there is no other option.

Family cannot always step up, l look after my elderly parents DF and DM with dementia. It is undeniably hard.
They live in an annex up 12 stairs in our house but luckily they can manage stairs.
When my Dfil had his hip operation there was no way we could also accommodate him, not a room free, too may stairs, we are beyond stretched with my parents, full time jobs and teenagers.
Plus he needed physio in his area for months etc.
There are many who for various reasons cannot manage to take care of relatives for obvious reasons and some have no family either.

miceonabranch · 01/11/2022 15:38

How can you expect to employ large numbers of young migrant males in care when there are no ways of verifying their background or to check for a criminal record? Care staff here are subject to an enhanced criminal record and background check. Many migrants enter the UK without papers. I doubt many of them would be suitable or would even want to do it.

oakleaffy · 01/11/2022 15:28

cptartapp · 31/10/2022 19:48

Over thirty years of nursing, many as a district nurse tells me that too many people live too long. At great expense. Cure this, cure that. Many oncologists for example will tell you they wouldn't put their own family through challenging and often futile treatment they are expected to give to some patients.
Add that to thousands of frail elderly insisting in staying in unsuitable living accommodation, falling about all over the place, refusing to pay for carers and in and out of A&E like a revolving door.
I was the only patient in a four bedded bay in hospital recently that wasn't waiting for discharge due to social care issues. That, after a 24 hour wait in A&E to get a bed where young diabetics lay on the floor with infusions due to overcrowding.

A nurse I know says similar- People are living far too long with zero quality of life.
A mentally astute person in their 80’s who is physically active is quite different , of course.

Maverickess · 01/11/2022 15:28

reigatecastle · 01/11/2022 15:13

We need a social care tax and better pay. Also increase inheritance tax so everyone shares the burden of the cost of social care, not just those who are unfortunate enough to get dementia or other age-related conditions and need it. If I get cancer the NHS will look after me - generally speaking. But if I get dementia or Parkinsons, I am on my own. How is that fair?

Also as a pp said, people need to downsize where feasible. That doesn't mean going into a retirement flat, but if you are rattling around a 5 bedroom house for goodness sake move to something smaller with a smaller garden which is easier to maintain if it's possible to stay in the same area with bus links etc. Preferably with a downstairs loo. Then you might manage for longer in your own home with cheaper home care, rather than needing to move into a care home.

My elderly SIL lives in a terrace house and she really needs to move to a flat somewhere in a nicer area. But she won't move because of local bus links. But she's in London, all of it has decent bus links so she could easily move somewhere else. But if she becomes infirm she will be stuck in an unsuitable house.

And given we have thousands of illegal immigrants, maybe some of them can work in our care sector (on a paid basis, I don't mean for free, I mean on the same (improved) wage that anyone would get), even if it's only on a temporary basis until they are qualified to do something else.

Unfortunately this attitude towards social care is one of the things that keeps the wages low, the conditions awful and therefore the standard of care lower than it should be. And that drives out the people who genuinely want to do it too, making matters worse.

Advocating for 'anyone' to do this job is half the problem, because then anyone does and can (or is pushed into doing it) it's just about getting it done, to any standard, not investing in the sector as a whole to ensure it's done well.

oakleaffy · 01/11/2022 15:19

reigatecastle · 01/11/2022 15:13

We need a social care tax and better pay. Also increase inheritance tax so everyone shares the burden of the cost of social care, not just those who are unfortunate enough to get dementia or other age-related conditions and need it. If I get cancer the NHS will look after me - generally speaking. But if I get dementia or Parkinsons, I am on my own. How is that fair?

Also as a pp said, people need to downsize where feasible. That doesn't mean going into a retirement flat, but if you are rattling around a 5 bedroom house for goodness sake move to something smaller with a smaller garden which is easier to maintain if it's possible to stay in the same area with bus links etc. Preferably with a downstairs loo. Then you might manage for longer in your own home with cheaper home care, rather than needing to move into a care home.

My elderly SIL lives in a terrace house and she really needs to move to a flat somewhere in a nicer area. But she won't move because of local bus links. But she's in London, all of it has decent bus links so she could easily move somewhere else. But if she becomes infirm she will be stuck in an unsuitable house.

And given we have thousands of illegal immigrants, maybe some of them can work in our care sector (on a paid basis, I don't mean for free, I mean on the same (improved) wage that anyone would get), even if it's only on a temporary basis until they are qualified to do something else.

Would scores of young men who don’t speak English be suitable to work in a care home?
Feeding and personal care?
Not fair on the residents
People being coerced into care work would be a disaster.

oakleaffy · 01/11/2022 15:16

I can see a time when Euthanasia is a legal option if people sign up for it while mentally well.

If one is still enjoying life, even in diminished form, that’s very different to if one is suffering from dementia and doesn’t recognise anyone and is unhappy .

This is what scares people- having dementia and zero quality of life- Euthanasia is allowed for much loved animals to spare them unnecessary suffering - But for humans?
We have to ( If dementia hits) endure years in a care home.

reigatecastle · 01/11/2022 15:13

We need a social care tax and better pay. Also increase inheritance tax so everyone shares the burden of the cost of social care, not just those who are unfortunate enough to get dementia or other age-related conditions and need it. If I get cancer the NHS will look after me - generally speaking. But if I get dementia or Parkinsons, I am on my own. How is that fair?

Also as a pp said, people need to downsize where feasible. That doesn't mean going into a retirement flat, but if you are rattling around a 5 bedroom house for goodness sake move to something smaller with a smaller garden which is easier to maintain if it's possible to stay in the same area with bus links etc. Preferably with a downstairs loo. Then you might manage for longer in your own home with cheaper home care, rather than needing to move into a care home.

My elderly SIL lives in a terrace house and she really needs to move to a flat somewhere in a nicer area. But she won't move because of local bus links. But she's in London, all of it has decent bus links so she could easily move somewhere else. But if she becomes infirm she will be stuck in an unsuitable house.

And given we have thousands of illegal immigrants, maybe some of them can work in our care sector (on a paid basis, I don't mean for free, I mean on the same (improved) wage that anyone would get), even if it's only on a temporary basis until they are qualified to do something else.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 01/11/2022 15:04

It’s a worry, I live in a rural area in Scotland where the amount Of elderly far outstrips the amount of young people as all the opportunities are in towns and cities and so we have this problem where many come here to retire and there isn’t the young enough people here to work in care

anyway robots is my answer, get you up dressed food and meds etc then the current carers can be companions giving a bit of company each day

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 15:03

As a separate point, we've reached the stage where we need to increase tax on wealth/assets not income.

We’ve already reached that point. Care is essentially means tested on wealth. The NHS takes so long to treat people that older patients use their capital for procedures to be done privately. Most retired people I know see the NHS as an emergency care service to be used only if you have a heart attack or stroke.

Thelnebriati · 01/11/2022 15:02

Stop asking women to take the financial hit to lower the tax bill. Its dishonest. Many of those same women will end their working lives being financially dependant on the State.

Eastangular2000 · 01/11/2022 14:59

Rafferty10 · 01/11/2022 12:41

Blossomtoes · Today 11:57

Rafferty10 · Today 11:21

we need to create many many nursing homes fast

No we don’t. We need to start allowing people to legally end their life when they’ve had enough.

That too but not all elderly people want to end their life, l am a fan of assisted dying with very strict controls of course, but what about the otherwise able 65 year old who needs to recover from a knee replacement or hip surgery?

People like this need to have nursing homes to go to to free up NHS beds.

My FIL had to stay in hospital for 12 weeks following a hip replacement as he couldn't manage home alone, yet did not need to be taking up a hospital bed.

These are exactly the situations where family support should be the default. 65 year olds should not need to be in nursing homes to recover from an op unless there is no other option.

Goldbar · 01/11/2022 14:31

Dontsayitsuseless · 01/11/2022 12:31

@Q2C4

"Who would pay for the additional costs though? The patients, then the state when the patients' money ran out. So taxes would go up."

OMG ! Taxes would go up !!!! Oh dear !!!

Bring it on!!! You want a decent public services then you have to pay for it through a fair, redistributive tax system!

As a separate point, we've reached the stage where we need to increase tax on wealth/assets not income. Otherwise you have an increasingly small pool of taxpayers bearing the increasingly large cost of providing care for a generation which unfortunately did not pay enough into the system to fund it themselves.

The problem is that wealth/property taxes are incredibly unpopular. People see them as the state 'stealing' their/their children's inheritance. Instead, they'd prefer taxpayers, including low and middle earners (who may have no hope of an inheritance themselves), to pay for their care through increased income taxes.

MichelleScarn · 01/11/2022 14:07

Dontsayitsuseless · 01/11/2022 12:31

@Q2C4

"Who would pay for the additional costs though? The patients, then the state when the patients' money ran out. So taxes would go up."

OMG ! Taxes would go up !!!! Oh dear !!!

Bring it on!!! You want a decent public services then you have to pay for it through a fair, redistributive tax system!

What is this 'fair, redistributive system'? Basically those of us who are the ones already being taxed getting told to pay more tax, then likely as seems to be the plan getting told not entitled to state support?

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 12:49

what about the otherwise able 65 year old who needs to recover from a knee replacement or hip surgery?

They go home and carry on with their life. Hip and knee replacement are minor ops these days.

Rafferty10 · 01/11/2022 12:41

Blossomtoes · Today 11:57

Rafferty10 · Today 11:21

we need to create many many nursing homes fast

No we don’t. We need to start allowing people to legally end their life when they’ve had enough.

That too but not all elderly people want to end their life, l am a fan of assisted dying with very strict controls of course, but what about the otherwise able 65 year old who needs to recover from a knee replacement or hip surgery?

People like this need to have nursing homes to go to to free up NHS beds.

My FIL had to stay in hospital for 12 weeks following a hip replacement as he couldn't manage home alone, yet did not need to be taking up a hospital bed.

Dontsayitsuseless · 01/11/2022 12:31

@Q2C4

"Who would pay for the additional costs though? The patients, then the state when the patients' money ran out. So taxes would go up."

OMG ! Taxes would go up !!!! Oh dear !!!

Bring it on!!! You want a decent public services then you have to pay for it through a fair, redistributive tax system!

JockTamsonsBairns · 01/11/2022 12:21

EducationDilemma · 31/10/2022 13:53

Also are home carers still only paid for the time they're actually with a client? For all the time driving around etc I was losing hours of pay every week which is why I stopped doing care work.

Yes, and it's an appalling way to treat a workforce who are already amongst the lowest paid in society.

I work rurally as a home carer. I get paid £5.25 for a half hour call, but I don't get paid for the next half hour that it takes me to drive to my next client. So, in a 7am-10pm shift, 15 hours out at work, I'll get paid for 8 or 9 hours.

Add on the cost of fuel, and it's little wonder so many of my colleagues have left to work in retail.

Recruitment and retention is a massive problem in Social Care these days. Many companies, mine included, offer existing staff a £500 bonus if they can recruit a friend. But, in all good conscience, I couldn't recommend this to anyone.
I personally love it, I've done it for 26 years, I'm good at it and well thought of. But the sector is on its arse, and there's no real motivation from anyone to sort it.
A round of applause on a Thursday evening for a couple of months made us feel a little bit valued while it lasted, and helped to salve the conscience of those who are willing to do bugger all else.

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 11:57

Rafferty10 · 01/11/2022 11:21

we need to create many many nursing homes fast

No we don’t. We need to start allowing people to legally end their life when they’ve had enough.

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 11:21

And there has to be a cross over point too, pay better wages, you'll have less people on top-up benefits.

Rafferty10 · 01/11/2022 11:21

we need to create many many nursing homes fast

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 11:19

If we want decent care in the UK the NHS, social care, schools all need better funding.
We need to pay for it. Simple.

Nothing is free, it needs to be paid for somewhere.

Maverickess · 01/11/2022 11:05

Q2C4 · 01/11/2022 10:47

Who would pay for the additional costs though? The patients, then the state when the patients' money ran out. So taxes would go up.

Yes taxes would need to be increased, also cut out the middle man and make social care less of a business that needs profit to please share holders and owners.
It's fairer than the current system of the staff subsidising care with low wages, crap conditions and providing their own equipment/paying for their own travel between clients.

Q2C4 · 01/11/2022 10:47

Dontsayitsuseless · 31/10/2022 13:58

Pay staff alot more , improve conditions and training and generally value staff better.

Who would pay for the additional costs though? The patients, then the state when the patients' money ran out. So taxes would go up.