Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we solve the social care crisis ?

334 replies

Worriedddd · 31/10/2022 13:33

We have complex needs patients being stuck in hospital for up to 2 years. Some even more they are ready to leave just there's no social care placements and they can't get the right staff anyway. For minimum wage carers will have support people with very challenging needs. There is high risk of assault in many care settings employers don't offer the right training like de-escalation and breakway. . You could get more money working for Lidl and aldi. Even with immigration people leave and find another job. What's the solution to this ?

OP posts:
Worriedddd · 01/11/2022 20:03

Another thing preventing people staying at home is the closure of NHS respite centres. Respite closes and families don't get a break so they ask social care to step in and provide permanent care costing more money for the state !!!

OP posts:
Maverickess · 01/11/2022 19:11

Burgoo · 01/11/2022 17:49

@JockTamsonsBairns "And we are totally devalued by the whole of society.
Why?"

Because you are willing to take all that BS and not complain about it. I worked out years ago that I am not a charity. If you want me to work in this field, you pay me decently. The problem is, as long as people do the job because it makes them "feel good" and because they feel they "need to" then things won't change.

The NHS is a prime example. It runs solely on good will of staff. If staff didn't do extra work out of hours etc the whole thing would crumple. I know people that do 3 hours of admin EVERY NIGHT because they haven't got time to do it in work time. They don't get paid for doing it, it is almost expected if you work in outpatients/community NHS. NHS managers know this. They rely on good will. The problem is, because good, hard-working nurses are willing to forego their own self-respect and personal time to do it, nothing gets solved. Whilst they work extra hours, doing the "right thing" by their patients, the government have absolutely no incentive to pay them more and increase resources. Why would they if they know nurses will do it anyway? They rely on guilt and collective shaming for not "going above and beyond" to get nurses to do things they aren't paid for.

Unfortunately, NHS and social care workers are their own worst enemy and I say this as someone who has been around decades in the area and see exactly why they do what they do. It's about time that they stand up and say "no, if you want this done you pay for it. I am not a charity!"

I sort of agree with this, but, I think you're missing a big factor here in that society demands that nurses/carers be in it because it's their vocation and not for the money - "Well we don't want people doing it for the money do we? We want people who actually care" which in essence is true I think, except when we've reached the point where these jobs aren't just putting up with a wage that's low or conditions that aren't ideal, there's an attitude that you should be grateful for the privilege of not being paid enough to live on, told you're not working hard enough to do any better for yourself, not have enough resources or support to do the job well and then get blamed for it and take the fall for it too.

Owners, management, share holders, budget managers in social services need to be held more to account rather than throwing their staff under the bus when something goes wrong - it's one of the reasons that I left social care, because I saw it too many times, people left in an unsuitable environment because no one wanted to spend more money on more suitable care, then when something happens it's blamed on incompetent staff, shifts short staffed day after day and then when something goes wrong the finger is pointed at the staff on shift - there needs to be an overhaul of standards for those at the top - proper staff/residents ratio devised and not just left up to the care provider to decide - because their interest is going to be saving on wages every time, especially when they have a convenient Scape goat to blame, while they wring their hands and whine that they don't know why they can't get and keep staff - yet do nothing about it.

tomissmymum · 01/11/2022 19:06

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 18:57

@tomissmymum that's horrendous to hear that about your poor mum. Dementia in your 50s is horrific. There is definitely a point where people cannot cope at home.

I know two people who ended up in homes after Dementia related accidents. Basically it took the accident and hospitalisation the authorities to accept they needed 24hr care.

She went into hospital on a Saturday - Monday GP rang at 8am and said, don't take her home . Hardest thing I've ever done in my life, its taken me several months to come to any sort of peace with it and even then I've still got days where I think, what the hell have I done . The only way I can sit with it is remembering GP saying I'm the one that's got to go on living, said I had to make a break while there was still enough of me left that I could recover . There just isn't the support for people to continue caring alone at home - you need a whole team of people .

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 18:57

@tomissmymum that's horrendous to hear that about your poor mum. Dementia in your 50s is horrific. There is definitely a point where people cannot cope at home.

I know two people who ended up in homes after Dementia related accidents. Basically it took the accident and hospitalisation the authorities to accept they needed 24hr care.

Vanderpump · 01/11/2022 18:12

Burgoo · 01/11/2022 17:42

Throwing money at the problem isn't helpful if you just hire a bunch of people who aren't RIGHT for the job. That said, there is no respect for care staff nowadays. It's seen as a low-paid, "clean up people's shit" type of job and therefore why would anyone want to go into it?

A few things that need changing:

Salaries: If you want to attract people into the job you need to pay decent rates. I can make more working at Tesco than I do dealing with difficult, challenging individuals with complex needs. It must be seen as a profession and be rewarded as such.

A standardised vocational program for all care staff: We should equip carers to be professionalised, and this means a set standard that all social care staff must meet. This means a code of conduct, training and support to progress.

Stronger emphasis on informal carers: Why are we relying on state funded social care (or even privately funded) when we could fund people to look after their own family members? We already rely heavily on care givers of family/friends - support people to care for their family/friends by funding it adequately. If I have a sick relative, I can't work and look after them simultaneously. This needs to change.

Nationalisation: We shouldn't be throwing away billions a year to private providers. They skim off profits and give dividends to shareholders. Social and Health Care should NEVER be for profit because that's when corners are cut. Money spent on publicly owned services eventually get pumped back into the system through taxation of employees etc. It would also be FAR cheaper. Hence why privatised services get given back to the NHS when private companies can't compete (price vs service provided).

On a side note, there needs to be a REALLY heavy focus on the fact if we want a service, we MUST have an adult conversation about how it is paid for. Because this country is full of people who want a service but aren't willing to stump up the funds for it. We haven't got a bottomless pit of money, and it has to be paid for.

The other thing is we need to be MUCH more radical re: the culture in the UK of not taking care of ourselves. Much of the issues facing social care are at least in part related directly to people not taking good decisions re: their health. For example, obesity is a HUGE crisis, leading to diabetes, heart conditions etc. the fact is we have to take much more responsibility over our bodies and health if we are to stem this problem. Just throwing money at it isn't enough. We need to value the services we have, and that means not needlessly causing ourselves more physical ailments that will cost the system billions a year.

I am NOT talking about neurological conditions/disabilities or other problems that are beyond our control. I am talking about the fact we spend hundreds of billions on preventable conditions that need social care support. Diabetes, hypertension, alcohol or drug related conditions etc are all HUGE drains on the system. Have a stroke, you may need 24-hour care. We need to drive the message that a stroke is something which is at least in part preventable and that it is a responsibility of each one of us to avoid these things happening. That isn't to blame those who have strokes, though if you smoke 40 a day, have a few take aways a week, barely move from your sofa etc it is hardly surprising you have one.

I've worked in the sector for decades. NOBODY seems to want to face up to their own responsibility to society re: doing everything they can to avoid needing extra care and support services. If you want the righ to "free" health and social care, then you must also have a responsibility to avoid needing it unless necessary. This shouldn't be controversial, but people will scream about it.

I couldn't agree more, I have worked for years as a Snr Manager within a local author Health and social care provider and relate you everything you have said

Free personal care Isn't working, unrealistic expectations , poor recruitment, inexperienced managers , poor working conditions and all of this within budget restrictions

Burgoo · 01/11/2022 17:54

@miceonabranch

YES! We keep people alive in a state of misery. Many with no capacity or ability to lead a meaningful life.

Burgoo · 01/11/2022 17:53

@KatieB55 "Care homes shouldn't take huge profits & pay staff minimum wage."

Whilst I agree, I also know that unless they are a large franchise most companies aren't making mega-money. My sister works in a private care home and the guy that owns it barely makes any money after wages, bills, insurance, governance etc. People forget that things like keeping the lights on has just gone up by 3+ times. These aren't additional extras and companies have to find the money.

As for your point... who is going to fund it? Regardless of what "should" be done, someone has to pay for it. Trained professionals? Fine, but that isn't going to be cheap. If you want quality staff who want to stick around, it is EXPENSIVE. Really, bloody, expensive! And the public don't seem to "get" this.

miceonabranch · 01/11/2022 17:51

I think we also need some grown up and sensible conversations around assisted dying for those of us who don't wish our lives to continue if we're incapacitated and have lost all hope of independence. If you don't want it, don't believe in it, want god to decide for you, just want to continue existing in any state no matter how diminished your life may have become then fine, but some of us want a peaceful way out instead.

Burgoo · 01/11/2022 17:49

@JockTamsonsBairns "And we are totally devalued by the whole of society.
Why?"

Because you are willing to take all that BS and not complain about it. I worked out years ago that I am not a charity. If you want me to work in this field, you pay me decently. The problem is, as long as people do the job because it makes them "feel good" and because they feel they "need to" then things won't change.

The NHS is a prime example. It runs solely on good will of staff. If staff didn't do extra work out of hours etc the whole thing would crumple. I know people that do 3 hours of admin EVERY NIGHT because they haven't got time to do it in work time. They don't get paid for doing it, it is almost expected if you work in outpatients/community NHS. NHS managers know this. They rely on good will. The problem is, because good, hard-working nurses are willing to forego their own self-respect and personal time to do it, nothing gets solved. Whilst they work extra hours, doing the "right thing" by their patients, the government have absolutely no incentive to pay them more and increase resources. Why would they if they know nurses will do it anyway? They rely on guilt and collective shaming for not "going above and beyond" to get nurses to do things they aren't paid for.

Unfortunately, NHS and social care workers are their own worst enemy and I say this as someone who has been around decades in the area and see exactly why they do what they do. It's about time that they stand up and say "no, if you want this done you pay for it. I am not a charity!"

Burgoo · 01/11/2022 17:42

Throwing money at the problem isn't helpful if you just hire a bunch of people who aren't RIGHT for the job. That said, there is no respect for care staff nowadays. It's seen as a low-paid, "clean up people's shit" type of job and therefore why would anyone want to go into it?

A few things that need changing:

Salaries: If you want to attract people into the job you need to pay decent rates. I can make more working at Tesco than I do dealing with difficult, challenging individuals with complex needs. It must be seen as a profession and be rewarded as such.

A standardised vocational program for all care staff: We should equip carers to be professionalised, and this means a set standard that all social care staff must meet. This means a code of conduct, training and support to progress.

Stronger emphasis on informal carers: Why are we relying on state funded social care (or even privately funded) when we could fund people to look after their own family members? We already rely heavily on care givers of family/friends - support people to care for their family/friends by funding it adequately. If I have a sick relative, I can't work and look after them simultaneously. This needs to change.

Nationalisation: We shouldn't be throwing away billions a year to private providers. They skim off profits and give dividends to shareholders. Social and Health Care should NEVER be for profit because that's when corners are cut. Money spent on publicly owned services eventually get pumped back into the system through taxation of employees etc. It would also be FAR cheaper. Hence why privatised services get given back to the NHS when private companies can't compete (price vs service provided).

On a side note, there needs to be a REALLY heavy focus on the fact if we want a service, we MUST have an adult conversation about how it is paid for. Because this country is full of people who want a service but aren't willing to stump up the funds for it. We haven't got a bottomless pit of money, and it has to be paid for.

The other thing is we need to be MUCH more radical re: the culture in the UK of not taking care of ourselves. Much of the issues facing social care are at least in part related directly to people not taking good decisions re: their health. For example, obesity is a HUGE crisis, leading to diabetes, heart conditions etc. the fact is we have to take much more responsibility over our bodies and health if we are to stem this problem. Just throwing money at it isn't enough. We need to value the services we have, and that means not needlessly causing ourselves more physical ailments that will cost the system billions a year.

I am NOT talking about neurological conditions/disabilities or other problems that are beyond our control. I am talking about the fact we spend hundreds of billions on preventable conditions that need social care support. Diabetes, hypertension, alcohol or drug related conditions etc are all HUGE drains on the system. Have a stroke, you may need 24-hour care. We need to drive the message that a stroke is something which is at least in part preventable and that it is a responsibility of each one of us to avoid these things happening. That isn't to blame those who have strokes, though if you smoke 40 a day, have a few take aways a week, barely move from your sofa etc it is hardly surprising you have one.

I've worked in the sector for decades. NOBODY seems to want to face up to their own responsibility to society re: doing everything they can to avoid needing extra care and support services. If you want the righ to "free" health and social care, then you must also have a responsibility to avoid needing it unless necessary. This shouldn't be controversial, but people will scream about it.

LiveintheNow · 01/11/2022 17:36

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 12:49

what about the otherwise able 65 year old who needs to recover from a knee replacement or hip surgery?

They go home and carry on with their life. Hip and knee replacement are minor ops these days.

They probably have some time off work to recover and then go back... state pension age is now 67/68.

Weeboo · 01/11/2022 17:32

@Eastangular2000

You're talking about an ideal world where

Family members like in the same country/county
Family members love each other
Family members have the funds to be able to give up work to do this
Families have homes large enough to be able to do this
There are 2 parents in each "caring" family

In most scenarios I see around me in my life this wouldn't apply.

Family members live several hours away from each other.
A single mother with 3 young children working 2 jobs to afford rent would not be able to do this.
Most people I know are in small 2-3 bed homes without ground floor bathrooms.
Many people cannot afford to live on one income, so could not afford to have 1 adult acting as carer.

Also, have you ever cared long term for an elderly family member with dementia, incontinent, and who is completely immobile and sometimes violent, and needs a hoist to be moved?

I've seen a close family member of mine attempt to care for their elder in this situation. They attempted suicide as they couldn't cope, and we're completely broken as a person.

In reality it's very very very difficult to provide care for an elderly family member.

Thisisnotmyname2 · 01/11/2022 17:27

Vote labour

tomissmymum · 01/11/2022 17:26

XingMing · 01/11/2022 17:11

@tomissmymum that sounds dreadful for both you and your poor mum. Flowers

🌸 it was hell, I wouldn’t want a single soul to go through it . I worked as an HCA for a few years before and I remember seeing patients who you’d question why we were preserving life when often all that meant was preservation of brain stem functions, digestion, eyes open, respiration, but little evidence of any sort of higher level functioning . Never thought for one moment I’d be looking at my mum and having the same thoughts . It’s incredibly difficult .

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 17:23

So very sorry @tomissmymum. My experience with my mum was a walk in the park compared with that.

KatieB55 · 01/11/2022 17:22

Care homes shouldn't take huge profits & pay staff minimum wage.
There should be minimum qualifications & training and a career path and a good pay structure. So professional staff who care are employed and not anyone who might turn up for an interview.
Convalescent homes should be opened to take patients who do not need hospital treatment, staffed by physios, OTs and nurses.

JockTamsonsBairns · 01/11/2022 17:20

ancientgran · 31/10/2022 19:29

Have you done care rotas? The only reason I could get enough people to do nights and weekends was because they also got more sociable shifts. If there were enough candidates looking for care jobs and enough of them wanted nights/weekends it would be great but years of doing care rotas tell me it isn't going to work now. Well it wouldn't work where I am, maybe you have more candidates for jobs where you are. I was able to offer regular hours to a limited number of people e.g. students wanting to work weekends, experienced staff who wanted to reduce hours but funnily enough I never had anyone who permanently wanted to do nights, late shifts or 6 am starts. I'd have had a stampede if I'd been offering everyone permanent days Monday to Friday but wouldn't have actually provided round the clock care for our residents.

Better money for unsocial hours would be great, shame the LAs or NHS won't actually pay enough for that.

This!!

The more my company take on carers with a 9am-2.30pm availability, the more of the unsociable shifts I have to do - at no extra pay.
I'm leaving my house at 6am and not getting home till 11pm, for a real-time pay rate of around £5p/h.
This is why recruitment is non-existent. Who in their right mind would do this job? (Apart from me 😂).

Seriously, we deal with acute mental health issues, aggression, bereavement, death, dementia, medication, family dynamics, immobility, incontinence...
We work against the clock, trying to provide care in a tight timescale, battling traffic between calls, in all weather conditions. We need to be knowledgeable enough to spot what needs to be reported to the District Nurses, because if we miss something, it can be life threatening.
We need to deal with families - for eg, sons who want one thing, and daughters who want another.
We get reprimanded if we arrive at 1.15 for a scheduled lunch call at 1pm, due to traffic, or an emergency at a previous call.
We face intense pressure to work 15hr days, because of staff shortages.
We don't get rest breaks to use the toilet or have something to eat.

And we are totally devalued by the whole of society.
Why?

XingMing · 01/11/2022 17:11

@tomissmymum that sounds dreadful for both you and your poor mum. Flowers

tomissmymum · 01/11/2022 17:01

It is extremely hard caring for someone with dementia at home, DM was diagnosed in June in her mid 50s . She’s now in a specialist unit .

I cared for her at home for as long as possible but from January onwards she needed 24/7 supervision and assistance with all activities of daily living - showering, dressing, toileting, meals made etc .

We got a carer for 15 mins in the morning at 10, again at 12 for 20 mins, 10 mins at 2, 20 mins between 4 and 7, and 15 mins at 8 .

Mum would get up 5am, and didn’t sleep much at night, wandering, hallucinating, screaming out at night, left the house more than once . I couldn’t do a single thing as I couldn’t leave her . I couldn’t even get a shower or go to the bathroom with the door shut towards the end . I went three weeks without more than an hour of sleep at a time .

People don’t know unless they live it how hard it is . It’s very easy to try and get on with it behind closed doors - guilt, shame, fear, you think you should be able to deal with it, it’s your mum/dad but bloody hell . My family got involved at crisis point, they took over everything for me - but I never told them before . It gets normalised after a while .

With the best will in the world it becomes impossible . I was literally begging and begging for help . We had hours and hours of meetings - one that had around 20 people present - and dozens of different adult protection referrals . Even after I rang 999 threatening suicide there was still very little help in the immediate days after - I remember one night being told there was zero beds in the entire county - in the end I had to take Mum to hospital and walk away. As long as you’re there to pick up the pieces, my experience was social work didn’t care .

It can’t fall solely to relatives without very intensive support, because doing it like I did is hell on Earth . I’ve been left with PTSD - nightmares and flashbacks - which is also costing the NHS a fortune to help me manage - on top of the massive bill for all the care mum has had and is now receiving .

And yes, I’ve spent the last year looking at my darling mum and thinking, you wouldn’t let your dog suffer like this . I don’t want her to die but this has been at times a living hell for her .

But I don’t know if that’s really the answer either .

XingMing · 01/11/2022 16:59

Yes, I think there needs to be a conversation about how much or how active medical treatment should be for the very geriatric and infirm. One of the many lovely doctors treating her told us very early on that fewer than 50% of nonagenarians would see their next birthday after the fall MIL had.

However, where is the line between palliative only care and treating infections or cementing fractures?

Blossomtoes · 01/11/2022 16:59

They have to ask @NameChangeForARaisin. My mum was 96, six stone with osteoporosis and dementia, although I said even attempting CPR would be insane because it would kill her, the GP still had to ask her. We took her “I’m a very old lady and I’ve had a good life” as consent.

NameChangeForARaisin · 01/11/2022 16:49

XingMing · 01/11/2022 16:27

It's a huge, complex and costly conundrum. MIL with dementia is about to return to her care home, which costs her £4,200 per month, for end of life caring, probably in the next day or two, after a month in an acute bed in hospital. Two thirds of the patients are DNR, and most have dementia; they mostly don't know where they are or why.

She was a fervent advocate for assisted dying, but now lacks agency to declare it. If she were my dog or cat or horse, the vet would been called to end the suffering several weeks ago.

I'm sorry to hear this, we have just been through a similar situation with my mum (but exacerbation of chronic illness through covid rather than dementia). She was late 80s.

I couldn't believe it when I asked her doctor to have a conversation about DNACPR with her. He literally said "if you have a further heart attack and your heart stops, would you like us to restart it" for you.
I mean, good grief, as if! CPR would be very very unlikely to work for her and she had close to zero quality of life to start with.
But yes, hero doctor, you go ahead and perform the barbarism that is CPR on a frail elderly person, so she dies in agony or survives requiring maximum care at a cost to all of us.

It's do difficult but I honestly think there needs to be a cut of age fir treatment

XingMing · 01/11/2022 16:47

Thanks @Dinoteeth, I am very fond of her, but it really can't come quickly enough. Her heart is failing, her lungs are filling with fluid and she will be bedbound from here on. But she will be better in a quieter place.

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 16:33

@XingMing I hope the end for her is soon 💐

XingMing · 01/11/2022 16:27

It's a huge, complex and costly conundrum. MIL with dementia is about to return to her care home, which costs her £4,200 per month, for end of life caring, probably in the next day or two, after a month in an acute bed in hospital. Two thirds of the patients are DNR, and most have dementia; they mostly don't know where they are or why.

She was a fervent advocate for assisted dying, but now lacks agency to declare it. If she were my dog or cat or horse, the vet would been called to end the suffering several weeks ago.