Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we solve the social care crisis ?

334 replies

Worriedddd · 31/10/2022 13:33

We have complex needs patients being stuck in hospital for up to 2 years. Some even more they are ready to leave just there's no social care placements and they can't get the right staff anyway. For minimum wage carers will have support people with very challenging needs. There is high risk of assault in many care settings employers don't offer the right training like de-escalation and breakway. . You could get more money working for Lidl and aldi. Even with immigration people leave and find another job. What's the solution to this ?

OP posts:
ancientgran · 03/11/2022 12:13

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 11:19

I had this argument when my Nana was ailing.

She had dementia. She was at the point where she had to be fed as she couldn’t remember how to lift a spoon. She was doubly incontinent. She’d forgotten how to form sentences, and on they very rare occasions she could she’d be frantically trying to find her parents.

She kept getting regular chest infections and every single time the Dr was called, he’d prescribe antibiotics and the care staff would have a fight every single day trying to get them into her. Inevitably she’d end up in hospital, on drips that she pulled out every day.

She ended up in hospital having hip surgery as she fell. Whilst in there she had another stroke and then got an infection. I was treated with massive suspicion by the hospital staff after my reply of “chance at what?” when they said we should try a different antibiotic to “give her the best chance”. You’d have thought I’d suggested murdering a heathy, happy woman rather than just not aggressively treating someone who had zero quality of life (in fact if we’d kept an animal in those conditions we’d have been in trouble)

Who agreed to the surgery and antibiotics? I have LPA for an elderly relative and I had to agree to the surgery and the surgeon was very realistic about the fors and againsts, I'm consulted on all med changes. I've agreed things like a DNR, vaccinations only if she isn't distressed. Maybe you need to talk to whoever is agreeing to these things?

There is a middle ground between aggressively trying everything possible and PTS like an ailing animal.

ancientgran · 03/11/2022 12:07

Winter2020 · 02/11/2022 22:40

Re care home rotas:
If weekday mornings/days are the popular shifts then of course don't advertise those shifts specifically. Advertise evening jobs and weekend ones if they are generally unpopular - it's not rocket science.

As for who would work nights? I work nights and only nights. Seven years in working nights in short break service for people with learning disabilities. I couldn't do a 24/7 rolling rota due to childcare needs shared with my husband and his work. My husband is home overnight and my shifts largely dovetail with his anyway so he is usually home for the kids when I sleep. In the past I have used breakfast and after school provision when needed to extend my chance to sleep during the school day.

Expecting 24/7 availability isn't working out for the sector so why not try something new? Who would want to be available any day, any time for probably the lowest paid sector of all? If retail can offer a Saturday job so can care.

Re immigrants being pretty much forced to work in care: When most other sectors have staff shortages they increase wages or offer golden hellos/bonuses etc e.g. supermarkets/haulage firms. Staff shortage in care = force someone to do it or ship in people from overseas.

How about offer a decent wage and decent terms and conditions (such as regular hours) that allow someone to have a decent quality of life. Radical idea that.

You are in a minority if you want to work nights. I know that from years of doing recruitment. The people who do it will normally do it for a limited time while childcare is an issue but very few want it on a long term basis. The same with weekend shifts, for a limited time for certain situations e.g the students I employed, but a constant turnover.

It doesn't work anyway, local care agency are currently advertising flexible shifts, fixed shifts, part time, full time and they can't get staff. If it works where you are that's great, I can assure you it is counter productive where I worked.

Many homes are closing, the struggle with costs is acute but LAs and NHS aren't increasing fees in line with inflation so increasing pay is impossible unless the fees increase.

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 11:19

Skidaramink · 03/11/2022 09:05

I agree with this. We shouldn’t be trying to prolong people’s lives as long as possible when they can no longer look after themselves and have little quality of life.

I had this argument when my Nana was ailing.

She had dementia. She was at the point where she had to be fed as she couldn’t remember how to lift a spoon. She was doubly incontinent. She’d forgotten how to form sentences, and on they very rare occasions she could she’d be frantically trying to find her parents.

She kept getting regular chest infections and every single time the Dr was called, he’d prescribe antibiotics and the care staff would have a fight every single day trying to get them into her. Inevitably she’d end up in hospital, on drips that she pulled out every day.

She ended up in hospital having hip surgery as she fell. Whilst in there she had another stroke and then got an infection. I was treated with massive suspicion by the hospital staff after my reply of “chance at what?” when they said we should try a different antibiotic to “give her the best chance”. You’d have thought I’d suggested murdering a heathy, happy woman rather than just not aggressively treating someone who had zero quality of life (in fact if we’d kept an animal in those conditions we’d have been in trouble)

Skidaramink · 03/11/2022 09:05

RedAppleGirl · 31/10/2022 13:38

Modern medicine is to blame for this, the ethics of keeping people alive is a desperately needed public discussion. I don't believe it's tenable anymore.

I agree with this. We shouldn’t be trying to prolong people’s lives as long as possible when they can no longer look after themselves and have little quality of life.

pumpkinscoop · 03/11/2022 08:57

The rolling shifts availability requirements are ridiculous and doesn't just apply to the care sector - there are plenty of customer service/call handler/retail jobs that want people available across varying shifts 8-8, 7 days a week. There are probably plenty of people willing to work only evenings and weekends to reduce childcare requirements but can't work week days, and others who could work evenings, and still more who could do 2 or 3 long days during the week.

The employers offer no flexibility, then wonder why they can't get staff.

Greeneyedminx · 03/11/2022 08:50

I think people fail to realise that 35% of people needing social care are in the 18 - 64 year bracket, so they will need care for many, many more years than people over the age of 65.
Do people recommend euthanasia for this group as well as the older group ? Thought not !!
This is such a complex situation that will never be resolved unless we are collectively working together to find a solution for this crisis, which is worsening day by day.
Until it affects you personally, you don’t think about it, but it is affecting everyone by default. No beds available for operations, no beds available for respite care - for any age, no staff, families at the end of their tether - unable to cope physically, emotionally and financially with caring for someone.
I don’t profess to know the answers, but we really do need to find a workable solution, but we all know no one wants to pay for it, by an increase in their taxation.
People with learning disabilities in the younger age groups do not have properties to sell to fund their care, many older people also do not have properties to sell to fund their care either.
Even if people do sell their properties, what happens when that money runs out?
Where I live, there are not millionaires in opulent houses, this is a very working class area, where the majority of people struggle with the cost of living. Where will they get their money from to fund their care?
This is such a nightmare for everyone concerned and must be so worrying for people who desperately need care and support.

WhatNoRaisins · 03/11/2022 08:19

Is the idea of advertising evening only or night only shifts really that bad. I'd have thought there would be loads of parents wanting to tag team their work hours to save on childcare, like one parent having an early morning job and doing school pick up so the other one would be looking for evenings.

Topgub · 03/11/2022 07:40

@Dinoteeth

So how should it be paid for?

lemmein · 03/11/2022 04:06

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 00:43

Sorry I thought you were talking about the NI increase to pay for care homes.

I don't agree with people's assets being taken into account when if comes to care. People should receive care as necessary.
Some people will blow their cash and enjoy it others scrimp and save to leave their kids something. Why should the savers loose out?

But you could argue why should the next generation pay inflated taxes to provide care for the elderly who have assets, when that same generation has been lumbered with student loans and little chance of ever owning their own homes. It's grossly unfair.

Somebody has to pay for it.

I agreed with the dementia tax.

Ramblingnamechanger · 03/11/2022 00:56

Reverse Brexit, recruit workers at an enhanced rate of pay and provide fantastic training and support. Maybe nationalise care / nursing homes , provide convalescence . Value the work more.

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 00:43

Sorry I thought you were talking about the NI increase to pay for care homes.

I don't agree with people's assets being taken into account when if comes to care. People should receive care as necessary.
Some people will blow their cash and enjoy it others scrimp and save to leave their kids something. Why should the savers loose out?

Blossomtoes · 03/11/2022 00:28

Dinoteeth · 02/11/2022 23:24

The argument against the dementia tax was it was slapped on NI rather than on IT, which meant only working age people paid it. Those with hefty pension incomes wouldn't be paying it.

That wasn’t the argument at all. Dementia tax proposed taking into account the value of a house when assessing whether people should pay for their own care at home in the same way as residential care. It would have actually saved taxpayers money but those with valuable houses but little in other assets would have had to pay themselves. It was abandoned because opposition came from traditional Tory voters.

Dinoteeth · 02/11/2022 23:24

Q2C4 · 02/11/2022 01:48

You might be happy to pay higher taxes and there is certainly a case for that. However, as Theresa May found to her cost when proposing the "dementia tax", many are not.

The argument against the dementia tax was it was slapped on NI rather than on IT, which meant only working age people paid it. Those with hefty pension incomes wouldn't be paying it.

Winter2020 · 02/11/2022 22:40

Re care home rotas:
If weekday mornings/days are the popular shifts then of course don't advertise those shifts specifically. Advertise evening jobs and weekend ones if they are generally unpopular - it's not rocket science.

As for who would work nights? I work nights and only nights. Seven years in working nights in short break service for people with learning disabilities. I couldn't do a 24/7 rolling rota due to childcare needs shared with my husband and his work. My husband is home overnight and my shifts largely dovetail with his anyway so he is usually home for the kids when I sleep. In the past I have used breakfast and after school provision when needed to extend my chance to sleep during the school day.

Expecting 24/7 availability isn't working out for the sector so why not try something new? Who would want to be available any day, any time for probably the lowest paid sector of all? If retail can offer a Saturday job so can care.

Re immigrants being pretty much forced to work in care: When most other sectors have staff shortages they increase wages or offer golden hellos/bonuses etc e.g. supermarkets/haulage firms. Staff shortage in care = force someone to do it or ship in people from overseas.

How about offer a decent wage and decent terms and conditions (such as regular hours) that allow someone to have a decent quality of life. Radical idea that.

Q2C4 · 02/11/2022 01:48

Dontsayitsuseless · 01/11/2022 12:31

@Q2C4

"Who would pay for the additional costs though? The patients, then the state when the patients' money ran out. So taxes would go up."

OMG ! Taxes would go up !!!! Oh dear !!!

Bring it on!!! You want a decent public services then you have to pay for it through a fair, redistributive tax system!

You might be happy to pay higher taxes and there is certainly a case for that. However, as Theresa May found to her cost when proposing the "dementia tax", many are not.

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 23:05

I know what you mean, all elderly caring seems to start with the occasional small job, like changing a light bulb and some will never need much more than that, others will need everything done for them and loose all dignity in the process.

JubileeTrifle · 01/11/2022 22:27

I suspect soon she will be in that middle ground of just needing more general help than personal care soon. Which most families would pick up (and we have previously but we won’t now, long story). But one bad illness or injury will change that I’m sure.

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 22:02

@ancientgran there is a long way between someone like the neighbour living independently and someone bedbound in the later stages of dementia. Where the right point is to end it i dont know but probably bedbound with no clue what, where or who you are is definitely beyond the point of quality life.

ancientgran · 01/11/2022 21:33

JubileeTrifle · 01/11/2022 20:48

We had a family member who fought for 18 months to keep her unwell elderly father alive. He bounced in and out of hospital every few weeks.
He was awake for only a few hours a day. Person would shout at doctors and nurses about his care and what improvements could be made. They would then ring us to complain about how no one was helping him get better.
He was then sent to a different hospital and
one doctor sat her down and told her that her dad was dying, he would not improve 1% from where he was at now and in fact would get worse for every day he was alive. That he was basically exhausted and she needed to give up.
She agreed and he actually passed away a few days later. I don’t think anyone had been honest in that 18 months with her. I can’t imagine what it all cost.
There’s too much belief in people getting fixed when really, it shouldn’t happen.

When MIL died in the end it was because she wouldn’t take medication properly. The doctor told DH they shouldn’t do anything to help her as she wasn’t even helping herself. It was the right thing to do. If DH had disagreed then it could have gone on and on though.

We have an elderly neighbour (she’s horrible) who will need help soon. Her son won’t ever help her, he won’t want her in a home as he wants her house money. God knows what will happen when she becomes unwell. i half suspect he’s going to look to me to do it (I won’t).

Your neighbour's son is one of the main reasons allowing family to end a vulnerable person's life is dangerous.

ancientgran · 01/11/2022 21:30

Askinforabaskin · 01/11/2022 21:26

A doctor friend of mine said that doctors need to be more like vets when it comes to appropriate treatment and the resulting quality of life.

A friend was in hospital when covid was rife. In the next bed a retired doctor, in his 80s I think. He was demanding he was moved too ICU, he wanted a ventilator. Friend heard Consultant talking to him, telling him it wasn't appropriate and it was time to speak to family and say his goodbyes, sick doctor not having it. Consultant said it is what you would have advised. Sick doctor agreed but said his feelings had changed now he was the one who was dying.

Askinforabaskin · 01/11/2022 21:26

A doctor friend of mine said that doctors need to be more like vets when it comes to appropriate treatment and the resulting quality of life.

XingMing · 01/11/2022 21:21

But not everyone who gets old. frail and ill has abused their body. MIL is a trained nurse and knows how sensible eating looks. But at 93, all she can taste is sugar. The other taste bud receptors have failed and bailed.

JubileeTrifle · 01/11/2022 20:48

We had a family member who fought for 18 months to keep her unwell elderly father alive. He bounced in and out of hospital every few weeks.
He was awake for only a few hours a day. Person would shout at doctors and nurses about his care and what improvements could be made. They would then ring us to complain about how no one was helping him get better.
He was then sent to a different hospital and
one doctor sat her down and told her that her dad was dying, he would not improve 1% from where he was at now and in fact would get worse for every day he was alive. That he was basically exhausted and she needed to give up.
She agreed and he actually passed away a few days later. I don’t think anyone had been honest in that 18 months with her. I can’t imagine what it all cost.
There’s too much belief in people getting fixed when really, it shouldn’t happen.

When MIL died in the end it was because she wouldn’t take medication properly. The doctor told DH they shouldn’t do anything to help her as she wasn’t even helping herself. It was the right thing to do. If DH had disagreed then it could have gone on and on though.

We have an elderly neighbour (she’s horrible) who will need help soon. Her son won’t ever help her, he won’t want her in a home as he wants her house money. God knows what will happen when she becomes unwell. i half suspect he’s going to look to me to do it (I won’t).

Worriedddd · 01/11/2022 20:40

JockTamsonsBairns · 01/11/2022 20:21

@reigatecastle

And given we have thousands of illegal immigrants, maybe some of them can work in our care sector (on a paid basis, I don't mean for free, I mean on the same (improved) wage that anyone would get), even if it's only on a temporary basis until they are qualified to do something else

I rest my case. This is my point entirely. Society thinks that "illegal immigrants", supposedly young Albanian men with little grasp of the language, and zero experience in care, can step up to the job and be good enough.

What an utterly ridiculous suggestion. What gives you the right to devalue my job like this? I've worked hard to build up my skills, and I've gained 26 years' worth of experience in being able to deliver the quality of care that vulnerable people deserve.
Absolutely disgusted by your post.

This also the ratios in care homes tends to be much more female than male. We don't young men with no employment history being forced to care for our most vulnerable. It's disgusting and abuse waiting to happen.

OP posts:
JockTamsonsBairns · 01/11/2022 20:21

@reigatecastle

And given we have thousands of illegal immigrants, maybe some of them can work in our care sector (on a paid basis, I don't mean for free, I mean on the same (improved) wage that anyone would get), even if it's only on a temporary basis until they are qualified to do something else

I rest my case. This is my point entirely. Society thinks that "illegal immigrants", supposedly young Albanian men with little grasp of the language, and zero experience in care, can step up to the job and be good enough.

What an utterly ridiculous suggestion. What gives you the right to devalue my job like this? I've worked hard to build up my skills, and I've gained 26 years' worth of experience in being able to deliver the quality of care that vulnerable people deserve.
Absolutely disgusted by your post.