Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we solve the social care crisis ?

334 replies

Worriedddd · 31/10/2022 13:33

We have complex needs patients being stuck in hospital for up to 2 years. Some even more they are ready to leave just there's no social care placements and they can't get the right staff anyway. For minimum wage carers will have support people with very challenging needs. There is high risk of assault in many care settings employers don't offer the right training like de-escalation and breakway. . You could get more money working for Lidl and aldi. Even with immigration people leave and find another job. What's the solution to this ?

OP posts:
Acheyknees · 31/10/2022 14:51

I agree with the poster who said we need to take more responsibility for our health and housing in old age. Just because an elderly person doesn't want to leave his unsuitable home shouldn't mean we provide multiple carer visits per day and ambulance call outs for preventable falls.
A relative is in the fire service providing and installing free fire alarms. He comes home in despair at the state some elderly people live in. Living in a single room of a massive home in the middle of nowhere with a single bar electric fire. On the other hand he visits new purpose homes for the elderly with a warden, alarms in the flooring that can detect someone has fallen and wide open corridors with chargers for mobility scooters. All this costs money of course.

oakleaffy · 31/10/2022 14:49

RedAppleGirl · 31/10/2022 13:38

Modern medicine is to blame for this, the ethics of keeping people alive is a desperately needed public discussion. I don't believe it's tenable anymore.

Agreed.
Our family have said if any of us dement or no longer have quality if life, DNR for sure.

PeachPies · 31/10/2022 14:49

Notlivinglife · 31/10/2022 14:47

@PeachPies bit of an unfair comment to make about Carers being uneducated.
Not true at all. I worked as a Carer for many years in a Healthcare setting and was considering a career in Nusing but I was a mature lady, life was so busy at the time and I was worried about the workload. Many of my ex colleagues qualified as Nurses.

Due to the low pay and no entry requirements it does end up a large portion being uneducated.

That’s why it need to be better paid and an actual career. Not just something those who can’t get any other job do. It’s not fair on those that require care.

Tbh the amount leaving due to the covid vaccine requirement doesn’t disprove my point around education either.

PeachPies · 31/10/2022 14:47

Eastangular2000 · 31/10/2022 14:46

I actually think that we should all have a responsibility to care for our own families before the state steps in. Too often people think that 'the state' should provide all the care required for society whereas I believe we have an obligation to care for our own first and foremost with the state being there as a back up rather than the first choice. This goes for both elderly and young people requiring care. If your parent needs care for a few weeks on leaving hospital then the expectation should be that family make arrangements to do so, in the same way that we care for children we should care for our older relatives. Of course this will never happen as people already have a massive sense of entitlement when it comes to childcare so they certainly aren't going to sacrifice anything to support family.

But how would that work? What financial support would be available for those who’d need to leave work to care for an elderly relative:

plus what about all those elderly people who have alienated their families

Notlivinglife · 31/10/2022 14:47

@PeachPies bit of an unfair comment to make about Carers being uneducated.
Not true at all. I worked as a Carer for many years in a Healthcare setting and was considering a career in Nusing but I was a mature lady, life was so busy at the time and I was worried about the workload. Many of my ex colleagues qualified as Nurses.

DirtyBlonde · 31/10/2022 14:46

Convalescent homes aren't the same as care homes.

They are for those who need some level of care/surveillance for what is expected to be a short time of further recuperation before returning home. So it gets people out of acute beds after a couple of days, and provides a longer stay with some level of nursing - typically for a couple of weeks - then the patient returns home, well and fit enough for independent living or with needs that fall within their existing care package.

Yes, care homes can provide the same service, but at a cost of reducing beds for those with long-term needs or those who need respite care for other reasons

Eastangular2000 · 31/10/2022 14:46

I actually think that we should all have a responsibility to care for our own families before the state steps in. Too often people think that 'the state' should provide all the care required for society whereas I believe we have an obligation to care for our own first and foremost with the state being there as a back up rather than the first choice. This goes for both elderly and young people requiring care. If your parent needs care for a few weeks on leaving hospital then the expectation should be that family make arrangements to do so, in the same way that we care for children we should care for our older relatives. Of course this will never happen as people already have a massive sense of entitlement when it comes to childcare so they certainly aren't going to sacrifice anything to support family.

PeachPies · 31/10/2022 14:37

funnymummmy · 31/10/2022 14:34

Why would they give a shit for a job that pays minimum wage?

Never said they should give a shit

merely countering the view that ‘good’ care staff left

If they were anti vaxx they’re not ‘good’ care staff

Bluekerfuffle · 31/10/2022 14:36

You’ve more or less said it yourself. Obviously more pay.

funnymummmy · 31/10/2022 14:34

PeachPies · 31/10/2022 13:39

then they weren’t good care staff

if they don’t give a shit about those they care for they should never be in that role

Why would they give a shit for a job that pays minimum wage?

Toddlerteaplease · 31/10/2022 14:32

I also like the idea of a national social care service as well.

JustStopOilyPoshKids · 31/10/2022 14:32

We also need to understand the breadth of what social care entails. It is not just old, sick people in need of care. Plenty of young, healthy people too.

£££ and training urgently needed. A massive change in societal attitudes too. Flip the narrative. We all belong. Maybe if we had respect for people whatever their level of ability/need it wouldn't attract the bullies and people desperate for any job.

More day centre/ activity / drop in provision.

Better support for family carers. If Carers Allowance worked more like a wage/ income would that mean more people across a family could reduce working hours and provide care rather than it typically falling on one female family member who does it all

DamnUserName21 · 31/10/2022 14:32

BeyondMyWits · 31/10/2022 13:39

We need a "next stage" plan for after hospital for those with care needs.

Old fashioned convalescent homes. It is then taking the pressure off hospital beds, with convalescent care, physiotherapy, etc helping re-enable people to move home with a care plan in place, or to a care home if needed.

They have this already. It's called care homes. Patient will be sent to a care home on a short-term rehab placement where they may have input from physio and/or other services. Some end up staying in the care home, some will go home, some will go on to another care home for a longer term placement depending on their needs.
A lot of care homes aren't able to meet capacity for this due to staffing and funding. Also, a lot of these patients are very high needs-need feeding, personal care, may or may not be bedbound, may need 2-4 carers to assist, may need wound care, oxygen, etc..

Toddlerteaplease · 31/10/2022 14:32

BeyondMyWits · 31/10/2022 13:39

We need a "next stage" plan for after hospital for those with care needs.

Old fashioned convalescent homes. It is then taking the pressure off hospital beds, with convalescent care, physiotherapy, etc helping re-enable people to move home with a care plan in place, or to a care home if needed.

This.

EducationDilemma · 31/10/2022 14:32

XmasElf10 · 31/10/2022 13:58

Its really tough because anything that needs investment requires money to be found. The money has to come from somewhere (and saying "make shit more efficient" rarely works). It can come from teachers, roads, police, fire, defense, charity support to other nations, benefits, higher taxes... but it can't come from thin air.

So what we need is more and better social care provision for patients with complex physical / mental care needs. Better pathways to the support, more supported living places, quicker transfers out of hospital, more joined up provision etc.. I agree that a career pathway in caring, an NHS style pay scale, the building of more dedicated care homes with equipment and staffing suitable for complex cases etc.. Personally I'd take the money out of defense and I'd increase taxes but there are plenty of arguments for why those 2 options are also bad for growth, investment, national security etc..

However I don't think you can make an argument about what the government SHOULD do without facing the consequences of how they should pay for it (And it's billions not thousands).

I would completely be in favour of much higher tax on all income if it covered all education including undergraduate uni, police, fire, a comprehensive health and social care system, cleaning and refurbishing town centres and public buildings, roads, drainage infrastructure, other major public services, and a universal basic income of about £400 a month over which we all work to earn money.

As it stands they don’t have enough money to meet people’s needs and the private sector can’t do it in a unified way on the scale we need.

oviraptor21 · 31/10/2022 14:23

Cost of care at home, unless live-in care for one person, is less than the cost of a place in a care home.
We should therefore be doing more to support this model where appropriate. Increase carers allowance and remove the maximum income requirement from it. Allow it to be split between more than one carer.
Incentivise elderly to move from inappropriate homes to safe and more compact environments, especially sheltered accommodation.
Increase the use of DNRs when people lose capability. More publicity around setting this up in the same way that a power of attorney is set up - should be explicitly included on the health and care PoA.

orbitalcrisis · 31/10/2022 14:23

Council run care homes and carers would be a good start!

Blossomtoes · 31/10/2022 14:23

mamabear715 · 31/10/2022 13:57

Well, it's always been the same, hasn't it?
A sum of money to set more care homes up for those 'bed-blocking' & pay staff sufficient wages, would be much cheaper in the long term than allowing bed blocking to continue. But that's too simple for those who make the decisions, to consider..

No, we used to have step down/rehab beds so people could have a lower level of care to get them ready to go home when they no longer had a clinical need fr a hospital bed. It worked really well. Obviously the NHS management in its infinite wisdom closed them all, despite a huge generation of ageing people coming down the road.

LaCerbiatta · 31/10/2022 14:19

Social care should not be provided privately, there should not be a middle man making money out of people's taxes or people's private payments for those who can afford it. Social carers should be employees of the state, NHS or something similar, with career progression, proper training, decent pensions, etc.

thebellagio · 31/10/2022 14:18

Fairyliz · 31/10/2022 14:14

People need to take more personal responsibility. So look after their own health better, they might still need care but for a shorter period of life.
They also need to plan for old age, so downsize when they are still young enough to move and sort everything out.

There does seem to be a weird mentality that people are independent their whole lives, but as soon as they get to elderly age "why should I pay for myself, the state should pay for me and my care"

But a big problem is because the NHS is so bloody good at keeping people alive and living longer, so this is always going to be a crisis that was going to hit at some point.

Fairyliz · 31/10/2022 14:14

People need to take more personal responsibility. So look after their own health better, they might still need care but for a shorter period of life.
They also need to plan for old age, so downsize when they are still young enough to move and sort everything out.

DirtyBlonde · 31/10/2022 14:14

Oh, and we could also do with some new players in the warden-assisted retirement complex sector.

At present, there are one or two big names, lots of non-obvious charges and onerous T&Cs.

If they were a more attractive option, I think more people might downsize in a timely fashion.

And yy to more bungalows (where land prices not too high) or maisonettes (elderly in the ground floor, anyone in the upper one)

Topgub · 31/10/2022 14:11

Lots of people moan about the current situation

These people also (ime) avoid tax and care home fees wherever possible

EndlessMagpies · 31/10/2022 14:11

We all know what the solution is. Better pay, conditions and training for staff, and a greater level of funding from central government. We also need to start valuing the contribution to society that people working in this industry deserve.

But that isn't going to happen any time soon, is it?

Badger1970 · 31/10/2022 14:10

I worked in care to get experience before going onto a nursing degree.

I left the job after 2 years and didn't ever enroll because it was exhausting, thankless and most other colleagues (thankfully not all) should never have been in the job. They did it because it was all that they could get, and had an air of "well they won't sack me as we're short staffed" attitude that made them untouchable no matter how shoddy their work was.

I also agree with the PP who said about medicine keeping people artificially alive with no actual quality of life. We seriously need to address this as a society.

Swipe left for the next trending thread