Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we solve the social care crisis ?

334 replies

Worriedddd · 31/10/2022 13:33

We have complex needs patients being stuck in hospital for up to 2 years. Some even more they are ready to leave just there's no social care placements and they can't get the right staff anyway. For minimum wage carers will have support people with very challenging needs. There is high risk of assault in many care settings employers don't offer the right training like de-escalation and breakway. . You could get more money working for Lidl and aldi. Even with immigration people leave and find another job. What's the solution to this ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Goldbar · 04/11/2022 17:06

WhatNoRaisins · 04/11/2022 13:20

I don't know how wishing back a different era or romanticising different cultures really helps here. Families don't have live near each other and both men and women have jobs. We can't just recreate some idealised version of the 1950s.

And yes by family it's almost always women doing the work.

Absolutely. Lockdown proved that society hasn't changed in this regard. When education, childcare and other services were cut back, it was women who bore the brunt of it.

If you put the responsibility back on families, you're essentially putting it back on women and, in extreme cases, driving them out of the workforce. Replacing their paid work with unpaid work, undermining their autonomy and independence and making them more vulnerable.

Dinoteeth · 04/11/2022 15:52

@cantba not everybody has family.

Those who do have families how do you know they are in a postition to help? Families are stretched keeping their own heads above water, young children to care for, debts to pay off, distance to travel, more and more only children or just two children.

We need a decent system, not be relying of family, which may or may not exist or be able to pitch in

WhatNoRaisins · 04/11/2022 13:20

I don't know how wishing back a different era or romanticising different cultures really helps here. Families don't have live near each other and both men and women have jobs. We can't just recreate some idealised version of the 1950s.

And yes by family it's almost always women doing the work.

JubileeTrifle · 04/11/2022 12:00

cantba · 04/11/2022 10:33

Social change. Families should take a greater responsibility in looking after their elders.

I hate the distinction between medical needs and social needs. Frankly if you support the idea of the nhs in full you should support care as needed being given. This isnt about an old lady getting company to go to the supermarket (family job really) but if you are demented and incontinent the fact you are sat in your own piss is really medical and should be treated as such.

The problem with care is that it has all been privatised. My mother had carers through an agency (whilst living at home as her needs went beyond social needs) - they got minimum wage whilst the agency chargdd them out to us at £30 an hour. Barely trained, i found my mum stripped completely naked with no dignity or cover whatsoever for a wash on her bed once. She had a full service wetroom and plenty of robes etc. There is plenty of money for care - its all just dripping into private hands.

We need more local authority care homes and they need to be staffed by people who are educated properly and paid properly. It should not be a profit industry.

The problem is when you say this is you mean women. That’s who is ends up falling onto.
Also the reality is DH moved 300 miles away from home to work. He helped his mother enormously when she was unwell but he had work and tiny children. His brother did almost nothing despite living 10 minutes away.

in the past people didn’t live as long, didn’t have the medical interventions keeping them alive so long, and women didn’t work and probably they all lived closer. Society has changed too much.

Blossomtoes · 04/11/2022 11:53

Where’s the money coming from?

cantba · 04/11/2022 10:33

Social change. Families should take a greater responsibility in looking after their elders.

I hate the distinction between medical needs and social needs. Frankly if you support the idea of the nhs in full you should support care as needed being given. This isnt about an old lady getting company to go to the supermarket (family job really) but if you are demented and incontinent the fact you are sat in your own piss is really medical and should be treated as such.

The problem with care is that it has all been privatised. My mother had carers through an agency (whilst living at home as her needs went beyond social needs) - they got minimum wage whilst the agency chargdd them out to us at £30 an hour. Barely trained, i found my mum stripped completely naked with no dignity or cover whatsoever for a wash on her bed once. She had a full service wetroom and plenty of robes etc. There is plenty of money for care - its all just dripping into private hands.

We need more local authority care homes and they need to be staffed by people who are educated properly and paid properly. It should not be a profit industry.

Maverickess · 03/11/2022 22:42

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 22:05

I do love “I’m not… but” phrases. Highly amusing as 99.9% the person goes on to do exactly what they said they would,

It’s what happens, in this case, when you live in a very small place and people are interlinked. So if the local GP is married to one of the care home managers, for example, they get more involved than they should.

it’s what happens when one person convinces themselves, and everyone around, that they know the patient better than anyone else.

In my opinion it was all to do with money. The inspection put it down to over-enthusiasm. Basically slated them, but it had an air of “they cared too much” which is bollocks.

IME care homes don't get involved in treatment because it's not deemed appropriate (as shown by the CQC not being happy about what happened to your relative) in fact I've had trouble getting relevant information, that we needed to care for someone properly, out of hospitals before regarding the person's condition or treatment, or planning for them returning or ongoing treatment etc because we're not NOK and have no legal rights really to that information or so I've been told (even though obviously it's needed in order to actually care for someone effectively) it's where involved relatives are a Godsend because they tell you what you need to know.
And I've also experienced being utterly dismissed by medical staff when I have relevant information that could help with treatment or wishes etc, so I am surprised that what the care home had to say was given any time or attention.

That this was allowed to happen was a failing on more than just the GP and care home manager, but of the hospital too imo, because as you pointed out, there's a financial interest that can't be denied at play (and I have no way of knowing) but I'd hazard a guess your relative was self funded - they usually pay more than state funded. It is unusual though.

I actually added the "I'm not doubting you" bit because I typed the rest and realised it sounded exactly like that was what I was doing, and in reality I wasn't, so no need for the snippy response really.

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 22:05

Maverickess · 03/11/2022 21:48

I'm not doubting you, but I'm a bit confused by the care home involvement here, they can't normally get involved too much, even with people who don't have family, I've worked in some not great places and yes, we've pushed for hospital admission for someone, but on the basis that they've developed needs that we cannot meet (they have nursing needs in a residential home where no nurse is present and community nursing isn't enough), and therefore it's not appropriate or safe for them to remain in our care, and it's urgently needed and unfortunately social services take so long to sort out anything like this the hospital's pick up the slack or people are at risk, and it's often ignored tbh, so I'm really surprised that the care home even had their opinions listened to regarding treatment options, because normally past 'Can you meet their needs' care homes have no say in what treatment someone has, they can advise families I guess, but other than that I didn't think they'd be given the opportunity to put their wants forward.

I do love “I’m not… but” phrases. Highly amusing as 99.9% the person goes on to do exactly what they said they would,

It’s what happens, in this case, when you live in a very small place and people are interlinked. So if the local GP is married to one of the care home managers, for example, they get more involved than they should.

it’s what happens when one person convinces themselves, and everyone around, that they know the patient better than anyone else.

In my opinion it was all to do with money. The inspection put it down to over-enthusiasm. Basically slated them, but it had an air of “they cared too much” which is bollocks.

Maverickess · 03/11/2022 21:48

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 20:22

In this case the complaint was upheld against them over it all. They pushed it constantly and they were later slated in their next inspection over their obsession with preservation at all costs.

I'm not doubting you, but I'm a bit confused by the care home involvement here, they can't normally get involved too much, even with people who don't have family, I've worked in some not great places and yes, we've pushed for hospital admission for someone, but on the basis that they've developed needs that we cannot meet (they have nursing needs in a residential home where no nurse is present and community nursing isn't enough), and therefore it's not appropriate or safe for them to remain in our care, and it's urgently needed and unfortunately social services take so long to sort out anything like this the hospital's pick up the slack or people are at risk, and it's often ignored tbh, so I'm really surprised that the care home even had their opinions listened to regarding treatment options, because normally past 'Can you meet their needs' care homes have no say in what treatment someone has, they can advise families I guess, but other than that I didn't think they'd be given the opportunity to put their wants forward.

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 20:22

DamnUserName21 · 03/11/2022 20:15

Hmmm, it's usually the family that push for ongoing treatment, not the GP/care home. I wonder what the care home/GP's side of the story is.

Anyway, there's a RESPECT form that GP's can put into place that can help address these kind of issues.

www.resus.org.uk/respect/respect-healthcare-professionals

In this case the complaint was upheld against them over it all. They pushed it constantly and they were later slated in their next inspection over their obsession with preservation at all costs.

DamnUserName21 · 03/11/2022 20:15

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 20:02

She didn’t have capacity. She thought she was covered by a DNR and LPOA. The care home and GP wouldn’t enter into discussion with the family. Even the ambulance service and hospital tried to intervene with the constant trips. If they hadn’t ended up keeping her in at one point and having tbt conversation I’m fairly sure the home and GP would still be coercing and manhandling her into taking antibiotics.

im well aware of why the hospital staff would err on the side of caution. My point was merely that that was one of the many things that superseded actually thinking of what was best for her.

Hmmm, it's usually the family that push for ongoing treatment, not the GP/care home. I wonder what the care home/GP's side of the story is.

Anyway, there's a RESPECT form that GP's can put into place that can help address these kind of issues.

www.resus.org.uk/respect/respect-healthcare-professionals

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 20:02

DamnUserName21 · 03/11/2022 19:50

If she had capacity, she could have refused antibiotics and hospital treatment. If she did not, you along with other involved parties could have have had a discussion with her GP and a collective decision could have been made on her behalf not to give her antibiotics and hospital treatment.

This is why advanced directives are so important!

But, of course, HCPs will always err on the side of caution and treat because, well, they don't want to lose their registration, livelihoods or go to prison!

She didn’t have capacity. She thought she was covered by a DNR and LPOA. The care home and GP wouldn’t enter into discussion with the family. Even the ambulance service and hospital tried to intervene with the constant trips. If they hadn’t ended up keeping her in at one point and having tbt conversation I’m fairly sure the home and GP would still be coercing and manhandling her into taking antibiotics.

im well aware of why the hospital staff would err on the side of caution. My point was merely that that was one of the many things that superseded actually thinking of what was best for her.

DamnUserName21 · 03/11/2022 19:50

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 17:21

In her case the infections were treated because they’d have killed her.

i think there’s a balance to be found. They said they had to be treated because she’d be in pain and die if they didn’t - but her having to be forced into taking them (which caused massive distress multiple times a day), being often carted off to hospital and given drips also hurt.

For me there was an irony that she could be given sedatives so they could move her round, give her drips and the likes in a pain free and peaceful way, but that couldn’t be done to alleviate discomfort from the infection.

In her case doing the “right thing”, and medical staff understandably not putting themselves at risk of being accused of anything, was put before doing what was actually the best thing for her as a person.

If she had capacity, she could have refused antibiotics and hospital treatment. If she did not, you along with other involved parties could have have had a discussion with her GP and a collective decision could have been made on her behalf not to give her antibiotics and hospital treatment.

This is why advanced directives are so important!

But, of course, HCPs will always err on the side of caution and treat because, well, they don't want to lose their registration, livelihoods or go to prison!

JustLyra · 03/11/2022 17:21

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 12:29

@JustLyra that's horrible and so sad that her life was prolonged when quality was no longer there.

Is it right not to treat infections? Is their a risk infections could be passed on?
Infections can be very painful, is that maybe why they treat them?

In her case the infections were treated because they’d have killed her.

i think there’s a balance to be found. They said they had to be treated because she’d be in pain and die if they didn’t - but her having to be forced into taking them (which caused massive distress multiple times a day), being often carted off to hospital and given drips also hurt.

For me there was an irony that she could be given sedatives so they could move her round, give her drips and the likes in a pain free and peaceful way, but that couldn’t be done to alleviate discomfort from the infection.

In her case doing the “right thing”, and medical staff understandably not putting themselves at risk of being accused of anything, was put before doing what was actually the best thing for her as a person.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 03/11/2022 17:12

With dementia it’s because very brutally there are very little medical interventions available

so drugs to alleviate dementia symptoms free on the NHS, any medical palliative care would be free but unfortunately much of what people with dementia need are things that are deemed non medical - help to dress, help to wash, help to eat etc they fall under social care

and social care isn’t necessarily free if you have cancer Marie curie

continuing healthcare funding is an utter dogs breakfast & always has been

DamnUserName21 · 03/11/2022 17:00

*excuse the typos. Long to live.

DamnUserName21 · 03/11/2022 16:59

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 14:54

Why is it right that people who die from cancer get their end of life care paid for by the state, yet people who have dementia are expected to pay their own end of life care? 🤔

I'm not 100% on this but think those with advanced dementia who don't have long to love can get full CHC funding. I can't remember when the criteria kicks in.

XingMing · 03/11/2022 16:51

That is a very pertinent question @Dinoteeth, and I look forward to reading the justifications. It's not right IMO.

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 14:54

Why is it right that people who die from cancer get their end of life care paid for by the state, yet people who have dementia are expected to pay their own end of life care? 🤔

BigWoollyJumpers · 03/11/2022 14:45

I have to agree with all these sentiments. It's a really hard road to tread though. Step Dad, triple bypass, prostate cancer, catherterised, vascular dementia. Because of his bag, he regularly had infections. He had sepsis three (!) times and survived due to fantastic care by NHS. He had annual stents to his urethra. He finally had a DNR, additionally Do Not Treat or Hospitalise, and died in his care home of Covid. DM was not particularly unwell, just old and tired. She also had a DNR, additionally Do Not Treat or Hospitalise. She also died of Covid in the care home. Both had declined the vax.

Blossomtoes · 03/11/2022 14:43

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 00:43

Sorry I thought you were talking about the NI increase to pay for care homes.

I don't agree with people's assets being taken into account when if comes to care. People should receive care as necessary.
Some people will blow their cash and enjoy it others scrimp and save to leave their kids something. Why should the savers loose out?

I completely support people paying for their own care. We laugh about our “care home fund” but it’s not a joke, we hope it won’t need to be used for care but it’s there if it’s needed. It means there’s more money in the system for people with no money and it means that we will have some choice.

Maverickess · 03/11/2022 12:57

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 12:29

@JustLyra that's horrible and so sad that her life was prolonged when quality was no longer there.

Is it right not to treat infections? Is their a risk infections could be passed on?
Infections can be very painful, is that maybe why they treat them?

IME (end of life care, not medical) antibiotics can be the best way to manage the symptoms of an infection as well as treat the infection itself, I've known people treated for an infection as part of symptom control alongside fluids and pain relief as the person treating feels they're the best way to alleviate the pain and discomfort that comes with an infection.
I guess it depends on the person, the symptoms and the infection though.

Dinoteeth · 03/11/2022 12:29

@JustLyra that's horrible and so sad that her life was prolonged when quality was no longer there.

Is it right not to treat infections? Is their a risk infections could be passed on?
Infections can be very painful, is that maybe why they treat them?

Thelnebriati · 03/11/2022 12:21

The difference is caused by a different culture among staff. The staff dealing with JustLyra's Nan didn't sound at all open to not giving treatment, it wasn't lack of communication.