Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what age you believe it’s appropriate to drink

144 replies

MaryIlover · 31/10/2022 09:09

I’ve seen quite a few threads on here lately in which it seems the prevailing view is that any drinking under the age of 18 is bad and should not be permitted or facilitated by parents. To be honest I don’t really find this marries up with my own experience. Personally I think it’s the norm or at least quite common to start having parties drinking with your friends at about year 10/11 so that would be around 14-16 and that feels about right. My worry with making my DC wait until 18 is that firstly it would cause resentment if they were being left out of all their friends and secondly by 18 most of her friends would be going out clubbing and much more used or alcohol and therefore DC would end up placing themselves in far more risky situations rather than being thrown in at the deep end. Personally I think 15/16 is about the right age (I was about 15 myself) but to condemn all ‘underage drinking’ just seems really out of touch and unrealistic. Aibu?

OP posts:
puffyisgood · 31/10/2022 13:28

Yeah, I think it's more than fine, probably a good idea even, to be offering a solitary, smallish, glass of beer or wine at say 13 or so.

In terms of getting smashed - I don't really like it full stop but I don't think it's a good idea for them to be doing it for the first time ever at university age. I think the start of sixth form is probably about the optimal time, accepting that many will do it younger.

PeachPies · 31/10/2022 13:25

marlowe5 · 31/10/2022 13:14

What @Eleusa says.

I'm currently totally fed up that a local parent has given my DC and friends alcohol over half term - lots of it - without my permission. Lots of lazy parenting happening locally where there is an attitude that 'they are good kids and are sensible' with no idea about what they are actually doing. I think as a parent I want to make decisions to guide my DC on what and how to drink and not have this made by other parents. Schools working with all the resulting safeguarding issues and complications from teen parties, I'm sure, could well do without it.

Then you should have got in there first

Its a bit silly to be annoyed about other parents managing alcohol the way they feel right in their own homes

Dixiechickonhols · 31/10/2022 13:23

As a mum of a 16 yr old, age 16 end of yr 11 has been age for her and her friends to start. They aren’t the cool crowd though.
Only a few parties so far but I do let her take some alcohol to drink (I’d rather know what she was drinking she takes those lo calorie 4% hard seltzers) and rather her be honest with me. I will pick them up drop and friends home etc. If I was a hard no on drinking she/they wouldn’t have a lift. I’d rather know she was safe rather than her sneaking around or worried about coming home as she had been drinking.
She’s legal to drink at a house party. Not all her friends drink some for personal choice some for religious reasons.

takealettermsjones · 31/10/2022 13:16

Kids in my family (European) are normally allowed a taste from very young, then their own small glass with a meal from about 10 ish. I'm not there yet with my own kids so we'll see but I do think it promotes a healthy relationship with alcohol, which is after all inescapable in our society.

marlowe5 · 31/10/2022 13:14

What @Eleusa says.

I'm currently totally fed up that a local parent has given my DC and friends alcohol over half term - lots of it - without my permission. Lots of lazy parenting happening locally where there is an attitude that 'they are good kids and are sensible' with no idea about what they are actually doing. I think as a parent I want to make decisions to guide my DC on what and how to drink and not have this made by other parents. Schools working with all the resulting safeguarding issues and complications from teen parties, I'm sure, could well do without it.

PeachPies · 31/10/2022 13:09

rookiemere · 31/10/2022 13:07

@PeachPies "I never drank as a teen, have never liked the taste, but then again I’m an extrovert who never needed a drink to get into the spirit (I’ll twerk on a table at 3 in the afternoon stone cold sober) and hope my kids are the same."

  • what with the drinking or the twerking Grin?

Both! Although DD8 is already starting to become a challenger in the family twerk offs!

rookiemere · 31/10/2022 13:07

@PeachPies "I never drank as a teen, have never liked the taste, but then again I’m an extrovert who never needed a drink to get into the spirit (I’ll twerk on a table at 3 in the afternoon stone cold sober) and hope my kids are the same."

  • what with the drinking or the twerking Grin?
rookiemere · 31/10/2022 13:02

Now DS is 16 we'll buy the odd pack of Peroni for him to take to a party and when we were away on holiday last week both he and his 16 year old pal had a few beers and cocktails.

I don't mind him having a few drinks, but I'd rather he stayed away from spirits. Luckily he's quite into his sports so only drinks on nights out and doesn't want to wreck his training days.

It's a difficult line to tread. I feel it would be counterproductive and hypocritical to ban alcohol until he is 18, but equally I don't want to do too much to facilitate it. The reason we buy some beer for him to take to parties is so that hopefully he avoids the stronger stuff.

PeachPies · 31/10/2022 13:00

I don’t drink, neither does DH (well tell a lie he has a glass of champagne on new years) and am planning to hope our views on alcohol pass down to DC (as they will have positive role models at home and in the family) but I wouldn’t mind them drinking from 14/15, and I wouldn’t mind supplying alcohol for parties from 16 onwards.

I never drank as a teen, have never liked the taste, but then again I’m an extrovert who never needed a drink to get into the spirit (I’ll twerk on a table at 3 in the afternoon stone cold sober) and hope my kids are the same.

VioletCharlotte · 31/10/2022 12:56

My two were year 10/11. 16th birthday parties seem to be the time when lost parents allow drink, mine are both summer born so we're 15. DS1 stuck to cider initially. DS2 got very drunk on Vodka at 15 (bought by a friends older sister) He was very sick and made an idiot of himself and had to be picked up at 8pm. He was mortified and it served as a good lesson to him!

Delatron · 31/10/2022 12:31

My nearly 14 year old doesn’t seem interested. I keep saying ‘go on have a shandy’ but he doesn’t even like fizzy drinks. Very health conscious. So maybe this generation will be slightly different.

I had my first drink (half a cider) with my parents and about 13 at a wedding. They wanted me to see the effects of a small amount whilst they were there. They also allowed my friends over to have a drink from about 15 I think. They’d rather I do it under their roof than lie/hide it. I still got quite drunk though most Fridays.

I try and make it clear to my boys the ill effects of drink. That for example, drinking a bottle of vodka could kill you. I think keeping the conversation open is helpful.

HippyChickMama · 31/10/2022 12:21

*with his birthday meal

HippyChickMama · 31/10/2022 12:21

Ds is 15 and has one drink on special occasions at home (a small Baileys on Christmas Eve, half a pint of beer with his birthday sort of thing). He's not really a going to parties type and I don't want him going to uni and bingeing alcohol because it's been forbidden. Dd is 9 and if we have champagne for a toast on a special occasion she has a thimble full diluted with orange juice or lemonade and will have a tiny amount of Baileys diluted with milk or a bit of Advocaat diluted with lemonade at Christmas. This is how I was bought up and feels right for us

cookiecreammmpie · 31/10/2022 12:09

I started drinking at friend's houses at about 14/15. I would get tipsy but not drunk to the point of not knowing what I was doing. I knew my limits. Eldest is 14 and he has been having a low alcohol drink at special family gatherings for about the past year and a half, so about 12. He's never been drunk.

HavfrueDenizKisi · 31/10/2022 12:02

It is not illegal to have an alcoholic drink under the age of 18. People seem very confused about that.

It is illegal to buy alcohol if you are under 18; to sell alcohol to an under 18; to be sold alcohol in a licensed setting if you are under 18; for an adult to buy alcohol for an under 18.

It is, however, against the law to give under 5s alcohol.

So I think, with teenagers, it's all about conversation. What alcohol does; why people drink it; how to manage a healthy relationship with alcohol; the dangers of excessive drinking.

Then it's really about sensible access from when your teenager can engage in good decision making. Saying a hard no until they hit 18 is never a good idea - it can lead to destructive behaviours with alcohol when they're finally 'allowed' it.

Funnily enough, when we were in France over the summer, having a celebration meal at a lovely restaurant, the maitre d brought a glass of champagne for our 14 year old to have with the adults. They didn't seem worried. She quite enjoyed it! She will have the odd lager shandy now and then with a meal.

To ask what age you believe it’s appropriate to drink
Lochjeda · 31/10/2022 11:54

My eldest was around 14 when I started letting her have one drink a night once a week. My 13 year old is much more mature and has started having one drink a night once a week with her friends either in my house or one of theirs. You don't need to be 18 to legally drink in a house you need to be 18 to purchase it and to be in an establishment like a club. My eldest has a good relationship with alcohol as a result. Both of them have never hid from me they are drinking as a result. Have never been out in the streets drinking or gotten wasted or anything like many of their friends have and do.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 31/10/2022 11:53

I think 15 was when we started buying DS a bottle of cider or beer to have at the weekends. I wanted him to get to know how alcohol made him feel and what his limits were before he went out and found out in public.

SeemingOKToday · 31/10/2022 11:48

Ds1 is 14 and has had a bottle of beer on odd occasions this year - New Year, family party, big summer BBQ. Actually I think at the BBQ he might have had 2.

Ds2 is 12 and has been allowed half a bottle/glass once or twice this year.

Ds3 is 5 and has had sips of various drinks in the past year and declared them all disgusting.

I don't see it as a big deal really.

FuckabethFuckor · 31/10/2022 11:42

My parents introduced watered-down wine from about 11 or 12 I think. They were keen that we saw it as normal to sometimes have a drink with food.

underneaththeash · 31/10/2022 11:41

My son is 16 and there has been alcohol at parties for about a year. Having said that, he doesn’t like the taste yet…(and doesn’t really like parties).

luciaann · 31/10/2022 11:38

15/16

lannistunut · 31/10/2022 11:12

Hbh17 · 31/10/2022 11:04

It is completely legal to drink under 18, so I'm not sure why anyone would make their son or daughter to wait until they are aged 18....

We don't drink really, so in order for us to provide alcohol to an e.g. 16yo we would have to go out of our way to buy them alcohol and suggest they drink it, which seems weird. We are vegetarian and would not buy them a steak to try that either.

Some people (like in my family) just don't really drink. Drinkers always seem to think everyone else drinks too, but statistically the number of non-drinkers is increasing.

Hbh17 · 31/10/2022 11:04

It is completely legal to drink under 18, so I'm not sure why anyone would make their son or daughter to wait until they are aged 18....

Putonyourshoes · 31/10/2022 10:51

I would want my son to learn about the feeling of being tipsy/drunk in the safety of our home with his parents around. We’re talking once he’s 15/16, having a beer or two when we’re celebrating a birthday, or a glass or two of Prosecco on NYE.
My feeling is that, not all but most, 18 year old’s, will want to go out to a pub or club and get drunk with their friends. I know when I was young I didn’t realise the “delay” in feeling the alcohol, so I’d be finishing my second drink which had not yet caught up with me, and be ordering my third. I’d start to feel drunk while drinking that third drink and order another. The drunkenness I was feeling was likely from the first or second drink, but by the time you feel that, you’ve already consumed more and usually, too much.
I think if teens can have supervised drinks at home before that experience, where an adult is appropriately controlling the kind of alcohol, the amount and the time it’s drank in, they get a feel for it. And therefore are more likely to drink safely on nights out with their mates.

AuntieStella · 31/10/2022 10:51

I agree that having an age-related cliff edge is unlikely to be a good thing.

Especially as unless your DC is one of the oldest in their year (and none of their friends have older siblings) then they're going to be able to get hold of alcohol and be at events where it's flowing freely before they are 18.

Relationship with alcohol starts young - by seeing how parents and other adults use it.

I've always majored on the thought that the best way is to find your happy place and stay in it. But that everyone makes mistakes whilst they're finding that out, and it's not the end of the world. But that no-one should be blind drunk in unsafe places, so always, always, always look out for your mates.

Also risks of spirits (when I was a student, spirits were relatively much more expensive, so a bottle was maybe a once-a-term treat) - get them, if you can, to prefer wine, beer or cider, because stomach/bladder capacity is likely to kick in before harmful levels are reached.

My DC had champagne as toasts at weddings, and maybe a drink at Christmas from an age that MN would frown on, but the French probably wouldn't mind. Wine from 16 (which is the age when it's first legal for it to be served to them in public with a meal)

But I think the key isn't the precise age you allow what. It's what you model to your DC and how you communicate

Swipe left for the next trending thread