Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What will be the answer when foodbanks start running out of stock

141 replies

ItisallPooh · 30/10/2022 23:16

I know more and more people are having to utilise food banks. In our area, a huge employer shut its doors last month for the last time, many families had mum, dad and sometimes even grandparents working there. I personally know quite a few families really worried about affording everything.
Whilst I was doing my weekly shop, it occurred to me that it has been ages since I put more than one item into the food bank trolley. To be honest, there are times I have struggled to even put one thing in. Costs are rising so much, our two income public sector incomes are not stretching far at all.
I noticed that the food bank trolley used to be piled high. It never is nowadays. And more and more people are having to rely on them. What happens to the people who are struggling when even the food banks start running low on stock?
I keep thinking about it all evening. Our family are doing ok, not brilliantly but we are coping but I remember growing up being hungry and knowing that I couldn't ask mum for something to eat because she had no money left. We were living off benefits as she was undergoing cancer treatment, we had left my dad and our business as he was abusive. Our situation did eventually improve but it haunts me. I hate the thought that there will be families in exactly that situation with the added issue of heating and electricity costing a fortune too.
Food banks are wonderful but working families SHOULDNT have to be accessing them. Their wages should cover it. What a state this country is in. What is going to happen when even the food banks are struggling to help people because other folk can no longer afford to put stuff into them.

OP posts:
Zebedee55 · 31/10/2022 07:32

People are definitely and increasingly finding feeding themselves a problem, adults as well as children. It's totally unacceptable in 2022 in the UK. 🙁

"NHS data revealed in 2021/22 some 10,724 patients were so malnourished they needed hospital care – an increase from 3,773 in 2009/10."

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/doctor-treating-record-numbers-malnourished-28360170

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:31

Backtothenineties · 31/10/2022 07:20

Probably.be a black mirror episode soon of people visiting a food bank and before they are accepted they face a trial of social media detectives who go through years worth of posts and receipts to see if they should starve or not in case they bought branded coffee from 5 years ago they don't deserve food as they should budget better

But actually, if she'd gone somewhere like citizens advice for help with debt they'd have gone through her spending with her and highlighted exactly this - that bills come first.
And the reason places like Trussell Trust want a referral is so that they can do exactly this, get people involved with services to help them make more of the money they have.
Because that way the money available to help people, can help more people!

gogohmm · 31/10/2022 07:30

I agree op that working families shouldn't need food banks but everyone's circumstances are different, I am a debt counsellor and help at a food bank - the number one problem is debt not income.

Benefits are sufficient if you live in a council/ha/rented property low enough cost to be covered by the local area rate and you don't have debts. However from personal experience through work I know that people are in houses too big/expensive so the housing element of their uc doesn't cover their rent, people have lots of unsecured debts due to unscrupulous lenders or borrowed before circumstances changed, some have feckless ex partners, more children than they can afford (families with 4+ children are over represented compared to frequency).

Long term financial literacy needs to be improved, I've spent hours explaining compound interest to clients! Secondly we need good quality long term rental homes suitable for families (houses or flats but need to be cheap to heat, have outside space for children even if shared). Finally we need to ensure men (well could be women but nearly always men) pay for their children, get rid of the various ways child maintenance is avoided - how about compulsory attending the job centre/searches if you claim you aren't working (or claiming benefits) to avoid paying!

WhiteFire · 31/10/2022 07:23

This is what happens when you expect Joe Public to feed Jane Public. It is not sustainable long term.

TheSilentPicnic · 31/10/2022 07:21

@KweenieBeanz
it is true that there is a small group of food bank users who are long term, who have no real prospect breaking the dependency. It is rare, though. The vast majority of our clients are short term users who have run out of money for food because of a crisis such as job loss, illness or accident.

Putting a hand out for a food parcel is not as easy as a lot of people seem to imagine. Our clients are those who are courageous enough to come forward and are often deeply ashamed. It isn’t a fast, easy process either, and the parcels are not flash. No one is doing it for the hell of it.

I really wish naysayers would take a break from talking crap and volunteer at a food bank, even for one shift. It’ll blow their tiny minds wide open to see the desperate need in our communities.

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:20

This just proves my point entirely.... There are people out there think celebrating a child's birthday comes above paying your essential bills.
If I was thousands in debt to the energy company I'd be saying to my mum no dont buy cinema tickets put that money toward the debt please it will help us more.
Keeping a roof over kids heads is more important than birthday treats.

Backtothenineties · 31/10/2022 07:20

Probably.be a black mirror episode soon of people visiting a food bank and before they are accepted they face a trial of social media detectives who go through years worth of posts and receipts to see if they should starve or not in case they bought branded coffee from 5 years ago they don't deserve food as they should budget better

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:16

Her family would have been better helping her pay her energy bill than spending £80 on cinema tickets.

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:15

Backtothenineties · 31/10/2022 07:14

How do you know it wasn't one of her kids birthday treat? Or her family paid and she was complaining as they had paid but not got the promotional offer? How do you know the debt wasn't applied if the energy company realised their had been an error and applied the 11,000 after she had gone to the cinema? It can happen.
It's awful in todays society people take it upon themselves to go Facebook detecting to see if they deserve to visit a food bank or not. You don't know their full circumstances.
Your point about the govt helping vulnerable people budget is a joke, the only thing they do is cut benefits as enough judge people like you kick up enough of a fuss that someone dared spend money 3 years ago so they shouldn't have food from a food bank so the govt cracks down on everyone

That's exactly the point. If you owe money for a basic energy bill you can't afford an £80 kids birthday treat!
I'm sorry but if I was thousands in debt to the energy company I'd be buying my child a £1 box of maltesers and explaining that we had to pay our bills!!

Backtothenineties · 31/10/2022 07:14

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:05

Obviously many foodbank users genuinely couldnt cut back any more, but the fact is some use the foodbank because then they can spend their food money on something else, like a treat. We do need to open our eyes to the fact some people are not good at prioritising what they spend money on.

BBC news article are covering a story about a woman forced to go on a prepayment meter for energy who has only 20p left on it. She owed 11k to the energy company.
Search for her name on FB and 2-3 years ago she was complaining on a cinema FB page about having paid £80 on tickets to a kids film and not being given some promotional item or other.
You don't run up 11k of debt in a couple of years. So at a time when she probably already owed money to the energy company, she spent £80 on cinema tickets. Not saying people should never have treats but clearly the time for luxuries has passed if you can't pay your basic bills.
The govt need to devote more energy to helping vulnerable people to manage their money, and to access the benefits they are entitled to.

How do you know it wasn't one of her kids birthday treat? Or her family paid and she was complaining as they had paid but not got the promotional offer? How do you know the debt wasn't applied if the energy company realised their had been an error and applied the 11,000 after she had gone to the cinema? It can happen.
It's awful in todays society people take it upon themselves to go Facebook detecting to see if they deserve to visit a food bank or not. You don't know their full circumstances.
Your point about the govt helping vulnerable people budget is a joke, the only thing they do is cut benefits as enough judge people like you kick up enough of a fuss that someone dared spend money 3 years ago so they shouldn't have food from a food bank so the govt cracks down on everyone

luckylavender · 31/10/2022 07:11

caringcarer · 31/10/2022 02:05

Government needs to raise the minimum wage. I know it won't solve all problems but would make life just a bit easier for many. My son's employer has just decided to give all employees a free meal in staff canteen in November and December. It will make a difference to some. More employers could be doing this.

The problem with that is that some companies are struggling too. Not all companies are large corporations. It's all very well to say the government should raise the National wage, it's not the government that pays it. Companies are subject to the same inflationary pressures of rents / mortgages / energy.

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:05

Obviously many foodbank users genuinely couldnt cut back any more, but the fact is some use the foodbank because then they can spend their food money on something else, like a treat. We do need to open our eyes to the fact some people are not good at prioritising what they spend money on.

BBC news article are covering a story about a woman forced to go on a prepayment meter for energy who has only 20p left on it. She owed 11k to the energy company.
Search for her name on FB and 2-3 years ago she was complaining on a cinema FB page about having paid £80 on tickets to a kids film and not being given some promotional item or other.
You don't run up 11k of debt in a couple of years. So at a time when she probably already owed money to the energy company, she spent £80 on cinema tickets. Not saying people should never have treats but clearly the time for luxuries has passed if you can't pay your basic bills.
The govt need to devote more energy to helping vulnerable people to manage their money, and to access the benefits they are entitled to.

Backtothenineties · 31/10/2022 07:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I've read some things on here but this is disgusting.
Children are actually starving over here now by the way, it's not going to happen it's already happening

TheSilentPicnic · 31/10/2022 07:03

MrsTerryPratchett · 31/10/2022 05:01

True. It could also be seen as a stealth tax on those, who donate.

I'd LOVE to know the political demographics of who donates.

Our biggest donors are older white people.

TheSilentPicnic · 31/10/2022 07:02

Obviously food banks should not exist. But here we are, they do and it doesn’t look like they’re going to go away any time soon.

I work for a giant charity and the need continues to rise, and now includes people who previously would have been donors.

We are buying baked beans for the first time in years, previously we always had enough donated.

I actually don’t know what the hell is wrong with us all that we have allowed this to happen. There is enough food for everyone, no one should be going hungry. It feels akin to a war crime to let people go hungry and homeless when we have such wealth.

TheSilentPicnic · 31/10/2022 06:57

Hawkins001 · 31/10/2022 00:15

there was a poster on here and their neighbour was throwing away good food from the food bank, that they were given.

That was a troll

lannistunut · 31/10/2022 06:55

DoodlePug · 31/10/2022 01:03

Fortunately they won't run out, more publicity means more donations.

I haven't physically been to a supermarket in ages so haven't put in the food bank. Saw your post and donated money online.

It's easy to forget but many people are willing to help.

Obviously the need for them is an absolute disgrace.

Food banks are saying they are low on stocks - donations have dropped slightly as most families have less spare cash, demand has increased significantly.

You are lying to yourself if you think there is not a serious issue coming.

DoubleDinnurs · 31/10/2022 06:53

Kaibashira · 31/10/2022 06:42

Let's see how many children starve? Let's see?

What the actual fuck is wrong with you?

Can I just ask what you contribute to society Whatnow11? That post sounds like it is coming from a 30 year old virgin who never leaves his bedroom.

Calm down.

The only other option would be stealing if you are that broke and have no other options, and I'm sure you would have an issue with that too.

DoubleDinnurs · 31/10/2022 06:48

mellongoose · 31/10/2022 06:34

@Zebedee55
Making sure people are getting enough to support to feed themselves is really the job of governments, not charities.

Actually, making sure people are getting enough to support themselves is really the job...of people themselves. Government is there for a safety net for those who cannot. Charities are there to support specific groups/causes.

The thing is, they are also there to manage the economy and they have done a very poor job of it (as have other countries). All this has been a long time coming since the last crash (I won't get into why here as it will be a very, very long post and it is too early in the morning).

Their job as a government is to do what they said they would do when they were elected. They haven't. They have done the opposite really. They have made conditions in the UK so bad that people who work cannot thrive and have to rely on this help. They refuse to tax the very wealthy and have enabled zero hours contracts and poor wage growth, so people do not have enough income to be independent. We cannot all be a nation of doctors and solicitors. Those who work should have enough to survive.

I get what you are saying in that people need to be self reliant, but many of the conditions out there contributing to this crisis is beyond the control of the average person. All they can do is go to work and cut their costs and that is what people are doing now and it isn't enough.

Kaibashira · 31/10/2022 06:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Let's see how many children starve? Let's see?

What the actual fuck is wrong with you?

Lalliella · 31/10/2022 06:38

mellongoose · 31/10/2022 06:34

@Zebedee55
Making sure people are getting enough to support to feed themselves is really the job of governments, not charities.

Actually, making sure people are getting enough to support themselves is really the job...of people themselves. Government is there for a safety net for those who cannot. Charities are there to support specific groups/causes.

You’re wrong. It’s the responsibility of governments to make sure that the levels of minimum wages and benefits are sufficiently high that people can feed themselves. That should be a basic human right.

DoubleDinnurs · 31/10/2022 06:37

lemmein · 31/10/2022 00:19

What's your point?

One person doing this means EVERYONE who uses them must be doing this and is undeserving. Hmm.

Similar to my mother who said that she wouldn't give to food banks as they 'all prioritise money for fags'. I asked her if that included the starving kids that get fed through food banks......🤔

I'm sure there might be some people who might use FBs as means to afford other things and to cut food bill down, but this is probably really rare. It is a hassle people don't want and you don't really have a huge amount of choice in what you get.

I think people say this sort of thing to make themselves feel better about not being charitiable and because it is easier mentally and emotionally to have the belief that people put themselves in these positions and it isn't sometime circumstances beyond their control. It is harder to acknowledge inequality and that you might come from a more privileged position, as you have to face the fact you haven't got to where you are all through hard work, sometimes it is also luck and starting from a more privileged position.

ChimChimeny · 31/10/2022 06:36

their way of coping (short term) will probably be to go on the rob

I work for Boots and baby formula has moved to eat the top.of most stolen products recently so it is happening (historically it has been expensive but small products like razor blades which are easy to steal and sell on)

Lalliella · 31/10/2022 06:36

I’m remembering the Hartlepool by-election and a voter saying he was voting Tory because they’d provided Hartlepool with lots of food banks and Labour hadn’t provided any. Like that was a good thing. Food banks shouldn’t exist. The government should be ensuring all its citizens are fed, it shouldn’t be the responsibility of charity.

It's really sad. This country has gone to shit. And it’s only going to get worse.

mellongoose · 31/10/2022 06:34

@Zebedee55
Making sure people are getting enough to support to feed themselves is really the job of governments, not charities.

Actually, making sure people are getting enough to support themselves is really the job...of people themselves. Government is there for a safety net for those who cannot. Charities are there to support specific groups/causes.