Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What will be the answer when foodbanks start running out of stock

141 replies

ItisallPooh · 30/10/2022 23:16

I know more and more people are having to utilise food banks. In our area, a huge employer shut its doors last month for the last time, many families had mum, dad and sometimes even grandparents working there. I personally know quite a few families really worried about affording everything.
Whilst I was doing my weekly shop, it occurred to me that it has been ages since I put more than one item into the food bank trolley. To be honest, there are times I have struggled to even put one thing in. Costs are rising so much, our two income public sector incomes are not stretching far at all.
I noticed that the food bank trolley used to be piled high. It never is nowadays. And more and more people are having to rely on them. What happens to the people who are struggling when even the food banks start running low on stock?
I keep thinking about it all evening. Our family are doing ok, not brilliantly but we are coping but I remember growing up being hungry and knowing that I couldn't ask mum for something to eat because she had no money left. We were living off benefits as she was undergoing cancer treatment, we had left my dad and our business as he was abusive. Our situation did eventually improve but it haunts me. I hate the thought that there will be families in exactly that situation with the added issue of heating and electricity costing a fortune too.
Food banks are wonderful but working families SHOULDNT have to be accessing them. Their wages should cover it. What a state this country is in. What is going to happen when even the food banks are struggling to help people because other folk can no longer afford to put stuff into them.

OP posts:
Intru · 31/10/2022 09:24

Underanothersky · 31/10/2022 08:26

But that would be punishing their children.

I can’t get my head around the thought process here. If a parent is spending money on cigarettes rather than feeding their children then it is they who are “punishing” their children, not a food bank who could quite reasonably telling them that they should not be queuing up for free food when they are spending money on smoking.

Intru · 31/10/2022 09:20

Slothtoes · 31/10/2022 04:01

Agree with everything you’ve said MrsTerryPratchett
of course it’s very possible that food banks run out as food costs and need for them rise exponentially. Then the government will have to act or have families in the UK, in 2022, starving to death.
These twelve years of Tory rule have really worked well for people on low incomes haven’t they, that foodbanks are this needed, and people are this reliant on them and worried sick about how to feed their families?

They have worked well for people on low incomes, yes. The minimum wage has increased at a far higher rate than has inflation, and the tax-free allowance has risen just as far, taking many lower-earners out of paying income tax completely.

mrsbyers · 31/10/2022 09:20

The trussell trust will have to spend the millions they have in the bank ? The apparently open door policy of many will return to referrals only so those in most need are prioritised ?

Hopelessacademic · 31/10/2022 09:18

haven't RTFT but what you see in the trolley isn't necessarily representative of what they get.
I donate money monthly to a foodbank. Recently, since we are OK financially, I have actually upped my donation, as I'm aware that many more people are struggling.

SpookabooAtTheZoo · 31/10/2022 09:15

Already twice in this thread people have said part of the problem is “people should move to somewhere cheaper”

Ok so do you have the £1000 or so it will cost to move? And where are all these cheaper houses because I don’t know anyone who looks at a list of houses that meet their needs and goes ‘actually I will have the more expensive one that I cannot afford’ and I do know a lot of people who are in unsuitable housing that is too small or quite far from their job but still costs more than is fair, because it’s all they can get.

MissTrip82 · 31/10/2022 09:02

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:20

This just proves my point entirely.... There are people out there think celebrating a child's birthday comes above paying your essential bills.
If I was thousands in debt to the energy company I'd be saying to my mum no dont buy cinema tickets put that money toward the debt please it will help us more.
Keeping a roof over kids heads is more important than birthday treats.

You searched for someone on FB and went diving far enough to find a comment from a few years ago because you were so committed to proving a stranger you’d read about was not one of the ‘deserving poor’? Really?

What a deranged thing to do. Imagine being so consumed with contempt for your fellow humans that you’d devote time to this. Utterly bizarre behaviour.

MissTrip82 · 31/10/2022 08:51

Hawkins001 · 31/10/2022 00:15

there was a poster on here and their neighbour was throwing away good food from the food bank, that they were given.

This is exactly why I loathe those types of posts and think the people who post them are utter pieces of shit.

A throwaway remark and it becomes accepted wisdom trotted out by others.

user55875537986543 · 31/10/2022 08:37

@Underanothersky yes. And no. If it was made clear and parents chose to still smoke then it would be the parents responsibility.

Some parents feed their children fizzy drinks and that’s punishing their children long term. Some parents don’t give their children fresh fruit or vegetables. Some parents don’t vaccinate their children. Some of these parents are uneducated and have limited funds, some are highly educated, have well paid jobs but take the “easy” route/don’t think about their child’s health.

Children are reliant on their parents making good decisions for them in every area of their lives, every day.

I would like all schools to be funded properly so that the schools can provide healthy snacks and lunches (and actually also breakfast and an early tea if needed too).

anyolddinosaur · 31/10/2022 08:30

Hopefully those with money will donate here www.trusselltrust.org/appeal/

I am finding what I donate has increased in cost by about 50%. At the moment I still give the same amount (ie number of items) but I'm grateful when I see our food bank is not asking for anything and I dont need to. Then I put things away for a post Christmas parcel because January is when things get really tough here.

Underanothersky · 31/10/2022 08:26

user55875537986543 · 31/10/2022 08:15

Such an interesting subject. I donate most weeks. I wish there was no need for food banks though.

In my less charitable moments I sometimes think that smokers should be banned from using them.

But that would be punishing their children.

user55875537986543 · 31/10/2022 08:15

Such an interesting subject. I donate most weeks. I wish there was no need for food banks though.

In my less charitable moments I sometimes think that smokers should be banned from using them.

Nonimai · 31/10/2022 08:15

Just to draw attention to the fact that food banks are not the only food resource. In our area new food initiatives are starting up, whether that is produce ( veg and fruit ) sharing initiatives, or food cupboards, food fridges, soup kitchens etc. I think OLIO ( food sharing website) is excellent. The supermarkets and major food retailers have started their own initiatives. Many of the initiatives are available to anyone, anonymously. It is right to mention baby formula, nappies, period products are also essential. IMO a healthy, free to all, simple school dinner - pasta/sauce and a piece of fruit, would at least protect the children, along with free period products in schools , allocating more space to allotments and orchards(instead of selling it all off for housing) - no I’m not saying that struggling people should grow their own, but those of us who can, will grow stuff if they have the space and generally it’s free food and gets shared. Authorities cannot be relied on to resolve this issue. It is disgusting that a wage does not cover necessities. It is disgusting that there is the suggestion that schools should be forced to cut their food provision further (see post from a school governor over the weekend) Ultimately, sadly, it is up to each one of us and our communities, to watch out for each other, to put what we can in the food bank trolley, volunteer at a local initiative if we can, use and promote OLIO ( I love OLIO) and make sure we have no wasted food in our own homes. (Sorry if that comes across as preachy).

CredibilityProblem · 31/10/2022 08:09

There's definitely a risk of food banks being unable to cope eventually. But in the short term they could increase supply considerably with a big publicity push reminding people of the need.

I'm pretty sure there's still a fair number of people who could give, and have given at various points but happen not to at the moment because it's not been explicitly highlighted (obviously it's implicit in the cost of living crisis news stories, but it's not received much of a push).

MummyGummy · 31/10/2022 08:06

Food banks need to be rationed to those most in need. The first step should be a referral to a charity like Step Change who can go though all their outgoings and help put debt management plans in place. Plus make sure they are claiming all benefits they are entitled to.

I’m sure there are some people who have genuinely cut back everything but there will be those who still have expensive phone contracts/smoke/Netflix etc where savings could be made. And then look at the big stuff like moving somewhere cheaper to live.

I do feel there is a large proportion of society that feels entitled to live however they want, hence record amounts of personal debt. No-one has the right to a particular lifestyle, if you can’t afford it you can’t have it.

There needs to be much more done in school to help children learn to budget and take responsibility for themselves financially.

There have been articles on the BBC about children having to share a toothbrush, a young mother with a newborn who can’t afford to top up her electricity etc. In the mothers case she was with an older man who already had 3 children, and would have known when she got pregnant their financial situation was difficult. Why bring a child into that? And in the background of the pictures were all sorts of toys/clutter which just aren’t necessary.

In most cases people have got themselves into a situation of food poverty and need help getting out of it so they can be self-sufficient in the long term. Not given ever increasing handouts which will make the problem worse.

Food banks should be a short term safety net for those in dire need.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 31/10/2022 08:03

I suppose there's always theft or prostitution 😒

SkylightSkylight · 31/10/2022 07:58

Intru · 31/10/2022 01:18

From whatever they’ve diverted it to. Hard decisions may need to be made, but most people are decent enough that they will find another solution than turning to crime. Whether it’s taking on some evening work, or taking in ironing.

@Intru

oh those people... the ones using it to pay rent & electric. Damn those pesky kids needing to eat & have showers.

yes, some might be forced to 'divert it' from booze & weed, but many more will already be using it for essentials.

SkylightSkylight · 31/10/2022 07:51

Stampsforall · 31/10/2022 01:08

Reallocating it back from where?

Daft wasteful things, like rent & fuel I guess🤷🏻‍♀️

DoubleDinnurs · 31/10/2022 07:49

Thanks CaronPoivre I do find some people's opinions so frustrating. They can't critically think or see that what is ckming will affect pretty much everyone. Thry just repeat what they have read by right wing press. Its reassuring to see on here people do have compassion and can see the bigger picture and don't fall for divisive media, but some people are beyond help!

CaronPoivre · 31/10/2022 07:45

DoubleDinnurs · 31/10/2022 07:40

This thread started as a good discussion, but it has descended into a discussion about whether people who are struggling are worthy of help, or if they are 'scrounging' unecessarily. We are forgetting that a lot of people with wealth scrounge too. How much money did we waste during the pandemic to corporate fraud or dodgy contracts that failed? Businesses get a lot of grants for things that they don't have to evidence have taken place.

Instead we are arguing about cans of baked beans! Yes we are the ones that donate, but if you don't donate, it shouldn't really bother you that much. You should be worried about the money coming out of your pocket as a taxpayer that is wasted by people who take tax payers money to lead a more privileged existence, which of spent differently could do much more good in our communities.

But lets keep arguing about the tins of beans and custard shall we....

Spot on !

DoubleDinnurs · 31/10/2022 07:40

This thread started as a good discussion, but it has descended into a discussion about whether people who are struggling are worthy of help, or if they are 'scrounging' unecessarily. We are forgetting that a lot of people with wealth scrounge too. How much money did we waste during the pandemic to corporate fraud or dodgy contracts that failed? Businesses get a lot of grants for things that they don't have to evidence have taken place.

Instead we are arguing about cans of baked beans! Yes we are the ones that donate, but if you don't donate, it shouldn't really bother you that much. You should be worried about the money coming out of your pocket as a taxpayer that is wasted by people who take tax payers money to lead a more privileged existence, which of spent differently could do much more good in our communities.

But lets keep arguing about the tins of beans and custard shall we....

SettingPrecedents · 31/10/2022 07:37

I think some posters are kidding themselves as to what “rock bottom” looks like. The crisis we’re heading in to, people have already got second jobs, they’ve already asked friends for help, they’ve already cut back on everything non essential, they’ve already warned their kids that Santa isn’t visiting this year. If that was me, you can bet I’d turning to something illegal - whether it’s stealing food or prostitution - to get food for my kids and keep a roof over their heads.

I agree that the government now takes advantage of the existence of food banks. Its not coincidental - that’s what the “big society” push by Cameron was all about.

CaronPoivre · 31/10/2022 07:35

It is abhorrent that we have a need of foodbanks. We are one of the richest nations in the world but the wealth is handed to the few and (unsurprisingly) doesn’t ‘trickle down’.
Yet another example of right wing media creating hate and divisions to avoid setting the culpability at government’s feet. People refuse to see what is happening. Blame the asylum seekers, blame the poor, blame the woke, blame Muslims, blame anyone except those who are truly responsible.

We are all responsible for every child. We all benefit from providing an educated and healthy younger generation.
Every person should be fed and have acceptable housing. We all suffer when people (veterans, the seriously unwell, people with learning disabilities and those in financial despair) are left to freeze on the streets or accommodated in overcrowded prisons.
The increased polarisation of wealth affects us all; it isn’t avoidable in the longer term as race/class/difference hatred and anger escalate.

Look back to 1933 and let’s learn from history what happens when we ‘other’ people and create a culture based on blame and dehumanising groups.

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:35

gogohmm · 31/10/2022 07:30

I agree op that working families shouldn't need food banks but everyone's circumstances are different, I am a debt counsellor and help at a food bank - the number one problem is debt not income.

Benefits are sufficient if you live in a council/ha/rented property low enough cost to be covered by the local area rate and you don't have debts. However from personal experience through work I know that people are in houses too big/expensive so the housing element of their uc doesn't cover their rent, people have lots of unsecured debts due to unscrupulous lenders or borrowed before circumstances changed, some have feckless ex partners, more children than they can afford (families with 4+ children are over represented compared to frequency).

Long term financial literacy needs to be improved, I've spent hours explaining compound interest to clients! Secondly we need good quality long term rental homes suitable for families (houses or flats but need to be cheap to heat, have outside space for children even if shared). Finally we need to ensure men (well could be women but nearly always men) pay for their children, get rid of the various ways child maintenance is avoided - how about compulsory attending the job centre/searches if you claim you aren't working (or claiming benefits) to avoid paying!

Absolutely this, there should be a lot more support available to help people with budgeting and it should start at school!

Ylvamoon · 31/10/2022 07:34

WhiteFire · 31/10/2022 07:23

This is what happens when you expect Joe Public to feed Jane Public. It is not sustainable long term.

^This.

Realistically they will give out less food and tighten up their criteria for assistance.

KweenieBeanz · 31/10/2022 07:33

Zebedee55 · 31/10/2022 07:32

People are definitely and increasingly finding feeding themselves a problem, adults as well as children. It's totally unacceptable in 2022 in the UK. 🙁

"NHS data revealed in 2021/22 some 10,724 patients were so malnourished they needed hospital care – an increase from 3,773 in 2009/10."

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/doctor-treating-record-numbers-malnourished-28360170

Some of this is also due to underfunded social care. Some people need carers to come and help them with food /eating and the care sector is an absolute disgrace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread