Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so strongly about sleepovers

141 replies

Energydrink · 30/10/2022 21:41

So, DP and I keep having a reoccurring argument about our position on sleepovers. Our DD is 3 years old , a long way off of sleep over her nursery friends house.

I think that she should not go to a sleepover until she is at least 10y, able to communicate if she wants to come home, confident enough to speak up for herself and able to tell me if something has upset her.

I would however welcome a child into our home that she has invited.

husband thinks that I am being ridiculous. He was sleepover friends from the age of 6 and he was fine. He also thinks that my attitude to an innocent activity is what is wrong with the world (sensationalism and scaremongering).

my view is that he is naïve and as much as I would like us to live in an ideal world where terrible things do not happen .. that is not reality. I would rather keep her safe then to expose her to risk.

AIBU to feel this way about sleepovers?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dunnoburt · 31/10/2022 22:19

I used to hate sleep overs, Still do now as an adult, like my creature comforts.....for that reason I won't push my 6 year old into a sleep over but nor will I stop her......(although at the moment I think she's way too young, family fine, friends no....)

Taswama · 31/10/2022 22:15

Not read the whole thread

If you are worried about child abuse, it's statistically more likely with a family member (uncle, grandfather) than a friend.

AloysiusBear · 31/10/2022 22:14

By 10 most dc have a phone.

Since when? Where i and where siblings live, kids only get phones starting secondary so 11/12.

OohMrBingley · 31/10/2022 22:13

Absolutely not happening. My DD especially was quite annoyed with me for some time (age 7 ish when the requests started) but now she knows there's no point as I will never ever change my mind on this. Plenty of time to see friends without putting them in harms way imo.

I’m sure she’s still annoyed with you, she just doesn’t bother expressing it.

She will probably go on to send her DC on sleepovers, because she’ll remember how much she wanted them and felt like she missed out.

’Twas ever thus….

AloysiusBear · 31/10/2022 22:13

6 is young for a sleepover except with family (eg cousins).

But by 8 or so you may find your child has long standing friends, where you've got to know the kids & their parents very well, and sleepovers aren't such a scary prospect.

Ginseng1 · 31/10/2022 22:10

Your child is 3 for crying out loud stop arguing about this until time comes. My DS was 10 (as it happened no interest before) when he had his first, DD was 9. DD2 is 6 I'll hold off long as poss only because the younger they are more chance I need to go collect mid of the night! They are a pain to host but they love them so much especially girls!

antelopevalley · 31/10/2022 21:57

7 and 8 are the best ages for sleepovers.

Changemyname1000x · 31/10/2022 21:54

Cubs and brownies do sleepovers from 7 and 8.

Changemyname1000x · 31/10/2022 21:52

I had one child do sleepover at 7 and another at 10. Depends on child.
Also to be honest the boys were easier. Which I was surprised by.
Some dc don't like sleepovers. As everyone has said. You don't know.

Child abuse is quite frequently carried out by young adult males (don't know exact stats) and I know a family who didn't let their daughters go to sleepovers where there was a much older brother. I think though the stats are usually higher with family connections (e.g cousins step-brothers, family friends carrying out so not to a guest). I explained this to my daughter in an age appropriate way. once they get phones they can call you. By 10 most dc have a phone.

ldontWanna · 31/10/2022 21:50

CoastalWave · 31/10/2022 21:43

I personally don't understand everyones obsession with sleepovers.

It's a blanket No in my house. 100%.

Most children who are sexually abused are abused by someone they know well. Why on earth would anyone send their child to sleep in a house with people you can't possibly know for definite how they 'behave' in private? Just as a side note - we have lovely neighbours. Lovely until they had a baby and now literally are screaming the F word 24.7 and being incredibly abusive to each other - behind closed doors (except not realising we can hear every single argument and it's grim) . I'm this close to phoning the police/social services. In public they are simply adorable. You have zero idea of knowing anyone for sure.

Absolutely not happening. My DD especially was quite annoyed with me for some time (age 7 ish when the requests started) but now she knows there's no point as I will never ever change my mind on this. Plenty of time to see friends without putting them in harms way imo.

Will you say no to residentials and other overnight school trips as well?

CoastalWave · 31/10/2022 21:43

I personally don't understand everyones obsession with sleepovers.

It's a blanket No in my house. 100%.

Most children who are sexually abused are abused by someone they know well. Why on earth would anyone send their child to sleep in a house with people you can't possibly know for definite how they 'behave' in private? Just as a side note - we have lovely neighbours. Lovely until they had a baby and now literally are screaming the F word 24.7 and being incredibly abusive to each other - behind closed doors (except not realising we can hear every single argument and it's grim) . I'm this close to phoning the police/social services. In public they are simply adorable. You have zero idea of knowing anyone for sure.

Absolutely not happening. My DD especially was quite annoyed with me for some time (age 7 ish when the requests started) but now she knows there's no point as I will never ever change my mind on this. Plenty of time to see friends without putting them in harms way imo.

AnonyMouseToday · 31/10/2022 21:43

I have 2 DC. Due to COVID, eldest didn't have a first sleepover til 10. He also went away on a residential 5 day trip with his sports club just before the sleepover, at just turned 10. He loved both. Younger DC is 8 and hasn't done a sleepover yet. I'd let him if he wanted one and we knew the family well, but it's just not something he wants to do yet

When I was 8 I went on an exchange tip abroad to europe and stayed with a random family I'd never met for 4 days! I had the best ever time!!! But I wouldn't in a million years let my kids do that!! What was my mum thinking!!? All worked out fine though! I wasn't abused or murdered etc . and the family I stayed with were nice and not the Adams family! Thank goodness!

mathanxiety · 31/10/2022 21:39

@Fundays12
There's a difference between 'equal' and 'fair.'

What is your goal here?

Fair is about everyone getting what they need in order to be successful.

In a just world, maybe your oldest child wouldn't need all the supervision and the medication. But he's getting what he needs in order to be successful. How about the younger two?

AnonyMouseToday · 31/10/2022 21:38

I have 2 DC. Due to COVID, eldest didn't have a first sleepover til 10. He also went away on a residential 5 day trip with hi

OohMrBingley · 31/10/2022 21:36

I honestly don’t understand why you’re arguing over this now. She’s 3! So of course you can’t envisage sending her on sleepovers.

By the time she’s ready and asking for them, you’ll be in a completely different place.

When my eldest was three, I didn’t know any of the families he went on to meet at school. By the time he was 7, we were good family friends with many of them.

He’d been on play dates many times, we’d socialised with them, and have gone on to become firm friends. I trust these people, as they trust DH and me.

Just bide your time, and perhaps only get worked up about it, if your judgment is really poor, and you’ve ended up befriending someone who comes across as dodgy. Or something. Confused

LoveMyCats1 · 31/10/2022 21:36

10 is too old yabu

ldontWanna · 31/10/2022 21:33

DD had her first sleepover at 8. We had other children come much younger, but she'd never been invited until then. Tbh, it was just about the right age for her. She was quite nervous and anxious but it went well. The invites kept coming and now at 10 she happily skips off without a backward glance.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 31/10/2022 21:29

I completely agree with you OP. My DD is 9 and has been to one friend’s house and that was after years of my friendship with her mum and building trust. I think that it can be very scary for children to have to sleep somewhere they suddenly don’t want to be and I made sure DD had a phone with her when she went to her friends.

EmmaDilemma5 · 31/10/2022 21:28

Fundays12 · 31/10/2022 21:25

Though for safety reasons I don’t know if I would have allowed it at all.

Is being fair about treating everyone the same though?

If you have three children, one with additional needs, is it really 'fair' to restrict the younger two just because the eldest can't?

If your eldest was unable to access water, would you tell the others they can't swim?

If your eldest couldn't go to university, would you suggest your youngest don't go too?

Rather than hold your younger ones back from experiences, why don't you adapt it. So eldest gets a different treat, maybe a day out with a friend involved, or something special for their bedroom. That would be more fair to me.

Brefugee · 31/10/2022 21:28

I think that she should not go to a sleepover until she is at least 10y, able to communicate if she wants to come home, confident enough to speak up for herself and able to tell me if something has upset her.

well it's your job to teach her to be like this.
but arguing about this with a 3 year old is pointless and daft. You have to let your child grow at their own pace, she might be ready at 7, she might not ever want to do it. It is your job as a parent to k now these things

EmmaDilemma5 · 31/10/2022 21:25

Notimeforaname · 30/10/2022 21:52

So youre definitely safe but no1 else is. Sleepovers are not safe for your child but fine for others. Right.

Well that is how life goes, we can only know ourselves.

Are you suggesting that the OP actually is a risk (even though she knows she isn't)?

Or are you saying because she knows she's not a risk she should think the same of everyone else?

Fundays12 · 31/10/2022 21:25

Fundays12 · 31/10/2022 21:22

My kids don’t go to sleepovers. Eldest has additional needs plus medications etc and wouldn’t cope so we don’t allow him to go which means the others (6 and 3 years) won’t either as otherwise it’s unfair on my eldest. I wouldn’t allow a child to go till about 8 even if I could and not to someone I didn’t know.

Though for safety reasons I don’t know if I would have allowed it at all.

Fundays12 · 31/10/2022 21:22

My kids don’t go to sleepovers. Eldest has additional needs plus medications etc and wouldn’t cope so we don’t allow him to go which means the others (6 and 3 years) won’t either as otherwise it’s unfair on my eldest. I wouldn’t allow a child to go till about 8 even if I could and not to someone I didn’t know.

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 31/10/2022 21:12

Energydrink · 30/10/2022 22:02

I guess the following statistics have me rattled

1 in 5 girls are SA
mostly between 5yo and 17yo
and rarely by strangers (family, friends etc)

his response is that there is a 4 in 5 chance that it won’t happen. I couldn’t bear having to tell my DD sorry for making the wrong judgement call

I totally agree with you, I have no history of childhood sexual abuse but those statistics are too high to take a risk. Your husband is a man,it is not something he would have to worry about on the same scale as a woman

rhowton · 31/10/2022 21:03

My DD will only be staying with my friends and their children or my immediate families.

She won't be going to school friends houses for sleepovers until senior school. Ill collect her at 10pm, but she won't be sleeping over.