Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you insist your kids sit “properly” at the dinner table?

208 replies

SirMoose · 30/10/2022 21:29

Please help with this massive parenting disagreement between me and my husband!

yabu: no excuses, children should always be sat nicely with chair tucked in, legs dangling down and not up on the chair.

yanbu: it doesn’t really matter at home if they slouch or have a leg bent up.

OP posts:
DelurkingAJ · 31/10/2022 08:08

LeMoo · 30/10/2022 21:37

@SirMoose have a look at the wobble cushions you can get on amazon. Really good for helping children sit still.

Also I voted yabu

Yes to a wobble cushion. DS1 (ASD and incapable of sitting still…Ed Psych said it was sensory feedback seeking) sits beautifully with a wobble cushion.

SirMoose · 31/10/2022 08:05

emptythelitterbox · 31/10/2022 08:02

How were you and your husband treated as children?

Were they strict?

We both had very strict, loveless, joyless upbringings. The only difference is I’m trying to not make the same mistakes with my kids whereas he seems to be wanting to repeat the cycle.

OP posts:
SirMoose · 31/10/2022 08:04

CaronPoivre · 31/10/2022 08:01

I suspect the issue is less about whether an average eight year old can sit still at a table and use cutlery - they can. Many children as young as five sit quietly through an hours church service or at a younger age through library story time quite regularly.
The issue is your disagreement and a child being able to manipulate the situation to allow them the upper hand. Why would they cry if being asked to sit properly? That’s playing emotional games and is being supported and encouraged. You need to both be adults, decide on what the rules are and stick to them together otherwise manipulative behaviours will increase and the poor child will end up thinking they get to control family life, with disastrous consequences.

She’s not manipulative at all she’s stressed. When it’s just us she’s fine. Meal times are enjoyable. I still pull her up on sitting nicely but I ask her nicely and I don’t tell her off.

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 31/10/2022 08:02

How were you and your husband treated as children?

Were they strict?

CaronPoivre · 31/10/2022 08:01

I suspect the issue is less about whether an average eight year old can sit still at a table and use cutlery - they can. Many children as young as five sit quietly through an hours church service or at a younger age through library story time quite regularly.
The issue is your disagreement and a child being able to manipulate the situation to allow them the upper hand. Why would they cry if being asked to sit properly? That’s playing emotional games and is being supported and encouraged. You need to both be adults, decide on what the rules are and stick to them together otherwise manipulative behaviours will increase and the poor child will end up thinking they get to control family life, with disastrous consequences.

Bookishish · 31/10/2022 07:49

I’m not clear on what she’s actually doing- in one post you say making a mess, falling off the chair etc and in another it’s just having a leg up. If she’s falling off the chair a lot then it’s a safety issue, not just manners.

But really this isn’t about that but the fact both you and your husband are failing to compromise or parent appropriately. It’s really not about who is right and wrong regarding sitting at the table, but that you haven’t been able to find any sort of compromise or agreed way of approaching it. Two adults should not be screaming and swearing at each other over this sort of thing.

Can you not agree that you’d like her to sit properly but that the current approach isn’t working, and think together about what might work better. A stool is a really good idea to put her feet on. And take steps in the right direction- if she manages to sit well for a few minutes, praise her for that.

SirMoose · 31/10/2022 07:41

Bramblejoos · 31/10/2022 07:38

My DB is 7 years younger than me. I always sat at the table - reasonable manners from copying DM. DB chomps and slurps -awful!! But by the time he came along DPs ate in front of tele.

be prepared for noisy eaters - you can’t hear the slurping above the tele.

Definitely no noisy eating tolerated. I’m pretty sure I have misophonia. The sound of people eating can fill me with such rage I need to leave the house.

OP posts:
Bramblejoos · 31/10/2022 07:38

My DB is 7 years younger than me. I always sat at the table - reasonable manners from copying DM. DB chomps and slurps -awful!! But by the time he came along DPs ate in front of tele.

be prepared for noisy eaters - you can’t hear the slurping above the tele.

lannistunut · 31/10/2022 07:33

SirMoose · 30/10/2022 21:34

8 year old. Just finds it completely possible to sit in a bloody chair. It’s an argument that happens every dinner time now to the point it’s causing everyone anxiety.

At 8 I would focus on the essentials but not expect perfection, no. What harm comes from having a leg bent?

Sitting still is quite a stretch for 8yos but also the arguments/stress will be making it worse.

Is there any difference when your DH is not at the table? I would not like to eat with him - where are HIS manners?

madnesss · 31/10/2022 07:31

I find it bizarre that you suspect ADHD/ASD and school are keeping an eye on her, yet you have no idea if she has problems sitting in school.

Also, your husbands behaviour towards a child who may have a disability is disgraceful. Let her sit as she feels comfortable, she isn't a performing robot. I think you both need to lower your expectations tbh, you have a lot of 'rules' which, if she is autistic will be causing her distress to adhere to. Open your world and learn about your child's needs and out those before your list of table expectations.

Benjispruce4 · 31/10/2022 07:29

Personally it does matter how they eat at home at that age as that is where the lifelong habits are formed . It’s rude to put feet on chairs, so she must learn not to do it at home. She would be told not to at school or in someone else’s house it would be considered rude so you need to help her to recognise that.

Benjispruce4 · 31/10/2022 07:27

Does she fidget a lot? Could she have adhd?

SirMoose · 31/10/2022 07:21

I absolutely care about table manners.

she must use a knife and fork correctly, she must eat with her mouth closed, she must scrape her plate and put it in the dishwasher when finished. I like her to sit up in her chair but as I’ve said quite a few times now, I’m not that bothered about a leg being tucked under her. This is where me and husband are clashing.

OP posts:
GeorgeorRuth · 31/10/2022 07:18

Lulu1919 · 31/10/2022 06:29

Yes
Bottom on chair
Facing forwards
Knife and fork
No elbows
Asking to leave the table
Please and thank you

Yes to this and add mouth closed while chewing.

LuciferRising · 31/10/2022 07:17

I sit with a leg often tucked up. At under 5 foot sitting 'nicely' is bloody uncomfortable. Daughter similar. We are both well behaved around guests and at resturants.

emptythelitterbox · 31/10/2022 07:15

Will she sit at the table properly when her father isn't home?

I like the idea about something to put her feet on. I always feel funny sitting on what I perceive to be tall chairs. You mentioned her being smaller so she may feel funny. Also, some chairs are unbearably uncomfortable. When they are, I can't help but fidget or sit on one leg.

I'd let it go for the most part. Try to have a peaceful mealtime. Tell her father to stop insisting.

LolaSmiles · 31/10/2022 07:15

It's hard to establish whether there's a potential sensory need or SEN there or whether she's being a typical child who has realised her parents aren't on the same page and this can be exploited.

If you know your DH cares about table manners and then she's allowed to sit how she likes and table manners aren't expected by you for 5 days then you're partially responsible for the upset on the other 2 because she's being set up to fail.

Your DC might have sensory needs and require some adjustments, but it's hard to establish that when you and your husband aren't on the same page and are disagreeing in front of her.

AshGirl · 31/10/2022 07:12

Only read the OP's posts but I immediately thought ADHD and/ or ASD given that your DD also doesn't sit 'properly' in other settings. Very very common amongst ND folk.

I think someone else has mentioned wobble cushions, and other practical solutions.

As for your DH, if he accepts that she may be ND then he needs to accept that she may not be able to sit in the way he prefers - and it is just a social preference!. If she is sitting (in any position) at the table and eating then that is a major win for a ND child!

maddiemookins16mum · 31/10/2022 07:05

Do her feet touch the floor? It’s really uncomfortable otherwise, try a step or something, she sits on the chair, feet on the step/stool etc, see how it goes. It’s one of the reasons kids kick the back of seats on planes, there legs are dangling and get restless.

FleecyMcFleeceFace · 31/10/2022 07:03
  1. Sitting oddly/uncomfortably even when prompted suggests some sort of issue with sitting properly. So on one front, you investigate that problem - ask the teacher for feedback, observe her in other settings (you said sofa sitting also unusual) like restaurants, friends' houses, her at table when Dad isn't there.
  1. Try a wobble cushion either under her bum or her feet, or a stool (especially a tilty one for sensory feedback). Observe any changes.
  1. You and dh need to discuss this away from the dinner table and come to an agreement. Then stick to your joint plan. Talk her through your agreed plan. The first part of the plan should be observing without correcting. Talk together ( without dc) about what you see. Your perspectives will differ.
  1. I suspect there is a wider issue with you and dh not communicating well, undermining each other. Kids pick this stuff up.
Arewethereyet22 · 31/10/2022 06:45

Nope, mine are up and down like the energiser bunny. Doesn’t bother me, they know how to sit at school/in public I don’t enforce this at home as long as they eat their meal.

TeenDivided · 31/10/2022 06:37

I'm wondering whether there could be poor core stability / dyspraxia.
Worth looking in to.

And sitting completely properly is not worth this level of argument.

In the same way we gave up trying to get DD2 to use a knife and fork 'correctly' - she just couldn't do it. Turns out she has dyspraxia, as does DD1.

Lulu1919 · 31/10/2022 06:29

Yes
Bottom on chair
Facing forwards
Knife and fork
No elbows
Asking to leave the table
Please and thank you

SirMoose · 31/10/2022 06:08

Intru · 31/10/2022 01:03

But you have a severe eating disorder and, according to your own posts, compromised executive function.

Given this, why are you so sure that your approach is in the right?

Oh you advance searched me you saddo. My eating disorder has nothing to do with my ability to parent my child thanks. I’m not going to respond to you anymore because I can see you being awful on other threads too so you’re clearly a troll.

OP posts:
CoalCraft · 31/10/2022 06:08

Also this thread has reminded me of my dad sternly telling me to get my elbows off the table and that I was holding my knife and fork in the wrong hands... Nonsense! Why would you want people to be uncomfortable??

My kids will be allowed to sit how they like at the table. As long as they're sat down and eating as tidily as their motor skills allow with no books/screens I don't see what else matters (they're a baby and toddler at the moment and the toddler's doing great with cutlery, bless her)