Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to consider a future with DD staying at home?

304 replies

Thefutureisorangey · 30/10/2022 17:03

Family consists of me, DH, DS (19, at university) and DD (16, in yr 11). We are starting to think about retirement but can't afford it without downsizing significantly. There is no other family.
DD is lovely, sweet, honest and vulnerable. Many diagnoses, including ASD, but not helpless - she just doesn't enjoy the chaos and noise of the world. We think she might scrape some grade 4s in her GCSEs. A levels wouldn't be academically appropriate, and our local colleges, though great and providing a brilliant provision, are rowdy and bustling.
So here is my AIBU. DD is showing no signs of ever wanting to fly the nest. She has explained this. We have tried to broaden her horizons but she is so introverted that even holidays now, if we could afford them, would be problematic. She wants to live with us "forever."
Has anybody got experience of this? In just a few months the school is going to want to know where her "destination" will be. Apprenticeships are crazily competitive, level 3 qualifications will be almost certainly too difficult for her, the level 2 qualifications that she's interested in are all very male-centred roles that she has recoiled from when she's actually experienced the environment, and I'm not sure what to do with her!
If we allow her to just stay at home, cleaning, cooking, volunteering for local old folk (which will very soon be us!), is that even an allowed thing?

OP posts:
mylifestory · 01/11/2022 14:27

The question is, what does she want to do in the short term of she hasnt thought about the long term seriously which is perfectly fine for any 16 year old. You made it sound a lot about you

Ellyess · 01/11/2022 14:23

I think you are being perfectly normal! Everybody has a picture of the future. In your case, you have a child who will remain a child longer than most others and will perhaps not want to 'fly the nest'.
None of us can see the future, so I would suggest you just take one day at a time. If you need to downsize soon, maybe you could still afford a three-bed house, so your DS has a room in the holidays. If not, then a 2-bed place, but many 3-bed houses are around the same price.
Your DD will change as she grows. She will become a woman, but at this stage now it's just not possible to imagine. So try and have faith and let things unfold as they go along, and try not to worry. You understand your DD so well, I am moved by how well you describe her, it seems to me she is better off with you for the next few years, and you would be so worried if she were not with you. Let time take care of the future.
Luckily for me, I have a great faith in God, given me not from my background but from a striking experience. If you can let go and let God take over, it is amazing how things seem to just sort out and fall into place. I shall pray for you all. I know it's not easy for everyone to have the same faith I have.
With all my best wishes and prayers.

justdoingmyduty · 01/11/2022 13:40

My DS is 23. It is just me and him living together at home. He has ASD, ADHD, OCD and general social anxiety. As a young child he couldn't cope with the school environment so I decided to home educate him. We did this for 10 years, but when DS was 15 he wanted to do something more. As he had no GCSEs and no real classroom experience, they had to start him at the very bottom of the educational rung. He did a year in an offsite campus for NEETs with additional needs. This was supposed to be a 2 year programme for 16-18 year olds, but after a year, they felt that he could be integrated into the main college and take a level 1 course. There were limited options, but DS chose IT has he like computers and gaming. They also gave him the opportunity to take Maths & English GCSE resit classes to see if he could take them too. I told him to try it and if he didn't like it or found it too hard, we could think again next September.

Fast forward 6 years, DS took IT levels 1, 2, level 3 which was a 2 year course during lockdown while learning remotely, level 4 HNC and level 5 HND. He passed his Maths and English GCSEs through the resit classes and also took A-Level Maths. He is currently doing an apprenticeship within the MOD.

Every year he likes to have plans about moving out and starting his own life, but he also knows that this would be difficult for him, even more so with the cost of living crisis. But every year he says, maybe I'll think about it next year. DS is 23 now and plans on staying at home until he is at least 27, then he will rethink his moving out plan. We had a lot of family and friends tell us that he would never achieve anything in his life and would never succeed in education. I always told him that he could do anything he wants to do, no matter how hard he thinks it will be. If he wants to move out then I will support him. If he chooses to stay I will support him too. I just want him to be safe and happy!

We never knew where his life would go and it's a massive thing that he has achieved so much and I'm so proud of him. But if he hadn't managed it, I would have been proud of him anyway. I keep reminding him to take one day at a time, and there's a first time for everything! We don't know how we are going to be able to deal with a situation until we are in that situation, so you might as well try.

There might not be a suitable course for your DD now, but something might come up in the future. Or there might never be the right course or the right time. Life will happen as it happen, just make every day count. My DS always says that it doesn't matter what you are doing, as long as you are doing something! Even if it just reading a book or watching your favourite movie.

CountessVimes · 01/11/2022 11:49

Does your DD have an EHCP? My son effectively missed yr 10/11 due to MH issues and left with only 3 GCSE's which although good are not enough. He was not capable of dealing with a bustling/busy college or sixth form even if they would have taken him and he would never have coped with an apprenticeship having to deal with not one but potentially 2 new environments. The local SENDiass department in our council proved incredibly helpful (surprisingly). We didn't think he would be able to go anywhere but they suggested a tiny college which we didn't even know existed. And I work in edcuation and though I knew of them all. They specialised in supporting teens with needs and only take a small handful of students each year. It has been the making of him and although he still struggles has blossomed more each year in ways we never expected. Please keep fighting and looking for ways to expand your DD's world, far too soon to make it so small.

whizzyrocket · 01/11/2022 11:45

I’m another asd parent, although mine are still primary age. It seems to me that if she only copes with a “small world” then that is the sort of workplace you need to set her up for. How is she with impulse control and recognising what is safe? Could she work with machinery? People with autism are often very detail oriented. Would carpentry/joinery appeal? Or agriculture? Or horticulture? There are plenty of jobs out there where the majority of it is done solo.

Horticulture is a field (excuse the pun) in which there are a lot of quiet, very caring people who would be understanding. It is also a joyful thing to do with your life with a great diversity of opportunities.

You can direct her toward a lot of courses and move to somewhere busier, but if she does not cope with the hubbub, isn’t she more likely to shut down? She needs to be steered into a quiet groove where she can feel comfortable around a few people I think, not toward the melée.

Saracen · 01/11/2022 11:00

Mollymoostoo · 31/10/2022 23:43

It isn't voluntary. It is law that a YP must be in education or training. If a YP doesn't engage, parents can be prosecuted qnd any voluntary placements must offer training.
Most FE colleges offer supported learning programmes that teach life skills and emoyability.

Not true. The parents' legal duty to educate their young person ends when the child finishes Compulsry School Age, which is the last Friday in June in the school year in which the child turns 16. That hasn't changed.

Raising the participation age did place a legal duty on the young person to remain in education or training until their 18th birthday, but to date no penalties have been enacted for noncompliance. Aside from the benefits system (which in most cases prevents parents claiming for young people who aren't in full-time nonadvanced education, and prevents most under-18s from claiming in their own right) there are no consequences for failing to comply.

The door is open for the government to enact criminal penalties for noncompliance, but they haven't announced an intention to do so. I think it unlikely that they will do so any time soon, given that they haven't been able to provide decent universal access to suitable courses. It would be embarrassing to be seen to be prosecuting young people who want to go to college and can't.

Saracen · 01/11/2022 10:48

Whatsleftnow · 30/10/2022 17:44

can I offer an alternative pov? As a ND teen, she is probably developmentally younger than her peers, possibly more like a 12 or 13 year old. If you think of her in that age range, what decisions would you be making?

She might manage her educational, and work opportunities better when she’s slightly older, so would returning to school or doing some training be an opportunity you would support in her twenties?

I would be very concerned about shutting her down too soon. With autism it’s very hard to get going again, so keeping some level of outside-the-house activity (education or work) would be a top priority even if it doesn’t amount to very much.

I’ve found lockdown set my ds back massively in terms of going out in crowds, travelling, public transport etc. It’s a long, slow climb back up. Are there any supports and services available to her, encouraging independence? Use whatever you possibly can before these disappear when she’s an adult.

(Sorry haven't RTFT, but have read all the OP's posts...) I agree completely with @Whatsleftnow . You don't have to have your DD's whole life planned out now. She is not yet ready for certain things, but she may be later.

I've been very reassured by my discussions with a friend who was a foster carer for decades; four of her young people stayed with her for many years. She specialised in taking on vulnerable young women, who often had neurodiversity. She told me that they tended to mature very significantly well into their 20s. For instance, she might have predicted that a particular 18yo would never be able to cope on her own, but by 25 she was quite capable. This is at odds with the view which our society and especially the school system pushes, which says young people suddenly become adults at 16/18 and need to be out in the world functioning completely with no help by that age.

I have a 16yo with a learning disability (not autism). She is much "younger" than her same-age peers. College isn't the right option in the near future, but maybe when she is older. She has been home educated all her life and so I think I have a different perspective, as we aren't surrounded by people saying BUT SHE'S FINISHED SCHOOL WHAT IS SHE GOING TO DO NOW?? I just keep on doing what I've been doing. For now, my job is to keep exposing her to different things and experiences and to keep developing her life skills and academic skills. She learned to read at 14 and is now getting to grips with arithmetic. She has no qualifications yet, but I think she may be ready for Functional Skills exams later on. The key point is that there's no hurry. She can move into the world as she is ready. It isn't a case of "grow up instantly or live your whole life with your parents".

When I talk to her about her future, I reassure her that she can live with us for a good few years to come. In passing, I also mention other possibilities for her future. She loves pets, for example, so I tell her that of course she can have as many pets as she is able to look after if she's living elsewhere, but many landlords don't allow pets so it might be tricky, and she will probably be house-sharing or living with a partner so she had better find someone else who likes pets too. So she starts to build visions of a future which doesn't involve living with us, and she starts to think about how to achieve her ambitions.

We talk about the types of jobs which suit different people, and watch people at work. She has done a bit of volunteering and will do more later. She knows eventually she'll need to get a job.

I would say my daughter's maturity level is about that of a 10 or 12 year old, and that is how I treat her. Long-term, her prospects are excellent. I don't have to make her do what other 16 year olds are doing. Her chronological age is a red herring.

DenaJT · 01/11/2022 09:09

I have a young friend on the ASD radar. They go to a college course specifically aimed at people with challenges with getting into employment. The course is called "Gateway to Employment" at Nartgarw college in Wales. The college even helps with placing the students in a work experience initially wide a view to being employed by that company. Worth a look to see if you have something similar locally.

Thatsnotmycar · 01/11/2022 09:06

Mollymoostoo · 31/10/2022 23:43

It isn't voluntary. It is law that a YP must be in education or training. If a YP doesn't engage, parents can be prosecuted qnd any voluntary placements must offer training.
Most FE colleges offer supported learning programmes that teach life skills and emoyability.

Yes, I didn’t think @Exsurrey was correct about it being voluntary.

Lindos · 01/11/2022 08:37

I suggest you read Leonard and Hungry Paul. It’s a lovely book with two male characters that live happily with their parents into adulthood. Both men and very different from your daughter but they don’t follow the usual path of leaving home.

toomuchlaundry · 01/11/2022 08:23

@Stewball01 you can’t put that expectation on a sibling

Stewball01 · 01/11/2022 08:11

For the future, would your son not take care of her?

toomuchlaundry · 01/11/2022 07:00

@Autumn61 that is like going back in time when the spinster daughter had to stay at home whilst all her other siblings moved out and had lives of their own

SimonaRazowska · 01/11/2022 06:56

@Autumn61 to me the idea of keeping a child at home for being quiet, and the added “benefit of her being able to look after her parents when they get old” is fairly archaic and selfish ;from the parents

give her wings, instead of clipping them

16 is young and a lot can change

Autumn61 · 01/11/2022 06:37

Hopefully, when her parents pass (?- good bit in the future) she will have had contact with social services and other Health Care Providers. She sounds as though she will be able to ‘keep house and look after herself assuming the environment she is in is suitable . Having her around when your are at a stage in your life when you need assistance, is a win win situation. Saying that, she is still a young woman and things may change for her if she gets the right kind of support. I only have one out of theee left at home and the third one frequently talks about ‘when he moves out’. If it was up to me I would keep him forever 🥲 My husband on the other hand ……

musingsinmidlife · 01/11/2022 06:00

It sounds like there is a codependency issue maybe. You don’t believe she can ever accomplish anything or have any independence so to you her sitting in your house for the rest of her life is a good option. She is 16 and isolating her now and allowing her to avoid any future interaction or education or having any independence or doing anything meaningful with her life is setting her up for problems. There are few people who thrive on sitting at one doing nothing for decades. It can lead to even more entrenched mental health issues and a deep unhappiness.

I would actually instead encourage her and support her in building independent skills and engaging in things she does enjoy so there are meaningful activities in her life and in finding ways to encourage mastery.

Don’t write her off at 16.

Spck · 01/11/2022 05:05

Has anyone come across a supported provision which offers courses in foreign language learning? My dd with ASD has a passion for learning foreign languages, did well at gcse but struggles hugely with writing extended essays so A levels weren’t possible. There doesn’t seem an alternative route into languages - I can’t find a btec type provision. It’s the only thing she has any spark for at all.

CatsnCoffee · 01/11/2022 03:02

OP, you tell us what your daughter dislikes and what she struggles with but you don’t say what she likes and what she can do.
I sympathise with your fears for her managing outside your home, but do your hopes for her not extend beyond teenage and adult life caring for her elderly parents and then being left, isolated when they die? This isn’t the 1800s. What are you doing to help her confidence and what are you doing to reinforce her low aspirations?
If she doesn’t pass Maths and English she will have to re-sit them in a further education setting. Do you have a local school with a sixth form? This wouldn’t be the rowdy, noisy environment you fear for her. Some sixth forms cater for GCSE re-sits and she could take an additional subject at a higher level (BTec etc), maybe in a vocational subject.
If you haven’t already, you could start giving her experiences to gain confidence outside the house. Accompany her to the train station and assist her to buy a ticket to the next stop. Arrange to meet her there and treat her to a coffee shop visit before returning home by the same method. Gradually, you can build on this until she can manage the trip unaided. Unless she’s likely to need a carer for her needs when you’re not there, she will need life skills like this.
Please don’t mistake introversion for feebleness. Enjoying solitude is something many people find very difficult. If you imagine her cooking and cleaning for you she’s definitely a capable person in her own right. Why should you use her as an unpaid carer in your old age? Do you intend to give her a salary (the least she deserves for a life of drudgery)? Does she have a say in her future? It sounds like you’re thinking of yourself and expecting her just to acquiesce.

THEDEACON · 01/11/2022 00:12

No point marrying her off to a farmer We farmer's wives need educatiotions to degree level and careers of our own to provide for the farm and the family You need to speak to the ASN staff at school for advice

Mollymoostoo · 31/10/2022 23:43

Thatsnotmycar · 31/10/2022 22:56

Do you have a link to support being in some form of education, training or employment with part time education/training until 18 is voluntary? Because I didn’t think it was and this government guidance doesn’t say the duty on young people to remain in education, training or employment with part time education/training unless one of the exceptions applies is voluntary.

EHCPs can last until 25 or 26 in some cases.

It isn't voluntary. It is law that a YP must be in education or training. If a YP doesn't engage, parents can be prosecuted qnd any voluntary placements must offer training.
Most FE colleges offer supported learning programmes that teach life skills and emoyability.

Mollymoostoo · 31/10/2022 23:40

OK so I work in FE and I need to say a couple of things

  1. She is 16 and is transitioning from school to 'what ever next'. This is a tough time for anyone, your child is going to feel this change even more having ASD.
  2. At 16 she can't make decisions for the rest of her life. Right now she wants to stay at home. She is 16, this is normal. At 25, she may feel differently.
  3. She does need to be in education or training of some sort. If she doesn't secure something she will be NEET and you could be prosecuted. In reality you probably won't be, but you could be.
  4. If she takes a job, even voluntary, there must be a training element to it. I would recommend something like the PDSA, RSPCA, dogs trust or some other charity where she can do voluntary work and training alongside.
People aged 16-18 with SEND can't just take a job as a cleaner. If she has an EHCP the LA has to support till aged 25.

Get proper advice and don't ask people on a forum who don't understand the system. Find your local parent partnership and get support and advice. And don't project your fears. She deserves to have a life and be safe and secure financially. This might be uncomfortable in the immediate future but will help prepare her for the future.

pollymere · 31/10/2022 23:15

It is a worry as there's such pressure for them to stay in education until 18. Our local college offers work experience courses, or you could consider traineeships. I am fortunate that we pulled ours from school so we can officially home educate until they feel ready to study.

Thatsnotmycar · 31/10/2022 22:56

Do you have a link to support being in some form of education, training or employment with part time education/training until 18 is voluntary? Because I didn’t think it was and this government guidance doesn’t say the duty on young people to remain in education, training or employment with part time education/training unless one of the exceptions applies is voluntary.

EHCPs can last until 25 or 26 in some cases.

Exsurrey · 31/10/2022 22:41

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 31/10/2022 21:19

There are people from the council that do check up on it. My friend is part of the team on our area that does.

Local authorities have a statutory duty to ensure all young people are in some form of education, employment or training. This is up until a young person is 18 (or 24 if they have an EHCP). There is no consequence if a young person decided not to engage though. Engagement is voluntary. The only thing that changes is a parents right to claim child benefit from 16yrs - 18yrs if the child is not in education.

some LAs offer support to help a young person to find appropriate education, employment or training. Other LAs don’t. They will all have a tracking team to chase young people and their destinations. This figure (note the number of young people, not the names of the young people) from the local authority is then reported to central government.

roarfeckingroarr · 31/10/2022 21:48

You could leave the house to her, not your son, if her needs are greater and he's self sufficient by then.

I have no advice but you sound like a truly loving, lovely mum.