Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU: Territorial Behaviour

68 replies

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 14:09

We are a family of 4, DH, DD17, DS19 (away at Uni) and me. We have a busy home with a lot of commitments.

DD17 has a BF of 3 years. He is lovely, they get on very well. He is helpful and cooks, cleans up and always offers to go to the shops etc (he drives). He is here a lot.

BF's Dad does not like DD and BF staying as he "needs space to relax" and his wife is unkind to DD and picks at her constantly, BF's mum's husband has a health condition and can't abide any noise in the house. I am happy for them to be here any or all of the time.

DH has started getting angry at BF being at our house. When I ask why he says he wants it to be "just us, the 3 of us". I disagree, it is her home and BF is no problem, I want to spend much time with DD as possible and accept that they come as a pair a lot of the time now.

Today he had massive tantrum screaming that other men get their homes to themselves. I responded by pointing out the myriad of ways in which our families and homes were different. He has stormed off.

DD does spend lots of time with us on her own and is far more than the average 17yo due to my work and disability.

Who is BU?

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · 30/10/2022 16:00

Yes - compromise is the way forward. It doesn’t matter who’s wrong or right, or why he likes the house private and you don’t. That’s all irrelevant. You have a difference of opinion so compromise. Try to find out what annoys your DH most - is it the BF being there every weekend, for example? Find out, then plan compromises - a middle way.

Some people can’t fully relax with ‘strangers’ in their home, no matter how nice they are. That’s a character difference not a failing. Your DH sounds stressed. You say he’s become more withdrawn - perhaps try to find out why, and see if he needs support from you.

roarfeckingroarr · 30/10/2022 15:53

He sounds like a difficult man to live with. You're handling this well OP.

LuckyLil · 30/10/2022 15:48

I think what you need here is compromise. It does come over a bit like you are ganging up on him just because you like the bf being there frequently. Your husband clearly doesn't like it and it's all well and good you feeling he's pushing DD away, but has it occurred to you he might feel pushed out himself?

OriginalUsername3 · 30/10/2022 15:48

I think it's partly male possession over his property, "my house" "my females" and also parental possession over "my children". He doesn't want another man getting comfortable in his house, taking his women away from him. And he doesn't want his child to grow up and distance herself from him and stop being the little girl who thought he was her hero and relished every little bit of attention he gave her.

And on both counts, tough shit. Life moves on, people grow up. He can embrace the now and the future or he can push it, and her, away.

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 15:44

autienotnaughty · 30/10/2022 15:42

I wouldn't accept this. If your dh stops dd bf staying she will spend time with him else where and you lose time with her (and potentially it could impact on your relationship) 3 times a week is not excessive. I'd be telling dh to enjoy his time on the 4 other nights of the week.

This is where I am atm.

Also I am very introverted, but he has become misanthropic in the last 5 years, this is the observation of everyone around us, not me.

OP posts:
autienotnaughty · 30/10/2022 15:42

I wouldn't accept this. If your dh stops dd bf staying she will spend time with him else where and you lose time with her (and potentially it could impact on your relationship) 3 times a week is not excessive. I'd be telling dh to enjoy his time on the 4 other nights of the week.

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 15:40

Thanks for all your comments, it's really got me thinking along some new lines. Appreciated.

OP posts:
OhmygodDont · 30/10/2022 15:37

So it’s ok if they feed him and tell him his/his stuffs great. That’s not an introvert that’s just an ego thing.

Im and introvert and understand and put myself out to make sure my children still have sleepovers and have friends round.

haha my mum is so the type to eat a pukka pie on the sofa watching Trashy tv as a family where as my I laws are dinner at the table much more like myself (for the children anyway 😅) so I get it. I tend to hate most tv.

CeciliaMars · 30/10/2022 15:30

Compromise and agree on no more than 2 nights a week?

LunaBlueSkies · 30/10/2022 15:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 15:11

picklemewalnuts · 30/10/2022 15:05

Have you reflected on an ASD component to his and his parents' behaviour? Could there be a lot of misunderstanding of relationships/feelings and resistance to change going on?

I find it helpful with my family members with autistic traits to simply reflect things back at them, without challenging it.

So I might say to your DH, 'She's growing up, isn't she? I suppose we have to accept that eventually other people will be more important to her than us.'
'It's lovely he makes her happy, and is so helpful to us. It does feel a bit strange to have him joining our family like this. We often don't like change.'
'I wonder whether it's difficult for you to see her changing, and becoming so grown up?'.

That tends to help mine

I wasn't going to mention any of this, because it is not strictly relevant but DH almost certainly has undiagnosed ASD. I met him when I was 18 and by 24 was running a service facilitating education for young people with high functioning ASD. I qualified as a Ed Psych and after years of gentle chit chat he did a screening which was very strongly suggesting a full clinical diagnosis. He refused. He will not discuss it or read about it. So yes, I am not unaware and have discussed this with DH and DD. DD is very happy to have her diagnosis and makes excellent use of support. I am very proud of her and how far she has come.

OP posts:
HelenWick · 30/10/2022 15:06

OhmygodDont · 30/10/2022 14:59

Out of interest and to prove a point op. How was he with ds’s girlfriends.

DS has had the same GF for 4 years but she was shielding for the whole of Covid (v vulnerable family member) and they have a hobby they do which means that she was rarely here other than for an afternoon here and there. She is from a very different background and thinks we're a bit much, which I can see we are for many. I think GFs worst nightmare would be sitting on the sofa with us all eating off our laps Royale Family style whereas BF just cosies himself in 😂😂

DS does have a couple of mates that were round a lot and DH got ratty with them, unless they brought him food and told him he had a great record collection 😂

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 30/10/2022 15:05

Have you reflected on an ASD component to his and his parents' behaviour? Could there be a lot of misunderstanding of relationships/feelings and resistance to change going on?

I find it helpful with my family members with autistic traits to simply reflect things back at them, without challenging it.

So I might say to your DH, 'She's growing up, isn't she? I suppose we have to accept that eventually other people will be more important to her than us.'
'It's lovely he makes her happy, and is so helpful to us. It does feel a bit strange to have him joining our family like this. We often don't like change.'
'I wonder whether it's difficult for you to see her changing, and becoming so grown up?'.

That tends to help mine

OhmygodDont · 30/10/2022 14:59

Out of interest and to prove a point op. How was he with ds’s girlfriends.

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 14:58

I'm not going to bother replying to the "you don't like DH much" trolls other than this:

Obviously I do because I remain married to him despite his misanthropy driving all his mates away over the last 10 years. It is perfectly possible to love someone deeply, with great loyalty and commitment, and still think they are being a fucking idiot and making themselves deeply unhappy.

OP posts:
HelenWick · 30/10/2022 14:55

Abitofalark · 30/10/2022 14:49

It sounds too much for him. Can't he ever have a week, including a weekend, without the visitor? Breathing space. Private space. The family unit. Not an overly regular or frequent extra presence. And there's possibly a feeling of mother and children all bunching up together and he a bit of an outsider or on his own in terms of influence on what happens in the family? Calling it boring or whatever is dismissive. A weekend visit every other week perhaps and once a week on weekdays in between, might be enough for him.

Yes I think that would be enough for him but it would not get the result he wants. DD would be out with BF he'll be here with me or by himself. He can't demand his 17yo sits next to him on the sofa watching reruns of Spongebob forever! (however lovely that might be)

OP posts:
nokidshere · 30/10/2022 14:53

@HundredMilesAnHour I was just about to type exactly that.

OP you don't sound like you like your DH much tbh, maybe that's the problem?

He has as much right to not want him there as you do for being ok with it. You need to talk to him and see if you can work out an arrangement that suits everyone.

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 14:52

picklemewalnuts · 30/10/2022 14:45

Have you asked him whether he wants the same relationship with his DD as he has with his parents?

Yes, he got upset and said he was nothing like them. He viscerally hates them. It is very hard work.

OP posts:
HelenWick · 30/10/2022 14:51

OhmygodDont · 30/10/2022 14:43

It’s exactly that. His daughter is his daughter not her bf’s, gf. His struggling to let go of her being his it’s not healthy for him or her if he gets away with it.

At 17 I’m surprised she thinks one night a whole month is good tbh but sounds like she knows what her dads like.

They have been on holiday together 3 times as well, for a week each time.

DD is only 17 and obviously in love, she has high functioning ASD and her alexithymia means it is hard for her to understand a lot of aspects of her emotions. We have spent a lot of time discussing her choices and how she moves forward with her relationship to make sure that she is not going to fast or getting muddled between sex/love etc. I understand that this might seem very odd to some but she brings these things to me and it works for us to have this agreement.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 30/10/2022 14:49

It sounds too much for him. Can't he ever have a week, including a weekend, without the visitor? Breathing space. Private space. The family unit. Not an overly regular or frequent extra presence. And there's possibly a feeling of mother and children all bunching up together and he a bit of an outsider or on his own in terms of influence on what happens in the family? Calling it boring or whatever is dismissive. A weekend visit every other week perhaps and once a week on weekdays in between, might be enough for him.

HundredMilesAnHour · 30/10/2022 14:48

It sounds like you prefer the BF to your DH. Everything you say is glowing about the BF but you sound like you don't like your DH much. Perhaps that is part of the problem.

OhmygodDont · 30/10/2022 14:48

That’s it my parents let us have sleep overs in fact dh moved in and paid rent at one point. With his family is was more like sneaking around. We got our own house at 17 in the end had a baby by 18. I’m not sure that’s what his parents where planning o.

picklemewalnuts · 30/10/2022 14:45

Have you asked him whether he wants the same relationship with his DD as he has with his parents?

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 14:44

I met DH when I was 18 and we were far less respectful to both our parents than DD and BF are. I look back and cringe at some of our antics. I mention this to DH and he "can't remember". His parents were very very unkind to me and it never let up so the kids have been to their home 3 times and have no relationships with them. My mum smiled and put up with us and tried to steer me and it worked and we are all so close now. We laugh about my daft carrying on as a teenager. I wonder what DH thinks, I really do.

OP posts:
OhmygodDont · 30/10/2022 14:43

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 14:41

This is interesting, lots saying it. I am seeing it like a male animal pissing on a tree tbh. Haha

It’s exactly that. His daughter is his daughter not her bf’s, gf. His struggling to let go of her being his it’s not healthy for him or her if he gets away with it.

At 17 I’m surprised she thinks one night a whole month is good tbh but sounds like she knows what her dads like.