Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

EBay selling nightmare

85 replies

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 12:26

Hello,

I have been buying and selling items from eBay for over 11 years. Not as a business, just as a person selling a few bits no longer required or to make extra space in my wardrobe etc.

I recently sold a brand new with tags Ted Baker coat for £130. The buyer received it and contacted me to ask why the postage was £3 more than what I actually paid and asked for a refund. I explained that the added charge was added on to cover my packaging and fuel costs and that it was clearly stated on the listing. There was no message from the buyer advising that there was something wrong with the coat or the coat was not as described. The buyer then submitted an 'item is not as described' refund request which I accepted. I was advised to do this by eBay after ringing them directly. I explained that they have used the 'item not as described' return policy falsely and eBay advised that they could see from our message correspondence that the buyer had never mentioned there was a problem with the coat itself.
I paid for a return label through eBay and received the coat back from the seller damaged/marked, smelling of cigarettes and had clearly been worn.
I've again been in touch with eBay who advise that I can offer the buyer a partial refund but the buyer can refuse this and then the buyer will be refunded fully and I'm out of pocket left with a coat that I can no longer sell as brand new and sell it at a significant loss.
I'm so annoyed about this. I've got 100% feedback and I'm a very genuine seller.
Has anyone else experienced this or have any advice?

OP posts:
skyeisthelimit · 30/10/2022 15:29

I love the way that people are victim blaming you over the £3. If the person was genuinely outraged over the £3 and that was the only issue, they would have accepted the refund. They also would not have returned the coat in such a bad state. If you clearly stated the postage, then they accepted those terms.

I only sell on Vinted now and haven't had any problems on there. I sell everything cheap and cheerful to get rid of it.

TheHauntedPencilCase · 30/10/2022 15:17

I'm sorry this happened. I've given up after 3 scams and have 2 bin liners of nice clothes to go to the charity shop tomorrow. Such a shame as I used to ebay loads and all really cheap but there were so many issues it wasn't worth the hassle and losses for such little money. I've not sold anything as expensive as items on this post so I know I'm lucky but it annoys me as I used to buy a lot from there as well which I think was good for clothing waste but now it's hardly used due to these issues so I hardly ever use it now.

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 15:17

@Theydoyaknow- classy.

OP posts:
CecilyP · 30/10/2022 15:15

SpookabooAtTheZoo · 30/10/2022 13:16

To be fair on a £130 item you could have avoided this by not trying to skim an extra £3 of profit from the postage, or by refunding when called on it. If you'd kept a positive relationship with the buyer by refunding the £3 you likely wouldn't have an unsellable item returned to you. Sorry but I've been ebaying as a buyer and seller for 18 years and this sort of thing really puts me off trusting some private sellers anymore.

Seriously? The postage is clearly shown on the listing; if the added postage takes it above what you have been prepared, you just don’t bid. And sellers don’t 109% know what the postage will be until items are weighed and packaged - the postage charge is usually a best guess, not an attempt to cheat buyers!

Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 15:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 15:13

Rosiestraws · 30/10/2022 14:59

Can't believe how many people are agreeing about the postage point! It is a postage and packing fee and yes that can include your time going to the shop, waiting in line for 10 min, a jiffy bag for the item, sellotape etc... yes if you only sell one item it's not much extra but if you sell a few it adds up! Also, surely most people just roughly estimate? I definitely guestimate as I'm not going to go to the post office to get a quote for every item and not going to pack up the item ready before it's sold to go in case a buyer asks for pictures etc. Often my postage to send costs more than I've quoted - so in this case would you say I should tell the buyer than and ask for it back!? As others have said, if you disagree with the postage then don't bid! I imagine a coat would be fairly heavy to post also...

I've literally just had two bad experiences this weekend selling after a long break selling on ebay (all just personal bits and bobs)

Firstly sold a divan bed frame and bed. Clearly stated sizing etc and it would need to be disassembled and collection only. The guy who won messaged asking if he could pick up same day. I confirmed yes and ran around clearing the house/pathway to the bed etc so he could pick up within an hour. He then messaged asking for the postcode (which was on the listing, but nevermind..) then he replied saying "the address you gave was close to us not in the middle of [City name]. I won't be able to pick it up until I can hire a van. This is very much more difficult than I thought". No idea what he was talking about with "address I gave" I went back to him and said this and said the postcode was on the listing, I'd also stated it was in the centre of City X on the listing (and ebay shows my postcode anyway when it's set to collection only), along with a screenshot of the listing but that if he wanted me to cancel his winning bid and refund him I would (as I already felt a bit worried about him turning up at my house now and thought he's likely to find fault with something)

He then messaged a bit more telling me about him needing to get a van, can't do it today etc and grumbling messages. (Not sure why he would only need to get a van because he realised I lived further from him than he thought - it's not like even if I was walking distance away he could move it without a van!?) Then asked if there was parking and a lift. Again - this info was on the listing! I replied that there was not parking, but there was a loading bay and two lifts - all information clearly stated on the listing. And he then huffed and puffed and said how it was all too complicated and could I refund him. So I did so and now have to relist. Total waste of time. No repercussions for him. No option to leave feedback that I can see, even?!

Another furniture item listed and winning bidder has not paid or responded to messages for payment. I cannot cancel their bid and sell to the next highest bidder for 4 calendar days! In which time the next highest bidder may well have found something else suitable. Zero follow up for the winning bidder when it is supposed to be a contract to buy! And I'm pretty sure I can't leave negative feedback for the buyer either now - will have to check.

Re Vinted, don't you have to send the item before you get payment?

That sounds absolutely horrendous! How stressful. Sounds like you dodged a bullet there though as annoying as it is.
It gets to the point where I'd prefer to just give things away for free to avoid the hassle of it all but even then you get asked to deliver it too for free or something equally as cheeky.
Yes, on Vinted the buyer pays for the item you're via Vinted platform and the money gets held by Vinted until the buyer confirms that it has been delivered and that they're happy with it/item is as described etc. I'm not quite sure what happens if they're not happy or the returns process etc.
I'm going to stick with fb market place or gumtree from now on. I've been royally screwed over by eBay so it's time to move on. It sadly seems that I'm not the only one this or something similar has happened to.
So sorry this has happened to you.

OP posts:
fatgirlslimmer · 30/10/2022 15:05

postage and packing is always emotive on eBay which is why I started using free postage and added it to the price, however it was probably a red herring and they were going to return the coat anyway.

eBay always stand by the buyer and sellers are scammed all of the time. It really is a disgrace when its £130+ you've lost

It's happened to me with smaller items but I stopped using eBay when I had similar with a coat. Brand new with tags and posted in a coat box with a garment cover, almost a week later I got an INAD case. When the postman handed me a tightly rolled bin bag I was convinced it would just have any old coat in it. I was genuinely surprised to find the original coat with tags (no garment cover) albeit a scrunched-up mess which then had to be sold as used.

Rosiestraws · 30/10/2022 14:59

Can't believe how many people are agreeing about the postage point! It is a postage and packing fee and yes that can include your time going to the shop, waiting in line for 10 min, a jiffy bag for the item, sellotape etc... yes if you only sell one item it's not much extra but if you sell a few it adds up! Also, surely most people just roughly estimate? I definitely guestimate as I'm not going to go to the post office to get a quote for every item and not going to pack up the item ready before it's sold to go in case a buyer asks for pictures etc. Often my postage to send costs more than I've quoted - so in this case would you say I should tell the buyer than and ask for it back!? As others have said, if you disagree with the postage then don't bid! I imagine a coat would be fairly heavy to post also...

I've literally just had two bad experiences this weekend selling after a long break selling on ebay (all just personal bits and bobs)

Firstly sold a divan bed frame and bed. Clearly stated sizing etc and it would need to be disassembled and collection only. The guy who won messaged asking if he could pick up same day. I confirmed yes and ran around clearing the house/pathway to the bed etc so he could pick up within an hour. He then messaged asking for the postcode (which was on the listing, but nevermind..) then he replied saying "the address you gave was close to us not in the middle of [City name]. I won't be able to pick it up until I can hire a van. This is very much more difficult than I thought". No idea what he was talking about with "address I gave" I went back to him and said this and said the postcode was on the listing, I'd also stated it was in the centre of City X on the listing (and ebay shows my postcode anyway when it's set to collection only), along with a screenshot of the listing but that if he wanted me to cancel his winning bid and refund him I would (as I already felt a bit worried about him turning up at my house now and thought he's likely to find fault with something)

He then messaged a bit more telling me about him needing to get a van, can't do it today etc and grumbling messages. (Not sure why he would only need to get a van because he realised I lived further from him than he thought - it's not like even if I was walking distance away he could move it without a van!?) Then asked if there was parking and a lift. Again - this info was on the listing! I replied that there was not parking, but there was a loading bay and two lifts - all information clearly stated on the listing. And he then huffed and puffed and said how it was all too complicated and could I refund him. So I did so and now have to relist. Total waste of time. No repercussions for him. No option to leave feedback that I can see, even?!

Another furniture item listed and winning bidder has not paid or responded to messages for payment. I cannot cancel their bid and sell to the next highest bidder for 4 calendar days! In which time the next highest bidder may well have found something else suitable. Zero follow up for the winning bidder when it is supposed to be a contract to buy! And I'm pretty sure I can't leave negative feedback for the buyer either now - will have to check.

Re Vinted, don't you have to send the item before you get payment?

Littlemisspawpatrol · 30/10/2022 14:50

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 14:45

@Theydoyaknow your post is hilarious. Read my post and replies properly. They weren't refused a refund. Its £3 at the end of the day! £3 that I'd have happily refunded if given the opportunity to save a petty quarrel and having to have my coat returned. Again postage costs were clearly listed. They didn't have to buy my item. I have the right to charge what I see is appropriate for postage. The whole point is they were a scumbag sending a dirty used coat back when it was sent in A1 brand new condition. This fixation on the measly £3 is so funny. You didn't happen to buy my Ted Baker coat did you? Are you the culprit? Hilarious.

Hey Pandora, if you do sell again I think when you print your own postage label, it doesn't show the cost of the posting. I used to add PayPal postage fees to my postage costs, if I sold an item for a pound and then had to pay fees on the postage it just wasn't worth it at all. So I would print my own postage so that they couldn't see how much I paid for postage and give me a low star for charging them an extra ten p or whatever.

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 14:45

@Theydoyaknow your post is hilarious. Read my post and replies properly. They weren't refused a refund. Its £3 at the end of the day! £3 that I'd have happily refunded if given the opportunity to save a petty quarrel and having to have my coat returned. Again postage costs were clearly listed. They didn't have to buy my item. I have the right to charge what I see is appropriate for postage. The whole point is they were a scumbag sending a dirty used coat back when it was sent in A1 brand new condition. This fixation on the measly £3 is so funny. You didn't happen to buy my Ted Baker coat did you? Are you the culprit? Hilarious.

OP posts:
Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 14:43

Littlemisspawpatrol · 30/10/2022 14:40

She wasn't making money on it, she was covering her fuel costs, which is part of the posting cost.

Ridiculous.

THisbackwithavengeance · 30/10/2022 14:41

I used to sell on eBay and had great feedback. Then had a run in with a massively unreasonable buyer; eBay didn't care so I cancelled my account and now sell on Vinted.

Vinted will probably go the same way at some point though. Unfortunately a significant % of the populace are dishonest by nature and internet shopping has only enabled them.

I would also keep their address though. Revenge is a dish best served cold.

Littlemisspawpatrol · 30/10/2022 14:40

Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 14:35

No I am not. I am saying that it is really mean NOT to refund €3 and blame it on fuel costs. The buyer obviously feels the same and objects to paying more for postage that what it actually costs. She asked for a refund of what the OP did NOT spend in postage costs after spending £120 on a coat, the OP refused.
The buyer then did the dirty. I am a seller on Ebay and have sold thousands of items, I put postage at exactly what is costs me because it irks me when others try to make money on people with postage costs.

She wasn't making money on it, she was covering her fuel costs, which is part of the posting cost.

Littlemisspawpatrol · 30/10/2022 14:38

Are your funds on hold or did they go into your bank account yet? If the latter, then just close your account and take eBay off your direct debits so they can't take any money off you

If the former then kick up a stink with ebay- threaten small claims court and going to the media until they release your funds.

Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 14:36

LuckyLil · 30/10/2022 14:24

OP has said repeatedly the buyer didn't even wait for a response to the £3 before raising a false claim.

Tghey were refused a refund and given justification as to why.

The buyer received it and contacted me to ask why the postage was £3 more than what I actually paid and asked for a refund. I explained that the added charge was added on to cover my packaging and fuel costs and that it was clearly stated on the listing

Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 14:35

Cancelledtwiceover · 30/10/2022 14:23

That's exactly what you are doing. You are blaming the op saying it's her own fault for it escalating.
The buyer returned a used coat, because they are a thief, not because the op didn't offer them a £3.00 refund.

No I am not. I am saying that it is really mean NOT to refund €3 and blame it on fuel costs. The buyer obviously feels the same and objects to paying more for postage that what it actually costs. She asked for a refund of what the OP did NOT spend in postage costs after spending £120 on a coat, the OP refused.
The buyer then did the dirty. I am a seller on Ebay and have sold thousands of items, I put postage at exactly what is costs me because it irks me when others try to make money on people with postage costs.

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 14:31

Thank you everyone for your advice and support. It's very much appreciated.

OP posts:
JudithHarper · 30/10/2022 14:27

It's easy to see which posters do this very same trick to other ebay sellers.

heartbroken22 · 30/10/2022 14:26

It's upto you how much you put on for postal charges even if it's higher than the actual cost because you're charged eBay fees on it so wtf. Tell her to use her legs and go to a shop next time. I'm sorry this happened to you.

LuckyLil · 30/10/2022 14:24

Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 14:06

Honestly I think it is really stingy. Had you refunded it as a goodwill gesture you would not be in this situation.

OP has said repeatedly the buyer didn't even wait for a response to the £3 before raising a false claim.

Cancelledtwiceover · 30/10/2022 14:23

Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 14:17

God no, I am not excusing that.

That's exactly what you are doing. You are blaming the op saying it's her own fault for it escalating.
The buyer returned a used coat, because they are a thief, not because the op didn't offer them a £3.00 refund.

blippi123 · 30/10/2022 14:21

I would advise anybody selling on eBay to sell items as "collection only"

There's so many scammers and changers out there now

I saw a post recently where somebody sold an iPhone advertised as having a faulty speaker. The buyer sent the phone back with the screen missing!

Thighdentitycrisis · 30/10/2022 14:20

As a seller, Can you still select ‘returns not accepted’ ?
Or does eBay resolution centre override this option?

whirlyhead · 30/10/2022 14:17

Part of the reason to set postage a bit higher on eBay is because eBay take a percentage of postal charges too. They started doing this after people were selling items for e.g. £10 with £20 postal charges in order to get around ebay charges.

lotuspie · 30/10/2022 14:17

When you sold the coat and advertised it as new. And the photos showed this. Cabt you now tell eBay that the coat you got has been ruined. And this buyer sent it to you in this state? Abd send pictures of the coat before and after