Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

EBay selling nightmare

85 replies

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 12:26

Hello,

I have been buying and selling items from eBay for over 11 years. Not as a business, just as a person selling a few bits no longer required or to make extra space in my wardrobe etc.

I recently sold a brand new with tags Ted Baker coat for £130. The buyer received it and contacted me to ask why the postage was £3 more than what I actually paid and asked for a refund. I explained that the added charge was added on to cover my packaging and fuel costs and that it was clearly stated on the listing. There was no message from the buyer advising that there was something wrong with the coat or the coat was not as described. The buyer then submitted an 'item is not as described' refund request which I accepted. I was advised to do this by eBay after ringing them directly. I explained that they have used the 'item not as described' return policy falsely and eBay advised that they could see from our message correspondence that the buyer had never mentioned there was a problem with the coat itself.
I paid for a return label through eBay and received the coat back from the seller damaged/marked, smelling of cigarettes and had clearly been worn.
I've again been in touch with eBay who advise that I can offer the buyer a partial refund but the buyer can refuse this and then the buyer will be refunded fully and I'm out of pocket left with a coat that I can no longer sell as brand new and sell it at a significant loss.
I'm so annoyed about this. I've got 100% feedback and I'm a very genuine seller.
Has anyone else experienced this or have any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Twillow · 31/10/2022 01:35

TheHumanExperience · 30/10/2022 20:42

P'S £3 is far too cheap for postage on an expensive item. I never send anything expensive not fully tracked. You will pay 10% in fees and you pay the fees for the postage as well, so he only paid you £2.70.... that's ridiculous.

OP charged £3 more than the postage actually cost.

FlumpyLump · 30/10/2022 21:22

A few years ago, I sold a mobile phone on eBay.

It was my dad's old phone who never leaves the house due to ill health and the phone spent it's life on the table in a case barely used. He wanted a different one and so I sold the old one for him.
It was boxed and in mint condition.

It sold for around £50 if I recall correctly.
I received positive feedback.

4 months later, I got a PayPal claim against me to say that the screen had smashed and they wanted a refund.

They did it through PayPal because eBay returns were 30/60 days back then I think.

PayPal actually sided with them and I had to refund.
Their policy at the time was that the buyer was allowed 180 days after a sale to raise any problems.
I'm not sure if that still applies.

I argued that they had the phone for 4 months, left positive feedback and anything could've happened in that time.
They still sided with the buyer.

I took it to the ombudsman and got my dad's money back, but they still got the refund also after using a phone for 4 months and breaking it.

I refused to sell anything on eBay after that.

TheHumanExperience · 30/10/2022 20:42

P'S £3 is far too cheap for postage on an expensive item. I never send anything expensive not fully tracked. You will pay 10% in fees and you pay the fees for the postage as well, so he only paid you £2.70.... that's ridiculous.

TheHumanExperience · 30/10/2022 20:38

I have been eBaying for 30 years now, having 6000 100% positive feedbacks.

However, I don't eBay much these days as it's full of scammers and opportunists.

Your major error was this
'The buyer then submitted an 'item is not as described' refund request which I accepted.'

You allowed the buyer to manipulate the eBay system in his favour. Item not as described gives you absolutely no protection from eBay. It was as described, so you should not have accepted that reason as the cause for return. Doing this, you shot yourself in the foot, and now you don't have a leg to stand on. Ebay frowns upon dodgy sellers. INAD is a black mark against you as a seller. You should have rejected this and asked the seller to correct the request, so you could accept the return. That the item is as described, so you could not refund for that reason. Better still, phone eBay before agreeing to anything, and explain to them.

It's a hard way to learn a lesson. If you are going to eBay you have to protect yourself by putting YOUR OWN Terms and Conditions on EVERY LISTING.

These include what the postage charges consist of. The definition of the condition of the items, i.e used means the item has been worn and is not in NEW condition. There may be minor signs of use, or if there are signs of use, show them in the pictures. Also, state the pictures form part of the item description and should be inspected thoroughly before bidding. You can also specify NO BIDDERS with LESS THAN 50 Positive feedbacks. This helps and you can remove bids and refuse to sell to new bidders who are potential scammers. Your T&Cs protect you.

By bidding on my item, you are fully accepting my T&Cs and no refunds will be given unless the item is grossly not as described.

Sorry you had to go through this. Hopefully, you didn't leave feedback for the item and can leave actual factual feedback. The item was brand new and tagged. Buyer returned item dirty, stinking of smoke, obviously worn, and leave 1 star and negative. This at least warns others of their scam.

I no longer leave feedback until 4-6 weeks after an item is sold, or until after feedback has been left for me. People sometimes prey on new eBayers because they know they are easy targets and too trusting.

Sorry, it's a waffle but I hope it helps.

girlfriend44 · 30/10/2022 20:26

I don't bother with ebay anymore
Have used FB marketplace in the past. Found ebay abit stressful especially for a higher paid item I was selling.

CaptainMum · 30/10/2022 19:44

I sold loads on eBay until last year, when I had a similar experience. I took everything down and only use Vinted now. It's been great so far!

SpookyPanda · 30/10/2022 19:43

Twillow · 30/10/2022 16:52

That's not how business works though is it - all costs need to be absorbed which usually means on the item prices.

Yes exactly so put it on the item price and be done with it. Postage price is for postage. Not petrol to the post office.

microbius · 30/10/2022 19:38

I sold on eBay for years with no problems. Literally, never a problem. This year, I sold only two things and both times buyers started complaining, trying to find faults with the items (priced really low) and were blatantly lying to get a full refund and keep the item> clearly the items were so cheap I wouldn't bother paying return postage to get the item back. As a result, I don't sell on eBay anymore. I don't know if the introduction of vinted, depop changed the dynamic and population of eBay. There now seems to be a culture of getting things for free through eBay. I can just take them to charity shop near me

Brigante9 · 30/10/2022 17:43

EBay can be a minefield. I bought trainers, listed as a 9, turns out that was a US 9. The seller hadn’t mentioned this or shown the label. He told me to go through PayPal as he refused to pay it back. Idiot didn’t seem to realise it was his PayPal account that would be debited when I inevitably won the case!

My DH sold an ipod, the buyer couldn’t get it working after multiple messages saying he needed it urgently as he was leaving the country-we upgraded the postage at our expense. He was told how to make it work, the usual turn it on, it was fine. Then he wanted a refund but didn’t want to return it because he didn’t have time to go to the Post Office (hello, they do collection!) then went over the time given him to return, complaining lots of times that he shouldn’t have to return a fully working iPod and we should just refund him. Bonkers.

IhearyouClemFandango · 30/10/2022 17:28

Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 13:56

Honestly I think trying to get another £3 was stingy especially when it was such an expensive item.

The buyer received it and contacted me to ask why the postage was £3 more than what I actually paid and asked for a refund. I explained that the added charge was added on to cover my packaging and fuel costs and that it was clearly stated on the listing

I would have replied that in this case I would return the £3 and not tried to justify it for FUEL COSTS??? There is mean and there is scabby and this is scabby. It backfired on you.

Yeah this tbh. People pay higher postage because they assume the parcel will weigh more. I would have refunded straight away and moved on.

Equally I wouldn't have messaged, I'd have just written you off as a CF. And of course I wouldn't have worn it and then sent it back.

Wonnle · 30/10/2022 17:22

Any fees eBay take from a sale are also taken off the postage charges don't forget , it's something like 12.8% all in

KatStafford · 30/10/2022 17:18

Whilst it’s terrible that the buyer used and damaged the coat, unfortunately you broke EBay’s terms and conditions by price gouging on the postage. On that basis, EBay are unlikely to take your side in the dispute regardless of the buyer’s (admittedly terrible) behaviour.

Twillow · 30/10/2022 16:52

SpookyPanda · 30/10/2022 16:48

You wouldn't expect to pay more for postage from a small business if they had to drive to a delivery office vs one where they have a collection. Your petrol cost is irrelevant.

That's not how business works though is it - all costs need to be absorbed which usually means on the item prices.

Twillow · 30/10/2022 16:51

Also re postage, eBay charge a cut of this too so it has to be factored in somewhere whether on the postage or the item price - it's on the listing so it's not like it's deceitful - any buyer has a choice to buy or not.

SpookyPanda · 30/10/2022 16:48

You wouldn't expect to pay more for postage from a small business if they had to drive to a delivery office vs one where they have a collection. Your petrol cost is irrelevant.

Twillow · 30/10/2022 16:47

SpookabooAtTheZoo · 30/10/2022 13:16

To be fair on a £130 item you could have avoided this by not trying to skim an extra £3 of profit from the postage, or by refunding when called on it. If you'd kept a positive relationship with the buyer by refunding the £3 you likely wouldn't have an unsellable item returned to you. Sorry but I've been ebaying as a buyer and seller for 18 years and this sort of thing really puts me off trusting some private sellers anymore.

I also tend to put freepost on more expensive items BUT I also do charge 50p more than the standard post rate when I do charge postage - I do need to package it it and drive to the post office, after all.
In this case the postage is irrelevant though, the scammer would have found some other excuse to do this.

SpookyPanda · 30/10/2022 16:47

Littlemisspawpatrol · 30/10/2022 14:40

She wasn't making money on it, she was covering her fuel costs, which is part of the posting cost.

No it isn't. Thats absurd. The posting cost is the postage cost maybe at a push plus the cost of packaging materials if bought new. Price items accordingly.

SpookyPanda · 30/10/2022 16:44

In future I'd just include the postage cost in the price and do "free postage" that cuts out that hassle.

Still a nightmare when people pull stunts like this though so is never sell anything over £20 so it's not toooo gutting when I have to refund it in full.

caffelattetogo · 30/10/2022 16:43

Jaxhog · 30/10/2022 15:55

Utter rubbish! A buyer knows full well what the postage AND packing costs are before they bid. If you don't like it, don't bid.

That's not true. If the postage is less than expected, the seller should either spend that much on postage (upgrade the delivery speed or add tracking etc) or refund the difference. eBay is very clear that sellers are not supposed to make a profit on postage fees. I automatically credit back any unused postage fees to the buyer.

xxxPandora · 30/10/2022 16:06

@Jaxhog - completely agree.

OP posts:
Theydoyaknow · 30/10/2022 16:04

caffelattetogo · 30/10/2022 15:52

I sell and buy a lot in there. It's almost back to how it was at the start - there's a lot of trust required. I can't help but think that by not automatically refunding them the £3 when you realised postage was cheaper than you'd listed it, you didn't help build that trust. I don't think it's reasonable to charge for your journey to the post office (in mileage or in time spent) in the same way that it wouldn't be appropriate to bill them for your Wi-Fi bill, your car servicing or the time spent photographing and writing the listing. When people feel scammed, even for a small amount, they are less likely to behave in a trustworthy way, in my experience.

I agree totally, better off even adding it to the price, telling me I am then paying for your petrol to go to the post office would have really pissed me off.

Jaxhog · 30/10/2022 15:55

SpookabooAtTheZoo · 30/10/2022 13:16

To be fair on a £130 item you could have avoided this by not trying to skim an extra £3 of profit from the postage, or by refunding when called on it. If you'd kept a positive relationship with the buyer by refunding the £3 you likely wouldn't have an unsellable item returned to you. Sorry but I've been ebaying as a buyer and seller for 18 years and this sort of thing really puts me off trusting some private sellers anymore.

Utter rubbish! A buyer knows full well what the postage AND packing costs are before they bid. If you don't like it, don't bid.

caffelattetogo · 30/10/2022 15:52

I sell and buy a lot in there. It's almost back to how it was at the start - there's a lot of trust required. I can't help but think that by not automatically refunding them the £3 when you realised postage was cheaper than you'd listed it, you didn't help build that trust. I don't think it's reasonable to charge for your journey to the post office (in mileage or in time spent) in the same way that it wouldn't be appropriate to bill them for your Wi-Fi bill, your car servicing or the time spent photographing and writing the listing. When people feel scammed, even for a small amount, they are less likely to behave in a trustworthy way, in my experience.

HelenWick · 30/10/2022 15:34

We had this but I managed to 'trick' the scammer into admitting removing the tags so EBAY had to refund me. I haven't used them again.

SimonJones · 30/10/2022 15:32

@xxxPandora It really is worth pursuing Ebay. You need to ring them and speak to someone in person, and keep badgering them. I was the victim of a twatty buyer who provided Ebay with the wrong address, then filed a claim for 'parcel not received'. Ebay initially sided with the twatty buyer, even though she was clearly in the wrong, but they reversed the decision when I contested it. It took a lot of badgering, though. I'm not a big seller - I just sell bits every now and then.