Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone else got a friend who’s a helicopter parent even though their dc are older teens?

64 replies

Enidanddelilah · 30/10/2022 09:08

I’ve got a friend who is completely obsessed with her dc and still micro manages every aspect of their life from boys and friends to school work. It’s all she talks about as well in a bragging, superior way. Her eldest is 17 and still does everything they are told, no rebellion at all. Anyone else know anyone like this? How did their dc turn out?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bookist · 19/06/2023 10:58

I think that for some parents the natural instinct to protect and care for your baby morphs into something obsessive and potentially destructive. I know of parents who would hire a holiday cottage in close vicinity to wherever their child was at PGA, scout camp etc. When they went away to university their parents moved to the same city. When they got their first job, their parents again moved to the same city. They speak on the phone twice a day, every day, without fail. Nothing takes precedence over these phone calls.

To be fair, the parents really don't have a happy marriage and I think the mother treats her son as a pseudo husband. She always gets dressed up and goes to extra efforts with her hair/make up when she's meeting her son. Her son is over thirty, but she still holidays with him every year, no one else is privy to where they go or what they do as this is their 'special, private time.' Somehow, the natural instincts in her brain have become muddled up. It's quite sad to witness.

Saracen · 19/06/2023 10:39

In a few cases people have mentioned here, you don't know the young person well enough to be sure they don't need extra help. Some teens and young adults have anxiety or other mental health issues and do need a lot of involvement from their parents.

My teen does. She has a mild learning disability. Someone who only knew her slightly wouldn't realise how immature and vulnerable she is, and would be shocked at how closely involved I am with her. I don't tell her what to do, but I do take a very keen interest in what she's doing, especially watching out for any sign of her being manipulated or groomed. She hates to upset people and always thinks things are her fault which clearly aren't, and she never sticks up for herself. I am usually with her - at a distance anyway - and when I'm not, she's with someone else I trust. I know who all her friends are and I make sure to observe their interactions occasionally to see how they treat her. I might be pushy if I really thought she was making a big mistake.

I do absolutely agree that helicopter parenting of an average child does them no favours, and my older child had a huge amount of freedom, more than most kids get. Just bear in mind that young people have different needs.

blackheartsgirl · 19/06/2023 10:10

I have a friend whose 3 dc are helicoptered, they are all early to late teens now

they literally cannot move without their mums say so, even asking permission to open their bedroom windows, in bed by 8 and the older one by 9, very limited access to their phones, their meals are all mapped out, the mum even joined their local sports team as an assistant so she could keep an eye on them. Very little privacy with re to their friendships etc. they are all lovely kids but the middle one is stating to show signs of frustration now.

I know why my friend is like this, she had a really unstable upbringing with little control over her life.

it’s sad really

Gronkle · 30/10/2022 16:32

I have a friend who bought her kids double beds so she could sleep with them, I thought it was very helicopter parenting when they were in primary school but she's still doing it now and they are 20M and 17F.

earsup · 30/10/2022 16:23

Gosh...an ex friend....awful woman...micro managed absolutely everything...her son is about 25...still tells him how many fish fingers to eat etc....what to wear...where to go....the son is as a result, a giant baby, cant do anything for himself...and sits meekly in the lounge...asks to go to toilet etc....i ditched her years ago....controlled everything...super neurotic and controlling....dreadful....hope never to bump into her again....!!

DeadbeatYoda · 30/10/2022 16:21

...(posted too early). That seemed a little OTT to me.

DeadbeatYoda · 30/10/2022 16:21

I think the term Helicopter parent means different things to different people. However slack you are, someone two levels less slack than you seems like a helicopter parent. It's a term used by some people to justify their own parental laziness. Having said that, I was chatting with a mum the other day that was standing on the corner of the street to wait for their14 yr old daughter to get off the bus ( there were eight girls in the group together) because they had never crossed the main road alone before.

Birdsofafeatherflocktogether · 30/10/2022 16:15

orangeisthenewpuce · 30/10/2022 16:14

That's not helicopter parenting. That's abuse and coercive control. Poor girl.

I did tell her this-and if she wanted I’d get her the help and support she needed
she agreed-then as soon as they got back,I was told to fuck off and stop being a control freak

she knows my door is open but so far-nothing

orangeisthenewpuce · 30/10/2022 16:14

Birdsofafeatherflocktogether · 30/10/2022 16:11

My son once had a girlfriend who had helicopter parents
she couldn’t go out apart from work
she wasn’t allowed to use her own car without permission
they had a tracker on her phone-they read every single text,would stalk her if she went out-read every single Facebook message-the lot
she wasn’t allowed a house key-or to move out
shed be allowed to stay over at my sons flat but if mummy said she had to go home,she had to go home
the mother told her what to wear and how to do her hair and make up-everyday
they chose every single subject she did at college
they chose her friends
took all her wages as ‘rent’
you name it-her parents had a finger in it

i live over 100 miles away and my son mentioned he’d like to come to ours with her
all fine-they where very welcome

her mother!jesus Christ was a nightmare
endless phone calls
she wanted our address
she wanted to see every room in my house via zoom to make sure we didn’t live in a drugs den
she wanted the details of both mine and dps jobs-and income (she demanded our payslips!)
she wanted to know what we had planned for everyday they where here-food-activities,times we got up/went to bed-nothing was off limits

this went on and on-and an hour before they where due to set off,the mother banned the girlfriend from coming as our house wasn’t good enough

they did talk her into allowing her to go-but the minute they got here,the phone calls started-every single hour

we went for a drink-I had the mother phoning me to scream at me for forcing her dd to get pissed

we went shopping-cue a call to tell me not to let her spend her own money

we went for a walk-I got shouted at for walking a dangerous route-it wasn’t-it was perfectly safe-and the mother had never been to our town so wouldn’t know anyway

etc etc

they went home at the end of the week-and the mother decided that they couldn’t be together anymore-and told girlfriend that she had to break up with my son,as my son had been hitting her (not true)
the girlfriend did break up with him (just before lockdown) and refused to say he’d been hitting her-so the mother just put it about that he had-he almost lost his job

ive never seen anything like it-im of the ‘live your life the way you want to-I’m here for you but I’m not living your life for you’

(oh and both of them where 22 at the time)

That's not helicopter parenting. That's abuse and coercive control. Poor girl.

Birdsofafeatherflocktogether · 30/10/2022 16:11

My son once had a girlfriend who had helicopter parents
she couldn’t go out apart from work
she wasn’t allowed to use her own car without permission
they had a tracker on her phone-they read every single text,would stalk her if she went out-read every single Facebook message-the lot
she wasn’t allowed a house key-or to move out
shed be allowed to stay over at my sons flat but if mummy said she had to go home,she had to go home
the mother told her what to wear and how to do her hair and make up-everyday
they chose every single subject she did at college
they chose her friends
took all her wages as ‘rent’
you name it-her parents had a finger in it

i live over 100 miles away and my son mentioned he’d like to come to ours with her
all fine-they where very welcome

her mother!jesus Christ was a nightmare
endless phone calls
she wanted our address
she wanted to see every room in my house via zoom to make sure we didn’t live in a drugs den
she wanted the details of both mine and dps jobs-and income (she demanded our payslips!)
she wanted to know what we had planned for everyday they where here-food-activities,times we got up/went to bed-nothing was off limits

this went on and on-and an hour before they where due to set off,the mother banned the girlfriend from coming as our house wasn’t good enough

they did talk her into allowing her to go-but the minute they got here,the phone calls started-every single hour

we went for a drink-I had the mother phoning me to scream at me for forcing her dd to get pissed

we went shopping-cue a call to tell me not to let her spend her own money

we went for a walk-I got shouted at for walking a dangerous route-it wasn’t-it was perfectly safe-and the mother had never been to our town so wouldn’t know anyway

etc etc

they went home at the end of the week-and the mother decided that they couldn’t be together anymore-and told girlfriend that she had to break up with my son,as my son had been hitting her (not true)
the girlfriend did break up with him (just before lockdown) and refused to say he’d been hitting her-so the mother just put it about that he had-he almost lost his job

ive never seen anything like it-im of the ‘live your life the way you want to-I’m here for you but I’m not living your life for you’

(oh and both of them where 22 at the time)

orangeisthenewpuce · 30/10/2022 15:45

I know someone who is very, very involved in her older sons lives. That's fair enough if they are happy with that but she never stops talking about them and what they are doing and if we are discussing anything, current affairs for instance, she tells me what her son's opinions would be. It's really boring, I'm not interested in her sons.

Kissingfrogs25 · 30/10/2022 15:23

I am conflicted about this, showing interest, being there for your teens and caring for them/parenting is not a bad thing. In my experience they need guidance and affection. Choosing clothes and wanting to be with them 247 with no freedom to see friends and have fun? Well thats just very weird, and I don't know anyone like that!

Of the parents I know taking time to look after their teens the dc do seem well adjusted and happy. I only had one true helicopter friend and her dd's hormones sorted it out around 15 😂and the mother gave up in the end!

BeanieTeen · 30/10/2022 15:13

I had a colleague a bit like this before. It was kind of odd because for ages I assumed she had children that were primary aged like mine. She’d talk about how busy she always was with the kids, how she had to do x y and z for them, including having hectic mornings getting them ready and out and how she never got a break. And I always sympathised because mine were like 4 and 6 at the time. And then one day it transpired that these kids were 15 and 18. I wasn’t that close with her so didn’t say much about it but I was a bit taken aback by the whole thing. Not sure if that’s helicopter parenting as such. But once I’d become of aware of the situation it did come across like she was keen to hold on to that feeling of being needed, I’m not sure it was a control thing.

CulturePigeon · 30/10/2022 15:07

A couple of stories, one really tragic and one just worthy of an eye-roll:

  1. Parent I knew of (NOT a friend - too bonkers) throughout my daughter's school life. Very, very wealthy with one child. The girl was pleasant and hard-working, but not excellent academically and very quiet and bland (don't mean to be unkind - but it's shorthand for a lot of detail). She had everything money could buy, and openly admitted that mum helped with homework as a matter of course. Mum wanted her to go to Oxford but the school wouldn't support the application. Mum insisted and the girl applied, only to have the most traumatic and gruelling interview at Oxford which affected her very badly. She wouldn't emerge from her room for over a week and was really knocked back by the experience. I think her parents had managed to buy everything for her until that point, and came up against the buffers when they found that they couldn't get her into Oxford.
  2. Girl left school at 16 and went into a job. She was late every day for the first week with no particular excuse. The boss called her in on Friday and reprimanded here. Mother phoned up the firm, furious that someone had made her cry.
crumpetswithjam · 30/10/2022 14:52

It varies according to the child, I think. My mum was much more involved with my life as a teen, as I was awkward and anxious (And autistic! Undiagnosed), and had few friends. I relied on her quite heavily, and it wasn't really her fault, she would give me opportunities for freedom, I just was reluctant to take them. I went to a (very good!) uni about an hour from home and popped back regularly (but lived in halls/digs). I moved home after uni for a few years to find my feet. My sister, on the other hand, moved to China after uni. My younger brother lived at home until he was in his thirties, but he lost our mum at a very important age developmentally, and that really wrecked a lot of his twenties. He also, like me, is neurodiverse.

I would say I'm the more independent one now. Dsis and her DH rely quite a bit on generous handouts from his folks. When the time was right, and I met DH, I moved to London, trained as a teacher and took off. Financially we are sound. We don't rely on anyone for anything. We have two kids and I find myself doing what my mum did and parenting them slightly differently, according to their level of need. I am happy for them to fly free if they wish. Equally, in the case of my DS, who I am likely to care for forever, I am happy to helicopter.

Wbeezer · 30/10/2022 14:48

I've just reminded me of the American parents who moved over to the UK for the duration of their childs uni course here. I dont know what kind of visa they have but I suspect they are wealthy.

Toddlerteaplease · 30/10/2022 14:42

There was a story on our local news about a lad who'd got a place at university to study his dream subject. And his mum got on the same course!

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 30/10/2022 13:50

Yes I have a friend with an older child and it's something that worries me greatly! It verges on munchausen by proxy where she says she's got to watch over her as her child has OCD/depressive episodes/is on suicide watch etc, but it's just not true. He's a lovely boy who has absolutely no issues at all!

UrslaB · 30/10/2022 12:38

Next door neighbor growing up is the epitome of a helicopter mom. She drove son to and from school, he didn't get to do any activities unless she was there and when she left the house to go shopping, he had to follow after her. When he did try to socialize as a teenager she was the weird mom who waited outside nearby in her car. Her son never left home. He works locally, comes home for lunch which she has on the table ready for him. His mother still buys all his clothes, and he has no friends that I can see whatsoever. He is in his early 30s, gorgeous looking fella, soft spoken but tied to his mother's apron strings. I mentioned I was running a charity pub quiz once and asked him to come, figured it would be good for him to get out, meet some people. Said I would put him on my team and introduce him to everyone. His response? He would have to ask his mom....FS. Yeah. He never appeared at that pub quiz.

In my wider group of friends growing up we had two girls with helicopter parents. Although, I think the title seems too innocuous and is a euphemism for abusive in the cases I witnessed. I think I knew their mums better than I knew my friends at one point because they were always in their business. Very controlling about school work, constantly landing at school, getting to go out with friends involved a business proposal, an interview and regimented schedule as well as phone calls to check in when we were all out. Even just a cinema trip or a meal, never mind discos etc as we aged...it was exhausting and I always felt sorry for them. Their careers were pretty much determined by their parents and they lived these regimented lives of scheduled activities, their very beings micromanaged down to what they wore, who they could be friendly with, how they had their hair cut and how they spent their leisure time.

When we went to university one of my friends rebelled. Her mum had been calling down to university digs (we were only about two hours from our home town), checking in on what she was eating, going to class, reading her university work and questioning who she was meeting/making friends with. My friend seemed to just have had enough and basically started sofa surfing with friends and acquaintances so her mum couldn't find her. (This was such a pain in the tit when she would land at our digs and I would have to go through the interrogation to explain that no, I have no f-ing clue where her daughter is) She started drinking and partying and just...yeah, I was having my own rebellion for different reasons but even I looked at her and thought...yeah she needs to slow down. In later half of second year of university, it all came to a head when she fell pregnant. Her mum hit the roof and landed down and tried to drag her DD back home, police were called, there was a huge scene and pretty much she stopped talking to her mum. She had some support from the baby's father and got a flat of her own, finished university and got a good job. She had a few rough years where she was dependent on the baby's father's family for support, and he was a real gaslighting waste of oxygen, but she became really successful. We are all early thirties now and she only started talking to her mum again about five years ago. Their relationship has a weird tenseness now since the mum still tries to take over and revert to helicopter mode but my mate is financially secure and has toughened up through life so has none of it. Although there is a weird pettiness about it now, like, if she is meeting her mom she will purposefully wear clothes/makeup she knows will annoy her mother and she will drop comments about her life and friends like she is baiting her mom. It's...weird and unhealthy.

The second friend, similar but worse situation. Real abusive helicopter parents, she wasn't even allowed to live away from home for university. They often felt more like her stalkers and jailers than her parents. She hated her subjects in school but did them because those were the subjects her parents wanted her to do and that her mom was an expert in. I remember one rare night she came out clubbing with us and she was staying at my student digs. The whole night was weird cause she was on tenterhooks about 'mum said I should wear this' and 'mum said I shouldn't drink this' or 'mum said I shouldn't talk to people who are studying x/y.' Anyway, we get back to digs and are just dropping off at 3am, when the door starts banging. It's her mum demanding she come home, despite the fact she had okayed her having a night out and staying over. She was 19. She looked like she wanted the floor to eat her. After university her family used connections to get her a job in a cousin's business and this was another way for them to regulate her life. She wasn't allowed to leave home to rent somewhere to live because her mum had a plan for her to be able to get a mortgage before she was 26 and her income was regimentally controlled into savings accounts. She had to take a packed lunch every day and was only 'allowed' one social outing a month on a strict budget. Her mom blocked numbers and deleted numbers of friends she disapproved of as bad influences from her daughter's phone without telling her. When the talk started of how nice the managing director of the company was and her folks could arrange for her cousin to set her up with him she snapped. She had let them organize her life for years, helicopter all the time but this was a step too far. She packed a bag, left like she was going to work and disappeared. She left a letter saying she couldn't take it anymore. Her parents went ape, tried reporting her missing to the police, harassed all of her friends trying to find out where she was. She stayed with me for two weeks and basically moved around friends before she went to a different city to sort herself out. Lived in a HMO for a few months and worked temporary jobs while she figured out a plan. She ended up leaving the country, and now lives in OZ. Had to go half way around the world to escape her mother who kept tracking her down and harassing her. She revealed later that she had been planning the escape for years and had been saving up her 'house deposit account' as an escape fund but the talk of 'good husband' from her mother had kicked her plan into high gear. She has no contact with her parents now although she does have contact with her siblings, especially a younger sister who she essentially helped escape her parents clutches too.

Bookishish · 30/10/2022 11:54

user55875537986543 · 30/10/2022 09:34

I don’t like this thread. None of you really know exactly what the relationships you’ve described are like. “Helicoptering” to you might look like “being involved and interested” to others. Children and teens need some independence but also really need their parents. It’s the “I often have no idea where my teen is!” parents that I worry about much more.

I completely agree.

witchesbubblebath · 30/10/2022 11:52

I am the product of one and it was deeply unpleasant although i knew no different. Horrible.

VariationsonaTheme · 30/10/2022 11:49

Her eldest is 17 and still does everything they are told, no rebellion at all

I'm not sure this is anything to do with being a helicopter parent. I’m most definitely not, I have an 18 and 15 year old, encourage their independence far beyond what some of their friends are asked to to do/allowed to do, and yet they still do everything I do ask of them without argument, always have. 🤷🏼‍♀️Maybe it’s precisely because I’m not always micromanaging them.

BiasedBinding · 30/10/2022 11:34

So she belittles you and makes you feel bad about yourself and you want stories to reassure you that her children are going to turn out badly? I think you should just concentrate on having the courage of your convictions that you are doing the right thing for your children.

Tootsey11 · 30/10/2022 11:25

You seem by your post to expect all teens to 'rebel'.

You are making judgements about a situation based on what your friend is saying, but you don't live in that family so can't possibly know. You're a judgey twat.

Tonty · 30/10/2022 11:24

TheMorigoul · 30/10/2022 10:14

@Tonty to a degree yes, it's a time in their development where they will be carving out their own identity. It's perfectly normal for teens to want to do things their own way, make their own mistakes and to question yours. If you prevent them from doing this they miss out on learning about who they are and they won't come back to you as an adult. They are supposed to pull away.

I have grown dc so very intune with what you describe.

Writing a blanket statement such as, 'Her eldest is 17 and still does everything they are told, no rebellion at all' is silly because not rebelling doesn't necessarily mean the dc is not developing properly as you have alluded to and rebellion has never been a mark of good upbringing particularly.

MN is fond of generalising and using their own experience to judge what is going on in other people's homes.

What is OP's definition of rebellion? a lot of what she has described is pointing more to her personally feeling inadequate rather than anything wrong with how her 'friend' is raising her dc.

One person's idea of 'teenage rebellion' is another person's idea of a completely out of control teen. How does OP really know they do everything they are told? is screaming in public and swearing at your parents in front of neighbours, 'teenage rebellion'? or a bit of grumbling, eye rolling & slamming doors? OP and her friend clearly have very different standards so best OP minds her own business and enjoys her family. If her df is bragging.... change the subject.