Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that medical professionals should not be cutting off the breasts of teenage girls?

146 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 30/10/2022 08:36

twitter.com/ChoooCole/status/1586016843088601088?s=20&t=oQb2o7XLCvcTpf-dGzhBIw

"My breasts were beautiful, now they’ve been incinerated for nothing. Thank you, modern medicine.”

Chloe Cole's story is heartbreaking.

AIBU to think that this is medical abuse and that we should not be doing this to children?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 20:48

twitter.com/moveincircles/status/1615739909783838720?t=0qsWc1NDj4oywSO1sqVnjA&s=08

Instead people are celebrating with cakes.

OP posts:
RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 10:38

Bring on the lawsuits.

The NHS will do the following surgeries on any female over 18 who self identifies as trans (no medical diagnosis necessary)

Surgery for trans men

Common chest procedures for trans men (trans-masculine people) include:

removal of both breasts (bilateral mastectomy) and associated chest reconstruction
nipple repositioning
dermal implant and tattoo

Gender surgery for trans men includes:

construction of a penis (phalloplasty or metoidioplasty)
construction of a scrotum (scrotoplasty) and testicular implants
a penile implant
Removal of the womb (hysterectomy) and the ovaries and fallopian tubes (salpingo-oophorectomy) may also be considered

Women who don’t self identify as trans cannot generally get a hysterectomy until they are at least 30 ‘in case they change their mind about having children’. What makes the fundamental difference between the two groups?

We know that people change their mind about being trans so why are they allowed surgery that has a permanent effect?

Artemi · 18/01/2023 10:31

anyolddinosaur · 04/11/2022 06:36

autistic girls are being told you dont like the things girls are supposed to like, you must be a boy. Reality is that girls who dont like the things girls are supposed to like grow up to be adult women. Some of them become lesbians, some meet a man they are attracted to, one who does not require them to conform to gender stereotypes, some are now persuaded to permanently ruin their health by transition.

It's a massive safeguarding failure.

Amen.

I'm a woman who thought I was trans as a teenager.
Turns out I'm just a "tomboy" but I am easily led to the point of becoming obsessive with certain ideology and wanting to belong to a group. I knew I was "different" . I thought my inability to understand female socialisation/other girls and my distress at my changing body and my volatile mood in response to hormones was because I was trans.
Turns out I am autistic.

The existence and visbility of butch lesbians - who were women in a different way, in a way that I could relate to, was a major factor that prevented me transitioning.

Rainbowshit · 18/01/2023 10:26

We're going to be seeing more and more lawsuits as these poor children grow up and realise what they have lost. It's tragic.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 09:55

nypost.com/2022/12/03/detransitioner-im-suing-the-doctors-who-removed-my-healthy-breasts/amp/

Removal of healthy breasts - lawsuits

OP posts:
Pr1mr0se · 18/01/2023 09:09

YANBU.
Adults have a responsibility to protect children.

PonyPatter44 · 04/11/2022 08:19

@MumOnAMountain - *Boys who say they want to be girls must be given puberty blockers, so we're told, so that they can keep their bodies small and slim and youthful, even though they grow older. So that they are meant to "pass" as female.

And girls who want to be boys - but they are given the same puberty blockers too? That also restrict girls' growth? So they turn out to be... even smaller than nature intended, even though they want to be men?*

Who could possibly have a vested interest in legal adults with the bodies of prepubescent children? Hmm...I wonder.

FrancescaContini · 04/11/2022 06:37

It’s catastrophic.

anyolddinosaur · 04/11/2022 06:36

autistic girls are being told you dont like the things girls are supposed to like, you must be a boy. Reality is that girls who dont like the things girls are supposed to like grow up to be adult women. Some of them become lesbians, some meet a man they are attracted to, one who does not require them to conform to gender stereotypes, some are now persuaded to permanently ruin their health by transition.

It's a massive safeguarding failure.

MumOnAMountain · 04/11/2022 00:06

Boys who say they want to be girls must be given puberty blockers, so we're told, so that they can keep their bodies small and slim and youthful, even though they grow older. So that they are meant to "pass" as female.

And girls who want to be boys - but they are given the same puberty blockers too? That also restrict girls' growth? So they turn out to be... even smaller than nature intended, even though they want to be men?

So how does that logic work, then?

I'm sorry, but I think this whole business is totally fucked up, and we need to protect all children from causing unnecessary irreversible damage to their bodies.

What people do as adults is their own business. But children? No. We do not experiment on children, or use children to justify adult choices. We do not do that.

maddening · 04/11/2022 00:03

www.transgendertrend.com/current-evidence/

maddening · 03/11/2022 23:55

Loopyloopy · 03/11/2022 23:39

Do you have actual data on all of that, or is it just suppostition?

Not to hand but data I have seen- check out info by Helen Joyce and Anabelle Shrier who for example.

Loopyloopy · 03/11/2022 23:39

maddening · 03/11/2022 23:35

Not sure on surgeries but the start is puberty blockers which is given to children here leading to wrong sex hormones prior to 18, which along with social transition leads to a high propensity to progress to surgery - where if nothing was done around 90% would self resolve and be at peace with their sex by 18. It is a pathway which is hard for a child to desist from once started.

Do you have actual data on all of that, or is it just suppostition?

maddening · 03/11/2022 23:37

And ironically males who identify as women or non binary are more likely to not have surgery (80% remain intact) and just have hormones and stick a bit of makeup on.

maddening · 03/11/2022 23:35

Loopyloopy · 30/10/2022 09:38

Is this genuinely happening in the UK to under 18s or is it just scaremongering? I'm not in the UK, but I'm very surprised at the idea of this being done to under 18s anywhere outside the US, except in extreme circumstances.

Not sure on surgeries but the start is puberty blockers which is given to children here leading to wrong sex hormones prior to 18, which along with social transition leads to a high propensity to progress to surgery - where if nothing was done around 90% would self resolve and be at peace with their sex by 18. It is a pathway which is hard for a child to desist from once started.

WandaWomblesaurus · 03/11/2022 23:01

NotBadConsidering · 31/10/2022 21:19

There was also a post on Reddit recently where someone saw that the official name for their “top surgery” was mastectomy on hospital paper work and was shocked. Didn’t even realise that’s what she was having done.

That's crazy.
It's just self harm dressing in rainbows.

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 31/10/2022 21:19

There was also a post on Reddit recently where someone saw that the official name for their “top surgery” was mastectomy on hospital paper work and was shocked. Didn’t even realise that’s what she was having done.

nothingcomestonothing · 31/10/2022 17:45

Exactly - showing that these girls do not grasp the consequences of what they are signing up for. Anyone who thinks they can have a mastectomy then just grow back their breasts has been lied to or is incapable of understanding the information they've been given. Either way, they are not giving informed consent.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/10/2022 17:37

I've read tweets and reddits from FTM transitioned who believe that they can grow their breasts back by just stopping T and taking supplemental oestrogen because men can grow breasts by taking it.

Oh ffs. Men can make the breast tissue they've already got grow. Some men's breasts grow because of medicines like spironolactone.

nothingcomestonothing · 31/10/2022 15:44

All political parties and most institutions have been captured by an insane, misogynist ideology. If you haven't been paying attention, you need to start.

100% this. Please, if you haven't looked into this issue, please do so now. The 'break it down for me' thread on the feminism:sex and gender board is a good place to start.

BlackForestCake · 31/10/2022 11:33

Threads like this usually get moved to the feminism/sex and gender board so that people don't see them. Hopefully this one will stay where it is. All political parties and most institutions have been captured by an insane, misogynist ideology. If you haven't been paying attention, you need to start.

tkmethrthis · 31/10/2022 11:29

Anyway, LP need to be less mealy mouthed about it. It’s just the tone of these threads when they veer into politics, which invariably they do, is about what Labour might do, than what the Tories have done these past 12 years.

Definitely agree.

I'm a long time LP voter, it is disappointing, especially in the light of the findings of the Cass Review, that in order to appease the likes of Ben Cohen at Pink News, Starmer isn't stating that he will protect children and young adults from physical harm.

LadyWithLapdog · 31/10/2022 11:18

@tkmethrthis I get it now. I thought he’d said something like TWAW in law but he supports single sex spaces. Anyway, LP need to be less mealy mouthed about it. It’s just the tone of these threads when they veer into politics, which invariably they do, is about what Labour might do, than what the Tories have done these past 12 years.

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/10/2022 10:38

I’ve had this witheringly explained to me by my teens as ‘That’s because they only give blockers to people who know they’re trans so obviously they won’t desist

Bit of an own goal then isn't it because that means that they are part of the transition not a pause .

I long for the day people realise that every explanation actually debunks what was said before. It breaks the cases it never makes them

WandaWomblesaurus · 31/10/2022 10:30

PauliString · 31/10/2022 09:38

And that's without considering that if they truly did just give 'time to think', then a significiant proportion (larger than 1-2%) would just come off them and not go onto cross sex hormones.

I’ve had this witheringly explained to me by my teens as ‘That’s because they only give blockers to people who know they’re trans so obviously they won’t desist.’

I’ve found the best response is a very mild ‘Crikey, you must have a lot more faith in medical science than I do.’

We are battling children and young people/young adults, who have been indoctrinated behind our backs by the internet and by schools to believe that humans can actually change sex, that artificial cross hormones are safe to use on young healthy bodies and that we are evil if we ask questions.

How do we combat this?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread