Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THE OP'S QUESTIONS-We will leave this thread up to allow posters to offer their condolences if they wish

338 replies

debbiedesperado · 29/10/2022 23:38

My mum is 80 and has chronic COPD. She has had no quality of life for the past 18 months and has been in and out of hospital frequently. Yesterday she was in a lot of pain in her leg, it was totally paper white when I looked and she couldn't move her toes or feel her leg. Up to a and e we went.

She has a blood clot in her leg. They said for a healthy person they would operate straight away however she wouldn't survive the operation. They put her on morphine, antibiotics and a drug to try and dissolve the clot.

The doctor and surgeon this morning said that nothing is working and at this stage they would want to amputate the leg but she won't survive the surgery so basically there is nothing they can do.

My mum knows what is going on and is quite calm about it although she is still in some pain and hasn't eaten. Palliative care is starting tomorrow.

I feel really overwhelmed and numb, her leg is turning black. What can I expect from here? It seems they are just waiting for sepsis to set in and this sounds like an extremely painful death.

What should I expect from here? Does anyone know a timeline that I can expect deterioration? I am trying to prepare myself but also thinking surely there must be SOMETHING they can do? It doesn't seem right to just let her lie there with a black leg and let sepsis set in.

OP posts:
SuspiciousHedgehog · 30/10/2022 08:28

Echoing what's been said about a hospice, if you can OP, it's a much bettwr environment for you as well as your mum, they are amazing

Vinyasa474 · 30/10/2022 08:26

Not sure if any other medics have come along and explained it a bit better than the doctors but basically, your mothers lungs would not manage GA or intubation. A major part of intubation is whether the patient would manage extubation (removing the tube). If she's been in and out for hospital for months then her lung capacity can't be very good. It sounds like she has a blood clot in a major artery which is blocking off circulation below the level of the clot - this can only be removed surgery but sometimes they try intravenous blood thinners (depends on the size and location and carries risks). If her leg is turning black it means the tissues are dead or dying (necrosis) and yes by this point amputation is the treatment but it is major surgery and from working on vascular surgery wards, younger patients with far less comorbidities have taken months and months to recover. It's not just the immediate post op recovery, it's the long term functioning and mood disorders etc. I think (based on the information you have provided) that they have chosen the least harmful option for her. First, we do no harm. I hope the palliative team see her quickly- they are so good at what they do and will help to ensure she is as comfortable as possible. They will also offer support to you and your family. I hope you are okay and that your mother is not suffering.

NoSki · 30/10/2022 08:21

So sorry you are going through this and of course you will do anything to save her.
mot sounds like an arterial clot which kills everything beneath it instantly it doesn’t get blood supply. Most people think of venous clots which you have blood thinning injections and you’re all good usually.
people who have suffered a slow decline often at the end relais something quick in days happening. My Grandfather had a heart attack and that was what he wanted as he was just getting to the stage with his COPD that he was going to be bed kind within the week and he hates that.
But nothing will stop you wanting to do anything

maybe record her talking or ask her if there are any bits of jewellery she wants to tell you the story behind etc. Palliative care will help and only sedate her if she wishes it and she’s in distress and pain.

AnnapurnaSanctuary · 30/10/2022 08:21

It wouldn't be right to operate in these circumstances OP, palliative care means they can focus on managing the pain which is the most important thing right now.

Thinking of you and your mum Flowers

hippoherostandinghere · 30/10/2022 08:19

I'm so sorry to hear of this difficult situation you are in. I know this is a difficult and emotive time for you OP but please read the advice of @olympicsrock and other medical professionals on this thread and try not let other whip you up into a frenzy. It's not a decision that will have been taken lightly.

We were told on my mum's birthday this year that there was nothing more they could do for her, she was in end stage liver failure. They stopped all meds, fluids and food. The Palliative care team came and installed a syringe driver to control any pain. She was settled and peaceful for 13 days before she quietly slipped away. It's heartbreaking and devastating but it was the right choice, she couldn't be cured. She was 66.

Will be thinking of you in this difficult time. Keep posting, you'll get lots of support here.

anyolddinosaur · 30/10/2022 08:16

What the NHS can do for her now is increase her pain relief to an extent that will control the pain but shorten her life. I have been through this with my then partner's father, although his problem was different. He had a gentle death surrounded by a loving family. It sounds as those your mother is still capable of taking her own decisions and this is also what she has chosen, her doctors will not over-ride that even if family disagree. My now husband's father was not able to make his own decision so the family had to agree - it was the right choice. Since then I have seen other deaths where an animal would have been euthanised but people suffer.

Accept your mother's decision. It is cruel to deprive someone of a gentle death to meet your own needs. Ask if hospice care is possible. It's a tough time for the family but in years to come you will realise this is what you would want yourself.

WisherWood · 30/10/2022 08:14

I just think, they say she will die on the operating table, but she will die if they just leave her and in a lot more pain. So couldn't they just try to operate? If she goes then she goes peacefully. Not operating and leaving her seems cruel.

I'm sorry you're going through this OP. However, I agree with PP that if they go into an operation knowing she wouldn't survive, they are effectively talking about euthanasia. I cannot imagine a surgeon wanting to go into an operation on an elderly person knowing that their actions would in all probability kill the patient.

As awful as it is, sometimes we have to accept death. I think modern western cultures can be very bad at this. Spend time with your mother. Make the most of being with her and being able to say goodbye. As horrible as it is to hear this, dying on the operating table is actually a rather brutal way to go. I think it is better for her to go in her own time, with pain relief and sedatives.

stemthetide · 30/10/2022 08:13

Posters glibly stating they would want surgery to be attempted have no clue.

They should read the posts from those who know what they are taking about and who also have empathy.

borntobequiet · 30/10/2022 08:13

My mother didn’t have COPD but did have heart disease. After she broke her hip aged 83 they did operate but she didn’t survive the operation. Her heart gave out and she never regained consciousness. I believe she died peacefully, but we weren’t there and never got a chance to say a proper goodbye, which still saddens me.
She had been a nurse so was in fact clear about the risk involved (as were we) and of course it was a very different situation. But it sounds as though the doctors are doing the right thing in this case.

40andfit · 30/10/2022 08:11

GlassDeli · 30/10/2022 01:45

In what way is the op 'euthanasia'? The purpose would not be to end a life, even if that were the result.

To be blunt they won’t get as far as operating. She would die as soon as they tried the anaesthetic.

purfectpuss · 30/10/2022 08:10

OP, it all sounds horrendous and that there really isn't any good outcome. However, surely if your mother is still able to make choices she should be given options and allowed to take whichever she chooses. She may decide she doesn't.t want to risk surgery and the consequences if she does survive of living with one leg when she is already very unwell are too much. Even she survives surgery she may not be able to heal well if her health is poor and succumb to infection anyway.

Fuuuuuckit · 30/10/2022 08:10

Oh op, I'm so sorry, you must be in such a fog of emotion and shock.

My mum had moderate COPD and they discovered lung cancer tumours. Her lung capacity was only 50% and they wouldn't operate due to the risk to her recovery. If your mum's COPD is severe her lung capacity will be much lower, so it does make awful sense that the risks are intensified to a point that they won't even consider it.

Severe COPD is life-limiting - you say her live has been limited for 18 months, it's likely to have been decreasing in quality much longer, and she possibly has other health stuff going on too. If she's fully understanding of the situation, perhaps there is some deep feeling of relief that her struggles - every waking breath - are coming to an end.

As pp said, once the situation with her leg triggers off the chain of sepsis, her death is likely to follow quickly.

Please use the time she is coherent to make sure her wishes are made clear, and heard.

In the meantime, please keep eating, have a drink, take time off work. Sleep will overtake you eventually. Unmumsnetty hugs xxx

curlymom · 30/10/2022 08:03

Sorry for this op.
my mum has copd and is 84. I think each case is different as mum had breast cancer three years ago, about your mums age, and had three general anaesthetics for the three operations including mastectomy. She isn’t as bouncy as before and they were worried but they did loads of tests before the ops before they went ahead. She’s ok now but her copd is usually well controlled. Every case is different.
it’s understandable you didn’t ask everything so I suggest writing it all down and taking your questions in. Cover every option. Sending you hugs x

FlowerBrooch · 30/10/2022 07:58

It is a very long time since I assisted in day surgery where general anaesthetics were administered. I think it’s quite hard for anyone without medical training and knowledge to disentangle the emotional side of illness with known procedures. It would be very wrong to put this poor lady through a GA and I see that @olympicsrock has written and explained with great detail and knowledge and I also wanted to thank them for taking the time to do so.

My Father knew he was dying and completely accepted it. He actually refused all cancer treatment, he was 83 at the time. He could have extended his life by maybe up to a year but decided he didn’t want to. His care was excellent and I cried with the lovely hospice nurse who was there with me when he passed. He seemed very happy when he was coming towards the actual end. We had chatted about various things and he was looking forward to seeing the sister he had who died when she was a very small child back in the 1930’s.

Quite often people just before they die perk up for a day, my Dad did and asked for fish and chips of all things, which he had and enjoyed. My father in law did the same, I had to explain to DH that it actually meant he was definitely going to pass soon. I’m just writing this because it gave DH some sort of hope and it worried me greatly.

Sending love, reach out here and in real life.

Coffeewinecake · 30/10/2022 07:55

That must have a be horrendous time for you and your DH, Kennykenkencat.
So sad reading everyone’s experiences

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 30/10/2022 07:53

giggly · 30/10/2022 06:55

I would also like to say how shocked I am at some of the posts in here with people who display such a lack of medical knowledge about end of life care but throw their tuppence in.
All this rubbish about NHS costs/ euthanasia/ lack of care is both deeply offensive as a NHS nurse and disrespectful to the thousands of medical and support staff who deal with life and death every day as a means of employment.
For those saying they would want their family member operated on have a mo g hard think about what that actually means.
As someone who prayed, bargained and silently begged for more time for my df as I wasn’t t (are we ever) ready to lose him, I did accept what was actually in his best interests.
Sending you lots of hugs and care OP

Agree. Telling the doctors not to attempt resuscitation on my df (different situation, intubated and only in his 60s) was the hardest thing I have ever done. They presented it as a choice but with stark warnings about what his quality of life would entail. I wanted to keep him around at all costs, but this is certainly not what he would want 💔

OP I am desperately sorry about the situation your dm and family are in. I hope that she is comfortable* *and that you and her important people are able to be with her 💐

LeFeu · 30/10/2022 07:52

I’m so sorry you’re going through this OP. Please know that palliative care are incredible and will keep your mum comfortable. When my gran died the palliative care nurses were happy to explain everything that was going on in a compassionate and clear way. Ask questions and remember the most important thing is your mum’s peace and dignity.

Thismonkeysgonetodevon · 30/10/2022 07:50

@olympicsrock Your kind, informative post also brought tears to my eyes. I think gathering as much knowledge as possible will be helpful as the not knowing and lack of communication can be very hard to deal with.

@spidersenses I’m very sorry for the loss of your dad. His experience sounds very similar to my dad’s. I would now always urge anyone to try to move their loved one to a hospice or home if at all practical.

LilyTheSavage · 30/10/2022 07:47

Beautiful post @olympicsrock . Compassionate and thoughtful.
Good luck OP. I hope your darling mum is peaceful and calm. More unmumsnetty hugs from me.

Missikat13 · 30/10/2022 07:46

I don't have experience of COPD but am currently witnessing what palliative care looks like with my dad. He has dementia (fairly late stage but was still able to converse, just no short term memory, or much memory at all from the last 10 years or so). 4 weeks ago he had a stroke, a huge bleed on the brain. He survived that, amazingly, but wasn't able to talk or move one side of his body afterwards at all. He was also unable to swallow. After trying a feeding tube and feeding by mouth, unsuccessfully, they have decided nothing more can be done and the dementia means rehab would be impossible.

We then moved to a palliative care situation. This means he's had all nutrition and his IV fluids removed and is constantly receiving drugs through a syringe driver to keep him comfortable and in no discomfort, anxiety or pain. I had no idea how long this could go on for, it's now been 10 days since he had any fluids and he's still going. We've been told it can be anything from a few days to a couple of weeks. It is a very hard experience, but the palliative care team have been amazing, checking him regularly and they then recommend the appropriate medication to keep him comfortable to the nursing staff. The nurses will then give as required and if we say he looks agitated or in pain at all they will give more. We are here a lot with him, although he's in hospital he has a side room and we can stay as long as we want, or overnight which we're doing a lot. I had no idea what to expect, but actually for us the info we've had since he moved to palliative care has been clearer than when they were trying treatment. It is very, very hard, and feels like you are just 'letting' someone you love die, but the point of palliative care is to ensure there is no pain, discomfort, anxiety, nausea etc. The palliative care nurses are something else, such care and compassion. Thinking of you, and wishing your mum the most comfortable loving end she can have. You will find strength to get through it and be able to be there with your mum which is a wonderful gift.

Coffeewinecake · 30/10/2022 07:44

montysma1 · 29/10/2022 23:48

Surely to god they should let her take the chances with the operation? If she didnt make it through surgery and died on the table, surely thats a more humane way to go than what they have in mind?

They can’t wheel her into theatre and knowingly kill her.
If this is the plan, who gets to pick the day, time of death? What if an urgent case comes in and they need to reschedule the moment of demise?
Do patients stay in hospital waiting for their allocated slot? Or do we build new centres where people stay whilst they wait for their appointment for euthanasia?

All sounds like hyperbole but this is the path we will head down. Many conditions are not dissimilar to incurable cancer in that eventually there will be a ceiling of treatment and the risk v benefit will tip heavily towards risk.

OP seems lovely and understandably looking at any way that her mum can be pain free and comfortable. I would feel the same.

Kennykenkencat · 30/10/2022 07:40

debbiedesperado · 29/10/2022 23:49

My thoughts exactly.

We had similar with Dh and ended up paying for all his cancer treatment and operations and months in a private hospital.

I really can’t put into words how angry I am at hearing this type of thing.

DH is still with us and still in remission

Mrsmch123 · 30/10/2022 07:38

@NorthernLights5 your not "just" a carer. As a nurse carers are my eyes and ears on the floor as they spend they most amount of time with my resident. If one of them tell me something is off with my resident I 100% believe them and act accordingly. I would be lost without my carers🥰

Rosebel · 30/10/2022 07:35

I'm so sorry and it does sound cruel. My great uncle was 96 when they amputated his leg. He survived the operation but did die 3 days later.
He was happy though after the operation and wasn't in pain but this was a long time ago, about 20 years, so perhaps now they're more likely to look at how their patients are to survive.
I suppose its a positive that you have the chance to say goodbye and usually palliative care is very peaceful.

Vallmo47 · 30/10/2022 07:30

OP I am very sorry for the pain you are going through. If you only manage to read one single reply on this thread please make it @olympicsrock. Your mum is calm and at peace with what is happening by the sounds of it. I wish you the very best.