Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THE OP'S QUESTIONS-We will leave this thread up to allow posters to offer their condolences if they wish

338 replies

debbiedesperado · 29/10/2022 23:38

My mum is 80 and has chronic COPD. She has had no quality of life for the past 18 months and has been in and out of hospital frequently. Yesterday she was in a lot of pain in her leg, it was totally paper white when I looked and she couldn't move her toes or feel her leg. Up to a and e we went.

She has a blood clot in her leg. They said for a healthy person they would operate straight away however she wouldn't survive the operation. They put her on morphine, antibiotics and a drug to try and dissolve the clot.

The doctor and surgeon this morning said that nothing is working and at this stage they would want to amputate the leg but she won't survive the surgery so basically there is nothing they can do.

My mum knows what is going on and is quite calm about it although she is still in some pain and hasn't eaten. Palliative care is starting tomorrow.

I feel really overwhelmed and numb, her leg is turning black. What can I expect from here? It seems they are just waiting for sepsis to set in and this sounds like an extremely painful death.

What should I expect from here? Does anyone know a timeline that I can expect deterioration? I am trying to prepare myself but also thinking surely there must be SOMETHING they can do? It doesn't seem right to just let her lie there with a black leg and let sepsis set in.

OP posts:
olympicsrock · 30/10/2022 10:10

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 09:49

'If OP’s mum didn’t have such bad COPD an above knee amputation might have been'

You do know that people with copd have hip and knee replacements all the time using spinal blocks rather then GAs? Granted it isn't an amputation but it is far more complex and lengthy surgery. People with copd are not usually written off.

Surgeons need to talk to actual anaesthetists before deciding these things.

Surgeons speak to anaesthetists all the time, we are one team after all. I have done major amputations under spinal anaesthetics and even regional blocks with sedation.
We know what is possible…. We also have perioperatuvr care geriatricians as part of the team who help patients make these decisions with a holistic viewpoint.

My point about not doing a major amputation in someone with severe COPD was not in relation in the technicalities of doing the operation/ anaesthesia but more in relation to her poor quality of life afterwards and life expectancy.

Anyway - OPs mum is an individual. OP should have a conversation with her consultant to explore what the options are .

SapatSea · 30/10/2022 10:08

My MIL was in this situation. The doctors did give her a time frame of 2-4 weeks before death. Perhaps your DM's doctor could give a likely time frame for her. MIL had a pacemaker, was on blood thinners and other meds but had been living an active life - so perhaps this is why she survived longer than expected, dying after 6 weeks. The hospital offered her a side room and palliative care or the option to contact hospice care but she wanted to die at home.

It seemed really stark to be told you would die of a clot and slowly be poisoned but MIL understood why they wouldn't operate and did have a couple of weeks when she was lucid enough for people to come and say goodbye and seemed remarkably calm about it all before weeks of sleepy dreams and oblivion as things progressed.

countrygirl99 · 30/10/2022 10:05

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:04

'An above knee amputation in an elderly person with serious medical problems means almost total loss of independence in the most basic ways. I would not choose it for myself or my loved ones.'

It is a quick operation which as I keep saying done under spinal has no affect on those with copd. It then allows patients to die with their pain under control and with dignity.

But OPs mum can't have a spinal due to the medication she had been on.

funnelfanjo · 30/10/2022 10:05

I’m sorry OP. We went through something very similar with my dad although the blood clot was elsewhere - the anaesthetist took one look at him and his charts and said no way was he a candidate for anaesthetic. Everyone was very kind saying there was nothing that could be done and dad was 88 and in frail health so we accepted it and did our best to make peace. The doctor said some patients hang on for a few days, but Dad slipped away quietly the first night. The nurses had found him a side room and he was not in any pain. Dying quietly in his sleep was the end he wanted, and apart from not being at home in his own bed, he got that. We found some comfort in that.

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:04

'An above knee amputation in an elderly person with serious medical problems means almost total loss of independence in the most basic ways. I would not choose it for myself or my loved ones.'

It is a quick operation which as I keep saying done under spinal has no affect on those with copd. It then allows patients to die with their pain under control and with dignity.

countrygirl99 · 30/10/2022 10:02

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 09:49

'If OP’s mum didn’t have such bad COPD an above knee amputation might have been'

You do know that people with copd have hip and knee replacements all the time using spinal blocks rather then GAs? Granted it isn't an amputation but it is far more complex and lengthy surgery. People with copd are not usually written off.

Surgeons need to talk to actual anaesthetists before deciding these things.

It already been explained that spinal blocks are not suitable for patients like the OPs mum that have been on high doses of blood thinners.

olympicsrock · 30/10/2022 10:01

I’m glad that a few MNs who have lost relatives to acute limb ischaemia have been able to share their experiences of it being a peaceful end with their relative being gradually less conscious and pain free over a few days.

The patient is usually in a side room and families are welcomed ( at any time at the end)

After a sudden event like this this is no infection , and if the leg remains dry there is no ‘smell’ just a change in colour and temperature. Any pain can be managed. The leg is under a clean sheet and is not distressing for anyone.

It is not a bad way to go at all.

oakleaffy · 30/10/2022 09:54

@olympicsrock That explains it very clearly- and humanely.
Your patients are fortunate to have someone like you on their corner.

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 09:49

'If OP’s mum didn’t have such bad COPD an above knee amputation might have been'

You do know that people with copd have hip and knee replacements all the time using spinal blocks rather then GAs? Granted it isn't an amputation but it is far more complex and lengthy surgery. People with copd are not usually written off.

Surgeons need to talk to actual anaesthetists before deciding these things.

fastandthecurious1 · 30/10/2022 09:46

OP my mum passed with similar circumstances but different main illness, December just gone. She was 71 also chronic COPD. She has what we thought was UTI symptoms and had a few weeks of antibiotics however the pain got worse and her appetite disappeared and she was sleeping more often that not.
I called a doctor out and she was admitted for kidney infection possibly.... at this point.
She went in at 8pm and i received a call at 3.45M from a surgeon telling me scans showed a perforated bowel and bad Infection. They were going to operate then and there to save her. I then got a call one hour later saving they had spoken to my mum about everything and they didn't think her lungs wound survive surgery and the complications were vast so she and they agreed not to proceed.
I then called her and it was she odd as she was so calm and matter of fact and chatty. I went to see her and the doctors came and told us everything together none would give any timeframe just hints it was imminent. She stayed in hospital had 3/4 good days of being awake chatty and herself, then 1 bad day of being very sick and sleepy, one full day asleep the whole day and not really aware I was there then the next 2 days entirely asleep with no ability to talk etc. she passed peacefully in the 7 day in hospital.
Any advice would be get in all the ti e you can as sepsis can take over quickly as can a burst blood clot ( she has one of those years previously also)
But the hospital (I got mum into macmillan) will make sure she's very comfortable and settled if need so dont worry about pain. Hugs to you x

TheNoodlesIncident · 30/10/2022 09:46

We have been through similar with MIL, she had atrial defibrillation and a clot in her bowel. She went into hospital fussing about her handbag and asking for coffee, slipped away five days later. They made her comfortable when it became clear that there was nothing that could done that would serve her best interests. I deeply regret that it was during Covid so only DH could be with her. I couldn't go and see her at all Sad , I never saw her again and poor DH had to do without support there (except for the nurses who were great, but they were understandably very busy).

Worse for DH was he had been through similar with his dad a few months earlier and again, I couldn't be there for him Sad

It is hard accepting that there is nothing that can be done to save the person, and the priority now is ensuring they don't suffer. The staff will be acting in your mum's best interests, it would clearly be wrong to put through an ordeal like surgery that would almost certainly end her life away from the ward, where you would be able to be with her. Thinking of you Flowers

olympicsrock · 30/10/2022 09:44

I’m glad to have been able to provide information that is comforting . Some of the posts on here are just going to cause OP more stress and distress.

At the end of the day we try to provide care that is in line with patient wishes. If OP’s mum didn’t have such bad COPD an above knee amputation might have been an option. It is not kind to put someone through the trauma of major surgery and pain of an amputation for them to die shortly afterwards .

If you explain to someone what their quality of life will be like afterward a major amputation many people CHOOSE palliative care, particularly if they have poor health, poor quality of life and a probable short life expectancy .

An above knee amputation in an elderly person with serious medical problems means almost total loss of independence in the most basic ways. I would not choose it for myself or my loved ones.

I hope that the medical team looking after OPs mum and making these decisions will have been able to gently and clearly explain that they can’t save her leg and the reality of what an above knee amputation vs palliative care mean. In many cases such as this one palliative care is the gentler kinder option. PM me if I can help.

Love and strength to OP

oakleaffy · 30/10/2022 09:44

Mrsmch123 · 30/10/2022 07:38

@NorthernLights5 your not "just" a carer. As a nurse carers are my eyes and ears on the floor as they spend they most amount of time with my resident. If one of them tell me something is off with my resident I 100% believe them and act accordingly. I would be lost without my carers🥰

Agreed-@NorthernLights5 I had a spine op a few years ago and the Carers were great.
Really patient and respectful of dignity . (bed bath &c)
I remember the carer I had - The woman in next bed said how good the Carer was, too.
A good one remembered - Especially when one feels vulnerable!
Thanks for doing a great job 💖

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 09:43

I'm so sorry op Flowers.

Surely even with copd she could have a spinal block for an amputation rather than a GA. Ask the consultant to please liaise with an anaesthetist asap. She could have sedation too it would mean she would be asleep not unconscious.

No one should die of gangrene please ask them to reconsider.

Lovemusic33 · 30/10/2022 09:35

So sorry you are going through this OP, the not knowing ‘when’ is just awful. She will be given drugs for the pain and eventually she will probably be on such a high dose or morphine she will hardly be awake. It does seem cruel but she won’t be in pain.

Bestcatmum · 30/10/2022 09:34

I'm so sorry OP. I'm an NHS critical care podiatrist and I have many patients in this situation having end of life care. There is nothing they can do except amputate and that is a risk that your mum has to decide for herself whether to take but sadly is not likely to survive. But it sounds like she can't have a GA. You are looking at end of life care now. Maybe it is time to ask about hospice care to relieve the symptoms.
I'm so sorry it is such a stressful time for you.

TonTonMacoute · 30/10/2022 09:32

I'm so sorry OP.

Many people are suggesting that dying in theatre would be a better option than leaving her. Can you really wave your mum off for an operation knowing that you are almost certainly not going to see her again?

Add to that the very knowledgeable post from olympicsrock above.

If your mum survives the operation the pain following an amputation will be off the scale compared with the pain she is in now.

Accept the sad truth and make the most of the time you have left with your mum.

ElizabethBest · 30/10/2022 09:30

@debbiedesperado im really sorry for the position you are in but there’s nothing peaceful about dying on the operating table. All you’d be asking here is essentially for medical staff to immediately execute her. We need to do what is in the best interests of the patient all round and a traumatic and invasive procedure is not it. If nothing more can be done then the kindest thing is to provide pain medication and sedatives and let her slip away when she is ready. I know that’s hard to hear, but it is.

To proceed with operating would also be taking up a trained team of specialists, and a theatre, and an ICU bed when there is no chance of recovery - it also wouldn’t be fair to other patients in need of those services who could tolerate surgery. I know other patients aren’t your priority but that’s the choice that staff are making.

Our overall mandate is that the patient comes first, and we must do no harm. This means that in an impossible choice between doing something that would definitely kill your mother and letting her die when her body is ready, we must always choose the latter, and make that as comfortable for her as possible.

Sunshinebug · 30/10/2022 09:30

How terribly sad. My thoughts are with you. We had a relative start palliative care and they said it could be anytime up to a year qualified for this type of care, however the nurse when asked also gave a view that it would be weeks not months in our case. This turned out to be very accurate, 3.5 weeks. Around the last week it became clear that everything was slowing down, sleeping most of the time, on morphine by this time round the clock and we were told it probably would be within days and this was when everyone visited to say their goodbyes. I’d encourage you to talk to the palliative nurses, very difficult as it is. If they have a view they will tell you but also they will be clear that it’s impossible to be totally accurate.

Huntswomanonthemove · 30/10/2022 09:29

montysma1 · 29/10/2022 23:48

Surely to god they should let her take the chances with the operation? If she didnt make it through surgery and died on the table, surely thats a more humane way to go than what they have in mind?

I disagree with you. The team will have considered how poorly she is and won’t put her through all that trauma if a poor outcome is expected.

My grandma was admitted with a similar story. She had palliative care in hospital and was sleepy and peaceful when we visited. She died a week after being admitted and we were so glad that she only received palliative care.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 30/10/2022 09:28

What is happening to your mum sounds very much like what happened to my cousin, almost word for word. Surgery was mentioned but he wouldn’t survive the operation. He was taken into a side ward where received palliative care, he died peacefully and in no pain a few days later. Sometimes the kindest thing is to do nothing. He died with his family next to him, if he’d had the surgery he wouldn’t have had that.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 30/10/2022 09:25

I'm so sorry this happening for you all. My only experience of palliative care comes from when my dad was in his last week or so with cancer. From our first visit to him on that ward we felt like we were in a different place. The ward sister said that they didn't want anyone to be in pain. They were focussed on making dad's last days as comfortable and peaceful as possible. While he was in a four bay ward we had to stick to visiting times but I was told to call any time, day or night, to see how he was.

A few days before he died he moved to a side room and we were told to come and go as we pleased. The care given to our whole family was all we could have asked for.

Don't be afraid to ask questions. Or to get someone else to ask them if you are too upset. Your mum is clearly very loved and it sounds like you have a wonderful family to support you.

Buteverythingsfine · 30/10/2022 09:17

I agree that @olympicsrock 's post is brilliant at explaining why these choices are made as they are- even if the OP's mum didn't have COPD, someone with poor quality of life may well choose not to have an amputation anyway if the prospect of painful prolonged suffering were ahead.

Mummyoflittledragon · 30/10/2022 09:14

Kennykenkencat · 30/10/2022 07:40

We had similar with Dh and ended up paying for all his cancer treatment and operations and months in a private hospital.

I really can’t put into words how angry I am at hearing this type of thing.

DH is still with us and still in remission

This is a very different scenario and I understand your frustration as I know someone given similar choices. Whether in the private or public sector, one would advocate for surgery under these circumstances. Please read the lovely and knowledgeable post from @olympicsrock

Buteverythingsfine · 30/10/2022 09:14

I have recently spent a lot of time visiting someone on a ward with lots of similar patients.

The most notably happy and calm patient was the lady on palliative care in the corner. She had two broken legs and it was explained to her family (as you can hear everything) that even if they operated on one, she could not weight bear on the other and basically infection and sepsis would set in anyway and it would be a longer and more painful death. She was on morphine, seemed happy and calm, was asked if she wanted to go home and said no she was happy in hospital, was listening to the radio, eating her hospital dinners and slept the vast majority of the time.

The other women on the ward, without exception, cried. Never when their families were visiting though. They had exceptionally ulcerated legs, breaks, bed sores, weeping wounds and most were 80-90 years old and the thought of not being able to walk about and live normally was heartbreaking to them. I spent a lot of time with one lady and she cried most of every day, just tears running down her face as she had a wound infection that had lasted 6 months and was extremely painful, in both legs.

I realised then why the lady on palliative care was feeling ok, she was on morphine (as were all the others) but more importantly she was clearly at peace with her death. Imagine having an amputation- I wouldn't want that at my age. Now imagine doing that age 80, having had poor quality of life already, with all the attendant problems of infections, inability to move, having to be toileted by others always (a lot of the ladies cried over their weeing/pooing which others had to clear up even though the carers were lovely about it, I guess it's the feeling of humiliation), the psychological loss of a limb, the threat of bed sores (as you can't move and have thinner skin). It's not the same prospect as a 30 year old with good healing properties having an amputation where there's a realistic prospect of a happy healthy mobile life ahead.

I think when you get old, or even when you are young and in terrible pain and discomfort, you realise there are things worse than death. Hugs to you OP, I would be led by your mum on this if you can, she is calm in the face of it, even though for you it must feel just so terrible. More hugs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread