Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THE OP'S QUESTIONS-We will leave this thread up to allow posters to offer their condolences if they wish

338 replies

debbiedesperado · 29/10/2022 23:38

My mum is 80 and has chronic COPD. She has had no quality of life for the past 18 months and has been in and out of hospital frequently. Yesterday she was in a lot of pain in her leg, it was totally paper white when I looked and she couldn't move her toes or feel her leg. Up to a and e we went.

She has a blood clot in her leg. They said for a healthy person they would operate straight away however she wouldn't survive the operation. They put her on morphine, antibiotics and a drug to try and dissolve the clot.

The doctor and surgeon this morning said that nothing is working and at this stage they would want to amputate the leg but she won't survive the surgery so basically there is nothing they can do.

My mum knows what is going on and is quite calm about it although she is still in some pain and hasn't eaten. Palliative care is starting tomorrow.

I feel really overwhelmed and numb, her leg is turning black. What can I expect from here? It seems they are just waiting for sepsis to set in and this sounds like an extremely painful death.

What should I expect from here? Does anyone know a timeline that I can expect deterioration? I am trying to prepare myself but also thinking surely there must be SOMETHING they can do? It doesn't seem right to just let her lie there with a black leg and let sepsis set in.

OP posts:
Kitkatandcoffee · 30/10/2022 11:01

Many years ago they amputated my grans leg because of a massive clot.
I wish they hadn’t done it she was so mentally stressed afterwards and died within a week.
It was awful. I wish they had just gave her palliative care rather than subjecting her to an amputation. she had went into it knowing that she would be disabled afterwards but it seemed to cause a break her mind. She was so distressed afterwards very muddled in her thinking and died very quickly. It was very distressing for us all.

CaptainMyCaptain · 30/10/2022 11:00

DonnaBanana · 30/10/2022 09:06

It doesn't seem right to just let her lie there with a black leg and let sepsis set in.

It is not right at all. Thirty years ago they would have operated. This is a consequence of statistics and targets. They don’t want your mum to potentially be an operative fatality and look bad on them. It’s horrible and sad when an amputation is the best chance of an improvement in quality of life.

Rubbish.

anyolddinosaur · 30/10/2022 10:57

@LookingAtYou As you recognise this is end of life care.
The OP is not being asked to decide, she is being asked to support the decision of a mother able to make up her own mind. You are assuming her doctors have not already considered all the options. You are assuming this has not already been talked through with the mother.

OP even some doctors dont know when to let go. If doctors were able to operate and if your mother survived how long would she have? How many bed sores and infections would she suffer?

Your mother has made her peace, your job is to let her go without making her suffer for her remaining time.

bewarethetides · 30/10/2022 10:57

debbiedesperado · 29/10/2022 23:47

I just think, they say she will die on the operating table, but she will die if they just leave her and in a lot more pain. So couldn't they just try to operate? If she goes then she goes peacefully. Not operating and leaving her seems cruel.

That is exactly what I would ask ... and what I would want for myself. I'd say what I want to say to my loved ones first. Then say no heroic efforts on the operating table, but a chance to live without a leg or a painfree death.

I'm so sorry, OP. My heart goes out to you both. Good luck advocating for your poor mum, I know it's not easy.

countrygirl99 · 30/10/2022 10:54

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:46

'OP - ask why she can't have it removed under Spinal?'

She is on thinners. Thinners are stopped all the time for blocks and surgery though.

When DHs dad had surgery under a spinal op he had to stop the thinners a week before surgery though.

NatalieIsFreezing · 30/10/2022 10:54

I am genuinely surprised at all the people suggesting that OP effectively ask doctors to end her mother's life, on the operating table. Do people think "tell them to take the chances with anaestgetic and surgery" is how the medical profession works?

iRun2eatCake · 30/10/2022 10:51

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:46

'OP - ask why she can't have it removed under Spinal?'

She is on thinners. Thinners are stopped all the time for blocks and surgery though.

And the thinning effect can also be reversed with other medication.

OP - for your own peace of mind - ask about Spinal and also ask if the blood clot can be removed under local anaesthesia - embolectomy

Worriedddd · 30/10/2022 10:49

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

No has anyone asked what her mum wants? She might not want the operation or an amputation. OP has said she has a poor quality of life, it should be about quality not quantity of life.

PearlclutchersInc · 30/10/2022 10:47

@debbiedesperado So sorry for your situation. You can perhaps take a little comfort in that your mum seems to be at peace. 💐

Bunnycat101 · 30/10/2022 10:46

Given the complications and her existing quality of life, the medical staff would have weighed up the balance of benefit. It must be heartbreaking for you all but I would prefer a well-managed death than a traumatic surgery with a poor chance of survival. Quality of life for me is more important than attempting to preserve life at any cost.

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:46

'OP - ask why she can't have it removed under Spinal?'

She is on thinners. Thinners are stopped all the time for blocks and surgery though.

iRun2eatCake · 30/10/2022 10:45

ivykaty44 · 29/10/2022 23:51

montysma1 How do you give anesthetic to someone with chronic COPD?

She wouldn't need an general anaesthetic.

OP - ask why she can't have it removed under Spinal?

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:44

'But you think docs should perform a high risk operation that will likely decrease the quality of life for this 80 year old woman further? Can you explain a bit more so I understand your thinking?'

It is about dying with dignity, not of gangrene. Of course it won't improve her quality of life but it is a quick operation that will then mean her pain would be better managed even if it is still a palliative care situation obviously not curative.

I understand we are talking about a person's loved one and I do not want to be insensitive but thinners are often stopped for an op, it's past that stage anyway and people with copd have blocks all the time. I just hope this patient and her family are getting the best advice.

rwalker · 30/10/2022 10:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

GingerScallop · 30/10/2022 10:33

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:12

'It already been explained that spinal blocks are not suitable for patients like the OPs mum that have been on high doses of blood thinners.'

But we are now talking about end of life care, the patient has gangrene thinners won't make any difference at this stage, they should be stopped for a block.Then sub cut could be given post op.

I have just seen so many times surgeons deciding these things without consulting anaesthetists.

Anyway sorry again op, just for any others reading always push for second and third opinions.

OP said her mum has had no quality of life for the last 18 months. 18 months. But you think docs should perform a high risk operation that will likely decrease the quality of life for this 80 year old woman further? Can you explain a bit more so I understand your thinking? This is obviously difficult for OP and family but am not sure how amputation is the best option

Perfectlystill · 30/10/2022 10:32

I am so sorry OP. This sounds horrendous for all of you. 💐

Livetoplay · 30/10/2022 10:22

It’s time for her to go. I know it’s hard to accept it but she has no quality of life. It’s just her time.

Supergirl1958 · 30/10/2022 10:20

First of all sorry about your situation. Secondly, my uncle was in a similar situation (though he was in his late 60s) and he passed away 2 weeks ago after original diagnosis in January 2020. medications and such helped, his situation wasn’t entirely the same, but similar. Hope you’re ok sending hugs xx

oakleaffy · 30/10/2022 10:20

FlowerBrooch · 30/10/2022 07:58

It is a very long time since I assisted in day surgery where general anaesthetics were administered. I think it’s quite hard for anyone without medical training and knowledge to disentangle the emotional side of illness with known procedures. It would be very wrong to put this poor lady through a GA and I see that @olympicsrock has written and explained with great detail and knowledge and I also wanted to thank them for taking the time to do so.

My Father knew he was dying and completely accepted it. He actually refused all cancer treatment, he was 83 at the time. He could have extended his life by maybe up to a year but decided he didn’t want to. His care was excellent and I cried with the lovely hospice nurse who was there with me when he passed. He seemed very happy when he was coming towards the actual end. We had chatted about various things and he was looking forward to seeing the sister he had who died when she was a very small child back in the 1930’s.

Quite often people just before they die perk up for a day, my Dad did and asked for fish and chips of all things, which he had and enjoyed. My father in law did the same, I had to explain to DH that it actually meant he was definitely going to pass soon. I’m just writing this because it gave DH some sort of hope and it worried me greatly.

Sending love, reach out here and in real life.

@FlowerBrooch What a lovely post ( Brought tears to my eyes- esp your Dad meeting his sister.
You are right about the visceral gut punch reaction people have when they are suddenly confronted with big issues like these- OP is worried her mum will suffer unduly with a degrading limb.

Non - medics of course wouldn’t know the risks of anaesthesia.
People generally fear a “Bad” death for either themselves or a loved one.
Olympicsrock, the Vascular consultant surgeon explained it beautifully to those of us who aren’t medics.

Marchmount · 30/10/2022 10:18

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:12

'It already been explained that spinal blocks are not suitable for patients like the OPs mum that have been on high doses of blood thinners.'

But we are now talking about end of life care, the patient has gangrene thinners won't make any difference at this stage, they should be stopped for a block.Then sub cut could be given post op.

I have just seen so many times surgeons deciding these things without consulting anaesthetists.

Anyway sorry again op, just for any others reading always push for second and third opinions.

Why do you think amputating the leg of an 80yo women with no quality of life is the best thing to do? Even if she makes it through surgery she will go back to having no quality of life except now she will be totally immobile. Just because something may be possible (and you don’t have the information to know that she would definitely make it through the operation) doesn’t mean it should be done. A good death is often the kindest outcome.

olympicsrock · 30/10/2022 10:18

To clarify - a limb salvage operation can’t be done under spinal if the patient is on blood thinners ( or if done there is high risk of spinal bleeding and paralysis) .

An amputation can be done and is often done under spinal anaesthetic. The issue is about whether is is kind / right to amputate a limb at a high level in someone who already has poor quality of life. It is a very traumatic event often with significant postoperative pain and complications which include pneumonia .

Calmdown14 · 30/10/2022 10:13

The OP has described her mum as having no quality of life for the last 18 months. To throw in a leg amputation as well is not going to be a good outcome, even in the unlikely event she survives the operation.

I'd want to be there holding her hand. Not have her die on an operating table or in ICU.

Once the opioids start with those already frail it's usually quite quick.

I hope you get chance to tell her all that you want to and to offer comfort when the time comes. So sorry you are facing this but I don't think providing false hope or demanding surgery is what's in her best interests.

LookingAtYou · 30/10/2022 10:12

'It already been explained that spinal blocks are not suitable for patients like the OPs mum that have been on high doses of blood thinners.'

But we are now talking about end of life care, the patient has gangrene thinners won't make any difference at this stage, they should be stopped for a block.Then sub cut could be given post op.

I have just seen so many times surgeons deciding these things without consulting anaesthetists.

Anyway sorry again op, just for any others reading always push for second and third opinions.

NameChangeForARaisin · 30/10/2022 10:12

OP I don't want to increase your stress in any way but I've recently been through a very similar experience with my mum who also chose the palliative care pathway.
My understanding of palliative care would be that my mum would be pain free and comfortable, but she was anything but. There are really strict rules about what type of medication can be administered and how/when. My mum did not "officially" lose her swallowing reflex (as there was no speech therapist available to assess her for 6 days) therefore she was not allowed iv meds. However, she repeatedly choked and couldn't swallow the oramorph or paracetamol solution, so she was effectively left without pain relief.😔
It's OK to say "she will be made comfortable" but id ask what exactly that will include and entail.
Thinking of you and sending strength.

workingeverysingkeday · 30/10/2022 10:11

olympicsrock · 30/10/2022 06:14

Dear OP,
I am so sorry that you are in this awful situation. I am a Consultant Vascular surgeon and often look after patients in this situation.
I promise you that this decision will have been made out of compassion and with your mum’s best interests at heart . This is in no shape or form a cost saving measure.
It sounds like the chances of your mother dying in theatre from complications is very high. She would be unable to have a general anaesthetic with bad COPD . You can’t safely give someone on high doses of blood thinners a spinal anaesthetic so the other option would be local anaesthetic which might be impossible if they needed to explore the lower leg arteries or make multiple cuts. It would be very distressing for your mother.

You say at the beginning of your post that she has had no quality of life for 18 months. This will have been take n into account - why put her through a distressing time before her death? Acute limb ischaemia is often an indicator that someone is at the end of their natural life and has multiple other problems .

Restoring the blood supply to a limb is a time critical event. With acute limb ischaemia where you have sudden onset loss of movement and sensation , you have less then 24 hours to operate in order for the nerves to recover and you to be able to have a useful foot to walk on. Perhaps this time has passed.

I always reassure patients that death from an acutely ischaemic limb is a gentle one. The toxins in her leg will cause kidney failure which makes you sleepy and then unconscious . She will have medicines as advised by palliative care to take away any pain, or anxiety . The length of time depends on how much of the leg has died and how unwell she is from other problems ( sometimes a heart attack or infection causing atrial fibrillation caused the blood clot) . The general timeframe is 3-7 days. You will be able to sit with her and she will be kept clean dry and comfortable . There may even be time for her to go home with palliative care nursing. This will be a good death and there will be time for you to chat and for her to know that you love her.
Please ask to speak to the consultant vascular surgeon looking after her . They will be happy to explain all of this in relation to your mum. It is our job to help patients and relatives make difficult decisions. Sometimes as here there is no good options .

The palliative care team will explain to you and your mother what will happen over the coming days and can make sure that things are as ‘good’/ comfortable for you both as possible.

Big unmumsnetty hug xxx

This post is so kind and informative. It's brought tears to my eyes.
My dad is supposed to have palliative care at home but they don't come. He's in pain and miserable.
He has a DNR now because any attempt to resuscitate him would kill him.

Operating would be cruel, sometimes doing nothing apart from keeping a loved one comfortable is kindest.
I wish my dad was in the same situation