Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THE OP'S QUESTIONS-We will leave this thread up to allow posters to offer their condolences if they wish

338 replies

debbiedesperado · 29/10/2022 23:38

My mum is 80 and has chronic COPD. She has had no quality of life for the past 18 months and has been in and out of hospital frequently. Yesterday she was in a lot of pain in her leg, it was totally paper white when I looked and she couldn't move her toes or feel her leg. Up to a and e we went.

She has a blood clot in her leg. They said for a healthy person they would operate straight away however she wouldn't survive the operation. They put her on morphine, antibiotics and a drug to try and dissolve the clot.

The doctor and surgeon this morning said that nothing is working and at this stage they would want to amputate the leg but she won't survive the surgery so basically there is nothing they can do.

My mum knows what is going on and is quite calm about it although she is still in some pain and hasn't eaten. Palliative care is starting tomorrow.

I feel really overwhelmed and numb, her leg is turning black. What can I expect from here? It seems they are just waiting for sepsis to set in and this sounds like an extremely painful death.

What should I expect from here? Does anyone know a timeline that I can expect deterioration? I am trying to prepare myself but also thinking surely there must be SOMETHING they can do? It doesn't seem right to just let her lie there with a black leg and let sepsis set in.

OP posts:
KatieBell12 · 30/10/2022 12:42

TruJay · 29/10/2022 23:47

Firstly, I am so deeply sorry you and your mum are in this situation.

Secondly, what in the world?! It’s sounds utterly barbaric, there’s nothing else to do?! This just seems absolutely awful, how can they just leave her to die this way?

Obviously I am not medically trained and I don’t mean to cause offence by comparing but we have a friend who currently has a blood clot in his leg (has also had them previously), he’s on medication to treat it and surgery hasn’t even been mentioned and he is ‘a healthy person’. A second clot has appeared in same leg but different place and medication has been upped, doc doesn’t seem overly concerned although friend in a lot of pain. Are there different types of clots? How can our friend be getting treatment but your mum is being left this way? Is medication not working due to your mum’s other health conditions?

I am so so sorry

The difference is that the OPs mum has chronic COPD and the leg will not be being adequately perfused with blood, hence the clot forming in the first place. It also means that thrombolytics(clot busting drugs) can't get to the site to work properly. The medics have assessed she wouldn't survive the surgery so it isn't an option. She will receive palliative care which will keep her pain free.

BrokenWing · 30/10/2022 12:38

It sounds like the consultants have made the very best decision for your mum, anything else would be very traumatic and unlikely to give the positive outcome you hope for.

It is natural for everything inside you to not want to "give up" on them, or not want them to stop "fighting" but there comes a time when you need to face reality and the consultants will understand this, they see it often, so ask the questions you need to to make sure your are satisfied there is now no alternative.

Wishing you strength over the next few days.

SockQueen · 30/10/2022 12:29

Anaesthetist here - but really, this isn't about the anaesthetic/operation itself. I completely agree with everything @olympicsrock has said. It might be possible to get this poor lady through an amputation (which while it may be relatively quick, is certainly not a small operation!). But it's not just about dying on the table, it's about what happens next.

Any operation is a major challenge to the body's physiology. You need a lot of strength and energy to recover well from something this big. In an elderly patient with poor physiological reserve, there's a high chance that the wound wouldn't heal, leaving her with a painful, broken down wound needing (also painful) dressing changes. Even super healthy patients need intensive physio and rehab to regain mobility after a challenge like this, for which it sounds like OP's poor mum doesn't have much strength. So it's likely she'd end up bedbound, or at best, hoisted into a chair for some time each day, needing help with every aspect of intimate care, and even more vulnerable than ever to pressure sores, UTIs, chest infections etc, one of which would eventually kill her, most likely after a few more months of suffering. The absolute best she could hope for would be to get back to slightly worse than she was before hospital - and is that a life she would want?

So the op might well not improve her pain, and whatever "chance" it might give her would not be a chance of return to full health. A good death is one of the best things we can do for our patients if the alternatives are not sensible.

From a personal perspective, my own grandma had an ischaemic leg about 20 years ago, in her case likely due to atrial fibrillation - she was 80, didn't have COPD but did have some other health problems. She did have an operation (limb salvage, hers wasn't as badly gone as OP's mum). But she was never the same again - ended up with horrible ulcers on that leg which gave her so much pain she could barely walk, and she weakened almost in front of our eyes over the next few months. She died within a year, but it had been a pretty miserable year.

TheClogLady · 30/10/2022 12:28

My adopted dad (a few months younger than your mum) faced a similar situation last year.

He decided to have active care withdrawn and floated away on a palliative care cloud of sedation. He was a retired doctor and was mentally sharp and was very sure in his decision making process. He made all his decisions on the Monday and died on the Wednesday morning.
it was more difficult for us, as a family, than it was for him (it didn’t help that covid restrictions were still in force so we didn’t all get to see him in those final hours).

If your mum wanted to go ahead with the op she could probably insist on it? It would have to come from her and not you though.

If she’s anything like my da, she’s probably feeling quite pragmatic about it all and not nearly as alarmed or upset as the rest of the family.

Whatever happens next, I sincerely wish you and your mum lots of love and peace xx

PritiPatelsMaker · 30/10/2022 12:24

I've done the typical MN thing of not answering your question. I don't think anyone can tell you how long it's going to be unfortunately debbie. I just hope it's peaceful at the end Flowers

Tubs11 · 30/10/2022 12:12

For different illness but similar circumstances my mum went through this. She was heavily sedated, kept comfortable and died peacefully 10 days later. It gave her and us time to say goodbye and if they'd operated we wouldn't have had that precious time with her. Spend every minute you can with her, holding her hand, talking to her, telling stories. It's a horrendous time for you all but is a peaceful ending to hopefully a long and happy life

FallingLeaves1111 · 30/10/2022 12:00

I am so very sorry OP. I would be thinking of where your Mum would like to pass, at home with district nurses? If she would like any kind of blessing. Possibly have her room with low light and candles. I have heard people say they don't want their bedroom feeling like a hospital. Do not be afraid to ask for more medication if you feel she is at all agitated. I hope it is peaceful, such a sad time for you.

Nanny0gg · 30/10/2022 11:51

Howamihere · 30/10/2022 00:15

Oh, I’m so very sorry. This is something I can’t fathom with the nhs - happy to pay out for nose/boob jobs but not to attempt to save a life. My step father was left to die because they felt he’d had his time, it’s euthanasia by nhs. The nhs is a fabulous thing and ideology but has lost its way - this would not be acceptable in most other 1st world Countries….but it is very sadly yet another example of this Country’s slide down the rankings. Do ask questions op, at least you will know you have done so and done the best for your Mum. I’m so sorry you find yourself in this situation 💐.

What horrible things to say.

It's not 'the NHS' who has made the decisions. It's the medical staff with far more knowledge and compassion than people who have no idea of the full situation.

Other 'first world' countries might continue because they'd get paid! Or their medical staff might also put the patient first.

Nanny0gg · 30/10/2022 11:49

montysma1 · 29/10/2022 23:48

Surely to god they should let her take the chances with the operation? If she didnt make it through surgery and died on the table, surely thats a more humane way to go than what they have in mind?

Well, it wouldn't be for me!

Nanny0gg · 30/10/2022 11:48

iRun2eatCake · 30/10/2022 10:45

She wouldn't need an general anaesthetic.

OP - ask why she can't have it removed under Spinal?

Can you imagine what an horrific experience that would be for her? And to what end?

Let the OP's mum (who is of sound mind) make her own decisions

oakleaffy · 30/10/2022 11:46

NatalieIsFreezing · 30/10/2022 10:54

I am genuinely surprised at all the people suggesting that OP effectively ask doctors to end her mother's life, on the operating table. Do people think "tell them to take the chances with anaestgetic and surgery" is how the medical profession works?

A skilled medic on here {Olympicsrock} explained beautifully for non medics how it works.
She had empathy and grace in her post, doubtless learned by dealing with distressed patients and their advocates.
To many not familiar with the details, death under anaesthetic would seem preferable to lingering for weeks with a dying leg and all that entails.

Nanny0gg · 30/10/2022 11:45

debbiedesperado · 29/10/2022 23:46

Thank you all, I do have support, an amazing family around us who have been visiting mum all day, she's very loved and has lived a good life. When I was told this morning I was alone and very shocked, I feel like I didn't ask enough questions so say thinking and thought I'd ask on here. Of course will ask more tomorrow. It's just so sad because she is acting her usual self today (just very tired and in some pain) but she's chatting away and I just wish there was something they could do to prevent this. The only saving Grace is she knows she is dying and seems very, very at peace and calm, I almost wonder if she's relieved given what she has been through the past few years but It sounds very, very painful and I don't want her to die a horrible death like that 😢

Is the palliative care from the hospital?

Can you contact Marie Curie or your nearest hospice for advice?

It is a difficult time and I'm so sorry for both of you Flowers

notmyrealmoniker · 30/10/2022 11:45

Littlesquirrel77 · 30/10/2022 11:04

So sorry. I would want them to try and operate as it seems she will die without why not give it a try? There is a small chance she will pull through. Leaving her like that seems cruel x

She's 80 with a chronic breathing disease and now a life threatening condition. It would be totally pointless to do a full leg amputation on someone who would end up in weeks of pain, her breathing issue would complicate things and would still impact her quality of life. Having seen people with this situation its a cruel and painful thing to do.

notmyrealmoniker · 30/10/2022 11:42

I think one to two weeks, but they will ensure she is comfortable and not in pain. Morphine will keep her comfortable. I'm so sorry, its one of those awful situations where nothing can be done except make her comfortable. I think when your life is centred around trying to breathe and costantly in and out of hospital with all the nasty interventions needed, you really don't want to continue this life. She is probably more sad that you will be losing her. I think for herself she may want peace now.

EwwSprouts · 30/10/2022 11:39

I do not want to give you false hope but we had this scenario with MIL at a similar age. Consultant said if it was my mum I wouldn't attempt surgery so DH said no surgery. MIL wasn't fit to consent and we mentally started to prepare ourselves. We were stunned when after a few weeks of some super special dressing (on the NHS) the gangrene disappeared and she went on to live another year. I would just ask the question have all treatment options been thoroughly considered before the palliative path is taken.

Bestcatmum · 30/10/2022 11:18

Quite often they don't operate if the persons circulation is too poor as the stump won't heal and then you'll be back to square one and in an even worse state. They will have taken all of this into consideration.

Worriedddd · 30/10/2022 11:16

Rosesandstars · 30/10/2022 11:10

Yes but I think the OP's point is that if her mother does need to pass away, then that she should do be allowed a good death- painfree and not riddled with infection.

You can have a pain free death while having an infection. They use a syringe driver which has morphine and midazolam.

SuSen · 30/10/2022 11:15

countrygirl99 · 30/10/2022 10:54

When DHs dad had surgery under a spinal op he had to stop the thinners a week before surgery though.

The blood thinners are for the blood clot in her mothers leg which is dying (turning black) as a result. One week without blood thinners and the whole leg would be dead and amputation would not be an option. In fact, one week without blood thinners and her mum would be dead.

Rosesandstars · 30/10/2022 11:10

Worriedddd · 30/10/2022 10:49

No has anyone asked what her mum wants? She might not want the operation or an amputation. OP has said she has a poor quality of life, it should be about quality not quantity of life.

Yes but I think the OP's point is that if her mother does need to pass away, then that she should do be allowed a good death- painfree and not riddled with infection.

Intelligenthair · 30/10/2022 11:09

Hi OP, we went through something similar with my Father- he was too unwell for a general and they couldn’t use a spinal due to the blood thinners he was on, plus the prognosis that he wouldn’t have recovered to any decent standard of living, so the decision was made to move him to EOL care.

It took about ten days. I won’t lie, it was a distressing time for my Mum and I but I don’t think he was aware of much of it tbh.

It was massively shocking and I am not surprised you feel bamboozled. Just in case you feel any sense of failure- you 100% didn’t let your Mum down by not being able to think of questions in such a shocking moment, and you are clearly a brilliant advocate for her just by coming and asking for advice here.

There are some well meaning posters here without medical knowledge or experience of comparable situations posting stuff that like i say is well meant but I’m not sure how helpful it actually is in your situation. Please read @olympicsrock ’s excellent posts, and know that you’re not alone- those of us who have been through are here holding your hand through the coming days.

SuSen · 30/10/2022 11:08

Littlesquirrel77 · 30/10/2022 11:04

So sorry. I would want them to try and operate as it seems she will die without why not give it a try? There is a small chance she will pull through. Leaving her like that seems cruel x

This is not ethical and would lead to the doctors involved being investigated. She would not survive and the doctors will know this from their experience however as they cannot predict absolute certain death they will only say her chance of survival is very low.

Saracen · 30/10/2022 11:07

I'm so sorry.

My experience is limited, but I remember that my mum had excellent hospice care and the nurses were quite experienced in knowing exactly what to expect. They were able to tell us based on my mum's appearance and how she said she was feeling, that they expected she had about a week left, or she was in her last few days etc. The morning she died, they knew she probably had only a few hours left and were able to let us know so all of us could be by her side.

They were also able to tell my mum and us what she would be experiencing in the days to come: how much of her time she would spend sleeping, whether she would dream, whether she would enjoy food, how alert she was likely to be when awake. That helped us understand the little things we could do to make her more comfortable, and to reassure us about whether she would suffer, and how we could tell if she needed more medication.

If you have a good palliative care team, they will be able to answer your questions better than the usual doctors can.

Rosesandstars · 30/10/2022 11:07

I'm so sorry OP. 💐

SuSen · 30/10/2022 11:05

From the details you have given they will not operate, her risk of harm (death) is too high therefore it is not ethical and euthanasia is not legal in this country.
Yes the alternative is not pleasant either.
She needs to ask for painkillers when she is in pain, even if she has had them recently, this is the best way to ensure her pain relief is reviewed frequently and she remains comfortable.
People receiving palliative care can live for many months (in some cases years) however from the details you have provided I do not think this will be the case. To answer your question I think your mother will pass away within the week, 2 weeks at the most.
You should all prepare yourself and focus on ensuring she is kept comfortable and pain free. You should also consider, does she wish to die in hospital, at home or in a hospice? This should be prioritised now because any deterioration could prevent transfer to her preferred choice.

Littlesquirrel77 · 30/10/2022 11:04

So sorry. I would want them to try and operate as it seems she will die without why not give it a try? There is a small chance she will pull through. Leaving her like that seems cruel x