Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman shouting at security in ASDA?

113 replies

Driedpotatochip · 29/10/2022 22:40

Just did a quick late night shop, only one door open and as I was walking in this woman with maybe her son were walking out when their trolley locked.

As they’d blocked one side of the door I had to wait whilst she was screaming at security at how dangerous this was and security were like - there was signs. But she just kept shouting saying she was going to do more than go to customer service.

Was she unreasonable or is locking trolleys ok? I’ve actually never seen it happen before.

OP posts:
AutumnsCrow · 30/10/2022 07:52

StridTheKiller · 30/10/2022 05:10

I witnessed a man shouting at the yogurts on our nearest Asda. ASDA innit?

That was possibly my DP trying to find out where they've hidden the Yeo Kefir yogurt this week. It sets him off.

Mummieslncorporated · 30/10/2022 07:39

What happens, though, if you don't have a receipt?

You tell them what till you were at, and they reprint it to check

PorridgewithQuark · 30/10/2022 07:36

You say she had to get her receipt out - so she had paid and wasn't a shoplifter as she was able to do this?

She was with her son - a child or baby presumably, or was she an older lady with an adult man? I ask because if she had a baby in the trolley seat then the wheels unexpectedly locking with a jolt might well give a parent a fright!

This happened leaving the building to go to the car park and in front of lots of people, so humiliating as well as a shock if she'd done nothing wrong.

Of course she shouldn't have shouted but it's fairly understandable that she was shocked and humiliated as well as very much inconvenienced.

Shouting at staff is always unreasonable and of course makes everything worse.

However her experience sounds unpleasant and if she was frazzled at the end of a long day at work, having just picked up a tired child from chilcare and done a big shop - spending a lot of money in the store - being upset is reasonable!

CryCeratops · 30/10/2022 07:19

Sainsbury’s have this too.
I’ve had this happen before when I’ve been picking things up from the Argos inside the Sainsbury’s shop with a trolley, and gone straight from the Argos to the car.

Although I’d assumed it must have been the Argos staff not deactivating some security tag on my items rather than me not taking the trolley through the Sainsbury’s checkout! It was all sorted out very quickly by the staff on the door anyway.

Hwory · 30/10/2022 07:13

Asdas my main shop so I’ve had this happen to me. It’s very ubrupt and it hurts.

I’ve also seen a pregnant woman go into the back of her trolley with the receipt in her hand.

Whilst I understand the need for loss prevention I’m glad people are suing. You can’t just injure your paying customers.

Womencanlift · 30/10/2022 07:11

ClinkeyMonkey · 30/10/2022 07:01

Crikey, never heard of this. Mind you, we probably don't have anything this sophisticated in NI. What happens, though, if you don't have a receipt? I hardly ever take a receipt if asked at either the self checkout or the real living person checkout (unless I'm buying an item which might need to be returned.) How would you prove you had paid if there was a trolley malfunction?

I was thinking the same. After reading this thread I have taken a mental note to always take a receipt as I only take one now if I buy something I potentially may return (clothes or home stuff) just incase I get a malfunctioning trolley

Soubriquet · 30/10/2022 07:03

My trolley did that once. I was quite confused but I didn’t get irate. It’s just a security measure.

It was quickly resolved

ClinkeyMonkey · 30/10/2022 07:01

Crikey, never heard of this. Mind you, we probably don't have anything this sophisticated in NI. What happens, though, if you don't have a receipt? I hardly ever take a receipt if asked at either the self checkout or the real living person checkout (unless I'm buying an item which might need to be returned.) How would you prove you had paid if there was a trolley malfunction?

HunterAngel · 30/10/2022 06:40

melj1213 · 29/10/2022 23:32

The trolley locking system is basically that when you come in through the main doors with the trolley it "activates" the trolley lock which is only "deactivated" when you go through the checkout/exit the self scan area, allowing you to exit the store unimpeded. If you don't go through a checkout then when you go through the main doors the trolley will lock as it hasn't gone through the area needed to deactivate it.

It is a loss prevention system as basically it should only lock the trolley if you're trying to leave the store without going through a payment point. If someone fills up a trolley with items then tries to dash out of the store without paying then the trolley will lock at the door and stop them ... They might grab a few items from the trolley as they make a run for it but the store doesn't lose all of the stock.

Obviously there will be innocent people who are affected occasionally - if an individual trolley lock has malfunctioned and not deactivated; if you go to the cafe after shopping then the trolley lock will reset after a certain amount of time; if you just come in for a browse and you don't buy anything etc - but when those trolleys lock then a simple check that you have a receipt/trolley is empty and the security colleague can unlock it manually with a handheld device.

Well that explains why it happened to me in sainsburys. We’d brought a bed for DS from the Argos inside the supermarket and the trolley wheels locked up in the lobby. I nearly tipped the whole thing over when it stopped so suddenly. Didn’t shout at anyone though, just sent DH to customer services, staff came over, waved a wand at the wheels and off we went

Cluckycluck · 30/10/2022 06:35

I didn't know this could happen either until it happened to me the other day. I'd gone to pick up a large item from the Argos within Sainsburys. I had not other shopping to get but needed the trolley to transport the item. A member of Argos staff was pushing the trolley as it was heavy and offered to help load it into my car. As we went through security the trolley locked as the trolley hadn't been through the Sainsburys checkout area. Even the Argos staff member wasn't aware that it could happen.

MightyOaks · 30/10/2022 06:23

StridTheKiller · 30/10/2022 05:10

I witnessed a man shouting at the yogurts on our nearest Asda. ASDA innit?

GrinGrinGrinGrin

grey12 · 30/10/2022 06:15

jonesy1999 · 29/10/2022 22:44

Never heard of locking trolleys. What is that? Do you mean the wheels lock if something in the trolley sets off the security alarm?

Had one the other day!!! Every 2 meters if iust completely stopped and rattled my small children on the seat. It was awful. And the security guard did nothing about it! I had to put it back!!!

mdinbc · 30/10/2022 06:09

This is the first I have heard of this type of cart. I don't believe they have such things here in western Canada yet. It certainly would help with cart theft. I often see carts left in bushes as people walk home with shopping and leave the carts in random places. Some of the stores have coin-operated locking mechanism to deter theft.

I do wonder with self check-out in so many stores; how do they manage theft? I'm sure there are a lot of people not scanning all of their items.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 30/10/2022 06:03

autastic · 29/10/2022 22:51

This happened to me and I shouted one because I was shocked and the also because I was in pain, it just locked and I was travelling forward and went straight into it and lost my balance and fell onto the metal. I was fucking angry there is no need for it, and as for signs the only one in the Asda I was in, someone was standing in front of it.
As a consequence I don't shop on Asda anymore.
seriously how many trolleys do they really lose?
I didn't carry on shouting as I recovered and I didn't shout at the staff, but I did complain.

I'm sure ASDA are devastated by that loss 🙄

I think it's a good thing, stores lose so much stock, it's a deterrent that works.

youkiddingme · 30/10/2022 05:48

Just a small thought - if the trolley locks in such a way that someone pushing it briskly could be hurt then I doubt any amount of signage makes that acceptable. Surely they could be designed to brake gradually rather than abruptly. Not everyone can read. Not everyone can see well enough to read signs that are at a distance.

PuttingDownRoots · 30/10/2022 05:43

My brother was telling me a few days ago that at the Sainsburys he visits in London (Dulwich I think( you have to scan your receipt to open a gate to leave the self checkout area.

Its sad these extra measures like security boxes, locking trolleys etc are needed.

Mummieslncorporated · 30/10/2022 05:29

It's common sense. You can't be charged with the theft of something if you are still inside the store and willing to pay

But for every individual caught and charged, there are plenty more that don't. Those makes much more sense - prevent big thefts to begin with, reduce the loss of stock and it will have the side effect of reducing the number of shoplifters, as they will go to stores without this technology instead.

Madwife123 · 30/10/2022 05:25

A quick google tells me there is already law suits filed due to injuries caused.

www.williamsons-solicitors.co.uk/case-studies/claimant-left-with-fractured-wrist-following-a-visit-to-her-local-supermarket/

yerdaindicatesonbends · 30/10/2022 05:24

DH works with the general public and it is becoming an increasingly common occurrence for people to start shouting for the smallest inconvenience so it’s not surprising unfortunately.

Madwife123 · 30/10/2022 05:21

Had no idea they do this and I shop in Asda at least once a week so the signs can’t be that obvious. Sounds dangerous to me. Imagine if you have mobility issues or health conditions such as EDS etc. Suddenly stopping without warning will result in most people hitting the trolley and that can easily cause injuries.

DoItAfraid · 30/10/2022 05:18

melj1213 · 29/10/2022 23:32

The trolley locking system is basically that when you come in through the main doors with the trolley it "activates" the trolley lock which is only "deactivated" when you go through the checkout/exit the self scan area, allowing you to exit the store unimpeded. If you don't go through a checkout then when you go through the main doors the trolley will lock as it hasn't gone through the area needed to deactivate it.

It is a loss prevention system as basically it should only lock the trolley if you're trying to leave the store without going through a payment point. If someone fills up a trolley with items then tries to dash out of the store without paying then the trolley will lock at the door and stop them ... They might grab a few items from the trolley as they make a run for it but the store doesn't lose all of the stock.

Obviously there will be innocent people who are affected occasionally - if an individual trolley lock has malfunctioned and not deactivated; if you go to the cafe after shopping then the trolley lock will reset after a certain amount of time; if you just come in for a browse and you don't buy anything etc - but when those trolleys lock then a simple check that you have a receipt/trolley is empty and the security colleague can unlock it manually with a handheld device.

Thank you for this explanation- I literally never knew this.

You explained it really well. You should write process manuals or other instructive documents.

StridTheKiller · 30/10/2022 05:10

I witnessed a man shouting at the yogurts on our nearest Asda. ASDA innit?

Slowslowlavaflow · 30/10/2022 05:06

It is not just Asda; happened to me in Tesco last week. I used the 'scan as you shop' and had forgotten a kid's jumper had a tag on it that needed removing. I set off the alarm at the exit and could not move the trolley forward. I did not even realise it was me who had set off the alarm and was struggling with the trolley thinking the wheels were malfunctioning. I was quite confused. Figured out it was me and the reason why after a quick chat with security and took the jumper to a member of staff at the self service area with the receipt to get the tag off. Was quite embarrassing as it was busy when I was exiting and lots of people were watching. As I returned and attempted to leave again, the trolley was still locked and the security guard took out a remote, pointed at the trolley wheel, pressed a button, and the trolley started rolling again. There were no signs around warning this could happen, but it was so busy and we were all moving slowly for the exit, that no one was hurt in any way.

user3193 · 30/10/2022 04:00

This also happened to me. I had gone in to buy a couple of big home items but they didn't have what I wanted. So I left with an empty trolley. Had my 6 month old boy sitting in the trolley and it locked on trying to go out the door. I was also quite shocked as the trolley kind of jolted up as it locked. Especially with a baby sitting in it.

GhastlyBoo · 30/10/2022 03:56

It sounds dangerous to me!

So can't you wheel the trolley to your car anymore?